Executive Compensation and Employee Remuneration: The Flexible Principles of Justice in Pay

Michel Magnan1, Dominic Martin2
1John Molson School of Business, Concordia University, Montreal, Canada
2École des sciences de la gestion, Université du Québec à Montréal, Downtown Station, Montreal, Canada

Tóm tắt

This paper investigates a series of normative principles that are used to justify different aspects of executive compensation within business firms, as well as the remuneration of lower-ranking employees. We look at how businesses perform pay benchmarking; employees’ engagement, fidelity and loyalty (and their effects on pay practices); and the acceptability of what we call both-ends-dipping, that is, receiving both ex ante and ex post benefits for the same work. We make two observations. First, either different or incoherent principles are used to justify the pay of executives compared to employees, or the same principles are applied differently. Second, these differences or inconsistencies tend to be to the benefit of executives and/or to the detriment of employees. We conclude by asking whether there is any reason for thinking differently about executive pay than we do about employee pay. Our analysis leads us to question the principles justifying current executive compensation and to wonder if these principles are potentially being instrumentalized to serve other ends.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Albrecht, S. L. (2011). Handbook of employee engagement: Perspectives, issues, research and practice. Human Resource Management International Digest, 19(7), 3–19.

Albuquerque, A. M., De Franco, G., & Verdi, R. S. (2013). Peer choice in CEO compensation. Journal of Financial Economics, 108(1), 160–181.

Alchian, A. A., & Demsetz, H. (1972). Production, information costs, and economic organization. The American Economic Review, 62(5), 777–795.

Allaire, Y. (2012). Pay for value: Cutting the Gordian knot of executive compensation. Montréal, QC: Institute for the Governance of Private and Public Firms.

Allaire, Y., & Dauphin, F. (2015). How Pershing square found success at Canadian Pacific Railway. Financial Post, Toronto, ON. Retrieved from http://business.financialpost.com/fp-comment/how-pershing-square-found-success-at-canadian-pacific-railway.

Anderson, J. (2008). Stock exchange’s ex-chief wins battle to keep pay. The New York Times, New York, NY. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/02/business/02grasso.html.

Anderson, S., & Klinger, S. (2016). A tale of two retirements: As working families face rising retirement insecurity. CEOs enjoy platinum pensions, Institute for Policy Studies, Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://www.ips-dc.org/report-tale-two-retirements.

Atkins, E. (2017). Hunter Harrison joins CSX Corp. as CEO. The Globe and Mail, Toronto, ON.

Atkinson, A. B. (2015). Inequality: What can be done?. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Bal, P. M., Kooij, D. T. A. M., & De Jong, S. B. (2013). How do developmental and accommodative HRM enhance employee engagement and commitment? The role of psychological contract and SOC strategies. Journal of Management Studies, 50(4), 545–572.

Barrick, M. R., Thurgood, G. R., Smith, T. A., & Courtright, S. H. (2015). Collective organizational engagement: Linking motivational antecedents, strategic implementation, and firm performance. Academy of Management Journal, 58(1), 111–135.

Bebchuk, L. A., Cremers, K. J. M., & Peyer, U. C. (2011). The CEO pay slice. Journal of Financial Economics, 102(1), 199–221.

Bebchuk, L. A., & Fried, J. (2006). Pay without performance: The unfulfilled promise of executive compensation (1st ed.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Bebchuk, L. A., & Grinstein, Y. (2005). The growth of executive pay. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 21(2), 283–303.

Bizjak, J. M., Lemmon, M. L., & Naveen, L. (2008). Does the use of peer groups contribute to higher pay and less efficient compensation? Journal of Financial Economics, 90(2), 152–168.

Bizjak, J., Lemmon, M., & Nguyen, T. (2011). Are all CEOs above average? An empirical analysis of compensation peer groups and pay design. Journal of Financial Economics, 100(3), 538–555.

Blasi, J. (2017). Tech companies are shutting employees out of the stock market’s boom. Fortune Magazine. Retrieved from http://fortune.com/2017/04/12/tech-stock-market/.

