Linking geological heritage and geoethics with a particular emphasis on palaeontological heritage: the new concept of ‘palaeontoethics’
Tóm tắt
Geoconservation and geoethics are two emergent domains in geosciences. During the last decade, both topics have increasingly gained the attention of geoscientists and the society, but the main geoethical dilemmas related to the conservation and management of geoheritage are not clearly identified yet. This work aims at providing an overview on the meaning and scope of geoethics and how it intersects geoheritage and the practice of geoconservation. Some case studies—many of which are under current debate and have a high potential as geoeducational resources—are presented for addressing ethical, social and cultural settings as well as dilemmas affecting geoheritage. We find that there are particular cases (mostly concerning the trade of fossils, and in particular the growing concern about activities that rely on amber from Myanmar) for which a clear dichotomy of views makes them much more problematic and complex. These cases deserve more suitable legal frameworks that help implement more balanced ethical standards and practice guidelines for geoconservation, guarantee human rights and needs in relation to that heritage and contribute to the advancement of geosciences. Particular attention is given to palaeontological heritage, as fossils are among the most threatened elements of the Earth’s diversity and are in need of more effective and statutory protection measures. In the context of geoethics applied to palaeontological heritage, and given the need of a clear understanding of what ethics in palaeontology means, a new concept—palaeontoethics—is proposed and formally defined.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Alcalá L, Morales J (1994) Towards a definition of Spanish palaeontological heritage. In: O’Halloran D, Green C, Harley M, Stanley M, Knill J (eds) Geological and Landscape Conservation. Geological Society, London, pp 57–61
Alegret L, Ortiz S (2010) El corte de Zumaya (España): registro de los foraminíferos bentónicos del Paleógeno inferior. Rev Mex Cienc Geol 27:477–489
Alegret L, Ortiz S, Orue-Etxebarria X, Bernaola G, Baceta JI, Monechi S, Apellaniz E, Pujalte V (2009) The paleocene-eocene thermal maximum: new data from the microfossil turnover at the Zumaia section, Spain. Palaios 24:318–328
Antić A, Peppoloni S, Di Capua G (2020) Applying the values of geoethics for sustainable speleotourism development. Geoheritage 12:73
Arenillas I, Arz JA, Molina E (2004) A new high-resolution planktic foraminiferal zonation and subzonation for the lower Danian. Lethaia 37:79–95
Arz JA, Arenillas I, Molina E (1999) Extinción de foraminíferos planctónicos en el tránsito Cretácico-Terciario de Zumaya (Guipúzcoa): ¿supervivencia o reelaboración? Rev Esp Micropal 31(3):297–304
Barret P, Johanson Z (2020) Myanmar amber fossils: a legal as well as ethical quagmire. Nature 586(7831):674–674
Barroso-Barcenilla F, Cambra-Moo O, Escaso F, Ortega F, Pascual A, Pérez-García A, Rodríguez-Lázaro J, Sanz JL, Segura M, Torices A (2009) New and exceptional discovery in the Upper Cretaceous of the Iberian Peninsula: the palaeontological site of “Lo Hueco”, Cuenca, Spain. Cretac Res 30(5):1268–1278
Brilha J (2015) Mining and geoconservation. In: Tiess G, Majumder T, Cameron P (eds) Encyclopedia of mineral and energy policy. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-40871-7_9-1 2p
Brilha J (2018) Geoheritage: inventories and evaluation. In: Reynard E, Brilha J (eds) Geoheritage: assessment, protection and management. Elsevier, Chennai, pp 69–85
