How does roadside vegetation management affect the diversity of vascular plants and invertebrates? A systematic review
Tóm tắt
With appropriate management, based on vegetation removal that reverses late-successional vegetation stages, roadsides can support high levels of biodiversity. However, current recommendations for roadside management to conserve or restore biodiversity are largely based on research on non-roadside grassland habitats, and much of the evidence on how roadside management practices affect biodiversity is found in non-peer-reviewed grey literature. Therefore, based on suggestions from key stakeholders and an initial systematic map that identified 97 studies on how biodiversity is affected by vegetation removal on roadsides, we conducted a full systematic review of the effects on plant and invertebrate diversity of disturbance-based maintenance of roadsides. The review was restricted to effects of non-chemical interventions such as mowing, burning, grazing and mechanical shrub removal. Studies were selected from the systematic map and from an updated search for more recent literature using a priori eligibility criteria. Relevant articles were subject to critical appraisal of clarity and susceptibility to bias, and studies with low or unclear validity were excluded from the review. Data on species richness, species diversity and abundance of functional groups were extracted together with metadata on site properties and other potential effect modifiers. Results from the 54 included studies were summarised in a narrative synthesis, and impacts of mowing practices on the total species richness and diversity of plants and on the abundance of forbs, graminoids and woody plants were quantitatively analysed using t tests of study-level effect ratios. Nearly all of the 54 studies included in the review were conducted in Europe (29) or North America (24). The vast majority of studies (48) examined impacts of mowing. Effects on vascular plants were reported in 51 studies, whereas 8 of the studies reported on invertebrates. Quantitative analysis of plant species richness and species diversity showed that mowing effects were dependent on the interplay between mowing frequency and hay removal. Thus, there were no statistically significant overall effects of mowing vs. no mowing, frequency of mowing, timing of mowing or hay removal. However, species richness was higher in roadsides mowed once or twice per year with hay removal than in unmown roadsides, and positively affected by mowing twice compared to once per year. Similar, but less pronounced, effects were found for plant species diversity. In addition, mowing had a negative impact on woody plant abundance, and increased mowing frequency had a negative impact on graminoid abundance. The few studies on invertebrates showed effects that diverged across taxon groups, and there was not enough data for quantitative analysis of these results. The results provide evidence on the effects of mowing on plant species richness. To increase plant species richness, roadsides should be mowed each year, preferably twice per year, and hay should be removed after each cutting. The review also identifies large knowledge gaps concerning roadside management and its effects on biodiversity, especially regarding invertebrates. Hence, this systematic review provides not only a valuable basis for evidence-based management but also guidance for future research on this topic, essential to inform management of road networks for biodiversity conservation.
Tài liệu tham khảo
The good verge guide. Salisbury; 2016. https://www.plantlife.org.uk/application/files/4614/8232/2916/Road_verge_guide_17_6.pdf. Accessed 5 July 2018.
Auestad I, Rydgren K, Austad I. Road verges: potential refuges for declining grassland species despite remnant vegetation dynamics. Ann Bot Fenn. 2011;48:289–303.
Lindborg R, Plue J, Andersson K, Cousins SAO. Function of small habitat elements for enhancing plant diversity in different agricultural landscapes. Biol Conserv. 2014;169:206–13.
Egoh BN, Bengtsson J, Lindborg R, Bullock JM, Dixon AP, Rouget M. The importance of grasslands in providing ecosystem services: opportunities for poverty alleviation. In: Potschin M, Haines-Young R, Fish R, Turner R, editors. Routledge Handb Ecosyst Serv. London and New York: Routledge; 2016. p. 421–41.
Lemaire G, Hodgson J, Chabbi A. Grassland productivity and ecosystem services. Wallingford: CABI; 2011.
Rydgren K, Jørn-Frode N, Ingvild A, Inger A, Einar H. Recreating semi-natural grasslands: a comparison of four methods. Ecol Eng. 2010;36:1672–9.
Habel JC, Dengler J, Janišová M, Török P, Wellstein C, Wiezik M. European grassland ecosystems: threatened hotspots of biodiversity. Biodivers Conserv. 2013;22:2131–8.
Wilson JB, Peet RK, Dengler J, Pärtel M. Plant species richness: the world records. J Veg Sci. 2012;23:796–802.
Eriksson O. Land-use history and fragmentation of traditionally managed grasslands in Scandinavia. J Veg Sci. 2002;13:743–8.
