May the resources be with you: a systematic review and framework of startup funding options

Management Review Quarterly - Trang 1-32 - 2023
Dustin Bauer1, Sebastian Junge1, Tobias Reif1
1Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nuremberg, Nuremberg, Germany

Tóm tắt

The funding landscape for startups has recently changed significantly. Not only have new funding partners emerged but established funding partners have also changed their behaviors. Startups can choose among different sources and regularly ask for more than monetary investment such as guidance and coaching. While numerous studies investigate the multitude of funding partners, offered funding instruments, and startups’ needs, the combination and integration of those perspectives have been under-researched in the entrepreneurial finance literature. To address this issue, we conduct a systematic literature review of 149 articles on startup funding. We find that startups possess different monetary and non-monetary needs depending on their life cycle stage, which influences their search for and selection of appropriate investors. In addition, we find numerous established and newly emerged equity and debt providers and their respective offerings. Based on our review, we propose a framework for allocating suitable investors to a startup’s life cycle stage and specific needs. We therefore extend the current dominant startup funding logics to incorporate a complementary view rather than understanding investors as substitutes. Hence, we contribute theoretically to the entrepreneurial finance literature and provide practical guidance for startups and investors.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Adelino M, Ma S, Robinson D (2017) Firm age, investment opportunities, and job creation. J Finance 72(3):999–1038 Ahmed H, Aassouli D (2022) Entrepreneurial finance, agency problems and Islamic ethics: complementarities and constraints. Ventur Cap 24(1):25–46 Amit R, Brander J, Zott C (1998) Why do venture capital firms exist? Theory and Canadian evidence. J Bus Ventur 13(6):441–466 Andrieu G, Groh AP (2012) Entrepreneurs’ financing choice between independent and bank-affiliated venture capital firms. J Corp Finance 18(5):1143–1167 Baum JAC, Silverman BS (2004) Picking winners or building them? Alliance, intellectual, and human capital as selection criteria in venture financing and performance of biotechnology startups. J Bus Ventur 19(3):411–436 Bellavitis C, Filatotchev I, Kamuriwo DS, Vanacker T (2017) Entrepreneurial finance: new frontiers of research and practice. Ventur Cap 19(1–2):1–16 Bellavitis C, Cumming D, Vanacker T (2022) Ban, boom, and echo! Entrepreneurship and initial coin offerings. Entrep Theory Pract 46(5):1136–1169 Bengtsson O (2011) Covenants in venture capital contracts. Manag Sci 57(11):1926–1943 Benson D, Ziedonis RH (2010) Corporate venture capital and the returns to acquiring portfolio companies. J Financ Econ 98(3):478–499 Berger AN, Udell GF (1998) The economics of small business finance: the roles of private equity and debt markets in the financial growth cycle. J Bank Finance 22(6–8):613–673 Bertoni F, Colombo MG, Quas A (2019) The role of governmental venture capital in the venture capital ecosystem: an organizational ecology perspective. Entrep Theory Pract 43(3):611–628 Blank S (2013) Why the lean start-up changes everything. Harv Bus Rev 91(5):63–72 Blaseg D, Cumming DJ, Koetter M (2021) Equity crowdfunding: high-quality or low-quality entrepreneurs? Entrep Theory Pract 45(3):505–530 Block JH, Sandner P (2009) What is the effect of the financial crisis on venture capital financing? Empirical evidence from US Internet start-ups. Ventur Cap 11(4):295–309 Block JH, Colombo MG, Cumming DJ, Vismara S (2018) New players in entrepreneurial finance and why they are there. Small Bus Econ 50:239–250 Block JH, Fisch CO, Obschonka M, Sandner PG (2019a) A