Mixed results in strategic IT alignment research: a synthesis and empirical study
Tóm tắt
The alignment of business strategy and IT has been a top managerial concern for decades. Yet despite much investigation, the effect of strategic IT alignment on organizational performance remains unclear, with mixed results reported in the literature. The purpose of this paper is to advance our understanding of mixed findings in IT alignment research. We first examine inconsistent findings reported in two streams of alignment research: the traditional firm-level IT alignment literature and the emerging literature into process-level IT alignment. We then empirically investigate whether firm- and process-level conceptualizations of IT alignment lead to different conclusions about the effect of alignment on performance. Using data from a survey of 120 firms, we show that firm-level IT alignment and process-level IT alignment yield different conclusions when testing the same theory under the same conditions. We also show that differences in firms’ strategic orientations can help explain these results. This research provides evidence that firm- and process-level conceptualizations of IT alignment are not interchangeable and that the choice of conceptualization can mean the difference between accepting and rejecting a theory.
Tài liệu tham khảo
AIS (2011) Association for Information Systems, Senior Scholars’ Basket of Journals. http://aisnet.org/default.asp?page=SeniorScholarBasket (accessed 15 September 2015).
Armstrong J and Overton T (1977) Estimating nonresponse bias in mail surveys. Journal of Marketing Research 14(3), 396–402.
Avison D, Jones B, Powell P and Wilson DB (2004) Using and validating the strategic alignment model. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 13(3), 223–246.
Bergeron F, Raymond L and Rivard S (2004) Ideal patterns of strategic alignment and business performance. Information & Management 41(8), 1003–1020.
Bower JL and Gilbert CG (2007) How managers’ everyday decisions create: or destroy: your company’s strategy. Harvard Business Review 85(2), 72–79.
Bradley RV, Pratt R, Byrd TA, Outlay CN and Wynn Jr DE (2012) Enterprise architecture, IT effectiveness and the mediating role of IT alignment in US hospitals. Information Systems Journal 22(2), 97–127.
Burton-Jones A and Straub DW (2006) Reconceptualizing system usage: an approach and empirical test. Information Systems Research 17(3), 228–246.
Byrd T, Lewis B and Bryan R (2006) The leveraging influence of strategic alignment on IT investment: an empirical examination. Information & Management 43(3), 308–321.
Chan YE (2002) Why haven’t we mastered alignment? the importance of the informal organization structure. MIS Quarterly Executive 1(2), 97–112.
Chan YE, Huff SL, Barclay DW and Copeland DG (1997) Business strategic orientation, information systems strategic orientation, and strategic alignment. Information Systems Research 8(2), 125–150.
Chan YE and Reich BH (2007) IT alignment: what have we learned? Journal of Information Technology 22(4), 297–315.
Chan YE, Sabherwal R and Thatcher JB (2006) Antecedents and outcomes of strategic IS alignment: an empirical investigation. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management 53(1), 27–47.
Chênevert D and Tremblay M (2009) Fits in strategic human resource management and methodological challenge: empirical evidence of influence of empowerment and compensation practices on human resource performance in Canadian firms. The International Journal of Human Resource Management 20(4), 738–770.
Chin WW (1998) Issues and opinion on structural equation modeling. MIS Quarterly 22(1), 7–26.
Coltman T, Tallon PP, Sharma R and Queiroz M (2015) Strategic IT alignment: twenty-five years on. Journal of Information Technology 30(2), 91–100.
Cragg P, King M and Hussin H (2002) IT alignment and firm performance in small manufacturing firms. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 11(2), 109–132.
Croteau AM and Bergeron F (2001) An information technology trilogy: business strategy, technological deployment and organizational performance. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 10(2), 77–99.
Croteau AM and Raymond L (2004) Performance outcomes of strategic and IT competencies alignment. Journal of Information Technology 19(3), 178–190.
Edwards JR (1994) The study of congruence in organizational behavior research: critique and a proposed alternative. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 58(1), 51–100.
Fornell C and Larcker DF (1981) Structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error: algebra and statistics. Journal of Marketing Research 18(1), 382–388.
