Evaluating topography-based methods in 3D decomposition of InSAR 1D velocities obtained for translational landslides: Thompson River valley in Canada
Tóm tắt
Interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) has gained considerable attention as a landslide monitoring strategy owing to its high accuracy, large coverage, and relatively low associated costs. A crucial drawback of InSAR, however, has limited its further incorporation: one-dimensional estimations along the sensor’s line-of-sight (LOS). This leads to an ambiguity in results and a less intuitive understanding of landslide kinematics. A frequently exercised approach to address this issue has been taking inspiration from the topography to establish compatibility assumptions between velocity components, yet little insight exists on the performance of these methods. The objective of this paper is to investigate the performance of four renowned topography-based methods—Surface Parallel Flow Model (SPFM), SPFM coupled with least-squares method (SPF-LSM), Aspect Parallel Flow Model (APFM), and Steepest Terrain Following Model (STFM)—in evaluating the magnitude and geometry of total velocity vectors. To this end, the analysis is performed on 202 Radarsat-2 and 243 Sentinel-1 scenes acquired over a section of the Thompson River valley, a critical railway corridor in Western Canada traversing 14 landslides. The results indicate that the APFM provides estimations with the lowest magnitude error (15–19 mm/yr or 18.75–23.75% of in situ measurements) compared to the other approaches. SPFM and SPF-LSM are highly sensitive to LOS variance and tend to bias the interpreted vectors toward the north orientation. However, APFM and STFM reflect more realistic aspect angles, with the former inclined to steeper travel angles and the latter suffering from erratic upward travel angles due to local topographies.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Ajvazi B, Czimber K (2019) A comparative analysis of different DEM interpolation methods in GIS: case study of Rahovec. Kosovo Geodesy and Cartography 45(1):43–48
Ao M, Zhang L, Shi X, Liao M, Dong J (2019) Measurement of the three-dimensional surface deformation of the Jiaju landslide using a surface-parallel flow model. Remote Sens Letters 10(8):776–785
Azadnejad S, Maghsoudi Y, Perissin D (2019) Investigating the effect of the physical scattering mechanism of the dual-polarization sentinel-1 data on the temporal coherence optimization results. Int J Remote Sens 40(18):7033–7047
Bar N, Arrieta M, Espino A, Diaz C, Mosquea LA, Mojica B, McQuillan A, Baldeon G, Falorni G (2022) Back-analysis of ductile slope failure mechanisms and validation with aerial photogrammetry, InSAR and GbRAR to proactively manage economic risks to protect the mine plan. In: Hammah et al. (eds) The Evolution of Geotech – 25 Year, 1st edn. CRC Press/Balkema, pp 512–526
Bechor NB, Zebker HA (2006) Measuring two-dimensional movements using a single InSAR pair. Geophys Res Lett 33(16):L16311
Bentivenga M, Bellanova J, Calamita G, Capece A, Cavalcante F, Gueguen E, Guglielmi P, Murgante B, Palladino G, Perrone A, Saganeiti L (2021) Geomorphological and geophysical surveys with InSAR analysis applied to the Picerno earth flow (southern Apennines, Italy). Landslides 18:471–483
Berardino P, Fornaro G, Lanari R, Sansosti E (2002) A new algorithm for surface deformation monitoring based on small baseline differential SAR interferograms. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 40(11):2375–2383
Biagini L, Macciotta R, Gräpel C, Tappenden K, Skirrow R (2022) Characteristics, kinematics and contributing factors of compound and translational landslides in the Interior Plains of Canada. Geosciences 12(8):289
