Manifestations of rural entrepreneurship: the journey so far and future pathways

Management Review Quarterly - Tập 71 - Trang 753-781 - 2020
Umesh Shrivastava1, Amit Kumar Dwivedi1
1Entrepreneurship Development Institute of India (EDII), Gandhinagar, India

Tóm tắt

Rural entrepreneurship has manifested into a diverse and progressive field of research in the last two decades. It has seen research amalgamating from different fields and faculties. Rural entrepreneurship however is scattered and lacks categorization. Therefore, literature review on rural entrepreneurship to understand what has been done and what can be done seems imperative. The main aim of this paper is to offer the readers a clear picture of different categories in rural entrepreneurship research. This aim is achieved by performing a Bibliometric citation analysis and thereafter a thematic analysis to identify major areas where rural entrepreneurship research has been concentrated in the last 20 years. The study is based on 158 papers on rural entrepreneurship published in the last two decades. Despite a vast pool of publications, four major themes are identified; Spatial dimension, Sustainability, Income Generation and Barriers in rural entrepreneurship. From these themes 16 sub-themes have emerged during the review. Many gaps are identified in each category and avenues for further advancement of rural entrepreneurship is discussed.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Afza T, Osman MHBM, Rashid MA (2010) Enterprising behavior of enterprise-less rural women entrepreneurs of Khyber PukhtanKhawa of Pakistan. Eur J Soc Sci 18(1):109–119 Akgün AA, Nijkamp P, Baycan T, Brons M (2010) Embeddedness of entrepreneurs in rural areas: a comparative rough set data analysis. Tijdschriftvooreconomischeensocialegeografie 101(5):538–553 Akgün AYA, Baycan-Levent TN, Nijkamp P, Poot J (2011) Roles of local and newcomer entrepreneurs in rural development: a comparative meta-analytic study. Reg Stud 45(9):1207–1223 Alemu AE, Adesina JO (2017) In search of rural entrepreneurship: non-farm household enterprises (NFEs) as instruments of rural transformation in Ethiopia. Afr Dev Rev 29(2):259–271 Aliyev F, Urkmez T, Wagner R (2019) A comprehensive look at luxury brand marketing research from 2000 to 2016: a bibliometric study and content Anal. Manag Rev Q 69(3):233–264 Anderson AR, McAuley A (1999) Marketing landscapes: the social context. Qual Mark Res: Int J 2(3):176–188 Anthopoulou T, Kaberis N, Petrou M (2017) Aspects and experiences of crisis in rural Greece. Narratives of rural resilience. J Rural Stud 52:1–11 Avramenko A, Silver JA (2009) Rural entrepreneurship: expanding the horizons. Int J Entrep Innov Manag 11(2):140–155 Azari MG, Allahyari MS, Abedi M (2017) Analysis of barriers against development of rural entrepreneurship in Guilan province, Iran. World Rev of Entrep Manag Sustain Dev 13(2–3):338–356 Bakas FE, Duxbury N, Vinagre de Castro T (2019) Creative tourism: catalysing artisan entrepreneur networks in rural Portugal. Int J Entrep Behav Res 25(4):731–752 Balfour B, Fortunato MW, Alter TR (2018) The creative fire: an interactional framework for rural arts-based development. Journal of Rural Studies 63:229–239 Barkley DL (2006) The value of case study research on rural entrepreneurship: Useful method. In Presented joint ERS-RUPRI conference exploring rural entrepreneurship: imperatives opportunities research, Washington, DC Bertella G, Cavicchi A (2017) From sharecroppers to “flying farmers”: new forms of tourism entrepreneurship in rural areas. E-review of Tourism Research 14(3):133–148 Besser TL, Miller NJ (2013) Community matters: successful entrepreneurship in remote rural US locations. Int J Entrep Innov 14(1):15–27 Block J, Fisch C (2020) Eight tips and questions for your bibliographic study in business and management research. Manag Rev Q 70:307–312 Block J, Fisch C, Rehan F (2019) Religion and