How ecovillages work: more-than-human understandings of rentabilidad in Mexican ecovillages
Tóm tắt
This article highlights the emergence of intentional communities known as ecovillages (ecoaldeas) in Mexico, exploring how humans seek to design sustainable futures in part by re-making rural livelihoods. Ecovillages are inherently speculative ventures, or as Burke and Arjona (2013) note, laboratories for alternative political ecologies, inviting—and indeed, necessitating—the reimagination of human lives with greater consideration for the natural world. In this sense, such communities might be understood as “exilic spaces” (O’Hearn and Grubačić 2016), in that they seek to build autonomous and self-sustaining agricultural, social, and economic systems while also reflecting a stance of resistance to neoliberal capitalist structures. At the same time, communities may also remain dependent on connections to broader regional or global markets in diverse and interconnected ways. Understanding ecovillages as diverse and emergent “worldings” (de la Cadena and Blaser 2018), I ask how these experimental social ventures reckon with their connections to the very systems they are positioned against. To trace out how communities negotiate this fragile space, this article is concerned with how ecovillagers spend their time at work—particularly when it comes to managing relationships with and between more-than-human beings. Drawing on participant observation with ecovillagers and more-than-human others they work with, I explore how the concept of “rentabilidad” (profitability) is differently constructed. To this end, I highlight ethnographic examples where rentabilidad is purposefully reconceptualized with more-than-human lives in mind; such a shift, I suggest, hinges on ecovillagers’ individualized relations with the beings they (imagine themselves) to care for.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Acosta A, Cajas-Guijarro J (2020) Ghosts, pluriverse and hopes. In: Vivares E (ed) The routledge handbook to global political economy: conversations and inquiries. Routledge, New York, pp 292–310
Akbulut B, Demaria F, Gerber JF, Kaul S (2022) Alternatives to sustainable development: what can we learn from the pluriverse in practice? Sustain Sci (in press)
Alberti FG, Garrido MAV (2017) Can profit and sustainability goals co-exist? New business models for hybrid firms. J Bus Strategy 38(1):3–13
Andrade D, Pasini F, Scarano FR (2020) Syntropy and innovation in agriculture. Curr Opin Environ Sust 45:20–24
Andreas M (2013) Must utopia be an island? Positioning an ecovillage within its region. In: Paper presented at the international communal studies association, Rachel Carson Center, Germany, 9–18 October
Baker T (2013) Ecovillages and capitalism: creating sustainable communities within an unsustainable context. In: Lockyer J, Veteto J (eds) Environmental anthropology engaging ecotopia: bioregionalism, permaculture, and ecovillages. Berghahn, New York, pp 285–300
Barkin D (2006) Building a future for rural Mexico. Lat Am Perspect 33:132–140
Bastian M (2019) Retelling time in grassroots sustainable economy movements. GeoHumanit 5(1):36–53
Bocken NMP, Short SW (2016) Towards a sufficiency-driven business model: experiences and opportunities. Environ Innov Soc Transit 18:41–61
Brightman M, Lewis J (2017) Introduction. In: Brightman M, Lewis J (eds) The anthropology of sustainability: beyond development and progress, Palgrave studies in anthropology of sustainability. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 1–34
Burke BJ, Arjona B (2013) Creating alternative political ecologies through the construction of ecovillages and ecovillagers in Colombia. In: Lockyer J, Veteto JR (eds) Environmental anthropology engaging ecotopia: bioregionalism, permaculture, and ecovillages, Berghahn, Oxford, New York, pp 235–250
Carruthers DV (1996) Indigenous ecology and the politics of linkage in Mexican social movements. Third World Q 17:1007–1028
Carruthers DV (1997) Agroecology in Mexico: linking environmental and indigenous struggles. Soc Nat Resour 10:259–272
Castree N (2009) The spatio-temporality of capitalism. Time Soc 18(1):26–61
Chan KM, Gould RK, Pascual U (2018) Relational values: what are they, and what’s the fuss about? Curr Opin Environ Sustain 35:A1–A7
Child JW (1998) Profit: the concept and its moral features. Soc Philos Policy 15:243–282
