Licensed to Drive, but Not to Work: The Labor Market Effects of Driver Licenses for Unauthorized Immigrants
Tóm tắt
Private transportation is often a prerequisite for access to work in the USA. But until recently, driving legally was impossible for the about 11 million unauthorized immigrants in the country. How did unauthorized immigrants’ labor market outcomes change when some states allowed them to get driver licenses? This paper uses American Community Survey microdata from 2010 to 2019 to examine the labor market effects of a recent policy change in California that gave about 2.6 million unauthorized immigrants access to driver licenses. Focusing on unauthorized immigrants of Mexican origin, I find that driver licenses improve this population’s access to private transportation by increasing car ownership rates and the propensity of driving to work. While driver licenses do not improve employment rates among likely unauthorized Mexican immigrants, they raise hours worked and earnings among those who are already employed. The effect on likely unauthorized Mexican immigrants’ employment remains insignificant across genders, age groups, and measures of local labor market accessibility. A power analysis, a placebo test, and several alternative model specifications support the robustness of my results. The paper’s findings suggest that driver licenses have smaller benefits for unauthorized immigrants than for other populations. The lack of employment authorization prevents unauthorized immigrants from enjoying the full benefits of private transportation.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Amuedo-Dorantes C, Arenas-Arroyo E, Sevilla A. Labor market impacts of states issuing driver’s licenses to undocumented immigrants. Labour Econ. 2020;63:101805.
Australian Bureau of Statistics. 2020. “9309.0 - Motor Vehicle Census, Australia, 31 Jan 2018.”. URL: https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/[email protected]/Lookup/9309.0Main+Features131%20Jan%202018. Accessed 13 Jun 2020.
Bania N, Coulton C, Leete L. Welfare Reform and Access to Job Opportunities in the Cleveland Metropolitan Area. Cleveland, OH: Center on Urban Poverty and Social Change; 1999.
Bansak C, Mattson H, Rice L. Cars, employment, and single mothers: the effect of welfare asset restrictions. Ind Relat. 2010;49(3):321–45.
Baum CL. The effects of vehicle ownership on employment. J Urban Econ. 2009;66(3):151–63.
Borjas GJ. The labor supply of undocumented immigrants. Labour Econ. 2017;46(1):1–13.
Bratsberg B, Reagan JF, Nasir ZM. The effect of naturalization on wage growth: a panel study of young male immigrants. J Labor Econ. 2002;20(3):568–97.
Cáceres M, Jameson KP. The effects on insurance costs of restricting undocumented immigrants’ access to driver licenses. South Econ J. 2015;81(4):907–27.
Capps R, Bachmeier JD, Fix M, van Hook J. A demographic, socioeconomic, and health coverage profile of unauthorized immigrants in the United States: Migration Policy Institute Issue Brief 5; 2013. https://www.migrationpolicy.org/research/demographic-socioeconomic-and-health-coverage-profile-unauthorized-immigrants-united-state. Accessed 13 Mar 2020.
Card D. The impact of the Mariel Boatlift on the Miami labor market. Ind Labor Relat Rev. 1990;43(2):245–57.
Cervero R, Sandoval O, Landis J. Transportation as a stimulus of welfare-to-work: private versus public mobility. J Plan Educ Res. 2002;22(1):50–63.
Cho, H. 2020. “Driver’s license reforms and job accessibility among undocumented immigrants.” unpublished manuscript. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. URL: http://heepyungcho.web.illinois.edu/docs/license.pdf. Accessed 19 Aug 2020.
Churchill BF, Mackay T, Tan BY. Unauthorized immigrants’ access to driver’s licenses and auto insurance coverage. Contemp Econ Policy. 2020;39(1):107–25.
DeFreitas G. Hispanic immigration and labor market segmentation. Ind Relat. 1988;27(2):195–214.
DMV. 2018. “DMV surpasses 1 million driver licenses under AB 60.” URL: https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/pubs/newsrel/2018/201830. Accessed 5 Jan 2019.
Enchautegui ME, Giannarelli L. The Economic Impact of Naturalization on Immigrants and Cities. Washington, DC: Urban Institute; 2015.