Gerdin J and Greve J (2004) Forms of contingency fit in management accounting research: a critical review. Accounting, Organizations and Society 29(3), 303–326.
Gerow JE, Grover V, Thatcher JB and Roth P (2014b) Looking toward the future of IT-business strategic alignment through the past: a meta-analysis. MIS Quarterly 38(4), 1059–1085.
Gerow JE, Thatcher JB and Grover V (2014a) Six types of IT-business strategic alignment: an investigation of the constructs and their measurement. European Journal of Information Systems 24(3), 1–27.
Hair JF, Ringle CM and Sarstedt M (2011) PLS-SEM: indeed a silver bullet. The Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice 19(2), 139–152.
Hair JF, Sarstedt M, Ringle CM and Mena JA (2012) An assessment of the use of partial least squares structural equation modeling in marketing research. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 40(3), 414–433.
Harris J, Johnson S and Souder D (2013) Model-theoretic knowledge accumulation, the case of agency theory and incentive alignment. Academy of Management Review 38(3), 442–454.
Hayes AF (2013) Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach. Guilford Press, New York.
Henderson JC and Venkatraman N (1993) Strategic alignment: leveraging information technology for transforming organizations. IBM Systems Journal 32(1), 4–16.
Hussin H, King M and Cragg P (2002) IT alignment in small firms. European Journal of Information Systems 11(2), 108–127.
Iivari J (1992) The organizational fit of information systems. Journal of Information Systems 2(1), 3–29.
Kappelman L, Mclean E, Luftman J, and Johnson V (2013) Key issues of IT organizations and their leadership: the 2013 SIM IT Trends Study. MIS Quarterly Executive 12(4), 227–240.
Karahanna E and Preston DS (2013) The effect of social capital of the relationship between the CIO and top management team on firm performance. Journal of Management Information Systems 30(1), 15–56.
Kearns GS and Lederer AL (2000) The effect of strategic alignment on the use of IS-based resources for competitive advantage. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 9(4), 265–293.
Kearns GS and Lederer AL (2003) A resource-based view of strategic IT alignment: how knowledge sharing creates competitive advantage. Decision Sciences 34(1), 1–30.
Kim G, Shin B., Kim K and Lee H (2011) IT capabilities, process-oriented dynamic capabilities, and firm financial performance. Journal of the Association for Information Systems 12(7), 487–517.
Lu Y and Ramamurthy K (2011) Understanding the link between information technology capability and organizational agility: an empirical examination. MIS Quarterly 35(4), 931–954.
Mclaren TS, Head MM, Yuan Y and Chan YE (2011) A multilevel model for measuring fit between a firm’s competitive strategies and information systems capabilities. MIS Quarterly 35(4), 909–929.
Meilich O (2006) Bivariate models of fit in contingency theory: critique and a polynomial regression alternative. Organizational Research Methods 9(2), 161–193.
Mintzberg H (1987) The strategy concept I: five Ps for strategy. California Management Review 30(2), 11–24.
Mintzberg H and Waters J (1985) Of strategies, deliberate and emergent. Strategic Management Journal 6(3), 257–272.
Newkirk HE, Lederer AL and Johnson AM (2008) Rapid business and IT change: drivers for strategic information systems planning? European Journal of Information Systems 17(3), 198–218.
Nunnally JC (1978) Psychometric Theory (2nd ed). McGraw-Hill, New York.
Oh W and Pinsonneault A (2007) On the assessment of the strategic value of information technologies: conceptual and analytical approaches. MIS Quarterly 31(2), 239–265.
Palmer JW and Markus ML (2000) The performance impacts of quick response and strategic alignment in specialty retailing. Information Systems Research 11(3), 241–259.
Podsakoff PM, Mackenzie SB, Lee J-Y and Podsakoff NP (2003) Common method biases in behavioral research: a critical review of the literature and recommended remedies. Journal of Applied Psychology 88(5), 879–903.
Podsakoff PM and Organ DW (1986) Self-reports in organizational research: problems and prospects. Journal of Management 12(4), 531–544.