Bullock JM, Jefferson RG, Blackstock TH, Pakeman RJ, Emmett BA, Pywell RF, Grime JP, Silvertown J. Semi-natural grasslands. In: The UK National Ecosystem Assessment Technical Report. UNEP-WCMC, Cambridge, 2011. http://uknea.unep-wcmc.org/Resources/tabid/82/Default.aspx. Accessed 19 June 2018.
Lennartsson T, Gylje S. Infrastrukturens biotoper – en refug för biologisk mångfald. Uppsala: Centrum för biologisk mångfald; 2009.
Stenmark M. Infrastrukturens gräs- och buskmarker. Hur stora arealer gräs och buskmarker finns i anslutning till transportinfrastruktur och bidrar dessa till miljömålsarbetet? Jordbruksverket. Sweden: Jönköping; 2012.
Jordbruksverket. Jordbruksstatistisk sammanställning 2016. Sweden: Jönköping; 2016. http://www.jordbruksverket.se/omjordbruksverket/statistik/jordbruksstatistisksammanstallning/jordbruksstatistisksammanstallning2016.4.4a82b0a7155953b608a84f0c.html. Accessed 20 May 2017.
Queiroz C, Beilin R, Folke C, Lindborg R. Farmland abandonment: threat or opportunity for biodiversity conservation? A global review. Front Ecol Environ. 2014;12:288–96.
Milberg P, Bergman KO, Cronvall E, Eriksson ÅI, Glimskär A, Islamovic A, et al. Flower abundance and vegetation height as predictors for nectar-feeding insect occurrence in Swedish semi-natural grasslands. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2016;230:47–54.
Lindborg R, Bengtsson J, Berg Å, Cousins SAO, Eriksson O, Gustafsson T, et al. A landscape perspective on conservation of semi-natural grasslands. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2008;125:213–22.
Bernes C, Bullock JM, Jakobsson S, Rundlöf M, Verheyen K, Lindborg R. How are biodiversity and dispersal of species affected by the management of roadsides? A systematic map protocol. Environ Evid. 2016;5:4.
Bernes C, Bullock JM, Jakobsson S, Rundlöf M, Verheyen K, Lindborg R. How are biodiversity and dispersal of species affected by the management of roadsides? A systematic map. Environ Evid. 2017;6:24.
Grime JP. Plant strategies and vegetation processes. Chichester: Wiley; 1979.
CEE. Collaboration for environmental evidence: guidelines and standards for evidence synthesis in environmental management. Version 5.0. 2018. www.environmentalevidence.org/information-for-authors. Accessed 08 Mar 2018.
CEE. Guidelines for systematic reviews in environmental management. Version 4.2. Bangor; 2013.
Bernes C, Bullock JM, Jakobsson S, Verheyen K, Lindborg R. How does roadside vegetation management affect the diversity of vascular plants and invertebrates? A systematic review protocol. Environ Evid. 2017;6:16.
Hijmans RJ, Cameron SE, Parra JL, Jones PG, Jarvis A. Very high resolution interpolated climate surfaces for global land areas. Int J Climatol. 2005;25:1965–78.
Wiebe N, Vandermeer B, Platt RW, Klassen TP, Moher D, Barrowman NJ. A systematic review identifies a lack of standardization in methods for handling missing variance data. J Clin Epidemiol. 2006;59:342–53.
Steward PR, Dougill AJ, Thierfelder C, Pittelkow CM, Stringer LC, Kudzala M, et al. The adaptive capacity of maize-based conservation agriculture systems to climate stress in tropical and subtropical environments: a meta-regression of yields. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2018;251:194–202.
van de Haterd RJ, Vleeming S, Hoefsloot G, Krijgsveld KL, Smits RR. De effecten van beheer op wegbermvegetaties. Resultaten van langjarig onderzoek naar vijf maairegimes en naar mantel- en zoombeheer. Bureau Waardenburg bv, Culemborg. Technical report 07-223. 2007.
van de Haterd RJW, van den Hengel B, Keizer PJ. Lange termijn effecten van maaibeheer in wegbermen. De Levende Natuur. 2009;110:88–94.
van Schaik AW., van den Hengel L. De effecten van een aantal maairegimes op flora en vegetatie in wegbermen. Rijkswaterstaat, Dienst Weg- en Waterbouwkunde, Hoofdafdeling Milieu. Technical report P-DWW-044-706. 1994.
Parr T, Way J. Management of roadside vegetation: the long-term effects of cutting. J Appl Ecol. 1988;25:1073–87.
Way JM. Further observations on the management of road verges for amenity and wildlife. In: Conference proceedings: Road verges in Scotland. Scotland: Edinburgh; 1970. p. 1–13.
