International migration and the religious schooling of children in the home country: evidence from Bangladesh
Tóm tắt
This paper investigates whether international migration increases the religious schooling of children in the home country. I find that migration by a household member from Bangladesh to a Muslim-majority country increases the likelihood that a male child in the household is sent to an Islamic school (madrasa). There is no significant impact on the likelihood of a male child’s madrasa enrollment if the household sends a member to a non-Muslim-majority country. Sending a household member abroad does not affect the likelihood of the household sending children to school at all; it only leads to reallocation toward Islamic schooling. The results are inconsistent with financial remittances underlying the effect of migration on religious schooling. Learning about the potential benefits of madrasa education may explain the results, but there are several weaknesses in the arguments in favor of this mechanism. A third potential mechanism is an increase in religiosity through migrants transferring religious preferences, but I cannot establish a causal relationship between international migration and migrant-sending households’ religiosity.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Abadie A, Athey S, Imbens G, Wooldridge J (2017) When should you adjust standard errors for clustering? Working Paper 24003, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA
Adams RH, Cuecuecha A (2013) The impact of remittances on investment and poverty in Ghana. World Development 50:24–40
Adams RH, Page J (2005) Do international migration and remittances reduce poverty in developing countries? World Development 33(10):1645–1669
Ahmed F, Roy D, Yanez-Pagans M, Yoshida N (2017) Design of a multi-stage stratified sample for poverty and welfare monitoring with multiple objectives: A Bangladesh case study. Poverty & Equity Global Practice Working Paper 100, World Bank Group, Washington, D.C
Aleksynska M, Chiswick BR (2011) Religiosity and migration: Travel into ones’ Self versus travel across cultures
Alesina A, Giuliano P, Nunn N (2013) On the origins of gender roles: Women and the plough. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 128(2):469–530
Al-Samarrai S (2007) Financing basic education in Bangladesh. Consortium for Educational Access, Transitions and Equity (CREATE) Pathways to Access Research Monograph Series 29, University of Sussex and Institute of Education and Development, BRAC University, Brighton
Ambler K, Aycinena D, Yang D (2015) Channeling remittances to education: A field experiment among Migrants from El Salvador. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 7(2):207–232
Antara NF (2019) New Madrasa curriculum to focus on spoken Arabic. Dhaka Tribune. Retrieved October 15, 2019, from https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/education/2019/06/22/new-madrasa-curriculum-to-focus-on-spoken-arabic
Antman FM (2011) The intergenerational effects of paternal migration on schooling and work: What can we learn from children’s time allocations? Journal of Development Economics 96(2):200–208
Antman FM (2012) Gender, educational attainment, and the impact of parental migration on children left behind. Journal of Population Economics 25(4):1187–1214
Asadullah MN, Chaudhury N (2008) Holy alliances: Public subsidies, Islamic high schools, and female schooling in Bangladesh. In: Girls’ education in the 21st century. The World Bank, Washington, D.C., pp 209–238
Asadullah MN (2006) Returns to education in Bangladesh. Education Economics 14(4):453–468
Asadullah MN (2009) Returns to private and public education in Bangladesh and Pakistan: A comparative analysis. Journal of Asian Economics 20(1):77–86
Asadullah MN, Chaudhury N (2010) Religious schools, social values, and economic attitudes: Evidence from Bangladesh. World Development 38(2):205–217
Asadullah MN, Chaudhury N (2013) Peaceful coexistence? The role of religious schools and NGOs in the growth of female secondary schooling in Bangladesh. Journal of Development Studies 49(2):223–237
Asadullah MN, Chaudhury N (2016) To Madrasahs or not to Madrasahs: The question and correlates of enrolment in islamic schools in Bangladesh. International Journal of Educational Development 49:55–69
Asadullah MN, Chakrabarti R, Chaudhury N (2015) What determines religious school choice? Theory and evidence from rural Bangladesh. Bulletin of Economic Research 67(2):186–207
Asadullah MN, Amin S, Chaudhury N (2019) Support for gender stereotypes: Does Madrasah education matter? The Journal of Development Studies 55(1):39–56
Autor D, Dorn D, Hanson G, Majlesi K (2016) Importing political polarization? The electoral consequences of rising trade exposure. Working Paper 22637, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA
Azar J, Marinescu I, Steinbaum M (2020) Labor market concentration. Journal of Human Resources, 1218–9914R1
Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (2011) Report of the household income and expenditure survey 2010. Technical report, Statistics and Informatics Division (SID). Ministry of Planning, Dhaka
Batista C, Vicente PC (2011) Do migrants improve governance at home? Evidence from a voting experiment. The World Bank Economic Review 25(1):77–104
Batista C, Seither J, Vicente PC (2019) Do migrant social networks shape political attitudes and behavior at home? World Development 117:328–343
