Evaluation of Palm Oil Eco-Industrial Park Configurations: VIKOR with Stability Analysis
Tóm tắt
Empty fruit bunch (EFB) is an underutilized waste generated by palm oil mills which has the potential to be converted into various useful products such as nanocrystalline cellulose (NCC), bioethanol, and electricity. The development of a palm oil eco-industrial park (EIP), consisting of palm oil mill and other relevant industrial plants that valorize EFB, can provide opportunities of economics sharing and improved ecosystem. However, the individual plants in the EIP will have their own individual goals and conflicting criteria with other stakeholders. Therefore, in this study, different EIP configurations consisting of palm oil mill, combined heat and power (CHP) plant, NCC plant, and bioethanol plant are established. The performances of different EIP configurations are evaluated by first adopting stability analysis to ensure a fair profit and cost distribution, followed by employing multi-criteria decision-making tool known as Vlsekriterijumska Optimizacija I Kompromisno Resenje (VIKOR) to address multiple conflicting criteria. Five criteria are considered for the evaluation of palm oil EIP configurations which include the overall symbiosis cost to profit ratio, total industrial output value, total CO2 equivalent emissions, industrial waste recycling rate, and energy recycling rate. The results demonstrated that EIP with the configuration consisting of palm oil mill, CHP plant, NCC plant, and bioethanol plant is the highest-ranked alternative. This is determined by the lowest value of comprehensive indicator, Qj, via VIKOR analysis when the five criteria were set to be equally important. Sensitive analyses are performed to demonstrate the relationship between Qj value with respect to the weightage of each criterion.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Andiappan V (2017) State-of-the-art review of mathematical optimisation approaches for synthesis of energy systems. Process Integration and Optimization for Sustainability 1(3):165–188
Andiappan V, Tan RR, Ng DK (2016) An optimization-based negotiation framework for energy systems in an eco-industrial park. J Clean Prod 129:496–507
Bacudio LR, Benjamin MFD, Eusebio RCP, Holaysan SAK, Promentilla MAB, Yu KDS, Aviso KB (2016) Analyzing barriers to implementing industrial symbiosis networks using DEMATEL. Sustainable Production and Consumption, 7:57–65
Beaudry G, Macklin C, Roknich E, Sears L, Wiener M, Greenhouse gas assessment of palm oil mill biorefinery in Thailand from a life cycle perspective. Biomass Conversion and Biorefinery 8(1):43–58
Benjamin MFD (2018) Multi-disruption criticality analysis in bioenergy-based eco-industrial parks via the P-graph approach. J Clean Prod 186:325–334
Benjamin MFD, Cayamanda CD, Tan RR, Razon LF (2017) P-graph approach to criticality analysis in integrated bioenergy systems. Clean Techn Environ Policy 19(7):1841–1854
Benjamin MFD, Andiappan V, Lee JY, Tan RR (2020) Increasing the reliability of bioenergy parks utilizing agricultural waste feedstock under demand uncertainty. J Clean Prod 269:122385
Bozell JJ, Petersen GR (2010) Technology development for the production of biobased products from biorefinery carbohydrates-the US Department of Energy’s “Top 10” revisited. Green Chem 12(4):539–554
Chan WM, Leong YT, Chew IML (2020) Multiple-criteria evaluation of centralized chilled water hub powered by industrial waste heat and renewable energy. J Clean Prod 247:119570
Chertow MR (2000) Industrial symbiosis: literature and taxonomy. Annu Rev Energy Environ 25(1):313–337
Chiew YL, Shimada S (2013) Current state and environmental impact assessment for utilizing oil palm empty fruit bunches for fuel, fiber and fertilizer–a case study of Malaysia. Biomass Bioenergy 51:109–124
de Assis CA, Houtman C, Phillips R, Bilek EM, Rojas OJ, Pal L et al (2017) Conversion economics of forest biomaterials: risk and financial analysis of CNC manufacturing. Biofuels Bioprod Biorefin 11(4):682–700
Duckstein L, Opricovic S (1980) Multiobjective optimization in river basin development. Water Resour Res 16(1):14–20
Fichtner W, Frank M, Rentz O (2004) Inter-firm energy supply concepts: an option for cleaner energy production. J Clean Prod 12(8-10):891–899. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2004.02.036
Forman EH, Gass SI (2001) The analytic hierarchy process—an exposition. Oper Res 49(4):469–486
Frosch RA, Gallopoulos NE (1989) Strategies for manufacturing. Sci Am 261(3):144–153
Ghaleb AM, Kaid H, Alsamhan A, Mian SH, Hidri L (2020) Assessment and comparison of various MCDM approaches in the selection of manufacturing process. Adv Mater Sci Eng 2020:1–16
Hwang CL, Lai YJ, Liu TY (1993) A new approach for multiple objective decision making. Comput Oper Res 20(8):889–899
Ibeto CN, Ofoefule AU, Agbo KE (2011) A global overview of biomass potentials for bioethanol production: a renewable alternative fuel. Trends Applied Scientific Research 6(5):410–425
Jelinski LW, Graedel TE, Laudise RA, McCall DW, Patel CK (1992) Industrial ecology: concepts and approaches. Proc Natl Acad Sci 89(3):793–797
Korhonen J (2001) Four ecosystem principles for an industrial ecosystem. J Clean Prod 9(3):253–259
Kumar A, Aswin A, Gupta H (2020) Evaluating green performance of the airports using hybrid BWM and VIKOR methodology. Tour Manag 76:103941
Kuznetsova E, Zio E, Farel R (2016) A methodological framework for Eco-Industrial Park design and optimization. J Clean Prod 126:308–324
Lee SH, Ng RT, Ng DK, Foo DC, Chew IM (2014) Synthesis of resource conservation networks in an integrated pulp and paper biorefinery. Ind Eng Chem Res 53(25):10417–10428
Leigh M, Li X (2015) Industrial ecology, industrial symbiosis and supply chain environmental sustainability: a case study of a large UK distributor. J Clean Prod 106:632–643
Leong YT, Lee JY, Tan RR, Foo JJ, Chew IML (2017) Multi-objective optimization for resource network synthesis in eco-industrial parks using an integrated analytic hierarchy process. J Clean Prod 143:1268–1283
Lim CI, Biswas W (2019) Sustainability assessment for crude palm oil production in Malaysia using the palm oil sustainability assessment framework. Sustain Dev 27(3):253–269
Ling W C, Verasingham AB, Andiappan V, Wan YK, Chew IM, & Ng DK (2019). An integrated mathematical optimisation approach to synthesise and analyse a bioelectricity supply chain network. Energy, 178:554–571.
