Examining pedagogical approaches and types of mathematics knowledge in educational games: A meta-analysis and critical review

Amory, 1999, The use of computer games as an educational tool: Identification of appropriate game types and game elements, British Journal of Educational Technology, 30, 311, 10.1111/1467-8535.00121 Arnab, 2015, Mapping learning and game mechanics for serious games analysis, British Journal of Educational Technology, 46, 391, 10.1111/bjet.12113 Bai, 2012, Assessing the effectiveness of a 3‐D instructional game on improving mathematics achievement and motivation of middle school students, British Journal of Educational Technology, 43, 993, 10.1111/j.1467-8535.2011.01269.x Bakker, 2015, Effects of playing mathematics computer games on primary school students' multiplicative reasoning ability, Contemporary Educational Psychology, 40, 55, 10.1016/j.cedpsych.2014.09.001 Baroody, 2007, An alternative reconceptualization of procedural and conceptual knowledge, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 115 Beserra, 2017, Using a fine-grained multiple-choice response format in educational drill-and-practice video games, Interactive Learning Environments, 25, 717, 10.1080/10494820.2016.1172244 Bisanz, 1990, Strategic and nonstrategic processing in the development of mathematical cognition, 213 Blumberg, 2019, Digital games as a context for children's cognitive development: Research recommendations and policy considerations, Social Policy Report, 32, 1, 10.1002/sop2.3 Borenstein, 2011 Borenstein, 2014 Boyle, 2016, An update to the systematic literature review of empirical evidence of the impacts and outcomes of computer games and serious games, Computers & Education, 94, 178, 10.1016/j.compedu.2015.11.003 Bray, 2017, Technology usage in mathematics education research–A systematic review of recent trends, Computers & Education, 114, 255, 10.1016/j.compedu.2017.07.004 Brezovszky, 2019, Effects of a mathematics game-based learning environment on primary school students' adaptive number knowledge, Computers & Education, 128, 63, 10.1016/j.compedu.2018.09.011 Callaghan, 2018, Are educational preschool apps designed to teach? An analysis of the app market, Learning, Media and Technology, 43, 280, 10.1080/17439884.2018.1498355 Chang, 2015, Differential effects of learning games on mathematics proficiency, Educational Media International, 52, 47, 10.1080/09523987.2015.1005427 Clark, 2007, Learning from serious games? Arguments, evidence, and research suggestions, Educational Technology, 47, 56 Clark, 2016, Digital games, design, and learning: A systematic review and meta-analysis, Review of Educational Research, 86, 79, 10.3102/0034654315582065 Cohen, 1988 Conole, 2004, Mapping pedagogy and tools for effective learning design, Computers & Education, 43, 17, 10.1016/j.compedu.2003.12.018 Crooks, 2014, Defining and measuring conceptual knowledge in mathematics, Developmental Review, 34, 344, 10.1016/j.dr.2014.10.001 Deci, 2001, Extrinsic rewards and intrinsic motivation in education: Reconsidered once again, Review of Educational Research, 71, 1, 10.3102/00346543071001001 Deen, 2015, The differences between problem-based and drill and practice games on motivations to learn, International Journal of Gaming and Computer-Mediated Simulations, 7, 44, 10.4018/IJGCMS.2015070103 Dewey, 1938 Dubé, 2019, Tablets as elementary mathematics education tools: Are they effective and why, 223 Dubé, 2020 Dubé, 2016, Are games a viable home numeracy practice?, 165 Dubé, 2021 Ellis, 2005, The paradigm shift in mathematics education: Explanations and implications of reforming conceptions of teaching and learning, Mathematics Educator, 15 Fabian, 2016, Mobile technology and mathematics: Effects on students' attitudes, engagement, and achievement, Journal of Computers in Education, 3, 77, 10.1007/s40692-015-0048-8 Federation of American Scientists, 2006 Foster, 2015, The play curricular activity reflection discussion model for game-based learning, Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 47, 71, 10.1080/15391523.2015.967551 Frenzel, 2010, Development of mathematics interest in adolescence: Influences of gender, family, and school context, Journal of Research on Adolescence, 20, 507, 10.1111/j.1532-7795.2010.00645.x Girard, 2013, Serious games as new educational tools: How effective are they? A meta‐analysis