Medical tourism in india: perceptions of physicians in tertiary care hospitals
Tóm tắt
Senior physicians of modern medicine in India play a key role in shaping policies and public opinion and institutional management. This paper explores their perceptions of medical tourism (MT) within India which is a complex process involving international demands and policy shifts from service to commercialisation of health care for trade, gross domestic profit, and foreign exchange. Through interviews of 91 physicians in tertiary care hospitals in three cities of India, this paper explores four areas of concern: their understanding of MT, their views of the hospitals they work in, perceptions of the value and place of MT in their hospital and their views on the implications of MT for medical care in the country. An overwhelming majority (90%) of physicians in the private tertiary sector and 74.3 percent in the public tertiary sector see huge scope for MT in the private tertiary sector in India. The private tertiary sector physicians were concerned about their patients alone and felt that health of the poor was the responsibility of the state. The public tertiary sector physicians’ however, were sensitive to the problems of the common man and felt responsible. Even though the glamour of hi-tech associated with MT dazzled them, only 35.8 percent wanted MT in their hospitals and a total of 56 percent of them said MT cannot be a public sector priority. 10 percent in the private sector expressed reservations towards MT while the rest demanded state subsidies for MT. The disconnect between their concern for the common man and professionals views on MT was due to the lack of appreciation of the continuum between commercialisation, the denial of resources to public hospitals and shift of subsidies to the private sector. The paper highlights the differences and similarities in the perceptions and context of the two sets of physicians, presents evidence, that questions the support for MT and finally analyzes some key implications of MT on Indian health services, ethical issues emerging out of that and the need for understanding the linkages between public and private sectors for a more effective intervention for an equitable medical care policy.
Tài liệu tham khảo
CII-McKinsey: Health Care in India: The Road Ahead. CII. 2002, New Delhi: McKinsey and Company and Indian Healthcare Federation
Planning Commission:: Tenth Five Year Plan, 2002-2007. 2002, New Delhi: Chapter on Health, Government of India, Volume 2
Planning Commission:: Eleventh Five Year Plan, 2007-2012. 2008, New Delhi: Chapter on Health, Government of India, Volume 2
Government of India: Ministry of health and family welfare, draft national health bill. 2009
Planning Commission:: Twelfth Five Year Plan, 2012-2017. 2013, New Delhi: Chapter on Health, Government of India, Volume 3
Qadeer I, Reddy S: Medical care in the shadow of public private partnership. Social Scientist. 2006, 34 (9–10): 4-20.
Baru RV: Privatisation of health services: a south asian perspective. Econ Pol Wkly. 2003, 38 (42): 4433-4437.
Chanda R: Trade in Health Services. 2010, http://www.who.int/trade/en/THpart1chap3.pdf webcite,
Budget 2003- 2004: speech of Jaswant Singh, minister of finance and company affairs, Feb. 28 2003. 2013, http://indiabudget.nic.in/bspeech/bs200304.pdf Webcite
CII: Great Advantage in India Medical Tourism: CII August 2004. 2013, http://www.medicaltourindia.com/medical-tourism-news.asp Webcite. Accessed on 5th May 2013
Banerji D: Landmarks in the development of health services in India. Public Health and the Poverty of Reforms. Edited by: Qadeer I, Sen K, Nayar KR. 2001, New Delhi: Sage Publication
Reddy S, Qadeer I: Medical tourism in India: progress or predicament?. Econ Pol Wkly. 2010, 45 (20): 69-75.
Whittaker A: Pleasure and pain: medical travel in Asia. Global Public Health. 2008, 3 (3): 271-290. 10.1080/17441690701463936.
Chanda R: Trade in health services. Bull World Health Organisation. 2002, 80 (2): 158-163.
Sengupta A, Nundy S: The private health sector in India. BMJ. 2005, 331: 1157-1158. 10.1136/bmj.331.7526.1157
Baum NM, Sarah EG, Susan DG, Peter DJ: Ethical issues facing public health practitioners. American Society for Bioethics and the Humanities Annual Meeting: Connecting and Collaborating 10 (19). 2007, 7-Washington, DC
Calman KC, Downie RS: Ethical principles and ethical issues in public health. Oxford Text Book of Public Health. Edited by: Roger D, Robert B, Mary AL, Martin G. 2011, London: Oxford University Press
Medical tourism policy. 2010, http://www.indiacore.com/tourism.html webcite,
Gujarat medical tourism policy: draft. 2010, http://www.discoveredindia.com/gujarat/tourism-sectors-in-gujarat/medical-tourism-in-gujarat.htm webcite,
Sengupta A: Medical tourism in India: winners and losers. Indian J Med Ethics. 2008, 5 (1): 4-5.
Kumar P, Simi TB: Barriers to movement of healthcare professionals a case study of India. 2010, http://www.cuts-citee.org/pdf/RREPORT07-03.pdf Webcite,
Venkata K, Prasad CB: Medical Tourism Industry - Advantage India. 2010, http://dspace.iimk.ac.in/bitstream/2259/483/1/255-260.pdf Webcite,
Hazarika I: Medical tourism: Its potential impact on the health workforce and health systems in India. J Health Plann Policy. 2010, 25 (3): 248-251. 10.1093/heapol/czp050.
Hopper CR: Adding insult to injury: the healthcare brain drain. J Med Ethics. 2008, 34 (9): 684-7. 10.1136/jme.2007.023143
Gupta SA: Medical Tourism in India: winners and loosers. Indian Journal of Medical Ethics. 2008, 14 (1): 4-5.
Bertinato L, Busse R, Fahy N, Quigley HL, McKee M, Palm W, Passarani I, Ronfini F: Policy brief cross border health care in Europe. 2010, http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/108960/E87922.pdf Webcite,
Health care reforms to impact medical tourism. 2010, http://www.imtjonline.com/news/?EntryId82=129713 Webcite,
Chotani S, Sultana S: Common Wealth Games in Delhi: How much does national prestige cost? A report; 2007. 2007, New Delhi: Monograph of The Hazards Centre