Bianchini S, Herrera G, Mateos RM, Notti D, Garcia I, Mora O, Moretti S (2013) Landslide activity maps generation by means of persistent scatterer interferometry. Remote Sens 5(12):6198–6222
Bishop N, Evans S, Petley D, Unger A (2008) The geotechnics of glaciolacustrine sediments and associated landslides near Ashcroft (British Columbia) and the Grand Coulee Dam (Washington). In Proc of the 4th GeoHazards Conference of Canadian Geotechnical Society, Quebec, Quebec, Canada
Bobrowsky P, Huntley D, Neelands P, MacLeod R, Mariampillai D, Hendry M, Macciotta R, Reeves H, Chambers J (2017) Ripley Landslide—Canada’s premier landslide field laboratory. In: Abstracts and Proceedings of GSA Annual Meeting
Carlà T, Tofani V, Lombardi L, Raspini F, Bianchini S, Bertolo D, Thuegaz P, Casagli N (2019) Combination of GNSS, satellite InSAR, and GBInSAR remote sensing monitoring to improve the understanding of a large landslide in high alpine environment. Geomorphology 335:62–75
Cenni N, Fiaschi S, Fabris M (2021) Integrated use of archival aerial photogrammetry, GNSS, and InSAR data for the monitoring of the Patigno landslide (Northern Apennines, Italy). Landslides 18(6):2247–2263
Chen H, Zhao C, Sun R, Chen L, Wang B, Li B (2022) Two-dimensional deformation monitoring of karst landslides in Zongling, China, with multi-platform distributed scatterer InSAR technique. Landslides 19(7):1767–1777
Clague JJ, Evans SG (2003) Geologic framework of large historic landslides in Thompson River Valley. British Columbia Environ Eng Geosci 9(3):201–212
Desmet PJJ (1997) Effects of interpolation errors on the analysis of DEMs. Earth Surf Processes and Landforms: the J of the Br Geomorphological Group 22(6):563–580
Eriksen HØ, Lauknes TR, Larsen Y, Corner GD, Bergh SG, Dehls J, Kierulf HP (2017) Visualizing and interpreting surface displacement patterns on unstable slopes using multi-geometry satellite SAR interferometry (2D InSAR). Remote Sens Environ 191:297–312
Eshraghian A, Martin CD, Cruden DM (2005) Landslides in the Thompson River Valley between Ashcroft and Spences Bridge, British Columbia. In: Hungr et al. (eds) Landslide Risk Management, 1st Edn. CRC Press, pp 437–446
Eshraghian A, Martin CD, Cruden DM (2007) Complex earth slides in the Thompson River Valley, Ashcroft. British Columbia Environ Eng Geosci 13(2):161–181
Eshraghian A, Martin CD, Morgenstern NR (2008a) Hazard analysis of an active slide in the Thompson River valley, Ashcroft, British Columbia. Canada Can Geotech J 45(3):297–313
Eshraghian A, Martin CD, Morgenstern NR (2008b) Movement triggers and mechanisms of two earth slides in the Thompson River Valley, British Columbia. Canada Can Geotech J 45(9):1189–1209
Fan H, Wang L, Wen B, Du S (2021) A new model for three-dimensional deformation extraction with single-track InSAR based on mining subsidence characteristics. Int J Appl Earth Obs Geoinf 94:102223
Ferretti A (2014) Satellite InSAR data: reservoir monitoring from space. EAGE Publications, Houten
Ferretti A, Fumagalli A, Novali F, Prati C, Rocca F, Rucci A (2011) A new algorithm for processing interferometric data-stacks: SqueeSAR. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 49(9):3460–3470
Ferretti A, Prati C, Rocca F (2001) Permanent scatterers in SAR interferometry. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 39(1):8–20
Frattini P, Crosta GB, Rossini M, Allievi J (2018) Activity and kinematic behaviour of deep-seated landslides from PS-InSAR displacement rate measurements. Landslides 15:1053–1070
