Judicial Innovation and Local Politics: Judicialization of Administrative Governance in East China

China Journal - Tập 69 - Trang 20-42 - 2013
Xin He1
1*This study was supported by a GRF grant of the Hong Kong Government. The paper was first presented at a workshop at the China Law Center of Yale Law School on 24 October 2011. I am grateful for the comments of the workshop participants. I also wish to acknowledge Mike Dowdle, Tom Ginsburg and Randall Peerenboom who provided valuable comments on an earlier version of the paper.

Tóm tắt

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

10.4159/9780674042056-009

Feng Chen and Xin Xu, "ctive Judiciary': Judicial Dismantling of Workers' Collective Action in China0022, The China Journal, No. 67 (January 2012), pp.87-107.

10.1017/CBO9780511791086

Hand Keith J., 2009, Stéphanie Balme and Michael Dowdle (eds), Building Constitutionalism in China, 221, 10.1057/9780230623958_13

10.1111/j.1540-5893.2006.00281.x

Fu Hualing, Building Constitutionalism in China, 163

Balme Stéphanie, Building Constitutionalism in China, 179

Kellogg Thomas, 2007, Harvard Human Rights Journal, 20, 141

Shen Kui, 2003, Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal, 12, 199

He Haibo, 2008, Columbia Journal of Asian Law, 22, 57

10.1017/S1744552307003023

Peerenboom Randall, 2010, Judicial Independence in China

Yu Xiaohong, 2009, Rise of Local Courts in China: Judicial Hierarchy, Institutional Adaptation and Regime Resilience0022

Ginsburg Tom, 2005, Institutions and Public Law: Comparative Approaches (New York: Peter Lang

Ginsburg Tom, 2009, Administrative Law and Governance in Asia

Wenku Baidu, 2011, Nantong

Jingwen Zhu, 1979, Zhongguo falü fazhan baogao 1979-2004 (China Legal Development Report

Randall Peerenboom, "More Law, Less Courts: Legalized Governance, Judicialization, and Dejudicialization in China0022, in Tom Ginsburg and Albert H. Y. Chen (eds), Administrative Law and Governance inAsia, pp.175-202.

Zhu Jingwen(ed.),Zhongguo falü fazhan baogao, pp.227-228; The Working Report of theSupreme People's Court, http://news.qq .com/a/20100311/003135.htm (2010), accessed 26 October 2010.

2007, accessed

2010, accessed

Online Sichuan, 2008, Jiceng fayuan jingfei jiang naru zhongyang yusuan baituo difang yilai

The number of mass plaintiff cases has increased rapidly: there were 538,941 nationwidein2004, up9.5per cent from 2003.

See Randall Peerenboom, "More Law, Less Courts0022, p.193.

Clarke Donald C., 2009, New York Times

Keith J. Hand, "Citizens Engage the Constitution0022, pp.221-242.

Du Mong, Zhengfu fawen jiang chutinglü naru kaohe `bi' guan chuting fayuan qianyujian sifa jianyi `cu' guan chuting: jiedu Jiangsu `gaoguan jianguan' weihe cheng changtai

He Xin, Building Constitutionalism in China, 143

Court Nantong Intermediate, Tuixing xingzheng jiguan fuzeren xingzheng susong chuting yingsu zhidu de jingyan

2011, Suining guiding mingaoguan yibashou xu chuting liangci buchuting mianzhi

Court Nantong Intermediate, Tuixing xingzheng jiguan fuzeren xingzheng susong chuting yingsu zhidu de jingyan

"Jiangsu `mingaoguan' anli shengsu chaoguo banshu gao chaiqian de zuiduo" (Half of Administrative Litigation Was Won, Most Related to Housing Demolitions), Yangzi wanbao (Yangtze Evening News), 28September 2010, http://www.czzfw.cn/news/news/2010/0928/10480_2.shtml, accessed 26 October 2010.

2011, Jiangsu fazhi ribao, A1

Zhang Xuehua, 2010, No. 64, 97

2007, People's Daily, 10

Tyler Tom, 1990, Why People Obey the Law (New Haven: Yale University Press

Xiaopeng Liu, 2007, Sifa jianyi weihe meiren `jiecha'er'?

Keith J. Hand, "Citizens Engage the Constitution0022, pp.221-242.

Keith J. Hand, "Citizens Engage the Constitution0022, p.222.

10.1177/0920203X07087720

2010, Xinhua Daily Telegraph

2012, Nantong 32 tiao sifa jianyi tulou

Thomas Kellogg, "Courageous Explorers0022, p.141; see also

Haibo He, "The Down of the Due Process Principle in China0022, p.57.

Tom Ginsburg, "The Judicialization of Administrative Governance0022, p.15; see also

Dowdle Michael W., Administrative Law and Governance in Asia, 23

Yongshun Cai, "Civil Resistance and Rule of Law in China0022, p.193.

The decision in favor of the Public Security Bureau was made after the collegial panel had been summoned and so instructed by the vice president

Morgan Bronwen, 2003, Social Citizenship in the Shadow of Competition: The Bureaucratic Politics of Regulatory Justification (Aldershot: Ashgate

Jiangbei ping'an ban (Jiangbei District Stability Maintenance Office, Chongqing Municipality), 2010, Jiceng fanying zhengdi chaiqian zhong beichaiqian qunzhong `kuaqu chuanlian' xianxiang tuchu yingyu gaodu zhongshi

Liu Yuenan and Ju Xiaoxiong, "Chaoyue lilun zhengyi yu xianxing falü zhidu juxian de shijian" (Transcending Theoretical Debates and Current Practice Within Institutional Limits:Researchon Concrete Evidence from Adjudication of Administrative Law Cases of Students Suing Universities in Guangzhou City Courts), Zhongguo gaodeng jiaoyu (China's Higher Education), No.Z3 (2005), pp.13-15.

Thomas Kellogg, "Courageous Explorers0022, p.142.

Xuwen Gao, 1999, 1999-2003 nian quanguo xingzheng fuyi, xingzheng susong tongji fenxi

Stéphanie Balme, "Ordinary Justice and Popular Constitutionalism in China0022, p.195.

Guarnieri Carlo, Judicial Independence in China, 241

Liu Yuenan and Ju Xiaoxiong, "Chaoyue lilun zhengyi yu xianxing falü zhidu juxian de shijian0022, p.15.

Randall Peerenboom, "More Law, Less Courts0022, p.197.