personality perspective on business angel syndication. J Bank Finance 100:306–327 Block JH, Fisch C, Vismara S, Andres R (2019b) Private equity investment criteria: an experimental conjoint analysis of venture capital, business angels, and family offices. J Corp Finance 58:329–352 Block JH, Groh A, Hornuf L, Vanacker T, Vismara S (2021a) The entrepreneurial finance markets of the future: a comparison of crowdfunding and initial coin offerings. Small Bus Econ 57(2):865–882 Block JH, Hirschmann M, Fisch C (2021b) Which criteria matter when impact investors screen social enterprises? J Corp Finance 66:101813 Blomkvist M, Korkeamäki T, Takalo T (2022) Learning and staged equity financing. J Corp Finance 74:102217 Boccaletti S, Rossi E, Rossolini M (2022) How can SMEs signal their quality and growth orientation to the market? An analysis of the cost of Italian corporate mini-bonds. J Int Finance Manag Account 33(2):219–251 Böckel A, Hörisch J, Tenner I (2021) A systematic literature review of crowdfunding and sustainability: highlighting what really matters. Manag Rev Q 71:433–453 Callahan JL (2014) Writing literature reviews. Hum Resour Dev Rev 13(3):271–275 Cantamessa M, Gatteschi V, Perboli G, Rosano M (2018) Startups’ roads to failure. Sustainability 10(7):1–19 Chen WD (2023) Crowdfunding: different types of legitimacy. Small Bus Econ 60:245–263 Chen Q, Ding S, Wu Z, Yang F (2016) Family control, international accounting standards, and access to foreign banks: evidence from international entrepreneurial firms. J Small Bus Manag 54(2):598–621 Chua JH, Chrisman JJ, Kellermanns F, Wu Z (2011) Family involvement and new venture debt financing. J Bus Ventur 26(4):472–488 Cline BN, Fu X, Tang T (2020) Shareholder investment horizons and bank debt financing. J Bank Finance 110:105656 Cohen S, Fehder DC, Hochberg YV, Murray F (2019) The design of startup accelerators. Res Policy 48(7):1781–1797 Colombo O (2021) The use of signals in new-venture financing: a review and research agenda. J Manag 47(1):237–259 Colombo MG, Cumming DJ, Vismara S (2016) Governmental venture capital for innovative young firms. J Technol Transf 41(1):10–24 Colombo MG, Fisch C, Momtaz PP, Vismara S (2022a) The CEO beauty premium: founder CEO attractiveness and firm valuation in initial coin offerings. Strateg Entrep J 16(3):491–521 Colombo MG, Montanaro B, Vismara S (2022b) What drives the valuation of entrepreneurial ventures? A map to navigate the literature and research directions. Small Bus Econ. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-022-00688-5 Conti A, Thursby M, Rothaermel FT (2010) Show me what you have: signaling, angel and VC investments in technology startups. Acad Manag Proc 2010(1):1–6 Cumming DJ, Johan S (2017) The problems with and promise of entrepreneurial finance. Strateg Entrep J 11(3):357–370 Cumming DJ, Vismara S (2017) De-segmenting research in entrepreneurial finance. Ventur Cap 19(1–2):17–27 Cumming DJ, Deloof M, Manigart S, Wright M (2019) New directions in entrepreneurial finance. J Bank Finance 100:252–260 Cumming DJ, Meoli M, Vismara S (2021) Does equity crowdfunding democratize entrepreneurial finance? Small Bus Econ 56(2):533–552 Cumming DJ, Hervé F, Manthé E, Schwienbacher A (2022) Testing-the-waters policy with hypothetical investment: evidence from equity crowdfunding. Entrep Theory Pract 46(4):1019–1053 Dabić M, Vlačić B, Paul J, Dana LP, Sahasranamam S, Glinka B (2020) Immigrant entrepreneurship: a review and research agenda. J Bus Res 113:25–38 De Rassenfosse G, Fischer T (2016) Venture debt financing: determinants of the lending decision. Strateg Entrep J 10(3):235–256 Denis DJ (2004) Entrepreneurial finance: an overview of the issues and evidence. J Corp Finance 10(2):301–326 Drover W, Busenitz L, Matusik S, Townsend D, Anglin A, Dushnitsky G (2017) A review and road map of entrepreneurial equity financing research: venture capital, corporate