Last Glacial snowlines in the Tibetan Plateau: an argument against an extensive coalescing icesheet
Tóm tắt
Two opposing theories are circulating with regard to the extent of the Last Glacial ice cover in the Tibetan Plateau. One says that only less than 20% of plateau was covered with ice, and another insists that the plateau be completely covered with an extensive coalescing icesheet. The extent of the ice cover is thought to be significant in shaping global climatic systems, and a further discussion on this issue may help to understand the earth's surface feedback mechanisms to the global climates. This paper focuses on the Last Glacial snowline reconstruction and uses the reconstructed snowline to argue against the existence of an extensive coalescing icesheet. The reconstructed Last Glacial snowlines suggest that the snowlines dropped 500–700 m in the western and northern marginal mountains and about 1000 m in the southern and eastern marginal mountains of the Tibetan Plateau. However, the magnitude of the snowline dropping decreases dramatically towards the interior of the plateau, from 300–400 m in those mountains adjacent to the marginal mountains to about 100 m in the driest area in the interior. This means that the snowlines were too high and associated glaciers were too limited to extend to the vast intermountainous basins. To be blamed are weakened summer monsoons and lowered condensation elevations, both of which were probably responsible for not bringing in an adequate amount of precipitation into the interior for developing an extensive coalescing icesheet. The relatively high radiation in these relatively low latitudes could be a major negative force to prevent the snow and ice from forming a coalescing icesheet. In contrast, the enhanced plateau blockade to the monsoons may have helped to significantly lower the snowlines and expand the glaciers in the outer slopes of the southern and eastern marginal mountains. The westerlies may have greatly helped those glaciers in the western and northern marginal mountains.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Cui, Z.J.; Xie, Y.Y.; Xiong, H.G.; Zeng, S.W.: Discussions on the Quaternary debris-flow history and sedimentary environment in China. In: Zhang L. Y. et al. (eds), Quaternary Glaciers and Environmental Research in West China, pp 254–270. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1991.
Duplessy, J.C.; Overpeck, J.T.: The PAGES/CLIVAR Intersection. Report of A Joint IGBP-WCRP Workshop (Venice, Italy).
Feng, Z. D.: Discussion on the climatic and relief snowlines. In: Li J.J., Zhang L.Y., Feng Z.D. (eds), Evolution of Mountain Glaciers and the Quaternary Glaciation, pp 93–101. Lanzhou University Press (in Chinese), 1984.
Feng, Z.-D.; Li, J.J.: A discussion on the snowline and ice cap in the Tibetan Plateau. INQUA Commission on Formation and Processes of Glacial Deposits: A Symposium on the Control of Glacier Dynamics and Subglacial Conditions on Glacial Landforms (July 2–8, Madison, Wisconsin). Programs with Abstracts, pp 16–17, 1989.
Feng, Z.-D.; Yao, T.D.; Li, J.J.; Sun, M.K.: Glaciological investigations of the Gongga Mount. Tibetan Research II: 241–253. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1985.
Feng, Z.-D.; Yao, T.D.; Li, J.J.: An approach to subglacial processes of an ancient ice cap near Daocheng, western Sichuan, China. In: Zhang X.S. et al. (eds), A Symposium of Second National Conference on Glaciology, pp 104–110. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1986.
Feng, Z.-D.; Zhou, S.Z.; Yao, T.D.; Qin, D.H.; Li, J.J.: Last glacial snowlines in the Tibetan Plateau. International Geological Correlation Program: A Symposium on Tectonics and glaciation (June 26–28, Winninpeg, Canada). Programs with Abstracts, pp 22, 1993.
Huntington, E.: A glacial lake in the Tibetan Plateau. Journal of Geology 14,7, 599–617 (1906).
Kou, Y.G.; Xie, W.R.; Xiao, S; Li, W.Z.: The heat balance on glacial surfaces in China. Memoirs of Lanzhou Institute of Glaciology and Cryopedology Academia Sinica 3: 91–101 (in Chinese), 1982.
Kuhle, M.: New research on high Asia: Tibet and Himalayas. GeoJournal 12,3, 341–343 (1986a).
Kuhle, M.: The upper limit of glaciation in the Himalayas. GeoJournal 13,4, 331–346 (1986b).
Kuhle, M.: Subtropical mountain — and highland — glaciation as ice age triggers and the waning of the glacial period in the Pleistocene. GeoJournal 14,4, 393–421 (1987).
Kuhle, M.: Present and Pleistocene glaciation on the north-western margin of the Tibet Plateau between Karakorum Main Ridge and the Tarim Basin supporting the evidence of a Pleistocene inland glaciation in the Tibet. GeoJournal 33, 133–272 (1994).
Kuhle, M.: Reconstruction of the 2.4 million km2 Late Pleistocene icesheet on the Tibet Plateau and its implication of global climate. Ouaternary International 45/46, 71–108 (1998).
Li, J.J.; Feng, Z.D.: Quaternary glacial relics in the Hengduan Mountains. In: Li J.J., Zhang L.Y., Feng Z.D. (eds), Evolution of Mountain Glaciers and the Quaternary Glaciation, pp 61–72. Lanzhou University Press (in Chinese), 1984.
Li, J.J.; Xu, S.Y.: The distribution of glaciers in the Tibetan plateau and its relationship to atmospheric circulation. In: A Collection of the Papers Presented in the international Conference on Recent Progress in Geoscientific Technologies, pp 84–93. Cambridge University Press, London, 1984.
