Examining whether touch sensory feedback is necessary for science learning through experimentation: A literature review of two different lines of research across K-16

Baddeley, 1992, Working memory, Science, 255, 556, 10.1126/science.1736359 Baddeley, 2003, Working memory: looking back and looking forward, Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 4, 829, 10.1038/nrn1201 Baddeley, 1974, Working memory, 47, 10.1016/S0079-7421(08)60452-1 Bara, 2004, The visuo-haptic and haptic exploration of letters increases the kindergarten-children's understanding of the alphabetic principle, Cognitive Development, 19, 433, 10.1016/j.cogdev.2004.05.003 Barsalou, 1999, Perceptual symbol systems, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 22, 577, 10.1017/S0140525X99002149 Barsalou, 2008, Grounded cognition, Annual Review of Psychology, 59, 617, 10.1146/annurev.psych.59.103006.093639 Barsalou, 2003, Social embodiment, Psychology of Learning and Motivation, 43, 43, 10.1016/S0079-7421(03)01011-9 Bayazit, 2001, Ligand binding with OBPRM and user input, 954 Bivall, 2011, Do haptic representations help complex molecular learning?, Science Education, 95, 700, 10.1002/sce.20439 Bivall, 2007, Designing and evaluating a haptic system for biomolecular education, 171 Brooks, 1990, Project GROPE – haptic displays for scientific visualization, ACM Computer Graphics, 24, 177, 10.1145/97880.97899 Burton, 2000, Attending to and remembering tactile stimuli: a review of brain imaging data and single-neuron responses, Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology, 17, 575, 10.1097/00004691-200011000-00004 Chan, 2006 Chini, 2012, Exploration of factors that affect the comparative effectiveness of physical and virtual manipulatives in an undergraduate laboratory, Physical Review Special Topics – Physics Education Research, 8, 010113, 10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.8.010113 Cox, 1999, Representation construction, externalised cognition and individual differences, Learning and Instruction, 9, 343, 10.1016/S0959-4752(98)00051-6 Dede, 2000, The design of immersive virtual learning environments: fostering deep understandings of complex scientific knowledge, 361 Fernald, 1943 Finkelstein, 2005, When learning about the real world is better done virtually: a study of substituting simulations for laboratory equipment, Physical Review Special Topics – Physics Education Research, 1, 1, 10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.1.010103 Fischer, 2008, Embodied language: a review of the role of the motor system in language comprehension, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 61, 825, 10.1080/17470210701623605 Gibbs, 2005 Gire, 2010, The effects of physical and virtual manipulatives on students' conceptual learning about pulleys, Vol. 1, 937 Glenberg, 1997, What memory is for. Creating meaning in the service of action, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 20, 1, 10.1017/S0140525X97000010 Hallman, 2009, Possibilities of haptic feedback simulation for physics learning, 3597 Han, 2013, Embodiment: a new perspective for evaluating physicality in learning, Journal of Educational Computing Research, 49, 41, 10.2190/EC.49.1.b Han, 2011, Incorporating haptic feedback in simulation for learning physics, Computers & Education, 57, 2281, 10.1016/j.compedu.2011.06.012 Jaakkola, 2008, Fostering elementary school students' understanding of simple electricity by combining simulation and laboratory activities, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 24, 271, 10.1111/j.1365-2729.2007.00259.x Jaakkola, 2011, A comparison of students' conceptual understanding of electric circuits in simulation only and simulation-laboratory contexts, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 48, 71, 10.1002/tea.20386 Jones, 2003, Learning at the nanoscale: the impact of students' use of remote microscopy on concepts of viruses, scale, and microscopy, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 40, 303, 10.1002/tea.10078 Jones, 2006, Haptic augmentation of science instruction: does touch matter?, Science Education, 90, 111, 10.1002/sce.20086 de Jong, 2010, Cognitive load theory, educational research, and instructional design: some food for thought, Instructional Science, 38, 105, 10.1007/s11251-009-9110-0 de Jong, 2013, Physical and virtual laboratories in science and engineering education, Science, 340, 305, 10.1126/science.1230579 Klahr, 2007, Hands on what? The relative effectiveness of physical versus virtual materials in an engineering design project by middle school children, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 44, 183, 10.1002/tea.20152 Klatzky, 2002, Touch, 147 Klatzky, 1987, There's more to touch than meets the eye: the salience of object attributes for haptics with and without vision, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 116, 356, 10.1037/0096-3445.116.4.356 Kontra, 2015, Physical experience enhances science learning, Psychological Science, 26, 737, 10.1177/0956797615569355 Lakoff, 1999 Lazonder, 2014, Relative effectiveness of physical and virtual manipulatives for conceptual change in science: how falling objects fall, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 30, 110, 10.1111/jcal.12024 Loomis, 1986, Tactual perception, 1 Low, 2005, The modality principle, 147 Luciano, 2009, Haptics-based virtual reality periodontal training simulator, Virtual Reality, 13, 69, 10.1007/s10055-009-0112-7 Manches, 2012, Tangibles for learning: a representational analysis of physical manipulation, Personal and Ubiquitous Computing, 16, 405, 10.1007/s00779-011-0406-0 Marras, 2006, Virtual dental patient: a system for virtual teeth drilling, 665 McDermott, 1996 