entrepreneurship: a map of the field and a bibliometric analysis. Manag Rev Q 1–37 Bock BB (2004) Fitting in and multi-tasking: Dutch farm women’s strategies in rural entrepreneurship. Sociol Rural 44(3):245–260 Bomani M, Derera E (2018) Towards developing a strategic framework for stimulating rural Entrepreneurship in Kwazulu-Natal, South Africa: a case study of three municipalities. Int J Econ Finance Stud 10(1):150–166 Braun V, Clarke V (2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol 3(2):77–101 Brooker E, Joppe M (2014) Entrepreneurial approaches to rural tourism in The Netherlands: distinct differences. Tour Plan Dev 11(3):343–353 Cabras I, Bosworth G (2014) Embedded models of rural entrepreneurship: the case of pubs in Cumbria, North West of England. Local Econ 29(6–7):598–616 Cahn M (2008) Indigenous entrepreneurship, culture and micro-enterprise in the Pacific Islands: case studies from Samoa. Entrep Reg Dev 20(1):1–18 Chadha V, Chadha N (2008) A regional perspective on rural industrialisation in India: the case of Punjab economy. J Rur Dev 27:213–230 Chan SW, Omar SS, Ramlan R (2016) The relationship between entrepreneurial orientation and manufacturing operations of Malaysian SMEs rural entrepreneurs. Adv Sci Lett 22(5–6):1635–1639 Chaves R, Magalhães AM, Benedetti OIS, Blos ALF, da Silva TN (2010) Decision making and rural entrepreneurship: a case of commercial exploitation of dairy sheep. Braz J Manag Reg Dev 6(3):3–21 Chelule E, Van Greunen D, Herselman M, Veldsman A (2011) Mobi-incubation user experience for rural entrepreneurs in emerging economies. In: 2011 IST-Africa conference proceedings, IEEE, pp 1–9 Cieslik K, D’Aoust O (2018) Risky business? Rural entrepreneurship in subsistence markets: evidence from Burundi. Eur J Dev Res 30(4):693–717 Conley KL (2015) Does broadband matter for rural entrepreneurs or ‘Creative Class’ employees? Doctoral dissertation Copus A, Psaltopoulos D, Skuras D, Terluin I, Weingarten P, Giray, FH, Ratinger T (2008a) Approaches to rural typology in the European Union. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 47-54 Copus A, Skuras D, Tsegenidi K (2008b) Innovation and peripherality: An empirical comparative study of SMEs in six European Union member countries. Economic Geography 84(1):51–82 Custance P, Hingley M, Wilcox D (2011) Developing a novel health and well-being service: the value of utilising the restorative benefits of nature in the UK. J Mark Manag 27(3–4):386–400 Dabson B (2001) Supporting rural entrepreneurship. Explor Policy Opt New Rural Am 27:35–48 Deakins D, Bensemann J, Battisti M (2016) Entrepreneurial skill and regulation: evidence from primary sector rural entrepreneurs. Int J Entrep Behav Res 22(2):234–259 DeRosa M, McElwee G, Smith R (2019) Farm diversification strategies in response to rural policy: a case from rural Italy. Land Use Policy 81:291–301 Driga O, Lafuente E, Vaillant Y (2009) Reasons for the relatively lower entrepreneurial activity levels of rural women in Spain. Sociol Rural 49(1):70–96 Dubois A (2016) Transnationalising entrepreneurship in a peripheral region–The translocal embeddedness paradigm. J Rural Stud 46:1–11 Duncombe R, Heeks R (2002) Enterprise across the digital divide: information systems and rural microenterprise in Botswana. J Int Dev: J Dev Stud Assoc 14(1):61–74 Figueiredo E, Raschi A (2012) Immersed in green? Reconfiguring the Italian countryside through rural tourism promotional materials. In: Hyde KF, Ryan C, Woodside AG (eds) Field guide to case study research in tourism, hospitality and leisure. (Advances in Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research, Vol. 6), Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley, pp 17–44 Fisch C, Block J (2018) Six tips for your (systematic) literature review in business and management research. Manag Rev Q 68:103–106 Fortunato MWP (2014) Supporting rural entrepreneurship: a review of conceptual developments from