Boatright, J. R. (2010). Executive compensation: Unjust or just right? In G. G. Brenkert & T. L. Beauchamp (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of business ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Boeri, T., Lucifora, C., & Murphy, K. J. (2013). Executive remuneration and employee performance-related pay: A transatlantic perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Buchanan, A. E. (1985). Ethics, efficiency and the market. Oxford: Clarendon.

Chasan, E. (2013). Last gasp for stock options? CFO Journal. The Wall Street Journal, New York, NY. Retrieved from https://blogs.wsj.com/cfo/2013/08/26/last-gasp-for-stock-options/.

Clifford, S. (2017). The CEO pay machine: How it trashes America and how to stop it. New York, NY: Penguin Random House.

Coase, R. H. (1937). The nature of the firm. Economica, 4, 386–405.

Cole, M. S., Walter, F., Bedeian, A. G., & O’Boyle, E. H. (2012). Job burnout and employee engagement: A meta-analytic examination of construct proliferation. Journal of Management, 38(5), 1550–1581.

Conyon, M. J., Peck, S. I., & Sadler, G. V. (2009). Compensation consultants and executive pay: Evidence from the United States and the United Kingdom. Academy of Management Perspectives, 23(1), 43–55.

Cowen, A. P., King, A. W., & Marcel, J. J. (2016). CEO severance agreements: A theoretical examination and research agenda. Academy of Management Review, 41(1), 151–169.

Cowherd, D. M., & Levine, D. I. (1992). Product quality and pay equity between lower-level employees and top management: An investigation of distributive justice theory. Administrative Science Quarterly, 37(2), 302–320.

Damodaran, A. (2015). CEO compensation: The pricing and valuing of top managers! ValueWalk, New York, NY. Retrieved from http://www.valuewalk.com/2015/04/ceo-compensation-the-pricing-and-valuing-of-top-managers.

Di Prete, T. A., Eirich, G. M., & Pittinsky, M. (2010). Compensation benchmarking, leapfrogs, and the surge in executive pay. American Journal of Sociology, 115(6), 1671–1712.

El-Hajji, M. A. (2015). The Hay system of job evaluation: A critical analysis. Journal of Human Resources, 3(1), 1–22.

Eyal, N. (2012). Informed consent. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2012/entries/informed-consent.

Faulkender, M., & Yang, J. (2010). Inside the black box: The role and composition of compensation peer groups. Journal of Financial Economics, 96(2), 257–270.

Feinberg, J. (1970). Doing & deserving: Essays in the theory of responsibility. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Feldman, F., & Skow, B. (2015). Desert. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2015/entries/desert.

Fiss, P. C. (2007). A set-theoretic approach to organizational configurations. Academy of Management Review, 32(4), 1180–1198.

Fredrickson, J. W., Davis-Blake, A., & Sanders, W. G. (2010). Sharing the wealth: Social comparisons and pay dispersion in the CEO’s top team. Strategic Management Journal, 31(10), 1031–1053.

Frydman, C., & Jenter, D. (2010). CEO compensation. Annual Review of Financial Economics, 2(1), 75–102.

Frydman, C., & Saks, R. E. (2010). Executive compensation: A new view from a long-term perspective, 1936–2005. Review of Financial Studies, 23(5), 2099–2138.

Gao, H., Luo, J., & Tang, T. (2015). Effects of managerial labor market on executive compensation: Evidence from job-hopping. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 59(2), 203–220.

Ghoshal, S. (2005). Bad management theories are destroying good management practices. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 4(1), 75–91.

Greckhamer, T. (2011). Cross-cultural differences in compensation level and inequality across occupations: A set-theoretic analysis. Organization Studies, 32(1), 85–115.

Greckhamer, T. (2016). CEO compensation in relation to worker compensation across countries: The configurational impact of country-level institutions. Strategic Management Journal, 37(4), 793–815.

Gross, S. E., & Rook, M. (2015). Using a total rewards strategy to achieve competitive advantage. In L. A. Berger & D. R. Berger (Eds.), The compensation handbook (pp. 13–26). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

Harman, G. (1975). Moral relativism defended. The Philosophical Review, 84(1), 3–22.

Harris, J. D. (2006). How much is too much? A theoretical analysis of executive compensation from the standpoint of distributive justice. In R. W. Kolb (Ed.), The ethics of executive compensation (pp. 67–86). Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.