Jantunen J, Saarinen K, Valtonen A, Saarnio S. Grassland vegetation along roads differing in size and traffic density. Ann Bot Fenn. 2006;43:107–17.
O’Farrell PJ, Milton SJ. Road verge and rangeland plant communities in the southern Karoo: exploring what influences diversity, dominance and cover. Biodivers Conserv. 2006;15:921–38.
Camp M, Best LB. Bird abundance and species richness in roadsides adjacent to Iowa rowcrop fields. Wildl Soc Bull. 1993;21:315–25.
Gordon, D R, Cox A., Seamon G., Slapcinsky JL, Jones DA. Native sandhill species revegetation techniques. University of Florida and the Florida Department of Transportation, US Technical report. 2001.
Young SL, Claassen VP. Release of roadside native perennial grasses following removal of yellow starthistle. Ecol Restor. 2008;26:357–64.
Charvat I, Agwa H, Hebberger J, Tallaksen J, Raley M, Gould E, et al. Mycorrhizal/plant factors involved in roadside reclamation. University of Minnesota and Minnesota Department of Transportation, US Technical report MN/RC-2000-30. 2000.
Noordijk J, Schaffers AP, Heijerman T, Boer P, Gleichman M, Sykora KV. Effects of vegetation management by mowing on ground-dwelling arthropods. Ecol Eng. 2010;36:740–50.
Noordijk J, Delille K, Schaffers AP, Sykora KV. Optimizing grassland management for flower-visiting insects in roadside verges. Biol Conserv. 2009;142:2097–103.
Helden AJ, Leather SR. Biodiversity on urban roundabouts—Hemiptera, management and the species-area relationship. Basic Appl Ecol. 2004;5:367–77.
Halbritter DA, Daniels JC, Whitaker DC, Huang L. Reducing mowing frequency increases floral resource and butterfly (Lepidoptera: Hesperioidea and Papilionoidea) abundance in managed roadside margins. Florida Entomol. 2015;98:1081–92.
Valtonen A, Saarinen K, Jantunen J. Effect of different mowing regimes on butterflies and diurnal moths on road verges. Anim Biodivers Conserv. 2006;29:133–48.
Milchunas DG, Sala OE, Lauenroth WK. Quantitative effects of grazing on vegetation and soils over a global range of environments. Am Nat. 1988;132:87–106.
Bullock JM, Franklin J, Stevenson MJ, Silvertown J, Sarah J, Gregory SJ, et al. A plant trait analysis of responses to grazing in a long-term experiment. J Appl Ecol. 2001;38:253–67.
Anonymous. Slåning af vejkanter. Odense, Fyns Amt; 1995.
Chaudron C, Perronne R, Bonthoux S, Di Pietro F. Influence of management practices on plant assemblages of road–field boundaries in an agricultural landscape. Appl Veg Sci. 2016;19:644–54.
Gaujour E, Amiaud B, Mignolet C, Plantureux S. Factors and processes affecting plant biodiversity in permanent grasslands. A review. Agron Sustain Dev. 2012;32:133–60.
Socher SA, Prati D, Boch S, Müller J, Baumbach H, Gockel S, et al. Interacting effects of fertilization, mowing and grazing on plant species diversity of 1500 grasslands in Germany differ between regions. Basic Appl Ecol. 2013;14:126–36.
Schelfhout S, Mertens J, Perring MP, Raman M, Baeten L, Demey A, et al. P-removal for restoration of Nardus grasslands on former agricultural land: cutting traditions. Restor Ecol. 2017;25:S178–87.
Kayhanian M, Suverkropp C, Ruby A, Tsay K. Characterization and prediction of highway runoff constituent event mean concentration. J Environ Manage. 2007;85:279–95.
Duprè C, Stevens CJ, Ranke T, Bleeker A, Peppler-Lisbach C, Gowing DJG, et al. Changes in species richness and composition in European acidic grasslands over the past 70 years: the contribution of cumulative atmospheric nitrogen deposition. Glob Chang Biol. 2010;16:344–57.
Peppler-Lisbach C, Könitz N. Vegetation changes in Nardus grasslands of the Werra-Meissner region (Hesse, Lower Saxony, Central Germany) after 25 years. Tuexenia. 2017;37:201–28.
Beyschlag W, Ryel RJ, Ullman I, Eckstein J. Experimental studies on the competitive balance between two Central European roadside grasses with different growth forms. Bot Acta. 1996;109:449–55.