Dawson J (2006) How ecovillages can grow sustainable local ecologies. Communities Mag 133:56–61
Dawson J (2013) From islands to networks: the history and future of the ecovillage movement. In: Joshua Lockyer, James R. Veteto (eds) environmental anthropology engaging ecotopia: bioregionalism, permaculture, and ecovillages, Berghahn, Oxford, New York, pp 217–234
de Janvry A (1981) The agrarian question and reformism in Latin America. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
de La Bellacasa PM (2017) Matters of care. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
de la Cadena M, Blaser M (2018) A world of many worlds. Duke University Press, Durham
Demaria F, Kothari A (2017) The post-development dictionary agenda: paths to the pluriverse. Third World Q 38:2588–2599
Dias MA, Loureiro CFB, Chevitarese L, de Mello e Souza C (2017) The meaning and relevance of ecovillages for the construction of sustainable social alternatives. Rev Ambient Soc 20:79–96
Ergas C (2010) A model of sustainable living: collective identity in an urban ecovillage. Organ Environ 23:32–54
Escobar A (2015) Degrowth, postdevelopment, and transitions: a preliminary conversation. Sustain Sci 10:451–462
Escobar A (2018) Designs for the pluriverse: radical interdependence, autonomy, and the making of worlds. Duke University Press, Durham
Farkas J (2017) To separate from the umbilical cord of society: freedom as dependence and independence in Hungarian ecovillages. Etnofoor 29:81–100
Frye D (1994) Speaking of the ejido: three modes of discourse about the Salinas reforms. Urban Anthropol Stud Cult Syst World Econ Dev 23:307–330
Graeber D (2001) Toward an anthropological theory of value: the false coin of our own dreams. Palgrave Macmillan US, New York
Haraway DJ (2016) Staying with the trouble: making kin in the Chthulucene. Duke University Press, Durham
Hernández C, Perales H, Jaffee D (2020) Without food there is no resistance: the impact of the Zapatista conflict on agrobiodiversity and seed sovereignty in Chiapas, Mexico. Geoforum (in press)
Himes A, Muraca B (2018) Relational values: the key to pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services. Curr Opin Environ Sust 35:1–7
Hinton JB (2020) Fit for purpose? clarifying the critical role of profit for sustainability. J Polit Ecol 27(1):236–262
Jackson H (1998) What is an ecovillage? Gaia Trust Education Seminar
Jackson T (2009) Prosperity without growth? The transition to a sustainable economy. Sustainable Development Commission
Kasper DVS (2008) Redefining community in the ecovillage. Hum Ecol Rev 15:12–24
Kirby A (2003) Redefining social and environmental relations at the ecovillage at Ithaca: a case study. J Environ Psychol 23:323–332
Kirksey SE, Helmreich S (2010) The emergence of multispecies ethnography. Cult Anthropol 25:545–576
Kolinjivadi V, Vela Almeida D, Martineau J (2020) Can the planet be saved in time? On the temporalities of socionature, the clock and the limits debate. Environ Plann E 3:904–926
Koretskaya O, Feola G (2020) A framework for recognizing diversity beyond capitalism in agri-food systems. J Rural Stud 80:302–313
Kothari A (2014) Radical ecological democracy: a path forward for India and beyond. Development 57(1):36–45
Kothari AF, Demaria F, Acosta A (2014) Buen vivir, degrowth and ecological swaraj: alternatives to sustainable development and the green economy. Development 57(3–4):362–375
Krzywoszynska A (2016) What farmers know: experiential knowledge and care in vine growing. Sociol Rural 56:289–310
Latour B (1998) Essays on science and society: from the world of science to the world of research? Science 280:208–209
LeVasseur T (2013) Globalizing the ecovillage ideal. In: Lockyer J, Veteto JR (eds) environmental anthropology engaging ecotopia: bioregionalism, permaculture, and ecovillages. Berghahn Books, Oxford New York, pp 251–268
Litfin K (2009) The global ecovillage movement as a holistic knowledge community. environmental governance: power and knowledge in a local-global world, pp 124–142
Litfin K (2012) Reinventing the future: the global ecovillage movement as a holistic knowledge community. In: Kütting G, Lipschutz R (eds) Environmental governance: power and knowledge in a local-global world. Routledge, Philadelphia
Litfin K (2014) Ecovillages: lessons for sustainable community. Wiley, Hoboken
Lockyer J (2017) Community, commons, and degrowth at Dancing Rabbit Ecovillage. J Polit Ecol 24(1):519–542