research to practice. Commun Dev 45(4):387–408 Frazier B, Stoel L, Niehm L, Eckerson N (2013) Optimism for new business survival in rural communities: an institutional perspective. J Small Bus Entrep 26(5):443–462 Fuller-Love N, Midmore P, Thomas D, Henley A (2006) Entrepreneurship and rural economic development: a scenario analysis approach. Int J Entrep Behav Res 12(5):289–305 Gaddefors J, Anderson AR (2017) Entrepreneursheep and context: when entrepreneurship is greater than entrepreneurs. Int J Entrep Behav Res 23(2):267–278 Gaddefors J, Anderson AR (2019) Romancing the rural: reconceptualizing rural entrepreneurship as engagement with context (s). Int J Entrep Innov 20(3):159–169 Gerasymchuk NA (2009) Rural enterpreneurship development by means of organization of cooperation between small agricultural and agrotourist enterprises. Actual Probl Econ 99:96–101 Gertler MS (2010) Rules of the game: the place of institutions in regional economic change. Reg Stud 44(1):1–15 Gieryn TF (2000) A space for place in sociology. Ann Rev Sociol 26(1):463–496 Gobin VJ, Santos P, Toth R (2017) No longer trapped? Promoting entrepreneurship through cash transfers to ultra-poor women in northern Kenya. Am J Agric Econ 99(5):1362–1383 Gollwitzer PM, Sheeran P (2006) Implementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis of effects and processes. Adv Exp Soc Psychol 38:69–119 Greenberg Z, Farja Y, Gimmon E (2018) Embeddedness and growth of small businesses in rural regions. J Rural Stud 62:174–182 Gurau C (2009) Rural entrepreneurship in post-communist Romania. Int J Bus Glob 3(2):158–172 Guthey GT, Whiteman G, Elmes M (2014) Place and sense of place: implications for organizational studies of sustainability. J Manag Inq 23(3):254–265 Halloran A, Roos N, Flore R, Hanboonsong Y (2016) The development of the edible cricket industry in Thailand. Journal of Insects as Food and Feed 2(2):91–100 He X (2019) Digital entrepreneurship solution to rural poverty: theory, practice and policy implications. J Dev Entrep 24(01):1950004 Henry C, McElwee G (2014) Defining and conceptualising rural enterprise. In: Henry C, McElwee G (eds) Exploring rural enterprise: new perspectives on research, policy and practice. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley, pp 1–8 Hernández-Maestro RM, González-Benito Ó (2014) Rural lodging establishments as drivers of rural development. J Travel Res 53(1):83–95 Herslund L (2012) The rural creative class: counterurbanisation and entrepreneurship in the Danish countryside. Sociol Rural 52(2):235–255 Hukampal SS, Bhowmick B (2016) Innovation network for entrepreneurship development in rural Indian context: exploratory factor analysis. Int J Innov Technol Manag 13(04):1650016 Iivonen S, Kyrö P, Mynttinen S, Särkkä-Tirkkonen M, Kahiluoto H (2011) Social capital and entrepreneurial behaviour advancing innovativeness in interaction between small rural entrepreneurs and researchers: a phenomenographic study. J Agric Educ Ext 17(1):37–51 Johnstone H, Lionais D (2004) Depleted communities and community business entrepreneurship: revaluing space through place. Entrep Reg Dev 16(3):217–233 Jones MV, Coviello N, Tang YK (2011) International entrepreneurship research (1989–2009): a domain ontology and thematic analysis. J Bus Ventur 26(6):632–659 Kajanus M, Kangas J, Kurttila M (2004) The use of value focused thinking and the A’WOT hybrid method in tourism management. Tour Manag 25(4):499–506 Kalantaridis C, Bika Z (2006) Local embeddedness and rural entrepreneurship: case-study evidence from Cumbria, England. Environ Plan A 38(8):1561–1579 Katekhaye D, Meyer N, Magda R (2019) Entrepreneurial core motivation as a success factor for rural entrepreneurship in Western India. Polish J Manag Stud 19 Kelemen E, Megyesi B, Kalamász IN (2008) Knowledge dynamics and sustainability in rural livelihood strategies: two case studies from Hungary. Sociol Rural 48(3):257–273 Khanduja