Eurostat. 2020. “Passenger cars in the EU.". URL: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Passenger_cars_in_the_EU#Overview. Accessed 13 Jun 2020.
Gautier PA, Zenou Y. Car ownership and the labor market of ethnic minorities. J Urban Econ. 2010;67(3):392–403.
Gonzalez D, Margulies P. A legal and policy analysis of driver’s licenses for undocumented Rhode Islanders, vol. 104: Roger Williams University Law Faculty Scholarship; 2017. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/80496202.pdf. Accessed 19 Aug 2019.
Guelespe D, Ibarra M, Cedillo R, Griffiths A, Nunez A. Integrating the undocumented community: a qualitative exploration of the process for obtaining DC’s limited purpose driver’s license: Georgetown University Center for Social Justice Research, Teaching & Service; 2016. URL: https://georgetown.app.box.com/s/jmdkkdb0tk8x6bysas4s161mgpwivxjk. Accessed 19 Aug 2019.
Gurley T, Bruce D. The effects of car access on employment outcomes for welfare recipients. J Urban Econ. 2005;58(2):250–72.
Hainmueller J, Hangartner D, Ward D. The effect of citizenship on the long-term earnings of marginalized immigrants: Quasi-experimental evidence from Switzerland. Sci Adv. 2019;5(12):1–8.
Hendricks SE. Living in Car Culture without a License: The Ripple Effects of Withholding Driver’s Licenses from Unauthorized Immigrants. Washington, DC: Immigration Policy Center; 2014.
Hill LE, Johnson HP. Unauthorized immigrants in California: estimates for counties. Sacramento, CA: Public Policy Institute of California; 2011.
Holzer HJ. Mismatch in the low-wage labor market: job hiring perspective. In: Kaye K, Nightingale DS, editors. The Low-Wage Labor Market: Challenges and Opportunities for Economic Self-Sufficiency: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; 2000. p. 127–45.
Holzer HJ, Ihlanfeldt KR, Sjoquist DL. Work, search, and travel among White and Black Youth. J Urban Econ. 1994;35(3):320–45.
van Hook J, Bachmeier JD. How well does the American Community Survey count naturalized citizens? Demogr Res. 2013;29(1):1–32.
van Hook J, Bachmeier JD, Coffman D, Harel O. Can we spin straw into gold? An evaluation of immigrant legal status imputation approaches. Demography. 2015;52(1):329–54.
Hudson K. The new labor market segmentation: labor market dualism in the new economy. Soc Sci Res. 2007;36(1):286–312.
Ihlanfeldt KR, Sjoquist DL. The spatial mismatch hypothesis: a review of recent studies and their implications for welfare reform. Hous Policy Debate. 1998;9(4):849–92.
Immigrant Legal Resource Center. 2015. “AB 60 Driver’s License Frequently Asked Questions.”. https://www.ilrc.org/sites/default/_les/resources/ab6042715.pdf. Accessed 21 March 2019.
Kain JF. Housing Segregation, Negro Employment, and Metropolitan Decentralization. Q J Econ. 1968;82(2):175–97.
Kain JF. The spatial mismatch hypothesis: three decades later. Hous Policy Debate. 1992;3(2):371–92.
King MC, Chiappetta J, Corbett JG, Escribano L, Salinas AL, Webb Sprague W. Assessment of the socio-economic impacts of SB 1080 on immigrant groups. Salem, OR: Oregon Department of Transportation; 2011.
Le Gallo J, L’Horty Y, Petit P. Does enhanced mobility of young people improve employment and housing? Evidence from a large and controlled experiment in France. J Urban Econ. 2017;97(1):1–14.
Lueders H, Mumper M. 2021. “Licensing the insured: providing driver licenses to unauthorized immigrants has not impacted auto insurance in California.” unpublished manuscript. Stanford University. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3541901. Accessed 16 Feb 2021
Lueders H, Hainmueller J, Lawrence D. Providing driver’s licenses to unauthorized immigrants in California improves traffic safety. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2017;114(16):4111–6.