Beam EA (2016) Do job fairs matter? Experimental evidence on the impact of job-fair attendance. Journal of Development Economics 120:32–40
Beine M, Docquier F, Schiff M (2013) International migration, transfer of norms and home country fertility: International migration, transfer of norms. Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue Canadienne d’économique 46(4):1406–1430
Berman E (2000) Sect, subsidy, and sacrifice: An economist’s view of ultra-orthodox Jews. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 115(3):905–953
Berman E, Stepanyan A (2004) How many radical Islamists? Indirect evidence from five countries. Working Paper
Bertoli S, Marchetta F (2014) Migration, remittances and poverty in Ecuador. The Journal of Development Studies 50(8):1067–1089
Bertoli S, Marchetta F (2015) Bringing it all back home — return migration and fertility choices. World Development 65:27–40
Betz T, Cook SJ, Hollenbach FM (2018) On the use and abuse of spatial instruments. Political Analysis 26(4):474–479
Bhuiyan MM (2018) BD to Bank on Madrasa teachers’ arabic skills. The financial express. Retrieved October 15, 2019, from http://thefinancialexpress.com.bd/public/economy/bd-to-bank-on-madrasa-teachers-arabic-skills-1535346365
Binzel C, Assaad R (2011) Egyptian men working abroad: Labour supply responses by the women left behind. Labour Economics 18:S98–S114
Bryan G, Chowdhury S, Mobarak AM (2014) Underinvestment in a profitable technology: The case of seasonal migration in Bangladesh. Econometrica 82(5):1671–1748
Bryan G, Choi JJ, Karlan D (2020) Randomizing religion: The impact of protestant evangelism on economic outcomes. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 136(1):293–380
Caeyers B, Fafchamps M (2016) Exclusion bias in the estimation of peer effects. Working Paper 22565, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA
Chauvet L, Mercier M (2014) Do return migrants transfer political norms to their origin country? Evidence from Mali. Journal of Comparative Economics 42(3):630–651
Chauvet L, Gubert F, Mesplé-Somps S (2016) Do migrants adopt new political attitudes from abroad? Evidence using a multi-sited exit-poll survey during the 2013 malian elections. Comparative Migration Studies 4(1):19
Clemens MA (2011) Economics and emigration: trillion-dollar bills on the sidewalk? Journal of Economic Perspectives 25(3):83–106
Clemens MA (2013) Why do programmers earn more in houston than hyderabad? Evidence from randomized processing of US Visas. American Economic Review 103(3):198–202
Clemens MA, Pritchett L (2019) The new economic case for migration restrictions: An assessment. Journal of Development Economics 138:153–164
Cohen-Zada D, Sander W (2008) Religion, religiosity and private school choice: Implications for estimating the effectiveness of private schools. Journal of Urban Economics 64(1):85–100
Conley TG, Hansen CB, Rossi PE (2012) Plausibly exogenous. The Review of Economics and Statistics 94(1):23
Cuadros-Menaca A, Gaduh A (2019) Remittances, child labor, and schooling: Evidence from Colombia. Econ Dev Cult Chang
Delavande A, Zafar B (2015) Stereotypes and Madrassas: Experimental evidence from Pakistan. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 118:247–267
Diabate I, Mesplé-Somps S (2019) Female genital mutilation and migration in Mali: Do return migrants transfer social norms? J Population Econ
Dildar Y (2015) Patriarchal norms, religion, and female labor supply: Evidence from Turkey. World Development 76:40–61
Dinkelman T, Mariotti M (2016) The long-run effects of labor migration on human capital formation in communities of origin. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 8(4):1–35
Docquier F, Lodigiani E, Rapoport H, Schiff M (2016) Emigration and democracy. Journal of Development Economics 120:209–223
Falco C, Rotondi V (2016) The less extreme, the more you leave: Radical Islam and willingness to migrate. World Development 88:122–133
Farhin N (2017) All Dhaka University Departments now open for Madrasa students. Dhaka Tribune. Retrieved September 19, 2019, from https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/education/2017/09/21/dhaka-university-departments-now-open-madrasa-students/
Fernández R (2011) Does culture matter? In: Benhabib J, Bisin A, Jackson MO (eds) Handbook of social economics, vol 1. Amsterdam: North-Holland, pp 481–510
Fisman R, Miguel E (2007) Corruption, norms, and legal enforcement: Evidence from diplomatic parking tickets. Journal of Political Economy 115(6):1020–1048
Forrester AC, Powell B, Nowrasteh A, Landgrave M (2019) Do immigrants import terrorism? Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 166:529–543
Fruehwirth JC, Iyer S, Zhang A (2019) Religion and depression in adolescence. Journal of Political Economy 127(3):1178–1209
Gruber JH (2005) Religious market structure, religious participation, and outcomes: Is religion good for you? The BE J Econ Anal Policy 5(1)
Hagevi M (2017) Religious change over the generations in an extremely secular society: The case of Sweden. Review of Religious Research 59(4):499–518
Imbens GW, Angrist JD (1994) Identification and estimation of local average treatment effects. Econometrica 62(2):467–475
Karadja M, Prawitz E (2019) Exit, voice, and political change: Evidence from Swedish mass migration to the United States. Journal of Political Economy 127(4):1864–1925