D, Kaushik P (2008) Synergising entrepreneurship, incubated business and socioeconomic upliftment in rural India. Int J Entrep Small Bus 6(1):68–79 Kimhi A (2010) Entrepreneurship and income inequality in southern Ethiopia. Small Bus Econ 34(1):81 Korsgaard S, Ferguson R, Gaddefors J (2015) The best of both worlds: how rural entrepreneurs use placial embeddedness and strategic networks to create opportunities. Entrep Reg Dev 27(9–10):574–598 Koyana S, Mason RB (2017) Rural entrepreneurship and transformation: the role of learnerships. Int J Entrep Behav Res Kraus S, Filser M, O’Dwyer M, Shaw E (2014) Social entrepreneurship: an exploratory citation analysis. RMS 8(2):275–292 Kulawczuk P (1998) The development of entrepreneurship in rural areas. The Transfer of Power: Decentralization in Central and Eastern Europe (97–109). Budapest, Hungary: The Local Government and Service Form Initiative Kumar S, Sureka R, Colombage S (2019) Capital structure of SMEs: a systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis. Manag Rev Q 4:1–31 Lafuente E, Vaillant Y, Rialp J (2007) Regional differences in the influence of role models: comparing the entrepreneurial process of rural Catalonia. Reg Stud 41(6):779–796 Lan H, Zhu Y, Ness D, Xing K, Schneider K (2014) The role and characteristics of social entrepreneurs in contemporary rural cooperative development in China: case studies of rural social entrepreneurship. Asia Pac Bus Rev 20(3):379–400 Lang R, Fink M (2019) Rural social entrepreneurship: the role of social capital within and across institutional levels. J Rural Stud 70:155–168 Lekhanya LM, Visser K (2016) Risks and factors contributing towards rural entrepreneurial orientation growth of business in an emerging economy. Risk governance & control: financial markets & institutions. 6(4):72–83 Lokesh J(2016) A study on integrated, innovative and inclusive framework for mobile telecom service users in rural Punjab (Doctoral dissertation, Lovely Professional University) Lordkipanidze M, Brezet H, Backman M (2005) The entrepreneurship factor in sustainable tourism development. Journal of cleaner production 13(8):787–798 Los Ríos-Carmenado D, Ortuño M, Rivera M (2016) Private–public partnership as a tool to promote entrepreneurship for sustainable development: WWP torrearte experience. Sustainability 8(3):199 Lourenço F, Sappleton N, Dardaine-Edwards A, McElwee, G., Cheng, R., Taylor, D. W., & Taylor, A. G. (2014). Experience of entrepreneurial training for female farmers to stimulate entrepreneurship in Uganda. Gender Manag: An Int J 29(7):382–401 Lundmark L, Müller DK (2010) The supply of nature-based tourism activities in Sweden. Turizam: međunarodniznanstveno-stručničasopis 58(4):379–393 Lyons TS (2002) Building social capital for rural enterprise development: three case studies in the United States. J Dev Entrep 7(2):193 Mackay M, Nelson T, Perkins HC (2018) Interpretive walks: advancing the use of mobile methods in the study of entrepreneurial farm tourism settings. Geogr Res 56(2):167–175 Magliacani M, Madeo E (2018) Exploring “culturalization” in rural entrepreneurial context through content analysis. Knowl Process Manag 25(4):292–301 Markantoni M, Van Hoven B (2012) Bringing ‘invisible’side activities to light. A case study of rural female entrepreneurs in the Veenkoloniën, the Netherlands. J Rural Stud 28(4):507–516 Mayer H, Habersetzer A, Meili R (2016) Rural–urban linkages and sustainable regional development: the role of entrepreneurs in linking peripheries and centers. Sustainability 8(8):745 McElwee G (2006) Farmers as entrepreneurs: developing competitive skills. J Dev Entrep 11(03):187–206 McElwee G, Atherton A (2011) 42 rural entrepreneurship. World Encycl Entrep 377–384 McElwee G, Smith R, Somerville P (2018) Conceptualising animation in rural communities: the Village SOS case. Entrep Reg Dev 30(1–2):173–198 Meccheri N, Pelloni G (2006) Rural entrepreneurs and institutional