López LS, Silva Prada DF (2015) El movimiento de ecoaldeas como experiencia alternativa de buen vivir [The ecovillage movement as alternative experience of buen vivir]. Polis 14:1–18
Lukka K (1990) Ontology and accounting: the concept of profit. Crit Perspect Account 1:239–261
Meijering L, Huigen P, Van Hoven B (2007) Intentional communities in rural spaces. Tijdschr Econ Soc Geogr 98:42–52
Morris O (2022) Communing with Others: More-than-human communities of Mexican ecovillages. PhD dissertation. Central European University Press, Vienna (in press)
Münster D (2018) Performing alternative agriculture: critique and recuperation in zero budget natural farming, south India. J Polit Ecol 25:748–764
Naylor L (2012) Food sovereignty and the politics of indigenous resistance in Chiapas, Mexico. In: Paper Prepared for Congress of the Latin American Studies Association, San Francisco, California, 23–26 May
Norton BG, Toman MA (1997) Sustainability: ecological and economic perspectives. Land Econ 553–568
O’Hearn D, Grubačić A (2016) Capitalism, mutual aid, and material life: understanding exilic spaces. Cap Cl 40:147–165
Odell J (2019) How to do nothing: resisting the attention economy. Melville House, New York
Parrique T, Barth J, Briens F, Kerschner C, Kraus-Polk A, Kuokkanen A, Spangenberg JH (2019) Decoupling debunked: evidence and arguments against green growth as a sole strategy for sustainability. European Environmental Bureau, Brussels
Paull J (2011) Biodynamic agriculture: the journey from Koberwitz to the world, 1924–1938. J Org Syst 6:27–41
Perramond E (2005) The politics of ecology: local knowledge and wild chili collection in Sonora, Mexico. J Lat Am Geogr 41:59–75
Pires CV, Lima A (2013) Ecoaldeias: práticas de cuidado a nível global e local. [Ecovillages: practices of care at the global and local level]. Configurações 11:99–111
Purvis B, Mao Y, Robinson D (2019) Three pillars of sustainability: in search of conceptual origins. Sustainability 14(3):681–695
Rainey DV, Robinson KL, Allen I, Christy RD (2003) Essential forms of capital for sustainable community development. Am J Agric Econ 85(3):708–715
Retsikas K, Marsden M (2018) Alternate modes of prosperity. HAU J Ethnogr Theory 8(3):596–609
Saxena AK, Chatti D, Overstreet K, Dove MR (2018) From moral ecology to diverse ontologies: relational values in human ecological research, past and present. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 35:54–60
Schaltegger S, Hansen EG, Lüdeke-Freund F (2016) Business models for sustainability: origins present research, and future avenues. Organ Environ 29(1):3–10
Singh B, Keitsch MM, Shrestha M (2019) Scaling up sustainability: concepts and practices of the ecovillage approach. Sustain Dev 27:237–244
Sonnenfeld DA (1992) Mexico’s green revolution 1940–1980: towards an environmental history. Environ Hist Rev 16:29–52
Spangenberg JH (2005) Economic sustainability of the economy: concepts and indicators. Int J Sustain Dev 8(1–2):47–64
Stephen L (1994) Accommodation and resistance: ejidatario, ejidataria, and official views of ejido reform. Urban Anthropol Stud Cult Syst World Econ Dev 23:233–265
Temesgen AK (2020) Building an island of sustainability in a sea of unsustainability?: a study of two ecovillages. Sustainability 12:1–27
Tsing AL (2015) The mushroom at the end of the world: on the possibility of life in capitalist ruins. Princeton University Press, Princeton
van Dooren T, Kirksey E, Münster U (2016) Multispecies studies: cultivating arts of attentiveness. Environ Hum 8:1–23
Velázquez Castro JA (2018) Multifunctional agriculture: relevance for tourism in Mexico. Rev Mexicana De Cienc Agric 9:1494–1507
Villanueva-G R, Roubik D, Colli-Ucan W (2005) Extinction of Melipona beecheii and traditional beekeeping in the Yucatán peninsula. Bee World 86:35–41
West S, Haider LJ, Masterson V, Enqvist JP, Svedin U, Tengö M (2018) Stewardship, care and relational values. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 35:30–38
Yetman D (2000) Ejidos, land sales, and free trade in northwest Mexico: will globalization affect the commons? J Am Stud 41:211–234
Zhong R, Pei F, Yang K, Xia Y, Wang H, Yan G (2021) Coordinating socio-economic and environmental dimensions to evaluate regional sustainability—towards an integrative framework. Ecol Indic 130:108085. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2021.108085