Guo G, Wang H, Bell D, Bi Y, Greer K (2003) KNN model-based approach in classification. In: OTM Confederated International Conferences “On the Move to Meaningful Internet Systems”, Berlin, Heidelberg. pp 986–996
Han Q, Sassa K, Mikoš M (2020) International Programme on Landslides (IPL): a programme of the ICL for landslide disaster risk reduction. In: Proceedings of the Workshop on World Landslide Forum, pp 187–203
Hendry MT, Macciotta R, Martin CD, Reich B (2015) Effect of Thompson River elevation on velocity and instability of Ripley Slide. Can Geotech J 52(3):257–267
Her Y, Heatwole CD, Kang MS (2015) Interpolating SRTM elevation data to higher resolution to improve hydrologic analysis. J of the American Water Resources Association 51(4):1072–1087
Herrera G, Gutiérrez F, García-Davalillo JC, Guerrero J, Notti D, Galve JP, Fernández-Merodo JA, Cooksley G (2013) Multi-sensor advanced DInSAR monitoring of very slow landslides: the Tena Valley case study (Central Spanish Pyrenees). Remote Sens Environ 128:31–43
Hu J, Li ZW, Ding XL, Zhu JJ, Zhang L, Sun Q (2014) Resolving three-dimensional surface displacements from InSAR measurements: a review. Earth Sci Rev 133:1–17
Huntley D, Rotheram-Clarke D, Pon A, Tomaszewicz A, Leighton J, Cocking R, Joseph J (2021) Benchmarked RADARSAT-2, SENTINEL-1 and RADARSAT Constellation Mission change-detection monitoring at North Slide, Thompson River Valley, British Columbia: ensuring a landslide-resilient national railway network. Can J Remote Sens 47(4):635–656
Intrieri E, Raspini F, Fumagalli A, Lu P, Del Conte S, Farina P, Allievi J, Ferretti A, Casagli N (2018) The Maoxian landslide as seen from space: detecting precursors of failure with Sentinel-1 data. Landslides 15:123–133
Jia H, Wang Y, Ge D, Deng Y, Wang R (2022) InSAR study of landslides: early detection, three-dimensional, and long-term surface displacement estimation—a case of Xiaojiang River Basin. China Remote Sens 14(7):1759
Jo MJ, Jung HS, Won JS (2017) Measurement of precise three-dimensional volcanic deformations via TerraSAR-X synthetic aperture radar interferometry. Remote Sens Environ 192:228–237
Joughin IR, Kwok R, Fahnestock MA (1998) Interferometric estimation of three-dimensional ice-flow using ascending and descending passes. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 36(1):25–37
Journault J, Macciotta R, Hendry MT, Charbonneau F, Huntley D, Bobrowsky PT (2018) Measuring displacements of the Thompson River valley landslides, south of Ashcroft, BC, Canada, using satellite InSAR. Landslides 15(4):621–636
Khorrami M, Abrishami S, Maghsoudi Y, Alizadeh B, Perissin D (2020) Extreme subsidence in a populated city (Mashhad) detected by PSInSAR considering groundwater withdrawal and geotechnical properties. Sci Rep 10(1):11357
Khoshlahjeh Azar M, Hamedpour A, Maghsoudi Y, Perissin D (2021) Analysis of the deformation behavior and sinkhole risk in Kerdabad, Iran using the PS-InSAR method. Remote Sens 13(14):2696
Komac M, Holley R, Mahapatra P, van der Marel H, Bavec M (2015) Coupling of GPS/GNSS and radar interferometric data for a 3D surface displacement monitoring of landslides. Landslides 12(2):241–257
Lannacone JP, Falorni G (2016) Towards InSAR guidelines for landslide monitoring. In Proc of the 69th Conference of Canadian Geotechnical Society, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Li M, Zhang L, Ding C, Li W, Luo H, Liao M, Xu Q (2020) Retrieval of historical surface displacements of the Baige landslide from time-series SAR observations for retrospective analysis of the collapse event. Remote Sens Environ 240:111695