assistance: an empirical study from mountainous Italy. Entrep Reg Dev 18(5):371–392 MikkoVesala K, Peura J, McElwee G (2007) The split entrepreneurial identity of the farmer. J Small Bus Enterp Dev 14(1):48–63 Moreira AC, Martins SPL (2009) CRER: an integrated methodology for the incubation of business ideas in rural communities in Portugal. J Enterp Commun: People Places Glob Econ 3(2):176–192 Muhammad N, McElwee G, Dana LP (2017) Barriers to the development and progress of entrepreneurship in rural Pakistan. Int J Entrep Behav Res 23(2):279–295 Müller S, Korsgaard S (2018) Resources and bridging: the role of spatial context in rural entrepreneurship. Entrep Reg Dev 30(1–2):224–255 Muñoz P, Kimmitt J (2019) Rural entrepreneurship in place: an integrated framework. Entrep Reg Dev 31(9–10):1–32 Ngorora PG, Mago S (2018) Prospects of entrepreneurship in South Africa’s rural areas: a case study of Eastern Cape Province’s Nkonkobe Municipal Area. Afr J Hosp Tour Leisure 7(2):1–16 North D, Smallbone D (2006) Developing entrepreneurship and enterprise in Europe’s peripheral rural areas: some issues facing policy-makers. Eur Plan Stud 14(1):41–60 Pato ML, Teixeira AA (2016) Twenty years of rural entrepreneurship: a bibliometric survey. Sociol Rural 56(1):3–28 Paul KC, Hamazah A, Samah BA, Ismail IA, D’Silva JL (2014) Rural Malay involvement in Malaysian herbal entrepreneurship. Asian Soc Sci 10(2):202 Pfister U (2001) Women’s bread—men’s capital: the domestic economy of small textile entrepreneurs in rural Zurich in the 17th and 18th centuries. Hist Family 6(2):147–166 Pittaway L, Cope J (2007) Entrepreneurship education: a systematic review of the evidence. Int Small Bus J 25(5):479–510 Podsakoff PM, MacKenzie SB, Bachrach DG, Podsakoff NP (2005) The influence of management journals in the 1980s and 1990s. Strateg Manag J 26(5):473–488 Prasad VC, Ganvir V (2005) Study of the principles of innovation for the BOP consumer—the case of a rural water filter. Int J Innov Technol Manag 2(04):349–366 Ranjan R (2015) Rural entrepreneurism and developmental outcomes under climate change threats. Clim Dev 7(4):353–366 Renski H (2008) New firm entry, survival, and growth in the United States: a comparison of urban, suburban, and rural areas. J Am Plan Assoc 75(1):60–77 Rooks G, Klyver K, Sserwanga A (2016) The context of social capital: a comparison of rural and urban entrepreneurs in Uganda. Entrep Theory Pract 40(1):111–130 Sadeghloo T, SojasiQeidari H, Salehi M, FaalJalali A (2018) Obstacles and methods of financing for the development of local entrepreneurship in Iran. Int J Dev Issues 17(1):114–138 Shahraki H, Movahedi R (2017) Reconceptualizing rural entrepreneurship discourse from a social constructionist perspective: a case study from Iran. Middle East Critique 26(1):79–100 Singh S (2013) Post-green revolution agro-entrepreneurship among capitalist farmers in Indian Punjab and Andhra Pradesh. J Entrep 22(2):161–180 Smith R (2006) Narrating the decline of subsistence entrepreneurship in a Scottish fishing community: 1934-2004. Int J Entrep Behav Res 12(1):40–62 Smith R (2017) Examining the characteristics, philosophies, operating practices and growth strategies of village entrepreneurs. Int J Entrep Behav Res 23(4):708–725 Spigel B (2017) The relational organization of entrepreneurial ecosystems. Entrep Theory Pract 41(1):49–72 Stathopoulou S, Psaltopoulos D, Skuras D (2004) Rural entrepreneurship in Europe: a research framework and agenda. Int J Entrep Behav Res 10(6):404–425 Stefan EB (2014) The management education of the rural entrepreneur. Amfiteatru Econ J 16(37):932–950 Steiner A, Atterton J (2014) The contribution of rural businesses to community resilience. Local Economy 29(3):228–244 Suntornpithug N, Suntornpithug P (2008) Don’t give them the fish, show them how to fish: framework of market-driven entrepreneurship in Thailand. J Small Bus Entrep 21(2):181–193 Sur M, Zhang J, Chen K (2014) The