venture capital, angel investment, crowdfunding, and accelerators. J Manag 43(6):1820–1853 Drucker P (2014) Innovation and entrepreneurship, 1st edn. Routledge, London Dudley E (2021) Social capital and entrepreneurial financing choice. J Corp Finance 70:102068 Dushnitsky G, Lenox MJ (2005) When do firms undertake RandD by investing in new ventures? Strateg Manag J 26(10):947–965 Estrin S, Khavul S, Wright M (2022) Soft and hard information in equity crowdfunding: network effects in the digitalization of entrepreneurial finance. Small Bus Econ 58(4):1761–1781 Fisch C (2019) Initial coin offerings (ICOs) to finance new ventures. J Bus Res 34(1):1–22 Fraser S, Bhaumik SK, Wright M (2015) What do we know about entrepreneurial finance and its relationship with growth? Int Small Bus J 33(1):70–88 Freeman J, Engel JS (2007) Models of innovation: startups and mature corporations. Calif Manag Rev 50(1):94–119 Frid CJ (2014) Acquiring financial resources to form new ventures: the impact of personal characteristics on organizational emergence. J Small Bus Entrep 27(3):323–341 Fryges H, Kohn K, Ullrich K (2015) The interdependence of RandD activity and debt financing of young firms. J Small Bus Manag 53:251–277 Fuertes-Callén Y, Cuellar-Fernández B, Serrano-Cinca C (2022) Predicting startup survival using first years financial statements. J Small Bus Manag 60(6):1314–1350 Graf-Vlachy L, Oliver AG, Banfield R, König A, Bundy J (2020) Media coverage of firms: background, integration, and directions for future research. J Manag 46(1):36–69 Gras D, Nason RS, Lerman M, Stellini M (2017) Going offline: broadening crowdfunding research beyond the online context. Ventur Cap 19(3):217–237 Gregson G, Bock AJ, Harrison RT (2017) A review and simulation of business angel investment returns. Ventur Cap 19(4):285–311 Gründerszene.de (2018) Gründerszene Datenbank: Unternehmen Zalando. https://www.gruenderszene.de/datenbank/unternehmen/zalando%0A Guenther C, Johan S, Schweizer D (2018) Is the crowd sensitive to distance? How investment decisions differ by investor type. Small Bus Econ 50(2):289–305 Hallen BL, Katila R, Rosenberg JD (2014) How do social defenses work? A resource-dependence lens on technology ventures, venture capital investors, and corporate relationships. Acad Manag J 57(4):1078–1101 Hatzijordanou N, Bohn N, Terzidis O (2019) A systematic literature review on competitor analysis: status quo and start-up specifics. Manag Rev Q 69(4):415–458 Hellmann T, Schure P, Vo DH (2021) Angels and venture capitalists: substitutes or complements? J Financ Econ 141(2):454–478 Hofmann A (2014) Alles über Zalando - eine Chronik. Gründerszene. https://www.gruender-szene.de/allgemein/zalando-geschichte-chronik%0A Hogan T, Hutson E, Drnevich P (2017) Drivers of external equity funding in small high-tech ventures. J Small Bus Manag 55(2):236–253 Hornuf L, Schwienbacher A (2018) Market mechanisms and funding dynamics in equity crowdfunding. J Corp Finance 50:556–574 Hornuf L, Klus MF, Lohwasser TS, Schwienbacher A (2021) How do banks interact with fintech startups? Small Bus Econ 57:1505–1526 Howell ST, Niessner M, Yermack D (2020) Initial coin offerings: financing growth with cryptocurrency token sales. Rev Financ Stud 33(9):3925–3974 Huang L, Pearce JL (2015) Managing the unknowable: the effectiveness of early-stage investor gut feel in entrepreneurial investment decisions. Adm Sci Q 60(4):634–670 Huang W, Meoli M, Vismara S (2020) The geography of initial coin offerings. Small Bus Econ 55(1):77–102 Isabelle D (2013) Key factors affecting a technology entrepreneur’s choice of incubator or accelerator. Technol Innov Manag Rev 3(2):16–22 Ismayil Y, Tunçalp D (2023) Research in new ventures’ nonmarket strategies: contributions and opportunities. Manag Rev Q 1–46 Jeon E, Maula M (2022) Progress toward understanding tensions in corporate venture capital: a systematic review. J