International human rights standards versus cultural practices: a case against harmful cultural practices in Sub-Saharan Africa, with a specific reference to FGM

Addis A. Individualism, communitarianism and the rights of ethnic minorities. Notre Dame L Rev. 1992;67:615–76. Ake C. The African context of human rights. Afr Today. 1987;34(1/2):5–12. Cobbah JAM. African values and the human rights debate: an African perspective. HRQ. 1987;9:309–29. Ibhawoh B. Restraining universalism: Africanist perspectives on cultural relativism in the human rights discourse. In: Zeleza T, McConnaughay P, editors. Human rights and economic international covenant on civil and political rights. vol. 999. UNTS. 1966. p 171. Legesse A. Human rights in African political culture. In: Thompson KW, editor. The moral imperatives of human rights: a world survey. Washington D.C.: University of America Press; 1980. Mutua M. Terrorism and human rights: power culture and subordination. BHR Rev. 2002;8:5. Peetush AK. Cultural diversity, non-western communities, and human rights. TPF. 2003;34:1–19. Renteln AD. The unanswered challenge of relativism and the consequences for human rights. HRQ. 1985;7:514. Sinha P. Human rights: a non-western viewpoint. Arch Fur Rechts Socialphisophie. 1981;19:67–77. Khushalani Y. Human rights in Asia and Africa. HRLJ. 1983;4:420. Jose GL. Writing literature reviews: a guide for students of the social and behavioral sciences. Glendale: Routledge; 2013. Hutchinson T, Duncan N. Defining and describing what we do: doctrinal legal research. Deakin Law Rev. 2012;17:93–119. Vogt WP. Dictionary of statistics & methodology. Thousand Oaks: Sage; 2005. Schwelb E, Alston P. The principal institutions and other human rights bodies found in the charter. In: Vasak K, Alston P, editors. International dimensions of human rights. Paris: Green Press; 1982. Macklem P. The sovereignty of human rights. Oxford: OUP; 2015. Macklem P. Minority rights in international law. IJCL. 2008;6:531–52. Macklem P. What is international human rights law: three applications of a distributive justice account. McGill L J. 2007;52:576–81. Kymlicka W, Citizenship C. A liberal theory of minority rights. Oxford: OUP; 1995. Pentassuglia G. Minority groups and judicial discourse in international law: a comparative perspective. London: Martinus Nijhoff; 2009. Taylor C. The politics of recognition. In: Gutmann Amy, editor. Multiculturalism: examining the politics of recognition. Princeton: PUP; 1994. An-Na’im A. Problem of universal cultural legitimacy for human rights. In: An-Naim A, Deng F, editors. Human rights in Africa: cross-cultural perspectives. Washington DC: Brookings Institute; 1990. Tobin J. The international obligation to abolish traditional practices harmful to children’s health: what does it mean and require of states. HRLR. 2009;9:373. Donnelly J. The relative universality of human rights. Hum Rights Q. 2007;29:281–304. Cowan J, Dembour M-B, Wilson R. Introduction. In: Cowan J, Dembour M-B, Wilson R, editors. Culture and Rights: Anthropological Perspectives. Cambridge: CUP; 2001. Jovanovic MA, Rights RMITC. Recognizing minority identities through collective rights. Hum Rights Q. 2005;27:625–51. Hertig RM. The history of the covenants: looking back half a century and beyond. In: Moeckli D, Keller H, Heri C, editors. The human rights covenants at 50: their past, present, and future. Oxford: OUP; 2018. Merry SE. Changing rights, changing culture. In: Cowan J, Dembour M-B, Wilson R, editors. Culture and rights: anthropological perspectives. Cambridge: CUP; 2001. Donnelly J, et al. Human rights, individual rights and collective rights. In: Berting J, et al., editors. Human rights in a pluralist world: individuals and collectivities. Westport: Meckler; 1990. Donnelly J. Universal human rights in theory and practice. Ithaca: CUP; 1988. Galenkamp M. Individualism versus collectivism: the concept of collective rights. Netherlands: Rotterdam; 1993. Graff JA. Human rights, peoples, and the right to self-determination. In: Baker J, editor. Group rights Toronto. Seri Iskandar: UTP; 1994. Jones P. Human rights group rights and peoples’ rights. HRQ. 1999;21:80–106. Marie J-B. Relations between peoples’ rights and human rights: semantic and methodological distinctions. HRLJ. 1986;7:195. Nordenfelt J. Human rights—what they are and what they are not. Nord J Int Law. 1987;56:3. Sieghart P. The lawful rights of mankind: an introduction to the international legal code of human rights. Oxford: OUP; 1985. Donnelly J. Universal human rights in theory and practice. 