Li, J.J.; Zheng, B.X.; Yang, X.J.; Xu, S.Y.: Glaciers in the Tibetan Plateau. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1986.
Li, J.J., Li, B.Y.; Zhang, Q.S. (eds): Quaternary Glacial Distribution Map of the Qinghai-Xizang Plateau. Science Press, Beijing. 1991a.
Li, J.J.; Zhou, S.Z.; Pan, B.T.: Quaternary glaciation in the eastern Tibetan Plateau. Quaternary Science, 3, 193–203 (in Chinese) 1991b.
Li, S.J.; Jiao, K.Q.: Glacial variations on the southern slope of the western Kunlun Mountains since 30,000 years BP. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 12,4, 311–318 (in Chinese) 1990.
Li, S.J.; Li, S.D.: Quaternary glacial and environmental changes in the region of Hoh Xil, Qinghai Province. Journal of Glaciology and geocryology, 14,4, 316–324 (in Chinese) 1992.
Li, S.J.; Sh, Y.F.: Regional differentiation of the glacial development and climatic environment in the last glacial maximum on the Tibet Plateau. In: Symposium on Global Change and Tibetan Plateau, pp 30–40. Meteorological Publishing House, Beijing (in Chinese), 1995.
Li, S.J.; Shi, Y.F.; Wang, S.M.: Geological record of climatic and environmental changes in the Zoige Basin during the last 30,000 years. In: Symposium on Tibet: Its Formation, Environmental Change and Ecological Systems, pp 227–235. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1995.
Li, S.J.; Zheng, B.X.: Lacustrine deposits and sedimentary environment during the Late Pleistocene in the southern slope of the west Kunlun Mountains. In: Zhang L.Y. et al. (eds), Quarternary Glaciers and Environmental Research in West China, pp 211–221, Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1991c.
Li, S.J.; Zheng, B.X.; Jiao, K.Q.: Preliminary research on lacustrine deposits and lake evolution on the southern slope of the western Kunlun Mountains. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 11,4, 306–314 (in Chinese) 1991d.
Liu, K.B.; Overpeck, J.T.; Xu, X.; Tang, L.; Cole, J.E.; Shen, C.; Trumbore, S.E.: Climatic and vegetation history of the eastern Tibet. Abstracts, GSA Annual Meeting, New Orleans, November 6–9, 1995.
Marsiat, I.: Simulation of northern hemisphere continental ice sheets over the last glacial-interglacial cycle: experiments with a latitude-longitude vertically integrated ice sheet model coupled to a zonally averaged climate model. Palacncliamtes 1, 59–98 (1994).
Shi, Y.F.; Li, J.J.: Glaciological research of the Qinghai-Xizang Platcau in China. In: The International Symposium on Tibetan Plateau, pp 1589–1597. Science Press, Beijing, 1981.
Shi, Y.F.: Glaciers in China. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1988.
Shi, Y.F.; and other eleven: Map of Snow, Ice and Frozen Ground in China with Explanation. China Cartographic Publishing House, Beijing, 1988.
Shi, Y.F.; Zheng, B.X.; Li, S.J.: Last glaciation and maximum glaciation in the Qinghai-Xizang (Tibet) Plateau: a controversy to M. Kuhle's ice sheet hypothesis. Z. Geomorphologie N.F. Suppl. Bd. 84, 19–35 (1992).
Sinitsun, M.: Central Asia. Central Publishing House, Moscow (in Russian), 1958.
Trinkler, E.: The ice age on the Tibetan Plateau and its adjacent regions. Geographic Journal 75,3, 225–232 (1930).
Verbitsky, M.Y.; Oglesby, R.J.: The effect of atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration on continental glaciation of the northern hemisphere. Journal of Geophysical Research 97,D5, 5895–5909 (1992).
Wang, J.T.; Li, S.J.: On glacial extents and climatic conditions during the last glaciation in West China. In: Zhang, L.Y. et al. (eds), Quaternary Glaciers and Environmental Research in West China, pp 38–45. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1991.
Wang, S.L.; Zhang, W.X.: On the permafrost evolution in the Qingshui River region of the Tibetan Plateau since the Late Pleistocene. Journal of Glaciology and Geocrypedology 7,1, 15–26 (in Chinese) 1985.
Wang, Z.T.; Han, Y.J.: Discussion on the Tarim Basin influence on glacial development in the southern Tianshan Mountains. Journal of Glaciology and Geocrypedology 6,1, 61–69 (in Chinese) 1984.
Wu, X.H.: Discussions on the present climates of glacial development and Quaternary glaciation in China. In: A Symposium on Quaternary Glaciations in China, pp 143–148. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1985.
Xu, D.M.; Shen, Y.P.: On ancient icesheet and ice age in the Tibetan Plateau. Journal of Glaciology and Geocrypedology 17,3, 213–229 (in Chinese) 1995.
Zhou, S.Z.; Li, J.J.; Li, S.J.: New understanding of Pleistocene glaciers in Tibetan Plateau. In (Zhang, L.Y. and other six, eds): Quaternary Glaciers and Environmental Research in West China, pp 67–73. Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese), 1991.
Zhou, S.Z.; Li, J.J.; Pan, B.T.; Zhang, Y.C.: Late Pleistocene iceshcet in the headwater area of the Yellow River. Acta Geographica Sinica 49,1, 64–72 (in Chinese) 1994.