Mendoza G, Polkey C. 2019. “States offering driver’s licenses to immigrants.”. http://www.ncsl.org/research/immigration/states-o_ering-driver-s-licenses-to-immigrants.aspx. Accessed 18 Sep 2019
Mengistu D, Pozo S, Sarnstrom T. An alternative approach for identifying a hidden immigrant population. J Econ Race Policy. 2019;2(1):121–35.
Meyer R, Vasey H. Immigration, social networks, and the emergence of ethnic segmentation in a low-skill labor market. Soc Sci Comput Rev. 2020;38(4):387–404.
Migration Policy Institute. 2021. “Unauthorized immigrant population profiles.”. https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/us-immigration-policy-program-data-hub/unauthorized-immigrant-population-profiles. Accessed 5 Feb 2021
New York State Senate. 2019. “Senate passes Driver’s License Access and Privacy Act (Green Light NY).”. https://www.nysenate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/senate-passes-drivers-license-access-and-privacy-act-green-light-ny. Accessed 17 Jun 2019
Ong P. Work and automobile ownership among welfare recipients. Soc Work Res. 1996;20(4):255–62.
Ong P. Car ownership and welfare-to-work. J Policy Anal Manag. 2002;21(2):239–52.
Ong P, Blumenberg E. The transportation-welfare nexus: getting welfare recipients to work. Los Angeles, CA: UCLA California Policy Options; 1999.
Passel JS, Cohn D’V. Unauthorized immigrant population: national and state trends, 2010. Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center; 2011.
Pastor M, Scoggins J. 2016. “Estimating the eligible-to-naturalize population.” unpublished manuscript. University of Southern California.
Peri G, Yasenov V. The labor market effects of a refugee wave: synthetic control method meets the Mariel Boatlift. J Hum Resour. 2019;54(2):267–309.
Pew Charitable Trusts. Deciding who drives: state choices surrounding unauthorized immigrants and driver’s licenses. Philadelphia, PA: Pew Charitable Trusts; 2015.
Pew Research Center. 2019. “U.S. unauthorized immigrant population estimates by state, 2016.”. https://www.pewresearch.org/hispanic/interactives/u-s-unauthorized-immigrants-by-state/. Accessed 13 Mar 2020
Pope NG. The effects of DACAmentation: the impact of deferred action for childhood arrivals on unauthorized immigrants. J Public Econ. 2016;143(1):98–114.
Pucher J, Lefèvre C. The United States: the car-dependent society. In: Pucher J, Lefèvre C, editors. The Urban Transport Crisis in Europe and North America. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan; 1996. p. 175–200.
Raphael S, Rice L. Car ownership, employment, and earnings. J Urban Econ. 2002;52(1):109–30.
Raphael S, Stoll MA. Can boosting minority car-ownership rates narrow inter-racial employment gaps? Brookings-Wharton Papers on Urban Affairs; 2001;99-145.
Statistics Canada. 2020. “Vehicle registrations, by type of vehicle.”. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=2310006701. Accessed 13 Jun 2020
Taylor P, Lopez MH, Passel JS, Motel S. Unauthorized immigrants: length of residency, patterns of parenthood. Washington, DC: Technical report Pew Hispanic Center; 2011.
U.S. Census Bureau. 2020. “American Community Survey (ACS) PUMS Data 2005-2019.”. https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/data/pums.html. Accessed 5 Feb 2021
U.S. Department of Transportation. 2020. “State Motor-Vehicle Registrations - 2018.”. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/policyinformation/statistics/2018/pdf/mv1.pdf. Accessed 13 Jun 2020
Warren R. Democratizing data about unauthorized residents in the United States: estimates and public-use data, 2010 to 2013. J Migr Hum Secur. 2014;2(4):305–28.
Warren R, Warren JR. Unauthorized immigration to the United States: annual estimates and components of change, by State, 1990 to 2010. Int Migr Rev. 2013;47(2):296–329.
Zimmerman K, Fishman N. Roadblock on the Way to Work: Driver’s License Suspension in New Jersey. Newark, NJ: New Jersey Institute for Social Justice; 2001.