Measuring the resilience of health systems in low- and middle-income countries: a focus on community resilience
Tóm tắt
The concept of community resilience has gained considerable attention in the global health discussions since the Ebola outbreak of West Africa in 2014–2015. However, there are no measurement models to quantify community resilience. Without measurement models, it is unclear how to test strategies for building community resilience or to describe their likely intended and unintended results and their impact on health outcomes. We propose a measurement model for community resilience with relevant constructs and indicators to measure these constructs. We conducted a scoping review, systematically searching, screening and selecting relevant articles from two bibliographic databases (PUBMED and Google Scholar) for literature using search terms such as “resilience”, “community resilience” and “health systems resilience”. We screened 500 papers, then completed a full text review of 112 identified as relevant based on their title and abstract. A total of 27 papers and reports were retained for analysis. We then aggregated and synthesised the various definitions of community resilience and the frameworks for understanding these definitions. We identified key constructs from these frameworks and organised these constructs into domains and sub-domains. We proposed indicators to capture aspects of these domains and sub-domains and operationalised these indicators as a measurement model for quantifying community resilience in health systems. We propose a model with 20 indicators to assess community resilience. These indicators tap into various constructs from different theoretical frameworks of community resilience and are useful for assessing the level of knowledge, financial resources, and human, social and physical capital that are needed (or lacking) to respond to any types of shock, including health shock at the community level. This is an initial attempt to describe a multilevel measurement model for quantifying community resilience. This model will help to guide the development and testing of strategies for strengthening community resilience and will require further work to assess its relevance, reliability and validity in different LMIC settings.
Tài liệu tham khảo
citation_title=Vancouver statement for the fourth global symposium on health systems research; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_id=CR1
citation_journal_title=Lancet; citation_title=What is a resilient health system? Lessons from Ebola; citation_author=ME Kruk, M Myers, ST Varpilah; citation_volume=385; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=1910-1912; citation_doi=10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60755-3; citation_id=CR2
citation_journal_title=Bull World Health Organ; citation_title=Health-system resilience: reflections on the Ebola crisis in western Africa; citation_author=M-P Kieny, DB Evans, G Schmets; citation_volume=92; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=850; citation_doi=10.2471/BLT.14.149278; citation_id=CR3
citation_journal_title=Health Policy Plan; citation_title=Impact of interventions and the incidence of ebola virus disease in Liberia—implications for future epidemics; citation_author=TD Kirsch, H Moseson, M Massaquoi; citation_volume=32; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=205-214; citation_doi=10.1093/heapol/czw113; citation_id=CR4
citation_journal_title=J Global Infect Dis; citation_title=The Emergence of Ebola as a Global Health Security Threat: From ‘Lessons Learned’ to Coordinated Multilateral Containment Efforts; citation_author=S Kalra, D Kelkar, SC Galwankar; citation_volume=6; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=164-177; citation_doi=10.4103/0974-777X.145247; citation_id=CR5
citation_journal_title=BMJ; citation_title=Building resilient health systems: a proposal for a resilience index; citation_author=ME Kruk, EJ Ling, A Bitton; citation_volume=357; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=j2323; citation_doi=10.1136/bmj.j2323; citation_id=CR6
citation_journal_title=Health Policy Plan; citation_title=Towards an understanding of resilience: responding to health systems shocks; citation_author=J Hanefeld, S Mayhew, H Legido-Quigley; citation_volume=33; citation_publication_date=2018; citation_pages=355-367; citation_doi=10.1093/heapol/czx183; citation_id=CR7
citation_journal_title=Int J Health Policy Manag; citation_title=Governance and capacity to manage resilience of health systems: towards a new conceptual framework; citation_author=K Blanchet, SL Nam, B Ramalingam; citation_volume=6; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=431-435; citation_doi=10.15171/ijhpm.2017.36; citation_id=CR8
citation_journal_title=Health Policy Plan; citation_title=Interrogating resilience in health systems development; citation_author=R Pas, M Ashour, A Kapilashrami; citation_volume=32; citation_issue=Suppl. 3; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=iii88-iii90; citation_id=CR9
Topp SM, Flores W, Sriram V, et al. Critiquing the concept of resilience in health systems: Health Systems Global.
https://www.healthsystemsglobal.org/blog/110/Critiquing-the-Concept-of-Resilience-in-Health-Systems.html
. Accessed 11 Aug 2019.
citation_journal_title=Health Policy Plan; citation_title=From bouncing back, to nurturing emergence: Reframing the concept of resilience in health systems strengthening; citation_author=EW Barasa, K Cloete, L Gilson; citation_volume=32; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=iii91-iii94; citation_doi=10.1093/heapol/czx118; citation_id=CR11
Institute of Development Studies. Making the most of resilience.
http://www.ids.ac.uk/files/dmfile/IF32.pdf
. Accessed 24 Aug 2019.