2nd ed. Ithaca: CUP; 2003. Mihr A. Minority participation: a challenge for human rights. JSSE. 2006;5:44–59. Azcarate P. de, Protection of minorities and human rights. Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci. 1946;243:124–8. Nickel JW. Making sens of human rights. 2nd ed. San Francisco: Wiley-Blackwell; 2007. Libesman H. Book review: indigenous difference and the constitution of Canada by Patrick Macklem. OHIJ. 2002;40:200–6. Macklem P. Indigenous difference and the constitution of Canada. Toronto: UTP; 2001. Tan K-C. Justice without borders: cosmopolitanism, nationalism, and patriotism. Cambridge: CUP; 2004. Alexy R. Law, morality and the existence of human rights. Ratio Juris. 2012;25:7–10. Byers D. The morality of human rights: a secular ground. JLR. 2011;26:22–30. Kymlicka W, Odysseys M. Navigating the new international politics. Oxford: OUP; 2007. Dinstein Y. Freedom of religion and protection of religious minorities. IYBHR. 1990;20:155. Thornberry P. The UN declaration on the rights of persons belonging to national or ethnic, religious and linguistic minorities: background, analysis, observations and an update. In: Philips A, Ross A, editors. Universal minority rights. Abo: Abo Akademi Tryckeri; 1995. Brems E. Enemies of allies? Feminism and cultural relativism as dissident voices in human rights. Hum Rights Q. 1997;19:161. Dworkin R. Freedom’s law: the moral reading of the American Constitution. Oxford: OUP; 1999. Cowan JK. Culture and rights after culture and rights. Am Anthrop. 2006;108:9–24. Tylor EB, Culture P. Research into the development of mythology, philosophy, religion, art, and custom. London: Gordon Press; 1974. Cameroff J, Cameroff JL. Ethnography and the historical imagination. Boulder: Westview; 1992. Bell L, Nathan AJ, Peleg I. Introduction: Culture, and Human Rights. In: Bell L, Nathan AJ, Peleg I, editors. Negotiating Culture and Human Rights. New York: CUP; 2001. Appadurai A. Modernity at large: cultural dimensions of globalization, Minneapolis: MUP. In: Ashton-Shenker D, editor. The challenge of the human rights and cultural diversity, (201). 1996. http://www.un.org/rights/dpi1627e.htm. Accessed 29 June 2017. Bird A, Michael JS. Towards emergent global cultures and effects of globalization on obsolescing national cultures. JIM. 2003;9:395–407. Lesbian and Gay Equality Project v. Minister of Home Affairs. ZACC 19 (Const. Ct. SA) at para. 102. 2005. An-Na’im A. Towards a cross-cultural approach to defining international standards of human rights: the meaning of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. In: An-Na’im A, editor. Human rights in cross-cultural perspectives: a quest for consensus. Philadelphia: UPP; 1992. EI-Obaid EOA, Appiagyei-Atua K. Human rights in Africa—a new perspective on linking the past to the present. McGill L J. 1996;41:850. Longman C, Bradley T. Interrogating the concept of “harmful cultural practices. In: Longman C, Bradley T, editors. Interrogating Harmful cultural practices: gender, culture and coercion. New York: Routledge; 2015. Herieka E, Dhar J. Female genital mutilation in the Sudan: survey of the attitude of Khartoum university students towards this practice. Sex Transm Infect. 2003;79:220. Mason C, Excision E. Medico-legal issues arising from male and female surgery in Australia. J Law Med. 2001;9:58. von der Osten-Sacken T, Uwer T. Is female genital mutilation an Islamic problem. Middle East Q. 2007;14:29–36. Mubangizi J. An assessment of the constitutional, legislative and judicial measures against harmful cultural practices that violate sexual and reproductive rights of women in south Africa. JIWS. 2015;16:158. Boulware-Miller K. Female circumcision: challenges o the practice as a human rights violation. HV Women’s L J. 1985;8(155):156. Hayford SR, Trinitapoli J. Religious differences in female genital cutting: a case study from Burkina Faso. J Sci Study Relig. 