of recent studies, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 29, 207, 10.1111/j.1365-2729.2012.00489.x Hattie, 2009 Hedges, 1981, Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators, Journal of Educational Statistics, 6, 107, 10.3102/10769986006002107 van den Heuvel-Panhuizen, 2013, Primary school students' strategies in early algebra problem solving supported by an online game, Educational Studies in Mathematics, 84, 281, 10.1007/s10649-013-9483-5 Hidi, 2006, Interest: A unique motivational variable, Educational Research Review, 1, 69, 10.1016/j.edurev.2006.09.001 Hirsh-Pasek, 2015, Putting education in “educational” apps: Lessons from the science of learning, Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 16, 3, 10.1177/1529100615569721 Holman, 2018, In defense of meta-analysis, Synthese, 196, 3189, 10.1007/s11229-018-1690-2 Hsieh, 2005, Three approaches to qualitative content analysis, Qualitative Health Research, 15, 1277, 10.1177/1049732305276687 Johnston, 2018, Exploring pedagogical foundations of existing virtual reality educational applications: A content analysis study, Journal of Educational Technology Systems, 46, 414, 10.1177/0047239517745560 Ke, 2019, Mathematical problem solving and learning in an architecture-themed epistemic game, Educational Technology Research & Development, 67, 1085, 10.1007/s11423-018-09643-2 Kebritchi, 2008, Examining the pedagogical foundations of modern educational computer games, Computers & Education, 51, 1729, 10.1016/j.compedu.2008.05.004 Kebritchi, 2010, The effects of modern mathematics computer games on mathematics achievement and class motivation, Computers & Education, 55, 427, 10.1016/j.compedu.2010.02.007 Kiili, 2005, Digital game-based learning: Towards an experiential gaming model, The Internet and Higher Education, 8, 13, 10.1016/j.iheduc.2004.12.001 Kiili, 2014, Studying the user experience of a tablet-based math game, International Journal of Game-Based Learning, 4, 60, 10.4018/IJGBL.2014010104 Kirriemuir, 2004 Kolb, 1984 Larkin, 2015, “An app! An app! My kingdom for an app”: An 18-month quest to determine whether apps support mathematical knowledge building, 251 Lee, 2019, Do math apps “teach” numeracy skills to young children? LeFevre, 2010, Pathways to mathematics: Longitudinal predictors of performance, Child Development, 81, 1753, 10.1111/j.1467-8624.2010.01508.x Lenhart, 2015 Lipsey, 2001 Maertens, 2016, Enhancing arithmetic in pre-schoolers with comparison or number line estimation training: Does it matter?, Learning and Instruction, 46, 1, 10.1016/j.learninstruc.2016.08.004 Malone, 1981, Toward a theory of intrinsically motivating instruction, Cognitive Science, 5, 333, 10.1207/s15516709cog0504_2 Mayer, 2014 Mayring, 2004, Qualitative content analysis, A companion to qualitative research, 1, 159 McEwen, 2015, Engaging or distracting: children's tablet computer use in education, Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 18, 9 McEwen, 2016, Intuitive or idiomatic: An interdisciplinary study of child‐tablet computer interaction, Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 67, 1169, 10.1002/asi.23470 McLaren, 2017, A computer-based game that promotes mathematics learning more than a conventional approach, International Journal of Game-Based Learning, 7, 36, 10.4018/IJGBL.2017010103 McManis, 2012, Finding the education in educational technology with early learners, Young Children, 67, 14 Miller, 2007, Using evidence‐based practices to build mathematics competence related to conceptual, procedural, and declarative knowledge, Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 22, 47, 10.1111/j.1540-5826.2007.00230.x O'Rourke, 2017, Commercially available digital game technology in the classroom: Improving automaticity in mental-maths in primary-aged students, Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 42, 50, 10.14221/ajte.2017v42n10.4 2020 Ok, 2016, How to find good apps: An evaluation rubric for instructional apps for teaching students with learning disabilities, Intervention in School and Clinic, 51, 244, 10.1177/1053451215589179 Olney, 2008, iPods in early childhood: Mobile technologies and storytelling, 696 O'Neil, 2005, Classification of learning outcomes: Evidence from the computer games literature, Curriculum Journal, 16, 455, 10.1080/09585170500384529 Ormrod, 1995 Outhwaite, 2019, Raising early