investment climate and enterprise performance in rural Pakistan: implications for rural non-farm employment generation. J Asia Pac Econ 19(3):488–505 Tate G (2010) Entrepreneurship and the environment for rural SMEs in the Shropshire Hills, UK, 1997–2009. J Entrep 19(2):191–207 Terluin IJ (2003) Differences in economic development in rural regions of advanced countries: an overview and critical analysis of theories. J Rural Stud 19(3):327–344 Theodorakopoulos N, Preciado DJS, Bennett D (2012) Transferring technology from university to rural industry within a developing economy context: the case for nurturing communities of practice. Technovation 32(9–10):550–559 Traore A, Bickersteth S (2011) Addressing the challenges of agricultural service provision: the case of Oxfam’s strategic cotton programme in Mali. Int J Agric Sustain 9(1):82–90 Ukanwa I, Anderson A (2018) Experiencing microfinance: effects on poor women entrepreneurs’ livelihood strategies. J Small Bus Enterp Dev 25(3):428–446 Vaillant Y, Lafuente E (2007) Do different institutional frameworks condition the influence of local fear of failure and entrepreneurial examples over entrepreneurial activity? Entrep Reg Dev 19(4):313–337 Vaismoradi M, Turunen H, Bondas T (2013) Content analysis and thematic analysis: implications for conducting a qualitative descriptive study. Nursing Health Sci 15(3):398–405 Van der Ploeg JD, Renting H, Brunori G, Knickel K, Mannion J, Marsden T, Ventura F (2000) Rural development: from practices and policies towards theory. Sociol Rural 40(4):391–408 Van Eck NJ, Waltman L (2014) Visualizing bibliometric networks. In: Ding Y, Rousseau R, Wolfram D (eds) Measuring scholarly impact. Springer, Cham Vesala KM, Peura J, McElwee G (2007) The split entrepreneurial identity of the farmer. J Small Bus Enterp Dev 14(1):48–56 Victurine R (2000) Building tourism excellence at the community level: capacity building for community-based entrepreneurs in Uganda. J Travel Res 38(3):221–229 Vik J, McElwee G (2011) Diversification and the entrepreneurial motivations of farmers in Norway. J Small Bus Manage 49(3):390–410 Von Reichert C, Cromartie JB, Arthun RO (2014) Reasons for returning and not returning to rural US communities. Prof Geogr 66(1):58–72 Wang JH, Chang CC, Yao SN, Liang C (2016) The contribution of self-efficacy to the relationship between personality traits and entrepreneurial intention. High Educ 72(2):209–224 Warren-Smith I (2014) Supporting female rural entrepreneurship: a case study of WiRE (Women in Rural Enterprise). In: Henry C, McElwee G (eds) Exploring rural enterprise: new perspectives on research, policy and practice. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley, pp 215–232 Warren-Smith I, Monk AS (2007) The socio-economic contribution of farm based female rural entrepreneurs. J R Agric Soc Engl 168:1 Weber P, Carlsen J (2009) Successful rural hosted accommodation in Western Australia: gender matters. In: Galindo MA, Guzman J, Ribeiro D. (eds.) Entrepreneurship and business. Springer, Berlin. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-70902-2_12 Whiteman G, Cooper WH (2000) Ecological embeddedness. Acad Manag J 43(6):1265–1282 Wortman MS Jr (1990) Rural entrepreneurship research: an integration into the entrepreneurship field. Agribusiness 6(4):329–344 Yadav V, Goyal P (2015) User innovation and entrepreneurship: case studies from rural India. J Innov Entrep 4(1):5 Young S (2010) The “moral hazards” of microfinance: restructuring rural credit in India. Antipode 42(1):201–223 Yu J, Zhou JX, Wang Y, Xi Y (2013) Rural entrepreneurship in an emerging economy: reading institutional perspectives from entrepreneur stories. J Small Bus Manag 51(2):183–195 Yuan J, Tsai T, Chang P (2018) Toward an entrepreneurship typology of bed and breakfasts. J Hosp Tour Res 42(8):1315–1336 Zahra SA (2007) Contextualizing theory building in entrepreneurship research. J Bus Ventur 22(3):443–452