2011;50:252–71. Louis HB. Irua and female genital mutilation: feminist and human rights discourse and the culture of divide. HRQ. 1995;8:4–8. Renteln AD. International human rights: universalism versus cultural relativism, vol. 1. London: Sage Publications; 1990. Williams-Breault BD. Eradicating female genital mutilation/cutting. Hum Rights Soc Dimens Health. 2018;20:223–34. Kenyatta J. Facing mount Kenya: the traditional life of the Gikuyu. London: Heinemann; 1938. Mutua M. Savages, victims, and saviors: the metaphor of human rights. HILJ. 2001;42:225. Mugo M. Elitist anti-circumcision discourse as mutilating and anti-feminist. Case W Res L Rev. 1997;47:461–6. Eleanora PG, Franco V, et al. At the roots of ethnic female genital modification. In: Denniston GC, et al., editors. Body integrity and the politics of circumcision: the culture, controversy and change. New York: Springer Press; 2006. Abdel-Azim S. Psychosocial and sexual aspects of female circumcision. Afr J Uorl. 2012;19:142. Elworthy DE. Female genital mutilation: proposals for changes. London: Minority Rights Group International; 1992. Worsely A. Infibulation and female circumcision: study of a little-known custom. J Obstet Gynaecol Br Emp. 1938;45:686–91. Finke E. Genital mutilation as an expression of power structures: ending FGM through education, empowerment of women and removal of taboos. Afr J Reprod Health. 2006;10:14. Serour GI. Medicalization of the female genital mutilation/cutting. AJU. 2013;19:146–7. WHO. Female genital mutilation: integrating the prevention and management of the health complications into the curricula of nursing and midwifery. A Teacher’s Guide. 2001; pp. 3, 94. http://www.who.int/gender/other_health/teachersguide.pdf. Accessed 12 Apr 2024. Wadessango N, Remba S, Cabaya O. Violation of women’s rights by harmful traditional practices. Anthropologist. 2011;13:121. WHO. Minority Rights Group International. Report 92/3. 1992. Steiner HJ, Alston P. International human rights in context: law, politics and morals, text and material. Oxford: OUP; 1996. Shell-Duncan B, Gathara D, Moore Z. Female genital mutilation/cutting in Kenya: is change taking place. New York: Population Council; 2017. Edyegu D. Sensitize public on female circumcision law. TNV. 2009. http://allafrica.com/stories/200912160586.html. Accessed 1 Mar 2018. Yusuf C. Female genital mutilation as a human rights issue: examining the effectiveness of the law against female genital mutilation in Tanzania. HRLJ. 2013;13:324–55. O’Manique J. The origins of justice: the evolution of morality, human rights and law. Philadelphia: UPP; 2003. Roman E. A race approach to international law (RAIL): is there new need for yet another critique of international law? UC Davis Law Review, 2004. http://www.law.ucdavis.educ/lawreview/Roman.pdf. Accessed 5 Oct 2018. Mubangizi J. A south African perspective on the clash between culture and human rights with particular reference to gender-related cultural practices and tradition. JIWS. 2012;12:36. WHO. Defining sexual health: report of a technical consultation on sexual health. Geneva: WHO Press; 2002. Smagadi A. Sourcebook of international human rights materials. London: BIICL; 2008. Bösl A, Diescho J. Human rights in africa: legal perspectives on their protection and promotion. Windhoek: KA Foundation; 2009. Magnarella PJ. Assessing the concept of human rights in Africa. Hum Rights Hum Welf. 2000;1:25–7. Busia KA. The position of the chief in the modern political system of Ashanti. London: OUP; 1951. Metz T. Ubuntu as a moral theory and human rights in south Africa. AHRLJ. 2011;11:539. Nkondo GM. Ubuntu as a public policy in South Africa. IJARS. 2007;2:90–1. Robertson AH, Merrills JG. Human rights in the world: an introduction to the study of the international protection of human. 