Habit, Omission and Responsibility
Tóm tắt
Given the pervasiveness of habit in human life, the distinctive problems posed by habitual acts for accounts of moral responsibility deserve more attention than they have hitherto received. But whereas it is hard to find a systematic treatment habitual acts within current accounts of moral responsibility, proponents of such accounts have turned their attention to a topic which, I suggest, is a closely related one: unwitting omissions. Habitual acts and unwitting omissions raise similar issues for a theory of responsibility because they likewise invite us to rethink the assumption that moral responsibility requires awareness of the relevant features of one’s conduct. And given the increasing interest in the problem of responsibility for unwitting omissions, it is reasonable to expect that the theoretical moves made in response to this problem might be used to make sense of judgments of responsibility regarding habitual acts. I substantiate these points by inquiring into whether some well-known accounts of unwitting omissions can be used to explain how we can be responsible for things we do out of habit.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Amaya S (2013) Slips. Noûs 47(3):559–576
Arpaly N (2002) Unprincipled virtue: an inquiry into moral agency. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Brett N (1981) Human habits. Can J Philos 11:357–376
Brownstein M, Saul J (eds) (2016) Implicit bias and philosophy, volume 2: moral responsibility, structural injustice, and ethics. Oxford University Press, UK
Clarke R (2014) Omissions: agency, metaphysics, and responsibility. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Clarke R (2017a) Blameworthiness and unwitting omissions. In: Nelkin DK, Rickless SC (eds) The ethics and law of omissions. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 63–83
Clarke R (2017b) Ignorance, revision, and commonsense. In: Robichaud P, Wieland JW (eds) Responsibility—the epistemic condition. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 233–251
Fischer JM, Ravizza M (1998) Responsibility and control: a theory of moral responsibility. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Fischer JM, Tognazzini NA (2009) The truth about tracing. Noûs 43(3):531–556
Goldberg S (2017) Should have known. Synthese 194(8):2863–2894
Graham PA (2014) A sketch of a theory of moral blameworthiness. Philos Phenomenol Res 88(2):388–409
Jacobs JA (2001) Choosing character: responsibility for virtue and vice. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
James W (1981) The Principles of psychology. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
King M, Carruthers P (forthcoming) Responsibility and consciousness. In Nelkin DK, Pereboom D (eds) Oxford handbook on moral responsibility. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Levy N (2011) Hard luck: how luck undermines free will and moral responsibility. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Levy N (2017) Methodological conservatism and the epistemic condition. In: Robichaud P, Wieland JW (eds) Responsibility—the epistemic condition. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 252–265
Lumer C (2017) Automatic actions—agency, intentionality, and responsibility. Philos Psychol 30:616–644
Mele A (2010) Moral responsibility for actions: epistemic and freedom conditions. Philos Explor 13(2):101–111
Murray S (2017) Responsibility and Vigilance. Philos Stud 174(2):507–527
Murray S, Murray ED, Stewart G, Sinnott-Armstrong W, De Brigard F (2019) Responsibility for forgetting. Philos Stud 176(5):1177–1201
Murray S, Vargas M (2020) Vigilance and control. Philos Stud 177(3):825–843
Nelkin DK (2016) Difficulty and degrees of moral praiseworthiness and blameworthiness. Noûs 50(2):356–378
Nelkin DK, Rickless SC (2015) Review of Randolph Clarke’s omissions: agency, metaphysics, and responsibility. Notre Dame Philos Rev 2015(02):33
Nelkin DK, Rickless SC (2017) Moral responsibility for unwitting omissions: a new tracing view. In: Nelkin DK, Rickless SC (eds) The ethics and law of omissions. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 106–130
Nilsen P, Roback K, Broström A, Ellström P (2012) Creatures of habit: accounting for the role of habit in implementation research on clinical behaviour change. Implement Sci 7:53
Ouellette JA, Wood W (1998) Habit and intention in everyday life: the multiple processes by which past behavior predicts future behavior. Psychol Bull 124:54–74
Pollard B (2006) Explaining actions with habits. Am Philos Q 43(1):57–69
Pollard B (2008) Habits in action. Vdm Verlag Dr. Mueller, Saarbrücken
Pollard B (2011) Identification, psychology, and habits. In: Aguilar JH, Buckareff AA, Frankish K (eds) New waves in philosophy of action new waves in philosophy. Palgrave Macmillan, London
Reason J (1990) Human Error. Cambridge University Press, New York
Rees CF, Webber J (2014) Automaticity in virtuous action. In: Snow N, Trivigno F (eds) The philosophy and psychology of character and happiness. Routledge, London, pp 75–90
Rosen G (2004) Skepticism about moral responsibility. Philos Perspect 18:295–313. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1520-8583.2004.00030.x
Rudy-Hiller F (2017) A capacitarian account of culpable ignorance. Pac Philos Q 98:398–426
Ryle G (1949/1984). The Concept of Mind. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Schlosser M (2013) Conscious will, reason-responsiveness, and moral responsibility. J Ethics 17(3):205–232
Sher G (2009) Who knew?: Responsibility without awareness. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Sher G (2017) Unintentional omissions. In: Nelkin DK, Rickless SC (eds) The ethics and law of omissions. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 3–16
Shoemaker D (2015) Responsibility from the margins. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Smith AM (2005) Responsibility for attitudes: activity and passivity in mental life. Ethics 115(2):236–271
Smith AM (2017) Unconscious omissions, reasonable expectations, and responsibility. In: Nelkin DK, Rickless SC (eds) The ethics and law of omissions. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 36–60
van t’Riet J, Sijtsema SJ, Dagevos H, De Bruijn GJ (2011) The importance of habits in eating behaviour. an overview and recommendations for future research. Appetite 57:585–596
Vargas M (2020) Negligence and self-governance. In: Mele AR (ed) Surrounding self-control. Oxford University Press, Oxford