Berkes F, Colding J, Folke C. Navigating social–ecological systems: building resilience for complexity and change. Cambridge University Press; 2002.
Gunderson LH, Holling CS. Resilience and adaptive cycles. In: Panarchy: Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems. Island Press; 2001. p. 25–62.
citation_journal_title=Glob Health Action; citation_title=Understanding the role of community resilience in addressing the Ebola virus disease epidemic in Liberia: a qualitative study (community resilience in Liberia); citation_author=O Alonge, S Sonkarlay, W Gwaikolo; citation_volume=12; citation_publication_date=2019; citation_pages=1662682; citation_doi=10.1080/16549716.2019.1662682; citation_id=CR15
citation_journal_title=Health Inf Libr J; citation_title=A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies; citation_author=MJ Grant, A Booth; citation_volume=26; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=91-108; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1471-1842.2009.00848.x; citation_id=CR16
Booth A, Sutton A, Papaioannou D. Systematic approaches to a successful literature review. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications Ltd; 2016.
https://uk.sagepub.com/en-gb/eur/systematic-approaches-to-a-successful-literature-review/book244586
. Accessed 11 Aug 2019.
citation_journal_title=Am J Community Psychol; citation_title=Community resilience as a metaphor, theory, set of capacities, and strategy for disaster readiness; citation_author=FH Norris, SP Stevens, B Pfefferbaum; citation_volume=41; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=127-150; citation_doi=10.1007/s10464-007-9156-6; citation_id=CR18
Patel SS, Rogers MB, Amlôt R, et al. What do we mean by ‘community resilience’? A systematic literature review of how it is defined in the literature. PLOS Curr Disasters. 2017.
https://doi.org/10.1371/currents.dis.db775aff25efc5ac4f0660ad9c9f7db2
.
citation_journal_title=Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci; citation_title=Conceptualizing community resilience to natural hazards – the emBRACE framework; citation_author=S Kruse, T Abeling, H Deeming; citation_volume=17; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=2321-2333; citation_doi=10.5194/nhess-17-2321-2017; citation_id=CR20
Sonn CC, Fisher AT. Sense of community: Community resilient responses to oppression and change. Journal of Community Psychology. 1998;26:457–472.
citation_journal_title=Biosecur Bioterror; citation_title=A psychosocial risk assessment and management framework to enhance response to CBRN terrorism threats and attacks; citation_author=L Lemyre, M Clément, W Corneil; citation_volume=3; citation_publication_date=2005; citation_pages=316-330; citation_doi=10.1089/bsp.2005.3.316; citation_id=CR22
citation_journal_title=J Public Health; citation_title=Resilience thinking in health protection; citation_author=M Castleden, M McKee, V Murray; citation_volume=33; citation_publication_date=2011; citation_pages=369-377; citation_doi=10.1093/pubmed/fdr027; citation_id=CR23
citation_title=Disruptions in place attachment; citation_inbook_title=Place attach; citation_publication_date=1992; citation_pages=279-304; citation_id=CR24; citation_author=BB Brown; citation_author=DD Perkins; citation_publisher=Springer US
citation_journal_title=Nat Hazards; citation_title=Community resilience to volcanic hazard consequences; citation_author=D Paton, M Millar, D Johnston; citation_volume=24; citation_publication_date=2001; citation_pages=157-169; citation_doi=10.1023/A:1011882106373; citation_id=CR25
citation_journal_title=J Jew Communal Serv; citation_title=Community resilience: lessons derived from Gilo under fire; citation_author=DM Ganor, Y Ben-Lavy; citation_volume=79; citation_publication_date=2003; citation_pages=105-108; citation_id=CR26
citation_journal_title=S Afr J Psychol; citation_title=Discerning community resilience in disadvantaged communities in the context of violence and injury prevention; citation_author=R Ahmed, M Seedat, A Niekerk; citation_volume=34; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=386-408; citation_doi=10.1177/008124630403400304; citation_id=CR27
citation_journal_title=J Commun Psychol; citation_title=Community resilience and the impact of stress: adult response to Israel’s withdrawal from Lebanon; citation_author=S Kimhi, M Shamai; citation_volume=32; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=439-451; citation_doi=10.1002/jcop.20012; citation_id=CR28
citation_journal_title=Aust J Emerg Manage; citation_title=Developing community resilience as a foundation for effective disaster recovery; citation_author=E Coles, P Buckle; citation_volume=19; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=6-15; citation_id=CR29
Pfefferbaum BJ, Reissman DB, Pfefferbaum RL, et al. Building resilience to mass trauma events. In: Doll LS, Bonzo SE, Sleet DA, et al., editors. Handbook of injury and violence prevention. Boston: Springer US; 2007. p. 347–58.
