If and Then: A Critique of Speculative NanoEthics

Springer Science and Business Media LLC - Tập 1 - Trang 31-46 - 2007
Alfred Nordmann1
1Institut für Philosophie, Technische Universität Darmstadt, Schloss, Darmstadt, Germany

Tóm tắt

Most known technology serves to ingeniously adapt the world to the physical and mental limitations of human beings. Humankind has acquired awesome power with its rather limited means. Nanotechnological capabilities further this power. On some accounts, however, nanotechnological research will contribute to a rather different kind of technological development, namely one that changes human beings so as to remove or reduce their physical and mental limitations. The prospect of this technological development has inspired a fair amount of ethical debate. Here, proponents and opponents of such visions of human enhancement are criticized alike for engaging in speculative ethics. This critique exposes a general pattern that extends to other nano-, bio-, or neuroethical debates. While it does not apply to all discussions of “enhancement technologies” it does apply to all ethical discourse that constructs and validates an incredible future which it only then proceeds to endorse or critique. This discourse violates conditions of intelligibility, squanders the scarce and valuable resource of ethical concern, and misleads by casting remote possibilities or philosophical thought-experiments as foresight about likely technical developments. In effect, it deflects consideration from the transformative technologies of the present.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Amato I (1999) Nanotechnology – shaping the world atom by atom. National Science and Technology Council, Interagency Working Group on Nanoscience, Engineering and Technology, Washington Anders G (1956) Die Antiquiertheit des Menschen. Beck, München Anders G (1972) Endzeit und Zeitende: Gedanken über die atomare Situation. Beck, München Bostrom N, Toby O (2006) The reversal test: eliminating status quo bias in applied ethics. Ethics 116:656–679 Bostrom N (2006) Welcome to a world of exponential change. In: Miller P, Wilsdon J (eds.) Better humans? The politics of human enhancement and life extension. DEMOS, London, pp 40–50 Bruland K, Mowery, DC (2004) Innovation through time. In: Fagerberg J, Mowery D, Nelson R (eds) The Oxford handbook of innovation. Oxford University Press 2004, Oxford Bunting M (2006) There is no stop button in the race for human re-engineering. The Guardian, Monday, 30 January 2006 Caplan A (2006) Is it wrong to try to improve human nature? In: Miller P, Wilsdon J (eds) Better humans? The politics of human enhancement and life extension. DEMOS, London, pp 31–39 Dupuy J-P (2005) The philosophical foundations of nanoethics: arguments for a method. Lecture at the Nanoethics Conference, University of South Carolina, 2–5 March 2005 Gehring P (2006) Was ist Biomacht? Vom zweifelhaften Mehrwert des Lebens. Campus, Frankfurt Green J (2005) Presentation at the key technologies conference. DG Research, Brussels (September 19) Grunwald A (2004) Vision assessment as a new element of the technology futures analysis toolbox. In: Proceedings of the EU-US scientific seminar: new technology foresight, forecasting & assessment methods, Seville, 13–14 May 2004 Grunwald A (2006) Nanotechnologie als Chiffre der Zukunft. In: Nordmann A, Schummer J, Schwarz A (eds) Nanotechnologien im Kontext: Philosophische, ethische, gesellschaftliche Perspektiven. Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft, Berlin, pp 49–80 Habermas J (2005) Die Zukunft der menschlichen Natur: Auf dem Weg zu einer liberalen Eugenik? Suhrkamp, Frankfurt. Compare the English edition The future of human nature. Blackwell, 2003, London Hagner M (2006) Der Geist bei der Arbeit. Historische Untersuchungen zur Hirnforschung. Wallstein, Göttingen Hård M, Jamison A (2005) Hubris and hybrids: a cultural history of technology and science. Routledge, London Harris J (2006) Enhancement, justice, and rights. Princeton Lectures, James Martin Institute, 14–16 March 2006 HLEG (High Level Expert Group) Foresighting the new technology wave (2004) Converging technologies: shaping the future of European societies. Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxemburg Hughes J, LaTorra M (2006) WTA NEWS 3 November 2006: News of the World Transhumanist Association http://transhumanism.org/index.php/WTA/rss_2.0/ accessed 14 February 2007 Hutchins E (1996) Cognition in the wild. MIT, Boston Jamison A (2006) Hubris or hybrids? On the cultural assessment of nanotechnology. EASST Review 25(3). http://www.easst.net/review/oct2006/jamison accessed 14 February 2007 Kurzweil R (2000) The age of spiritual machines. Penguin Books, New York Kurzweil R (2005) The singularity is near. Penguin Books, New York Miller P, Wilsdon J (2006) Stronger, longer, smarter, faster. In: Miller P, Wilsdon J (eds) Better humans? The politics of human enhancement and life extension. DEMOS, 2006, London, pp 13–27 Miller P, Wilsdon J (2006) The man who wants to live forever. In: Miller P, Wilsdon J (eds) Better humans? The politics of human enhancement and life extension. DEMOS, London, pp 51–58 Moor J, Weckert J (2004) Nanoethics: assessing the nanoscale from an ethical point of view. In: Baird D, Nordmann A, Schummer J (eds) Discovering the nanoscale. IOS, Amsterdam, pp 301–311 Müller S (2006) Minimal-invasive und nanoskalige Therapien von Gehirnerkrankungen: Eine medizinethische Diskussion. In: Nordmann A, Schummer J, Schwarz A (eds) Nanotechnologien im Kontext: Philosophische, ethische, gesellschaftliche Perspektiven. Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft, Berlin, pp 345–370 Nordmann A (2005) Wohin die Reise geht: Zeit und Raum der Nanotechnologie. In: Gamm G, Hetzel A (eds.) Unbestimmtheitssignaturen der Technik. Transcript, Bielefeld, pp 103–123; English version. No future for nanotechnology? Historical development vs. global expansion. forthcoming in Jotterand F (ed) Nanotechnology and nanoethics: framing the field. Springer, Dordrecht Nordmann A (forthcoming) Ignorance at the heart of science? Incredible narratives on brain-machine interfaces. Forthcoming in a volume edited by Johannes Ach, Münster Nordmann A (forthcoming) Tomorrow’s people, today’s challenge. Forthcoming in a collection of contributions to the 2006 James Martin Institute’s World Forum on Science and Civilization Roco MC, Bainbridge WS (eds) (2002) Converging technologies for improving human performance. National Science Foundation/Department of Commerce, Arlington Sandel M (2004) The case against perfection. Atl Mon 293:51–62 Treder M (2004) Emancipation from death. In: Immortality Institute (ed) The scientific conquest of death. Libros en Red., Buenos Aries, pp 187–196. http://www.imminst.org/book1/ accessed 14 February 2007 Urquhart A (2004) Complexity. In: Floridi L (ed) The Blackwell guide to philosophy of computing and information. Blackwell, Malden, pp 18–27 Wilsdon J (2006) Who would not seize the chance to live to 150? Financial Times, 7 February 2007 Workshop (2006) State-of-the-art and socio-economic aspects of brain–machine (BMI) & brain–computer interfaces (BCI). unpublished draft minutes