Harvard Business Review. (2014). The whys and wherefores of executive pay. Harvard Business Review, 92(7/8), 32–33.

Hermalin, B. E. (2005). Trends in corporate governance. The Journal of Finance, 60(5), 2351–2384.

Hewitt, A. (2012). 2012 Trends in global employee engagement. Aon Corporation.

Himmelberg, C. P., & Hubbard, R. G. (2000). Incentive pay and the market for CEOs: An analysis of pay-for-performance sensitivity. New York, NY: Columbia University.

Hofstede, G. H., Hofstede, G. J., & Minkov, M. (2010). Cultures and firms: Software of the mind: Intercultural cooperation and its importance for survival. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

Holmstrom, B. (1979). Moral hazard and observability. The Bell Journal of Economics, 10(1), 74–91.

Holmstrom, B. (1982). Moral hazard in teams. The Bell Journal of Economics, 13(2), 324–340.

Holmstrom, B., & Kaplan, S. N. (2003). The state of US corporate governance: What’s right and what’s wrong? Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 15(3), 8–20.

Holmstrom, B., & Milgrom, P. (1991). Multitask principal-agent analyses: Incentive contracts, asset ownership, and job design. Journal of Law Economics and Organization, 7, 24–52.

Jeffrey, S. (2004). The benefits of tangible non-monetary incentives. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago, Graduate School of Business.

Jeffrey, S. A. (2009). Justifiability and the motivational power of tangible noncash incentives. Human Performance, 22(2), 143–155.

Jensen, M. C., & Murphy, K. J. (1990a). Performance pay and top-management incentives. Journal of Political Economy, 98(2), 225–264.

Jensen, M. C., & Murphy, K. J. (1990b). CEO incentives: It’s not how much you pay, but how. Harvard Business Review, 68(3), 138–149.

Jensen, M. C., Murphy, K. J., & Wruck, E. G. (2004). Remuneration: Where we’ve been, how we got to here, what are the problems, and how to fix them. Finance working paper, European Corporate Governance Institute, Brussels, Belgium.

Kahn, W. A. (1990). Psychological conditions of personal engagement and disengagement at work. Academy of Management Journal, 33(4), 692–724.

Kahneman, D., & Tversky, A. (2008). Choices, values and frames (p. 840). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Khurana, R. (2007). From higher aims to hired hands: The social transformation of American business schools and the unfulfilled promise of management as a profession. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Kolb, R. W. (2012). Too much is not enough: Incentives in executive compensation. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Krausz, M. (1989). Relativism: Interpretation and confrontation. IN: University of Notre Dame Press.

Krausz, M. (2010). Relativism: A contemporary anthology. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

Lambert, R. A. (2001). Contracting theory and accounting. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 32(1), 3–87.

Laurentian Bank of Canada. (2016). Management proxy circular. Montréal, QC: Laurentian Bank.

Le Grand, J. (1990). Equity versus efficiency: The elusive trade-off. Ethics, 100(3), 554–568.

Legrand, J., & Bartlett, W. (1993). Quasi-markets and social policy. London: MacMillan.

Leinwand, P., & Mainardi, C. (2010). The coherence premium. Harvard Business Review, Boston, MA. Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2010/06/the-coherence-premium.

McMahon, C. (2013). Public capitalism: The political authority of corporate executives. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Milkovich, G. T., Newman, J. M., & Gerhart, B. A. (2014). Compensation (11th ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill/Irwin.

Mintzberg, H. (1982). A note on that dirty word efficiency. Interfaces, 12(5), 101–105.

Mishel, L., & Sabadish, N. (2012). CEO pay and the top 1%: How executive compensation and financial-sector pay have fueled income inequality. Washington, DC: Issue brief, Economic Policy Institute.

Mishel, L., & Schieder, J. (2017). CEO pay remains high relative to the pay of typical workers and high-wage earners. Report, Economic Policy Institute, Washington, DC.

Mone, E., Eisinger, C., Guggenheim, K., Price, B., & Stine, C. (2011). Performance management at the wheel: Driving employee engagement in firms. Journal of Business and Psychology, 26(2), 205–212.

Moriarty, J. (2005). Do CEOs get paid too much? Business Ethics Quarterly, 15(2), 257–281.