Bond CA, Strong A, Burger N, et al. Resilience Dividend Valuation Model Framework Development and Initial Case Studies [Internet]. RAND Corporation; 2017. p. 176. Available from:
https://doi.org/10.7249/RR2129
. [cited 2019 May 12].
citation_journal_title=Prog Hum Geogr; citation_title=Social and ecological resilience: are they related?; citation_author=WN Neil Adger; citation_volume=24; citation_publication_date=2000; citation_pages=347-364; citation_doi=10.1191/030913200701540465; citation_id=CR32
citation_journal_title=Am Behav Sci; citation_title=Community resilience interventions: participatory, assessment-based, action-oriented processes; citation_author=B Pfefferbaum, RL Pfefferbaum, RL Horn; citation_volume=59; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=238-253; citation_doi=10.1177/0002764214550298; citation_id=CR33
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health: Center for health security. a framework for healthcare disaster resilience: a view into the future.
https://www.centerforhealthsecurity.org/our-work/publications/a-framework-for-healthcare-disaster-resilience-a-view-to-the-future
. Accessed 6 June 2019.
citation_journal_title=BMJ Glob Health; citation_title=Everyday resilience in district health systems: emerging insights from the front lines in Kenya and South Africa; citation_author=L Gilson, E Barasa, N Nxumalo; citation_volume=2; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=e000224; citation_doi=10.1136/bmjgh-2016-000224; citation_id=CR35
Rose A. Defining and measuring economic resilience to disasters. Disaster Prevention and Management. 2004;13:307–314.
citation_journal_title=Reliab Eng Syst Saf; citation_title=A metric and frameworks for resilience analysis of engineered and infrastructure systems; citation_author=R Francis, B Bekera; citation_volume=121; citation_publication_date=2013; citation_pages=90-103; citation_doi=10.1016/j.ress.2013.07.004; citation_id=CR37
Bruneau M, Chang SE, Eguchi RT, et al. A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities. Earthquake Spectra. 2003;19:733–52.
UNDP. Community based resilience analysis (CoBRA) conceptual framework and methodology. 2017.
https://www.undp.org/content/undp/en/home/librarypage/environment-energy/sustainable_land_management/CoBRA/cobra_guide.html
. Accessed 6 Mar 2019.
citation_journal_title=J Environ Plan Manag; citation_title=A measurement of community disaster resilience in Korea; citation_author=DK Yoon, JE Kang, SD Brody; citation_volume=59; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_pages=436-460; citation_doi=10.1080/09640568.2015.1016142; citation_id=CR40
Morley P, Parsons M, Marshall G, et al. The Australian natural disaster resilience index. 2015.
https://www.bnhcrc.com.au/publications/biblio/bnh-2345
. Accessed 22 May 2019.
W.A. F, Kafle SK. Integrated Community Based Risk Reduction: An Approach to Building Disaster Resilient Communities. 4th Annual International Workshop & Expo on Sumatra Tsunami Disaster & Recovery. 2009.
citation_title=City resilience framework; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_id=CR43
United Nations. Guidance on measuring the reduction of disaster risks and the implementation of the hyogo framework for action. 2008.
https://www.unisdr.org/files/13101_ImplementingtheHFA.pdf
. Accessed 29 July 2019.
citation_title=Community resilience: a social justice perspective; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_id=CR45; citation_author=BH Morrow
citation_title=Measuring community action program impacts on multi-dimensional poverty; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_id=CR46; citation_author=M Torgerson; citation_publisher=Oregon State University
Perfrement T, Lloyd T. The composite resilience index—a modelling tool to measure the resilience of local communities to climate extremes. 2015.
https://theresilienceindex.weebly.com/our-solution.html
. Accessed 2 June 2019.
citation_journal_title=Am J Trop Med Hyg; citation_title=The relationship between distance to water source and moderate-to-severe diarrhea in the global enterics multi-center study in Kenya, 2008–2011; citation_author=BL Nygren, CE O’Reilly, A Rajasingham; citation_volume=94; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_pages=1143-1149; citation_doi=10.4269/ajtmh.15-0393; citation_id=CR48
Ostadtaghizadeh A, Ardalan A, Paton D, et al. Community disaster resilience: a systematic review on assessment models and tools. PLoS Curr. 2015.
https://doi.org/10.1371/currents.dis.f224ef8efbdfcf1d508dd0de4d8210ed
.