Financial Performance of Contract Tree Farming for Smallholders: The Case of Contract Eucalypt Tree Farming in Thailand
Tóm tắt
Eucalypt (Eucalyptus spp.) tree farming is a source of income for many smallholders in developing and emerging countries and critical to the resource supply of many pulp and paper companies. These companies rely on smallholders adopting tree farming, sometimes by offering a contract. This paper reports a study from four regions of Thailand, where smallholder eucalypt tree farming is practiced, which investigated the financial performance of contract eucalypt tree farming for smallholders. A total of 82 contract eucalypt tree farmers and 81 independent tree farmers were systematically selected and surveyed in these regions, using door-to-door personal interviews. Focus groups and key informant interviews were also used to gain in-depth understanding of the issues. An investment appraisal analysis was used to determine and evaluate comparative financial returns from various cutting cycle periods, through computation of the net present value (NPV). There was no evidence that contracts increase the NPV of tree growing. It could be that tree growers entered into a contractual agreement with the expectation of higher benefits and the importance of this expectation diminishes as the crop matures, and tree farmers appreciate the strong market for eucalypt wood in Thailand. Contracts do not increase inequalities in terms of income but they might increase inequalities in terms of knowledge, because farmers with more land have better access to new knowledge provided by the contracting company.
Tài liệu tham khảo
ADB (2005a) LAO: industrial tree plantation project. Loan completion report, ADB edn. Asian Development Bank, Manila
ADB (2005b) Proposed loan and Asian development fund grant Lao People’s Democratic Republic: forest plantations development project. ADB report and recommendation of the President to the Board of Directors, ADB edn. Asian Development Bank, Manila
Albers HJ, Robinson EJZ (2007) Spatial-temporal aspects of cost-benefit analysis for park management: an example from Khao Yai National Park, Thailand. J For Econom 13(2–3):129–150
Barney K (2005) At the supply edge: Thailand’s forest policies, plantation sector, and commodity export links with China. China and forest trade in the Asia-Pacific region: implications for forests and livelihoods. Forest Trends, Washington DC
Boulay A (2010) Contract tree farming and smallholders: drivers of adoption and livelihood impacts in Thailand. PhD thesis, Australian National University, Canberra
Boulay A, Tacconi L (2012) The drivers of contract eucalypt farming in Thailand. Int For Rev 14(1)
Boulay A, Tacconi L, Kanowski P (2012) Drivers of adoption of eucalypt tree farming by smallholders in Thailand. Agrofor Syst:1–11. doi:10.1007/s10457-011-9451-y
Cairns R (2000) Outgrower timber schemes in KwaZulu-Natal: do they build sustainable rural livelihoods and what interventions should be made? Instruments for sustainable private sector forestry., South Africa seriesInternational Institute for Environment and Development and CSIR-Environmentek, London and Pretoria
Clapp RA (1994) The moral economy of the contract. In: Little PD, Watts MJ (eds) Living under contract. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison
Cossalter C, Pye-Smith C (2003) Fast-wood forestry: myths and realities. Myths and realities. CIFOR, Bogor
Desmond H, Race D (2000) Global survey and analytical framework for forestry out-grower arrangements. Department of Forestry, Australian National University for Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome
ESCAP UN (2007) Statistical Yearbook for Asia and the Pacific 2007. http://www.unescap.org/stat/data/syb2007/22-Inflation-and-interest-rates-syb2007.asp. Accessed 28 May 2008
Evans J, Turnbull JW (2004) Plantation forestry in the tropics, 3rd edn. Oxford University Press, New York
Harrison SR, Herbohn JL (2001) Towards a vibrant tropical small-scale forestry industry: imperatives, opportunities and challenges. In: Harrison SR, Herbohn JL (eds) Sustainable farm forestry in the tropics: social and economic analysis and policy. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 271–282
Key N, Runsten D (1999) Contract farming, smallholders, and rural development in Latin America: the organization of agroprocessing firms and the scale of outgrower production. World Dev 27(2):381–401
Little PD, Watts MJ (1994) Living under contract: contract farming and agrarian transformation in Sub-Saharan Africa. The University Of Wisconsin Press, Madison
Maille P (1991) Refining a previous analysis of the economics of a eucalyptus/agricultural crop combination. Agrofor Syst 14(1991):145–148
Mayers J (2006) Poverty reduction through commercial forestry: What evidence? What prospects? Research paper no. 2, vol 2. The Forests Dialogue, Yale University School of Forestry & Environmental Studies
Mayers J, Vermeulen S (2002) Company-community forestry partnerships: from raw deals to mutual gains? Instruments for sustainable private sector forestry series. International Institute for Environment and Development, London
Mayers J, Evans J, Foy T (2001) Raising the stakes: impacts of privatisation, certification and partnerships in South African forestry. Instruments for sustainable private sector forestry. International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED), London
Niskanen A (1998a) Financial and economic profitability of reforestation in Thailand. For Ecol Manag 104(1–3):57–68. doi:10.1016/s0378-1127(97)00263-6
Niskanen A (1998b) Value of external environmental impacts of reforestation in Thailand. Ecol Econom 26(3):287–297
Salee K (2009) Manager of contract farming at Phoenix Pulp and Paper. Personal communication with Boulay A, Khon Kaen
Scherr SJ, White A, Kaimowitz D (2002) Making markets work for forest communities. Forest Trends, Washington D.C., United States of America
Singh S (2002) Contracting out solutions: political economy of contract farming in the Indian Punjab. World Dev 30(9):1621–1638
Thaiutsa B (2002) Silvicultural management of private eucalyptus plantations for wood chips in Thailand. In: Wei R-P, Xu D (eds) International symposium on eucalyptus plantations: research, management and development. Guangzhou, China
Tiwari DN (2000) Sustainability criteria and cost–benefit analysis: an analytical framework for environmental–economic decision making at the project level. Environ Dev Econom 5(259–288)
Wannawong S, Belt GH, McKetta CW (1991) Benefit-cost analysis of selected agroforestry systems in Northeastern Thailand. Agrofor Syst 16(1):83–94
Warning M, Key N (2002) The social performance and distributional consequences of contract farming: an equilibrium analysis of the Arachide de Bouche program in Senegal. World Dev 30(2):255–263
Wilson J (1986) The political economy of contract farming. Rev Radic Polit Econom 18(4):47–70
Wiriyapong N (2008) Siam cement group eyes concessions in Laos, Cambodia Bangkok Post, 09 May 2008