Kerr WR (2008) Ethnic scientific communities and international technology diffusion. Review of Economics and Statistics 90(3):518–537
Kibria N (2008) Muslim encounters in the global economy: Identity developments of labor migrants from Bangladesh to the Middle East. Ethnicities 8(4):518–535
Lavy V, Sand E, Shayo M (2018) Charity begins at home (and at School): Effects of religion-based discrimination in education. Working Paper 24922, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA
Levitt P (1998) Social remittances: Migration driven local-level forms of cultural difiusion’. International Migration Review 32(4):24
Lokshin M, Glinskaya E (2009) The effect of male migration on employment patterns of women in Nepal. The World Bank Economic Review 23(3):481–507
Manski CF (1993) Identification of endogenous social effects: The reflection problem. The Review of Economic Studies 60(3):531–542
McAuliffe M, Khadria B, Bauloz C (2019) World Migration Report 2020. Geneva: IOM. OCLC: 1200352799
McKenzie D, Rapoport H (2007) Network effects and the dynamics of migration and inequality: Theory and evidence from Mexico. Journal of Development Economics 84(1):1–24
McKenzie D, Rapoport H (2011) Can migration reduce educational attainment? Evidence from Mexico. Journal of Population Economics 24(4):1331–1358
McKenzie D, Stillman S, Gibson J (2010) How important is selection? Experimental Vs. Non-experimental measures of the income gains from migration. Journal of the European Economic Association 8(4):913–945
McKenzie D, Gibson J, Stillman S (2013) A land of milk and honey with streets paved with gold: Do emigrants have over-optimistic expectations about incomes abroad? Journal of Development Economics 102:116–127
McQuillan K (2004) When does religion influence fertility? Population Dev Rev 30(1)
Mendola M (2008) Migration and technological change in rural households: Complements or substitutes? Journal of Development Economics 85(1–2):150–175
Mercier M (2016) The return of the prodigy son: Do return migrants make better leaders? Journal of Development Economics 122:76–91
Munshi K (2003) Networks in the modern economy: Mexican migrants in the U.S. Labor Market. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 118(2):549–599
Munshi K, Rosenzweig M (2016) Networks and misallocation: Insurance, migration, and the rural-urban wage gap. American Economic Review 106(1):46–98
Myers SM (2000) The impact of religious involvement on migration. Social Forces 79(2):755–783
Naufal GS (2011) Labor migration and remittances in the GCC. Labor History 52(3):307–322
Nguyen MC, Winters P (2011) The impact of migration on food consumption patterns: The case of Vietnam. Food Policy 36(1):71–87
Nikolova M, Roman M, Zimmermann KF (2017) Left behind but doing good? Civic engagement in two post-socialist countries. Journal of Comparative Economics 45(3):658–684
Nunn N, Wantchekon L (2011) The slave trade and the origins of mistrust in Africa. American Economic Review 101(7):3221–3252
Olea JLM, Pflueger C (2013) A robust test for weak instruments. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 31(3):358–369
Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (2019) Member states. Retrieved September 17, 2019 from https://www.oic-oci.org/states/?lan=en
Pfutze T (2012) Does migration promote democratization? Evidence from the Mexican transition. Journal of Comparative Economics 40(2):159–175
Sabates R, Hossain A, Lewin KM (2010) School drop out in Banglades:h New insights from longitudinal evidence. Consortium for Educational Access, Transitions and Equity (CREATE) Pathways to Access Research Monograph Series 49, University of Sussex and Institute of Education and Development, BRAC University, Brighton
Sander W (2005) Catholics and catholic schooling. Education Economics 13(3):257–268
Shrestha SA (2017) No man left behind: Effects of emigration prospects on educational and labour outcomes of non-migrants. The Economic Journal 127(600):495–521
Simpson E (2003) Migration and islamic reform in a port town of western India. Contributions to Indian Sociology 37(1–2):83–108
Spilimbergo A (2009) Democracy and foreign education. The American Economic Review 99(1):528–543
Theoharides C (2018) Manila to Malaysia, Quezon to Qatar: International migration and its effects on origin-country human capital. Journal of Human Resources 53(4):1022–1049
Tuccio M, Wahba J (2018) Return migration and the transfer of gender norms: Evidence from the Middle East. Journal of Comparative Economics 46(4):1006–1029
Tuccio M, Wahba J, Hamdouch B (2019) International migration as a driver of political and social change: Evidence from Morocco. Journal of Population Economics 32(4):1171–1203
Williams NE, Thornton A, Young-DeMarco LC (2014) Migrant values and beliefs: How are they different and how do they change? Journal of Ethnic & Migration Studies 40(5):796–813
World Bank (2010) Secondary school Madrasas in Bangladesh: Incidence, quality, and implications for reform. Bangladesh Development Series Paper no. 27, World Bank, Washington, D.C
World Bank (2019) Migration and remittances—recent developments and outlook. Migration and Development Brief 31, World Bank Group, Washington, D.C
Yang D (2008) International migration, remittances and household investment: Evidence from Philippine migrants’ exchange rate shocks. The Economic Journal 118(528):591–630