4th ed. Oxford: OUP; 1996. Swanson J. The emergence of new rights in the African charter. NYLS J Int Comp Law. 1991;12:328. Baynes K. The liberal/communitarian controversy and communicative ethics. In: Rasmussen D, editor. Universalism vs. Communitarism. Boston: UMP; 1990. Depaigne V. Individualism human rights and identity: human rights law commentary, vol. 1. Nottingham: UNP; 2005. Gyekye K. An essay on African philosophical thought: the Akan conceptual scheme. Philadelphia: TUP; 1995. Howard R. Group versus individual identity in the African debate on human rights. In: An-Na’im A, Deng F, editors. Human rights in Africa: cross cultural perspectives. Washington D.C.: Brookings Institution; 1990. Nahum F. African contributions to human rights. A Paper Presented at the Seminar on Law and Human Rights in Development. Gaborone, Botswana, May 24–28. 1982. 2:5. Panikkar R. Is the notion of human rights a western concept? Diogenes. 1982;120:75–102. Kent A. Between freedom and subsistence: china and human rights. Hong Kong: OUP; 1993. Zakaria F. Culture is destiny: a conversation with Lee Kuan Yew. Foreign Affairs. 1994;73:109–11. Nnamuchi O. Circumcision or mutilation—voluntary or forced excision. LJ. 2012;25:91. Beyleveld D, Brownsword R. Human dignity in bioethics and biolaw. Oxford: OUP; 2001. Brown C. Universal human rights: a critique. In: Dunne T, Wheeler NJ, editors. Human rights in global politics. Cambridge: CUP; 1999. Waldron J. Minority rights and the cosmopolitan alternative. In: Kymlicka W, editor. Rights of minority cultures. Oxford: OUP; 1995. Anonymous. Human rights documents: committee on foreign affairs, Washington: U.S. Govt, Printing Office, 1983. Marks SP. The past and future of the separation of human rights into categories. Md J Int’l L. 2013;24:209–43. Scott C. Interdependence and permeability of human rights norms: towards a partial fusion of the international covenants on human rights. Osgoode Hall Law J. 1989;27:769–878. van Boven T. The relation between peoples’ rights and human rights in the african charter. HRLJ. 1986;7:183. Darwall S. Hume and the invention of utilitarianism. Philadelphia: PSUP; 1995. Milne AJM. Human rights and human diversity: an essay in the philosophy of human rights. Albany: SUNY; 1986. McDonald M. Should communities have rights? Reflections on liberal individualism. Can J Law Juris. 2015;4:217–23. Ludlow DRL. Humanitarian intervention and the Rwandan genocide. TJCS. 1999;19:1–18. Silk J. Traditional culture and prospects for human rights. In: An-Na’im A, Deng F, editors. Human rights in Africa: cross cultural perspectives. Washington DC: Brookings Institution; 1990. Falk R. Cultural foundations for international protection of human rights. In: An-Na’im A, editor. Human rights in cross-cultural perspectives: a quest for consensus. Philadelphia: UPP; 1992. Schloendorff v. Society of N.Y. Hospital, 105 N.E. 92, 93 (N.Y. 1914). 1914. Zurynski Y, et al. Female genital mutilation in children presenting to Australian paediatricians. Arch Dis Child. 2017;102:509–15. Martin R. Human rights and social recognition thesis. JSP. 2013;44:1–3. Capps P. Human dignity and the foundation of international law. Oxford: Hart Publishing; 2010. Boas F. The mind of primitive man. Science. 1901;13:281–9. Donnelly J. Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice. New Jersey: Third Edition; 2013. Deng FM. Identity, diversity and constitutionalism in Africa, Washington D.C.; 2009. Ibhawoh B., Restraining universalism: Africanist perspectives on cultural relativism in the human rights discourse. In: Zeleza T, McConnaughay P, Eds., Human Rights, the Rule of Law and Development in Africa, Pensylvania, UPP, 2004, p. 26. Jack D., The concept of human rights, 1st Edition, 1985, Routledge, p. 230. Marie-Bénédicte D., Changing Rights, Changing Culture, in Jane Cowan, Marie-Bénédicte Dembour and Richard Wilson, Eds, Culture and Rights: Anthropological Perspectives Cambridge: CUP, 2001, p. 60. Montgomery H., Imposing Rights? A case study of child prostitution in Thailand, in Jane Cowan, Marie- Bénédicte Dembour and Richard Wilson, Eds, Culture and Rights: Anthropological Perspectives Cambridge: CUP, 2001, p. 82. Ashton-Shenker D. “The Challenge of the Human Rights and Cultural Diversity” (2014), available online at: http://www.un.org/rights/dpi1627e.htm.