Brilha J (2021) Geoheritage. In: Elias S, Alderton D (eds) Encyclopedia of geology, 2nd edn. Elsevier, pp 569–578. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-409548-9.12106-2
Brilha J, Gray M, Pereira DI, Pereira P (2018) Geodiversity: an integrative review as a contribution to the sustainable management of the whole of nature. Environ Sci Policy 86:19–28
Bobrowsky P, Cronin V, Di Capua G, Kieffer S, Peppoloni S (2017) The emerging field of geoethics. In: Gundersen LC (ed) Scientific integrity and ethics: with applications to the geosciences (Special Publication 73). American Geophysical Union, Washington, DC, pp 175–212
Budik P, Turek V (2003) Trilobitenland Tschechien. Officiel Katalog der 40. Mineralientage München GEOFA Deutsche Geo-Fachmesse. Fachhändlertag 31:94–99
Canudo JI, Molina E (1992) Planktic foraminiferal faunal turnover and bio-chronostratigraphy of the Paleocene-Eocene boundary at Zumaya, northern Spain. Rev Soc Geol Esp 5(1–2):145–157
Di Capua G, Peppoloni S (2019) Defining geoethics. Website of the IAPG - International Association for Promoting Geoethics. http://www.geoethics.org/definition
Dowling R (2011) Geotourism’s Global Growth. Geoheritage 3:1–13
Dunkley Jones T, Manners H, Hoggett M, Kirkland Turner S, Westerhold T, Leng MJ, Pancost RD, Ridgwell A, Alegret L, Duller R, Grimes ST (2018) Dynamics of sediment flux to a bathyal continental margin section through the paleocene–eocene thermal maximum. Clim past 14:1035–1049
Finney SC, Hilario A (2017) GSSPs as international geostandards and as global geoheritage. In: Reynard E, Brilha J (eds) Geoheritage: assessment, protection, and management. Elsevier, Chennai, pp 179–189
Foss SE (2019) Geoethics in the Field: Leading by Example. Earth 8:8–10
Gayubar A, Arenillas I, Molina E (2001) Santaliestra: Un paraíso geológico y paleontológico amenazado. Nat Arag 7:29–35
Gordon JE (2019) Geoconservation principles and protected area management. Int J Geoheritage Parks 7:199–210
Gray M (2013) Geodiversity: valuing and conserving abiotic nature, 2nd edn. Wiley Blackwell, Chichester, p xi + 495
Gutiérrez-Marco JC (2020) Recherche géologique, géoconservation et exploitation commerciale des sites fossilifères. Actes de la Session Plénière Solennelle, Académie Hassan II des Sciences et Techniques, Rabat, 25–27 février 2020, 107–140
Gutiérrez-Marco JC, García-Bellido DC (2018) The international fossil trade from the Paleozoic of the Anti-Atlas, Morocco. In: Hunter AW, Álvaro JJ, Lefebvre B, Van Roy P, Zamora S (eds) The great ordovician biodiversification event: insights from the Tafilalt Biota, Morocco, Geological Society, London, Special Publications, pp 1–28
Haug JT, Azar D, Ross A et al (2020) Comment on the letter of the society of vertebrate paleontology (SVP) dated April 21, 2020 regarding “fossils from conflict zones and reproducibility of fossil-based scientific data”: Myanmar amber. PalZ 94:431–437
Hendey QB (1989) Langebaanweg: a record of past life. South African Museum, Cape Town, 71 pp
Henriques MH, Pena dos Reis R, Brilha J, Mota TS (2011) Geoconservation as an emerging geoscience. Geoheritage 3:117–128
Henriques MH, Pena dos Reis R (2015) Framing the palaeontological heritage within the geological heritage: an integrative vision. Geoheritage 7:249–259
Henriques MH, Pena dos Reis R (2019) Improving geoconservation of the palaeontological heritage through a semiotic vision. Spanish J Palaeontol 34(1):95–102
Jones ED (2020) Assumptions of authority: the story of Sue the T-rex and controversy over access to fossils. Hist Philos Life Sci 42:2
Liston JJ, You H-L (2015) Chinese fossil protection law and the illegal export of vertebrate fossils from China. J Vertebr Paleontol 35:1–7