McNeil, 2007, When theories don't add up: disentangling the manipulatives debate, Theory into Practice, 46, 309, 10.1080/00405840701593899 Millar, 1999, Memory in touch, Psicothema, 11, 747 Minogue, 2006, Haptics in education: exploring an untapped sensory modality, Review of Educational Research, 76, 317, 10.3102/00346543076003317 Minogue, 2009, Measuring the impact of haptic feedback using the SOLO taxonomy, International Journal of Science Education, 31, 1359, 10.1080/09500690801992862 Minogue, 2006, The impact of haptic augmentation on middle school students' conceptions of the animal cell, Virtual Reality, 10, 293, 10.1007/s10055-006-0052-4 Olympiou, 2012, Blending physical and virtual manipulatives: an effort to improve students' conceptual understanding through science laboratory experimentation, Science Education, 96, 21, 10.1002/sce.20463 Pohlenz, 2010, Virtual dental surgery as a new educational tool in dental school, Journal of Cranio-Maxillofacial Surgery, 38, 560, 10.1016/j.jcms.2010.02.011 Pouw, 2014, An embedded and embodied cognition review of instructional manipulatives, Education Psychology Review, 26, 51, 10.1007/s10648-014-9255-5 Reiner, 1999, Conceptual construction of fields through tactile interface, Interactive Learning Environments, 7, 31, 10.1076/ilee.7.1.31.3598 Reiner, 2009, Sensory cues, visualization and physics learning, International Journal of Science Education, 31, 343, 10.1080/09500690802595789 Renken, 2013, Computer simulations and clear observations do not guarantee conceptual understanding, Learning and Instruction, 23, 10, 10.1016/j.learninstruc.2012.08.006 Schönborn, 2011, Exploring relationships between students' interaction and learning with a haptic virtual biomolecular model, Computers & Education, 57, 2095, 10.1016/j.compedu.2011.05.013 Smith, 2005, The development of embodied cognition: six lessons from babies, Artificial Life, 11, 13, 10.1162/1064546053278973 Sweller, 1994, Cognitive load theory, learning difficulty and instructional design, Learning and Instruction, 4, 295, 10.1016/0959-4752(94)90003-5 Sweller, 1998, Cognitive architecture and instructional design, Educational Psychology Review, 10, 251, 10.1023/A:1022193728205 Toth, 2012, Blended inquiry with hands-on and virtual laboratories: the role of perceptual features during knowledge construction, Interactive Learning Environments, 1 Toth, 2009, Designing blended inquiry learning in a laboratory context: a study of incorporating hands-on and virtual laboratories, Innovative Higher Education, 33, 333, 10.1007/s10755-008-9087-7 Triona, 2003, Point and click or grab and heft: comparing the influence of physical and virtual instructional materials on elementary school students' ability to design experiments, Cognition and Instruction, 21, 149, 10.1207/S1532690XCI2102_02 Vidal, 2008, Simulation of ultrasound guided needle puncture using patient specific data with 3D textures and volume haptics, Computer Animation and Virtual Worlds, 19, 111, 10.1002/cav.217 Wiebe, 2009, Haptic feedback and students' learning about levers: unraveling the effect of simulated touch, Computers & Education, 53, 667, 10.1016/j.compedu.2009.04.004 Williams, 2003, Haptics-augmented simple-machine educational tools, Journal of Science Education and Technology, 12, 1, 10.1023/A:1022114409119 Wilson, 2001, The case for sensorimotor coding in working memory, Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 8, 44, 10.3758/BF03196138 Wilson, 2002, Six views of embodied cognition, Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 9, 625, 10.3758/BF03196322 Winn, 2006, Learning oceanography from a computer simulation compared with direct experience at sea, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 43, 25, 10.1002/tea.20097 Zacharia, 2005, The impact of interactive computer simulations on the nature and quality of postgraduate science teachers' explanations in physics, International Journal of Science Education, 27, 1741, 10.1080/09500690500239664 Zacharia, 2007, Comparing and combining real and virtual experimentation: an effort to enhance students' conceptual understanding of electric circuits, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 23, 120, 10.1111/j.1365-2729.2006.00215.x Zacharia, 2003, The effects of an interactive computer-based simulation prior to performing a laboratory inquiry-based experiment on students' conceptual understanding of physics, American Journal of Physics, 71, 618, 10.1119/1.1566427 Zacharia, 2008, Comparing the influence of physical and virtual manipulatives in the context of the physics by inquiry curriculum: the case of undergraduate students' conceptual understanding of heat and temperature, American Journal of Physics, 76, 425, 10.1119/1.2885059 Zacharia, 2014, The effects on students' conceptual understanding of electric circuits of introducing virtual manipulatives within a physical manipulatives oriented curriculum, Cognition and Instruction, 32, 101, 10.1080/07370008.2014.887083 Zacharia, 2012, Is physicality an important aspect of learning through science experimentation among kindergarten students?, Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 27, 447, 10.1016/j.ecresq.2012.02.004 Zacharia, 2015, Using physical and virtual manipulatives to improve primary school students' understanding of concepts of electric circuits Zacharia, 2011, Physical versus virtual manipulative experimentation in physics learning, Learning and Instruction, 21, 317, 10.1016/j.learninstruc.2010.03.001 Zacharia, 2008, Effects of experimenting with physical and virtual manipulatives on students' conceptual understanding in heat and temperature, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 45, 1021, 10.1002/tea.20260