Governance issues in the Ecosystem Approach: what lessons from the Forest Stewardship Council?

European Journal of Forest Research - Tập 130 - Trang 395-405 - 2010
Heiko Garrelts1, Michael Flitner1
1Artec, Research Centre for Sustainability Studies, University of Bremen, Bremen, Germany

Tóm tắt

The certification scheme of the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) and the Ecosystem Approach (EA) as conceptualised under the Convention on Biological Diversity show substantial convergence in their broader aims and normative background. Taking this finding as a starting point, the paper discusses what lessons could be learned from FSC’s experience in developing and implementing specific norms and standards. The elaborate decision-making mechanisms of FSC may prove useful for the refinement and implementation of the EA, in particular regarding the transformation of generic principles into national and regional level standards. FSC’s strong reliance on market mechanisms, however, and the related influence of dominant economic actors limit its suitability as an overall blueprint for the implementation of the EA.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Astleithner F, Hamedinger A, Holman N, Rydin Y (2004) Institutions and indicators: the discourse about indicators in the context of sustainability. J Housing Built Environ 19(1):7–24 Bass S, Thornber K, Markopoulos M, Roberts S, Grieg-Gran M (2001) Certifications’s impacts on forests, stakeholders and supply chains. IIED, London Burger D, Lang B, Hess J (2005) Forest certification: taking stock from a development policy perspective. In: Burger D, Hess J, Lang B (eds) Forest certification: an innovative instrument in the service of sustainable development? Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ), Eschborn, pp 3–21 Cashore B, Auld G, Newsom D (2004) Governing through markets: forest certification and the emergence of non-state authority. Yale University Press, New Haven CBD (2000) COP 5 Decision V/6 (UNEP/CBD/COP/5/6) CBD (2004) COP 7 Decision VII/11, Annex II: A, 20 (UNEP/CBD/COP/7/11) Counsell S, Loraas KT (2002) Trading in credibility: the myth and reality of the Forest Stewardship Council. Rainforest Foundation, London Cumming GS, Cumming DHM, Redman CL (2006) Scale mismatches in social-ecological systems: causes, consequences, and solutions. Ecol Soc 11(1):14. http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol11/iss1/art14/, Sep 28, 2009 Dingwerth K (2007) The new transnationalism. Transnational governance and democratic legitimacy. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke Dingwerth K (2008) North-south parity in global governance: the affirmative procedures of the Forest Stewardship Council. Glob Gov 14:53–71 Ebeling J (2005) Market-based conservation and global governance. Can forest certification compensate for poor environmental law enforcement? Insights from Ecuador and Bolivia, MA. Thesis, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität, Freiburg im Breisgau Ebeling J, Yasué M (2009) The effectiveness of market-based conservation in the tropics: forest certification in Ecuador and Bolivia. J Environ Manage 90:1145–1153 Ellis K, Keane J (2008) A review of ethical standards and labels: is there a gap in the market for a new ‘good for development’ label? Overseas Development Institute working paper 297 Flitner M, Garrelts H (2008) Die Bedeutung des ökosystemaren Ansatzes der CBD für den Schutz der Biodiversität in Wäldern. Natur und Landschaft 83(4):150–153 Flitner M, Matthes U, Oesten G, Roeder A (eds) (2006) The ecosystem approach in forest biosphere reserves: results from three case studies (= BfN-Skripten 168). Bundesamt für Naturschutz, Bonn Frankenhauser D, Flitner M (2006) The ecosystem approach in forest areas—starting points. In: Flitner M et al (eds) The ecosystem approach in forest biosphere reserves: results from three case studies. Bundesamt für Naturschutz, Bonn, pp 3–17 FSC (1996) FSC international standard. FSC principles and criteria for forest stewardship. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn FSC (2003a) FSC social strategy. Building and implementing a social agenda. Version 2.1. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn FSC (2003b) The decentralized FSC network: promoting responsible forest management globally and locally. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn FSC (2009a) Facts and figures. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn. http://www.fsc.org/facts-figures.html, Sep 28, 2009 FSC (2009b) FSC membership list. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn. http://www.fsc.org/fileadmin/web-data/public/document_center/membership_documents/FSC_Membership_List_-_ENG.pdf, Sep 28, 2009 FSC (2009c) Forest stewardship council A.C: by-laws. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn FSC (2009d) FSC around the world. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn. http://www.fsc.org/fsc-locations.html, Sep 28, 2009 FSC (2009e) FSC Accreditation documents. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn. http://www.fsc.org/accreditation_docs.html, Sep 28, 2009 FSC (2009f) Our vision and mission. Forest Stewardship Council, Bonn FSC—Lake States Working Group of the FSC—US (2005) Revised final regional forest stewardship standard for the Lake States-Central Hardwoods Region (USA). Version LS V3.0 February 10, 2005. http://www.forestrycenter.org/library.cfm?refID=74101, Sep 28, 2009 FSC-Watch (2009a) Homepage (about). http://fsc-watch.org, Sep 28, 2009 FSC-Watch (2009b) Thousands of indigenous people evicted from FSC-certified Mount Elgon National Park. http://www.fsc-watch.org/archives/2008/07/01/Thousands_of_Indigen, Sep 28, 2009 Gale F (2005) Global democratic governance. Learning from the Forest Stewardship Council. Paper presented to the 46th annual ISA Convention Honolulu, Hawaii March 1–5 Gale F, Haward M (2004) Public accountability in private regulation: contrasting models of the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) and the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC). Refereed paper presented to the Australian Political Studies Association conference. University of Adelaide 29, September–1 October 2004 Hartje V, Klaphake A, Schliep R (2003) The international debate on the ecosystem approach. Critical review—international actors, obstacles and challenges (= BfN-Skripten 80). Bundesamt für Naturschutz, Bonn Haufler V (2003) New forms of governance: certification as social regulation of the global markets. In: Meidinger E, Elliott C, Oesten G (eds) Social and political dimensions of forest certification. Remagen-Königswinter, pp 237–247 Hess J (2005) Impacts, obstacles to and risks of forest certification. In: D. Burger, J. Hess, B. Lang (eds.) Forest certification: An innovative instrument in the service of sustainable development? Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit, Eschborn Holman N (2009) Incorporating local sustainability indicators into the structures of local governance: a review of the literature’. Local Environ 14(4):365–375 Kern K (2004) Globale Governance durch transnationale Netzwerkorganisation. Möglichkeiten und Grenzen zivilgesellschaftlicher Selbstorganisation. In: Gosewinkel D, Rucht D, van den Daele W, Kocka J (eds) Zivilgesellschaft–national und transnational. WZB-Jahrbuch 2003. Edition sigma, Berlin, pp 285–308 Klooster D (2005) Environmental certification of forests: the evolution of environmental governance in a commodity network. J Rural Stud 21:403–417 Kruedener Bv (2000) FSC forest certification—enhancing social forestry developments? For Trees People Newsl 43:12–18 McDermott CL, Noah E, Cashore B (2008) Differences that matter? Framework for comparing environmental certification and government policies. J Environ Policy Plann 10(1):47–70 Meidinger E (1999) Private environmental regulation, human rights and community. Buffalo Environ Law J 7:123–237 Murray J (1998) Corporate codes of conduct and labour standards. In: Kyloh R (ed) Mastering the challenge of globalisation. Towards a trade union agenda. ILO Bureau for workers’ activities. Working paper produced under project INT/97/MO1/ITA (“Information, technology, workers’ participation and social dialogue”). Geneva, ILO, pp 45–104 Pattberg PH (2005) What role for private rule-making in global environmental governance? Analysing the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC). Int Environ Agreements 5:175–189 Ponte S (2008) Greener than thou: the political economy of fish ecolabeling and its local manifestations in South Africa. World Dev 36(1):159–175 Poschen P (2000) Social criteria and indicators for sustainable forest development. A guide to ILO texts. Forest certification working paper no. 3, Eschborn Rydin Y, Holman N (2004) Re-evaluating the contribution of social capital in achieving sustainable development. Local Environ 9(2):117–133 Salvador S (2007) Social issues in the chain of custody. Presentation at the BWI global wood and forestry meeting, December 11 and 12, 2007 Sayer JA, Maginnis S (2005) New challenges for forest management. In: Sayer J, Maginnis S (eds) Forests in landscapes. Ecosystem approaches to sustainability. Earthcan, London, pp 1–16 Taylor PL (2005a) In the market but not of it: fair trade coffee and Forest Stewardship Council certification as market-based social change. World Dev 33(1):129–147 Taylor PL (2005b) A fair trade approach to community forest certification? A framework for discussion. J Rural Stud 21:433–447