Manni R (2012) Paleontological Museums and Geoethics. Ann Geophys 55(3):469–472
Mayer T (2015) Research integrity: the bedrock of the geosciences. In: Wyss M, Peppoloni S (eds) Geoethics: ethical challenges and case studies in earth sciences. Elsevier, Waltham, pp 71–81
Matteucci R, Gosso G, Peppoloni S, Piacente S, Wasowski J (2014) The geoethical promise: a proposal. Episodes 37(3):190–191
Mazák JH (2012) Retraction for Christiansen and Mazák, a primitive late pliocene cheetah, and evolution of the cheetah lineage. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 109(37):15072
Meléndez G (2018) Palaeontological heritage in Spain: from conservation to education. Geoheritage 10(3):341–342
Meléndez G, Soria M (1994) The legal framework and scientific procedure for the protection of palaeontological sites in Spain: recovery of some special sites affected by human activity in Aragón (Eastern Spain). In: O’Halloran D, Green C, Harley M, Stanley M, Knill J (eds) Geological and landscape conservation. The geological society, London, pp 329–334
Meléndez G, Soria-Llop C (2000a) El debate del patrimonio paleontológico en España: el papel de la sociedad, las administraciones públicas y los paleontólogos. Geotemas 1(2):317–320
Meléndez G, Soria-Llop C (2000b) Protecting the palaeontological heritage in Spain: public awareness and legislation, and the role of the Spanish palaeontological society. In: Barettino D, Wimbledon WAP, Gallego E (eds) Geological heritage: its conservation and management. Instituto Tecnológico Geominero de España, Madrid, pp 185–201
Molina E, Arenillas I, Pardo E (1999) High resolution planktic foraminiferal biostratigraphy and correlation across the Paleocene/Eocene boundary in the Tethys. Bull Soc Géol Fr 174(4):521–530
Molina E, Alegret L, Arenillas I, Arz JA, Gallala N, Grajales-Nishimura M, Murillo-Muñetón G, Zaghbib-Turki D (2009) The global boundary stratotype section and point for the base of the Danian stage (paleocene, paleogene, “tertiary”, cenozoic): auxiliary sections and correlation. Episodes 32(2):84–95
Morales J, Baquedano E (2017) La colina de los Tigres Dientes de Sable: Los yacimientos miocenos del Cerro de los Batallones (Torrejón de Velasco, Comunidad de Madrid). Obra Social La Caixa. CSIC, Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, Museo Arqueológico Regional. Comunidad de Madrid. 600 pp
Ortega F, Sanz, JL, Barroso-Barcenilla F, Cambra-Moo O, Escaso F, García-Oliva M, Marcos-Fernández F (2008) El yacimiento de macrovertebrados fósiles del Cretácico Superior de "Lo Hueco" (Fuentes, Cuenca). In: Steve J, Meléndez, G (eds) Paleontológica Nova (IV EJIP), Universidad de Zaragoza, Publicaciones del Seminario de Paleontología de Zaragoza, SEPAZ, 8, pp 119–131
Page KN (2004) The protection of Jurassic sites and fossils: challenges for global Jurassic science (including a proposed statement on the conservation of palaeontological heritage and stratotypes). Riv Ital Paleontol Stratigr 110(1):373–379
Page KN (2018) Fossils, heritage and conservation: managing demands on a precious resource. In: Reynard E, Brilha J (eds) Geoheritage: assessment, protection, and management. Elsevier, Chennai, pp 107–128
Page KN, Wimbledon W (2008) The conservation of Jurassic heritage in the UK - a critical review of the role of governmental organisations and their effectiveness. Volumina Jurassica 6:163–173
Page KN, Meléndez G (1995) Protecting the Jurassic: global boundary stratotypes and conservation. Geol Today 11(6):226–228
Page KN, Meléndez G, Gonera M (1999) Protected sites or protected heritage? – Systems and opinions for palaeontological conservation from a trans-European perspective. In: Barettino D, Vallejo M, Gallego E (eds) Towards the balanced management and conservation of the geological heritage in the new millenium. Sociedad Geológica de España, Madrid, pp 45–51