Powell TC and Dent-Micallef A (1997) Information technology as competitive advantage: the role of human, business, and technology resources. Strategic Management Journal 18(5), 375–405.
Preston DS and Karahanna E (2009) Antecedents of IS strategic alignment: a nomological network. Information Systems Research 20(2), 159–179.
Ray G, Barney JB and Muhanna WA (2004) Capabilities, business processes, and competitive advantage: choosing the dependent variable in empirical tests of the resource-based view. Strategic Management Journal 25(1), 23–37.
Raymond L and Croteau AM (2009) Manufacturing strategy and business strategy in medium-sized enterprises: performance effects of strategic alignment. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management 56(2), 192–202.
Reynolds P and Yetton P (2015) Aligning business and IT strategies in multi-business organizations. Journal of Information Technology 30(2), 101–118.
Richard PJ, Devinney TM, Yip GS and Johnson G (2009) Measuring organizational performance: towards methodological best practice. Journal of Management 35(3), 718–804.
Ringle C, Wende S and Will A (2005) SmartPLS 2.0 (M3) beta. University of Hamburg, Germany.
Sabherwal R and Chan YE (2001) Alignment between business and IS strategies: a study of prospectors, analyzers, and defenders. Information Systems Research 12(1), 11–33.
Stalk G, Evans P and Sgulman LE (1992) Competing on capabilities: the new rules of corporate strategy. Harvard Business Review 70(2), 57–69.
Suddaby R (2010) Editor’s comments: construct clarity in theories of management and organization. Academy of Management Review 35(3), 346–357.
Tallon PP (2003) The alignment paradox. CIO Insight 1(40), 75–76.
Tallon PP (2008) A process-oriented perspective on the alignment of information technology and business strategy. Journal of Management Information Systems 24(3), 227–268.
Tallon PP (2010) A service science perspective on strategic choice, IT, and performance in US banking. Journal of Management Information Systems 26(4), 219–252.
Tallon PP (2012) Value chain linkages and the spillover effects of strategic information technology alignment: a process-level view. Journal of Management Information Systems 28(3), 9–44.
Tallon PP and Pinsonneault A (2011) Competing perspectives on the link between strategic information technology alignment and organizational agility: insights from a mediation model. MIS Quarterly 35(2), 463–486.
Tallon PP, Kraemer KL and Gurbaxani V (2000) Executives’ perceptions of the business value of information technology: a process-oriented approach. Journal of Management Information Systems 16(4), 145–173.
Tallon PP, Queiroz M, Coltman T and Sharma R (2016) Business process and information technology alignment: construct conceptualization, empirical illustration, and directions for future research. Journal of the Association for Information Systems 17(9), 563–589.
Teece DJ (1986) Profiting from technological innovation: implications for integration, collaboration, licensing and public policy. Research Policy 15(6), 285–305.
Teece DJ (2007) Explicating dynamic capabilities: the nature and microfoundations of (sustainable) enterprise performance. Strategic Management Journal 28(1), 1319–1350.
Venkatraman N (1989) Strategic orientation of business enterprises: the construct, dimensionality, and measurement. Management Science 35(8), 942–962.
Wade M and Hulland J (2004) Review: the resource-based view and information systems research: review, extension, and suggestions for future research. MIS Quarterly 28(1), 107–142.
Weber R (2003) Editor’s comments: theoretically speaking. MIS Quarterly 27(3), iii–xii.
Werts C, Linn R and Jöreskog K (1978) A general method of estimating the reliability of a composite. Educational and Psychological Measurement 38(2), 933–938.
Wetzels M, Odekerken-Schroder G and Van Oppen C (2009) Using PLS path modeling for assessing hierarchical construct models: guidelines and empirical illustration. MIS Quarterly 33(1), 177–195.
Wu S, Straub D and Liang TP (2015) How information technology governance mechanisms and strategic alignment influence organizational performance: insights from a matched survey of business and IT managers. MIS Quarterly 39(2), 497–518.
Yayla AA and Hu Q (2012) The impact of IT-business strategic alignment on firm performance in a developing country setting: exploring moderating roles of environmental uncertainty and strategic orientation. European Journal of Information Systems 21(4), 373–387.