Bus Ventur 37(4):106226 Kaiser M, Berger ES (2021) Trust in the investor relationship marketing of startups: a systematic literature review and research agenda. Manag Rev Q 71:491–517 Kang HD, Nanda VK, Park HD (2021) Technology spillovers and capital gains in corporate venture capital investments: evidence from the biopharmaceutical industry. Ventur Cap 23(2):129–155 Kerr WR, Lerner J, Schoar A (2014) The consequences of entrepreneurial finance: evidence from angel financings. Rev Financ Stud 27(1):20–55 Köhn A (2018) The determinants of startup valuation in the venture capital context: a systematic review and avenues for future research. Manag Rev Q 68(1):3–36 Kolokas D, Vanacker T, Veredas D, Zahra SA (2022) Venture capital, credit, and fintech start-up formation: a cross-country study. Entrep Theory Pract 46(5):1198–1230 Kumar A, Paul J, Unnithan AB (2020a) Masstige marketing: a review, synthesis and research agenda. J Bus Res 113:384–398 Kumar S, Sureka R, Colombage S (2020b) Capital structure of SMEs: a systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis. Manag Rev Q 70:535–565 Lamine W, Mian S, Fayolle A, Wright M, Klofsten M, Etzkowitz H (2018) Technology business incubation mechanisms and sustainable regional development. J Technol Transf 43:1121–1141 Lefebvre V (2021) Zero-debt capital structure and the firm life cycle: empirical evidence from privately held SMEs. Ventur Cap 23(4):371–387 Lehnertz N, Plagmann C, Lutz E (2022) Why deep pockets make great borrowers: an empirical analysis of venture loans. J Bus Econ 92:1431–1453 Luger M, Koo J (2005) Defining and tracking business start-ups. Small Bus Econ 24(1):17–28 Manigart S, Baeyens K, Van Hyfte W (2002) The survival of venture capital backed companies. Ventur Cap 4(2):103–124 Marsh P (1982) The choice between equity and debt: an empirical study. J Finance 37(1):121–144 Mietzner M, Proelss J, Schweizer D (2018) Hidden champions or black sheep? The role of underpricing in the German mini-bond market. Small Bus Econ 50(2):375–395 Milosevic M, Le Pendeven B, Fendt J (2020) Follow-on financing through syndication in the VC industry: a signaling perspective of VC human capital and fund characteristics. Ventur Cap 22(1):35–69 Miloud T, Aspelund A, Cabrol M (2012) Startup valuation by venture capitalists: an empirical study. Ventur Cap 14(2–3):151–174 Mishra R, Singh RK, Koles B (2021) Consumer decision-making in omnichannel retailing: literature review and future research agenda. Int J Consum Stud 45(2):147–174 Mochkabadi K, Volkmann CK (2020) Equity crowdfunding: a systematic review of the literature. Small Bus Econ 54(1):75–118 Mohammadi N, Sakhteh S (2022) Start-up accelerator value chain: a systematic literature review. Manag Rev Q 1–34 Montani D, Gervasio D, Pulcini A (2020) Startup company valuation: the state of art and future trends. Int Bus Res 13(9):31–45 Moritz A, Block J, Heinz A (2016) Financing patterns of European SMEs: an empirical taxonomy. Ventur Cap 18(2):115–148 Nanda R, Rhodes-Kropf M (2013) Investment cycles and startup innovation. J Financ Econ 110(2):403–418 Neuhaus J, Isaak A, Bostandzic D (2022) Million dollar personality: a systematic literature review on personality in crowdfunding. Manag Rev Q 72(2):309–345 Neumann T (2021) The impact of entrepreneurship on economic, social and environmental welfare and its determinants: a systematic review. Manag Rev Q 71(3):553–584 Nguyen B, Canh NP (2021) Formal and informal financing decisions of small businesses. Small Bus Econ 57(3):1545–1567 Nicholls-Nixon CL, Maxheimer MM (2022) How coaching services help early stage entrepreneurs: an exploration of gender differences. J Small Bus Enterp Dev 29(5):742–763 Parker SC, Van Praag CM (2012) The entrepreneur’s mode of entry: business takeover or new venture start? J Bus Ventur 27(1):31–46 Pasquini RA, Robiolo G, Sarria Allende V (2019) Matching in entrepreneurial finance