Palacio-Prieto JL, Gómez-Aguado de Alba GC (2014) Caverns and geotourism in Mexico: the case of the Cacahuamilpa Cavern. Int J Geoheritage 2(1):56–64
Peppoloni S, Di Capua G (2015) Geoethics, the role and responsibility of geoscientists. Geological Society of London, Special Publications, 419. 187 pp
Peppoloni S, Di Capua G (2016) Geoethics: ethical, social, and cultural values in geosciences research, practice, and education. In: Wessel G, Greenberg J (eds) Geoscience for the public good and global development: toward a sustainable future, Geological Society of America, special paper 520, 17–21
Peppoloni S, Di Capua G (2020) Geoethics as global ethics to face grand challenges for humanity. In: Di Capua G, Brobowsky PT, Kieffer SW, Palinkas C (eds) Geoethics: status and future perspectives. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 508, 1–17
Peppoloni S, Bilham N, Di Capua G (2019) Contemporary geoethics within the geosciences. In: Bohle M (ed) Exploring geoethics: ethical implications, societal contexts, and professional obligations of the geosciences. Palgrave Pivot, pp 25–7
Prosser CD, Brown EJ, Larwood JG, Bridgland DR (2013) Geoconservation for science and society – an agenda for the future. Proc Geol Assoc 124:561–567
Rayfield EJ, Theodor JM, Polly PD (2020) Fossils from conflict zones and reproducibility of fossil-based scientific data. Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (SVP), letter, 21/04/2020
Ripple JW, Wolf C, Newsome TM, Barnard P, Moomaw WR (2020) World scientists’ warning of a climate emergency. Bioscience 70(1):8–12
Robinson E (2001) In defence of the amateur collector. In: Bassett MG, King AH, Larwood JG, Parkinson NA, Deisler VK (eds) A future for fossils, national museum of wales geological series No. 19, Cardiff: 76–79
Schaub H (1969) L’Illerdien, état actuel du problème. Mémoire Du BRGM 69:256–266
Schaub H (1992) The campo section (NE Spain), a tethyan parastratrotype of the Cuisian. Neues Jahrb Geol Palaontol Abh 186:63–70
Schmitz B, Pujalte V, Molina E, Monechi S, Orue-Etxebarria X, Alegret L, Apellaniz E, Arenillas I, Aubry MP, Baceta JI, Berggren W, Bernaola G, Caballero F, Clemmensen A, Dinarès-Turell J, Dupuis Ch, Heilmann-Clausen C, Hilario A, Knox R, Martín-Rubio M, Ortiz S, Payros A, Petrizzio MR, von Salis K, Speijer R, Sprong R, Steurbaut E, Thomsen E (2011) The global boundary stratotype sections and points for the bases of the Selandian (middle paleocene) and Thanetian (upper paleocene) stages at Zumaia, Spain. Episodes 34(4):220–243
Štrba L, Krsak B, Sidor C (2018) Some comments to geosite assessment, visitors, and geotourism sustainability. Sustainability 10:2589. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10082589
Tičar J, Tomić N, Valjavec MB, Zorn M, Marković SB, Gavrilov MB (2018) Speleotourism in Slovenia: balancing between mass tourism and geoheritage protection. Open Geosci 10(1):344–357
Tortell PD (2020) Earth 2020: Science, society, and sustainability in the anthropocene. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 117:8683–8691
Triebold M (2007) Fossils: new journal will oppose illegal trade. Nature 446:136
Wang X (2013) Mortgaging the future of Chinese paleontology. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110(9):3201
Wiedmann T, Lenzen M, Keyßer LT, Steinberger JK (2020) Scientists’ Warning on Affluence. Nat Commun 11:3107
Wimbledon WAP, Smith-Meyers S (2012) Geoheritage in Europe and its conservation. ProGEO, Oslo
Zhou Z-H, Clarke JA, Zhang F (2002) Archaeoraptor’s better half. Nature 420:285–285