Lowe EA, Moran SR, Holmes DB, Martin SA (1995) A fieldbook for the development of eco-industrial parks. Report for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Oakland, CA: Indigo Development International
Majdi I (2013) Comparative evaluation of PROMETHEE and ELECTRE with application to sustainability assessment (Doctoral dissertation, Concordia University)
Malaysian Palm Oil Board (2019a) Production of oil palm products 2019. Retrieved 13 April 2020, from http://bepi.mpob.gov.my/index.php/en/production/production-2019/production-of-oil-palm-products-2019.html
Malaysian Palm Oil Board (2019b) Number & capacities of palm oil sectors 2019. Retrieved 13 April 2020, from http://bepi.mpob.gov.my/index.php/en/sectoral-status/sectoral-status-2019/number-a-capacities-of-palm-oil-sectors-2019.html
Malaysian Palm Oil Board (2020) Monthly Prices: Mac 2020. Retrieved 13 April 2020, from http://bepi.mpob.gov.my/index.php/en/?option=com_content&view=article&id=906&Itemid=138
Mateusz P, Danuta M, Małgorzata Ł, Mariusz B, Kesra N (2018) TOPSIS and VIKOR methods in study of sustainable development in the EU countries. Procedia Computer Science 126:1683–1692
Ong MC, Leong YT, Wan YK, Chew IML (2021) Multi-objective Optimization of Integrated Water System by FUCOM-VIKOR Approach. Process Integration and Optimization for Sustainability 5(1):43-62
Opricovic S, Tzeng GH (2002) Multicriteria planning of post-earthquake sustainable reconstruction. Comput Aided Civ Infrastruct Eng 17(3):211–220
Opricovic S, Tzeng GH (2004) Compromise solution by MCDM methods: a comparative analysis of VIKOR and TOPSIS. Eur J Oper Res 156(2):445–455
Opricovic S, Tzeng GH (2007) Extended VIKOR method in comparison with outranking methods. Eur J Oper Res 178(2):514–529
Reeb C, Hays T, Venditti R, Gonzalez R, Kelley S (2014) Supply chain analysis, delivered cost, and life cycle assessment of oil palm empty fruit bunch biomass for green chemical production in Malaysia. Bioresources 9(3):5385–5416
Sermyagina E, Saari J, Kaikko J, Vakkilainen E (2016) Integration of torrefaction and CHP plant: operational and economic analysis. Appl Energy 183:88–99
Tan RR, Ng RT, Andiappan V, Wan YK, Ng DK (2015) An optimization-based cooperative game approach for allocation of costs and benefits in interplant process integration. Chem Eng Trans 45:403–408
Tan RR, Andiappan V, Wan YK, Ng RT, Ng DK (2016a) An optimization-based cooperative game approach for systematic allocation of costs and benefits in interplant process integration. Chem Eng Res Des 106:43–58
Tan RR, Benjamin MFD, Cayamanda CD, Aviso KB, Razon LF (2016b) P-graph approach to optimizing crisis operations in an industrial complex. Ind Eng Chem Res 55(12):3467–3477
Tao L, Chen X, Aden A, Kuhn E, Himmel ME, Tucker M, Franden MAA, Zhang M, Johnson DK, Dowe N, Elander RT (2012) Improved ethanol yield and reduced minimum ethanol selling price (MESP) by modifying low severity dilute acid pretreatment with deacetylation and mechanical refining: 2) Techno-economic analysis. Biotechnol Biofuels 5(1):69
Teh KC, Tan RR, Aviso KB, Promentilla MAB, Tan J (2019) An integrated analytic hierarchy process and life cycle assessment model for nanocrystalline cellulose production. Food Bioprod Process 118:13–31
Tenaga Nasional Berhad (2014) Electricity Tariff Schedule. Retrieved 13 April 2020, from https://www.tnb.com.my/assets/files/Tariff_Rate_Final_01.Jan.2014.pdf
Trottier S (2015) Understanding the changes to global warming potential (GWP) values. Retrieved 13 April 2020, from https://ecometrica.com/assets/Understanding-the-Changes-to-GWPs.pdf
Wang G, Feng X, Chu KH (2013) A novel approach for stability analysis of industrial symbiosis systems. J Clean Prod 39:9–16
Yu X, Lu Y, Cai M (2018) Evaluating agro-meteorological disaster of China based on differential evolution algorithm and VIKOR. Nat Hazards 94(2):671–687
Zhao H, Zhao H, Guo S (2017) Evaluating the comprehensive benefit of eco-industrial parks by employing multi-criteria decision making approach for circular economy. J Clean Prod 142:2262–2276