Moriarty, J. (2006). How to (try to) justify CEO pay. In R. W. Kolb (Ed.), The ethics of executive compensation. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.

Murphy, M. (2015). The big number. Wall Street Journal, New York, NY. Retrieved from http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-big-number-1445904434.

Murphy, K. J., & Zabojnik, J. (2004). CEO pay and appointments: A market-based explanation for recent trends. The American Economic Review, 94(2), 192–196.

Néron, P.-Y. (2015). Egalitarianism and executive compensation: A relational argument. Journal of Business Ethics, 132(1), 171–184.

Nozick, R. (1974). Anarchy, state, and utopia. New York, NY: Basic Books.

Olsaretti, S. (2004). Liberty, desert and the market: A philosophical study. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Oyer, P. (2004). Why do firms use incentives that have no incentive effects? The Journal of Finance, 59(4), 1619–1650.

Piketty, T. (2014). Capital in the twenty-first century (A. Goldhammer, Trans.). Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

Rajgopal, S., Taylor, D., & Venkatachalam, M. (2012). Frictions in the CEO labor market: The role of talent agents in CEO compensation. Contemporary Accounting Research, 29(1), 119–151.

Rich, B. L., Lepine, J. A., & Crawford, E. R. (2010). Job engagement: Antecedents and effects on job performance. Academy of Management Journal, 53(3), 617–635.

Saks, A. M. (2006). Antecedents and consequences of employee engagement. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 21(7), 600–619.

Schellhardt, T. D. (1998). Executive pay (A special report): Pay checks. They show them the money: Lawyer-agents like Robert J. Stucker help executives win the big bucks—And not overlook the fine print. New York, NY: The Wall Street Pub.

Schumpeter, J. (1942). Creative destruction—Capitalism, socialism and democracy (Vol. 825). Reedited by Routledge, May 13, 2013.

Scott, D., McMullen, T., & Royal, M. (2011). Reward fairness. Scottsdale AR: Report, WorldatWork.

Securities and Exchange Commission. (2006). Final rules 33-8732a, Item 402(b)(2)(xiv). Washington, D.C.

Shaw, W. H. (2006). Justice, incentives, and executive compensation. In R. W. Kolb (Ed.), The ethics of executive compensation (pp. 87–100). Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.

Sorenson, S., & Garman, K. (2013). How to tackle U.S. employees’ stagnating engagement. Gallup, Washington. Retrieved from Gallup http://news.gallup.com/businessjournal/162953/tackle-employees-stagnating-engagement.aspx.

Spencer Stuart. (2016). U.S. Board Index. New York. Retrieved from: https://www.spencerstuart.com/~/media/pdf%20files/research%20and%20insight%20pdfs/spencer-stuart-us-board-index-2016_1mar2017.pdf.

Stadler, C. (2015). How to become a CEO: These are the steps you should take. Forbes Magazine, New York, NY. Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/christianstadler/2015/03/12/how-to-become-a-ceo-these-are-the-steps-you-should-take/#4016d7ce1217.

Stiglitz, J. E. (2015). The great divide: Unequal societies and what we can do about them. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Company.

St-Onge, S. (2014). Gestion de la rémunération—Théorie et pratique. Montréal, QC: Chenelière Education.

Sur, S., Magnan, M., & Cordeiro, J. (2015). Disentangling CEO compensation: A simultaneous examination of time, industry, and firm-level effects. Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences/Revue Canadienne des Sciences de l’Administration, 32(1), 30–46.

Tomasello, M. (1999). The cultural origins of human cognition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Tomasi, J. (2012). Free market fairness. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

United Technologies Corporation. (2016). Annual proxy statement. Farmington, CT: United Technologies Corporation.

Van Dyke, M. (2015). Base salary: Using non-monetary awards to support behaviors that drive business results. The compensation handbook: A state-of-the-art guide to compensation strategy and design (pp. 143–156). New York: McGraw-Hill.

Williamson, O. E. (1975). Markets and hierarchies, analysis and antitrust implications: A study in the economics of internal organization. New York, NY: Free Press.

Williamson, O. E. (1981). The economics of organization: The transaction cost approach. American Journal of Sociology, 87, 548–577.