networks. Ventur Cap 21(2–3):195–221 Paul J, Criado AR (2020) The art of writing literature review: what do we know and what do we need to know? Int Bus Rev 29(4):101717 Pena I (2004) Business incubation centers and new firm growth in the Basque country. Small Bus Econ 22(3):223–236 Pereiro LE (2001) Tango and cash: entrepreneurial finance and venture capital in Argentina. Ventur Cap 3(4):291–308 Picken JC (2017) From startup to scalable enterprise: laying the foundation. Bus Horiz 60(5):587–595 Polzin F, Toxopeus H, Stam E (2018) The wisdom of the crowd in funding: information heterogeneity and social networks of crowdfunders. Small Bus Econ 50(2):251–273 Quas A, Martí J, Reverte C (2021) What money cannot buy: a new approach to measure venture capital ability to add non-financial resources. Small Bus Econ 57(3):1361–1382 Radojevich-Kelley N, Hoffman DL (2012) Analysis of accelerator companies: an exploratory case study of their programs, processes, and early results. Small Bus Inst J 8(2):54–70 Ralcheva A, Roosenboom P (2020) Forecasting success in equity crowdfunding. Small Bus Econ 55(1):39–56 Rebouças R, Soares AM (2021) Voluntary simplicity: a literature review and research agenda. Int J Consum Stud 45(3):303–319 Riding A, Orser BJ, Chamberlin T (2012a) Investing in RandD: small- and medium-sized enterprise financing preferences. Ventur Cap 14(2–3):199–214 Riding A, Orser BJ, Spence M, Belanger B (2012b) Financing new venture exporters. Small Bus Econ 38(2):147–163 Robb AM, Robinson DT (2014) The capital structure decisions of new firms. Rev Financ Stud 27(1):153–179 Schückes M, Gutmann T (2021) Why do startups pursue initial coin offerings (ICOs)? The role of economic drivers and social identity on funding choice. Small Bus Econ 57:1027–1052 Sharma S, Malik K, Kaur M, Saini N (2021) Mapping research in the field of private equity: a bibliometric analysis. Manag Rev Q 72:1–29 Simón-Moya V, Revuelto-Taboada L, Ribeiro-Soriano D (2016) Influence of economic crisis on new SME survival: reality or fiction? Entrep Reg Dev 28(1–2):157–176 Södergren J (2021) Brand authenticity: 25 years of research. Int J Consum Stud 45(4):654–663 Stevenson RM, Kuratko DF, Eutsler J (2019) Unleashing main street entrepreneurship: crowdfunding, venture capital, and the democratization of new venture investments. Small Bus Econ 52(2):375–393 Stinchcombe AL (1965) Social structure and organizations. In: McNally R (ed) Handbook of organizations, pp 142–193 Svetek M (2022) Signaling in the context of early-stage equity financing: review and directions. Ventur Cap 24(1):71–104 Takahashi H (2015) Dynamics of bank relationships in entrepreneurial finance. J Corp Finance 34:23–31 Thies F, Huber A, Bock C, Benlian A, Kraus S (2019) Following the crowd: does crowdfunding affect venture capitalists’ selection of entrepreneurial ventures? J Small Bus Manag 57(4):1378–1398 Vaznyte E, Andries P (2019) Entrepreneurial orientation and start-ups’ external financing. J Bus Ventur 34(3):439–458 Vismara S (2016) Equity retention and social network theory in equity crowdfunding. Small Bus Econ 46(4):579–590 Walthoff-Borm X, Schwienbacher A, Vanacker T (2018) Equity crowdfunding: first resort or last resort? J Bus Ventur 33(4):513–533 Weiblen T, Chesbrough HW (2015) Engaging with startups to enhance corporate innovation. Calif Manag Rev 57(2):66–90 Yang X, Sun SL, Zhao X (2019) Search and execution: examining the entrepreneurial cognitions behind the lean startup model. Small Bus Econ 52:667–679 Yang X, Zhang H, Hu D, Wu B (2023) The timing dilemma: understanding the determinants of innovative startups’ patent collateralization for loans. Small Bus Econ 60:371–403 Yu S (2020) How do accelerators impact the performance of high-technology ventures? Manag Sci 66(2):530–552 Zellweger TM, Kammerlander N (2015) Family, wealth and governance: an agency account. Entrep Theory Pract 39(6):1281–1303