achievement in math with interactive apps: A randomized control trial, Journal of Educational Psychology, 111, 284, 10.1037/edu0000286 Outhwaite, 2017, Closing the gap: Efficacy of a tablet intervention to support the development of early mathematical skills in UK primary school children, Computers & Education, 108, 43, 10.1016/j.compedu.2017.01.011 Papadakis, 2018, The effectiveness of computer and tablet assisted intervention in early childhood students' understanding of numbers. An empirical study conducted in Greece, Education and Information Technologies, 23, 1849, 10.1007/s10639-018-9693-7 Pitchford, 2015, Development of early mathematical skills with a tablet intervention: A randomized control trial in Malawi, Frontiers in Psychology, 6, 485, 10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00485 Plass, 2013, The impact of individual, competitive, and collaborative mathematics game play on learning, performance, and motivation, Journal of Educational Psychology, 105, 1050, 10.1037/a0032688 Prensky, 2001, Digital natives, digital immigrants. Part 1, On The Horizon, 9, 1, 10.1108/10748120110424816 Riconscente, 2013, Results from a controlled study of the iPad fractions game Motion Math, Games and Culture, 8, 186, 10.1177/1555412013496894 Rideout, 2019 Rittle-Johnson, 2015, Not a one-way street: Bidirectional relations between procedural and conceptual knowledge of mathematics, Educational Psychology Review, 27, 587, 10.1007/s10648-015-9302-x Rittle-Johnson, 1998, The relation between conceptual and procedural knowledge in learning mathematics: A review, 75 Rittle-Johnson, 2001, Developing conceptual understanding and procedural skill in mathematics: An iterative process, Journal of Educational Psychology, 93, 346, 10.1037/0022-0663.93.2.346 Rittle‐Johnson, 2006, Promoting transfer: Effects of self‐explanation and direct instruction, Child Development, 77, 1, 10.1111/j.1467-8624.2006.00852.x Rittle‐Johnson, 2017, Developing mathematics knowledge, Child Development Perspectives, 11, 184, 10.1111/cdep.12229 2019, The development of arithmetic skills, 51 Rutherford, 2014, A randomized trial of an elementary school mathematics software intervention: Spatial-temporal math, Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, 7, 358, 10.1080/19345747.2013.856978 Schacter, 2016, Math shelf: A randomized trial of a prekindergarten tablet number sense curriculum, Early Education & Development, 27, 74, 10.1080/10409289.2015.1057462 Shin, 2012, Effects of game technology on elementary student learning in mathematics, British Journal of Educational Technology, 43, 540, 10.1111/j.1467-8535.2011.01197.x Stegenga, 2011, Is meta-analysis the platinum standard of evidence?, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 42, 497, 10.1016/j.shpsc.2011.07.003 Valdez, 2013, Math snacks: Using animations and games to fill the gaps in mathematics, Journal of Curriculum and Teaching, 2, 154, 10.5430/jct.v2n2p154 van der Ven, 2017, Effects of a tablet game intervention on simple addition and subtraction fluency in first graders, Computers in Human Behavior, 72, 200, 10.1016/j.chb.2017.02.031 Wang, 2018, A microworld-based role-playing game development approach to engaging students in interactive, enjoyable, and effective mathematics learning, Interactive Learning Environments, 26, 411, 10.1080/10494820.2017.1337038 Wiburg, 2016, Impact of Math Snacks games on students' conceptual understanding, Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science Teaching, 35, 173 Wouters, 2013, A meta-analytic review of the role of instructional support in game-based learning, Computers & Education, 60, 412, 10.1016/j.compedu.2012.07.018 Wu, 2012, Re-exploring game-assisted learning research: The perspective of learning theoretical bases, Computers & Education, 59, 1153, 10.1016/j.compedu.2012.05.003 Wu, 2012, Investigating the learning‐theory foundations of game‐based learning: A meta‐analysis, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 28, 265, 10.1111/j.1365-2729.2011.00437.x Yeh, 2019, Enhancing achievement and interest in mathematics learning through Math-Island, Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning, 14, 5, 10.1186/s41039-019-0100-9 Young, 2012, Our princess is in another castle: A review of trends in serious gaming for education, Review of Educational Research, 82, 61, 10.3102/0034654312436980