Liu X, Zhao C, Zhang Q, Yin Y, Lu Z, Samsonov S, Yang C, Wang M, Tomás R (2021) Three-dimensional and long-term landslide displacement estimation by fusing C-and L-band SAR observations: a case study in Gongjue County, Tibet. China Remote Sens Environ 267:112745
Lucieer A, Jong SMD, Turner D (2014) Mapping landslide displacements using Structure from Motion (SfM) and image correlation of multi-temporal UAV photography. Prog Phys Geog 38(1):97–116
Ma P, Cui Y, Wang W, Lin H, Zhang Y (2021) Coupling InSAR and numerical modeling for characterizing landslide movements under complex loads in urbanized hillslopes. Landslides 18(5):1611–1623
Macciotta R, Hendry M, Martin CD, Elwood D, Lan H, Huntley D, Bobrowsky P, Sladen W, Bunce C, Choi E, Edwards T (2014). Monitoring of the Ripley Landslide in the Thompson River Valley, BC. In: Proceedings of the 6th Canadian Geohazards Conference, Kingston, Ontario, Canada
Macciotta R, Hendry M, Martin CD (2016) Developing an early warning system for a very slow landslide based on displacement monitoring. Nat Hazards 81(2):887–907
Milczarek W, Kopeć A, Głąbicki D, Bugajska N (2021) Induced seismic events—distribution of ground surface displacements based on InSAR methods and Mogi and Yang models. Remote Sens 13(8):1451
Ng AHM, Ge L, Zhang K, Li X (2012) Estimating horizontal and vertical movements due to underground mining using ALOS PALSAR. Eng Geol 143:18–27
Perissin D, Wang T (2011) Repeat-pass SAR interferometry with partially coherent targets. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 50(1):271–280
Porter M, Savigny K, Keegan T, Bunce C, MacKay C (2002) Controls on stability of the Thompson River landslides. In: Proceedings of the 55th Conference of Canadian Geotechnical Society, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
Ren K, Yao X, Li R, Zhou Z, Yao C, Jiang S (2022) 3D displacement and deformation mechanism of deep-seated gravitational slope deformation revealed by InSAR: a case study in Wudongde Reservoir. Jinsha River Landslides 19(9):2159–2175
Rotheram-Clarke D, Huntley D, LeSueur P, Cocking R, Joseph J, MacLeod R (2022) Direct comparison of RADARSAR Constellation Mission InSAR, UAD derived point cloud comparison & RTK GNSS deformation monitoring GNSS deformation monitoring at North Slide, Thompson River Valley, British Columbia. In: Proceedings of the 75th Conference of Canadian Geotechnical Society, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
Samsonov S, Tiampo K (2006) Analytical optimization of a DInSAR and GPS dataset for derivation of three-dimensional surface motion. IEEE Geosci Remote Sens Lett 3(1):107–111
Samsonov S, Dille A, Dewitte O, Kervyn F, d’Oreye N (2020) Satellite interferometry for mapping surface deformation time series in one, two and three dimensions: a new method illustrated on a slow-moving landslide. Eng Geol 266:105471
Samsonov S, Gonzalez PJ, Tiampo K, d’Oreye N (2013) Spatio-temporal analysis of ground deformation occurring near Rice Lake, Saskatchewan, and observed by Radarsat-2 DInSAR during 2008–2011. Can J Remote Sens 39(1):27–33
Samsonov S, Tiampo K, Rundle J, Li Z (2007) Application of DInSAR-GPS optimization for derivation of fine-scale surface motion maps of Southern California. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 45(2):512–521
Schafer MB (2016) Kinematics and controlling mechanics of the slow moving Ripley Landslide. Dissertation, University of Alberta
Schlögl M, Gutjahr K, Fuchs S (2022) The challenge to use multi-temporal InSAR for landslide early warning. Nat Hazards 112(3):2913–2919
Sharifi S, Hendry MT, Macciotta R, Evans T (2022a) Evaluation of filtering methods for use on high-frequency measurements of landslide displacements. Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci 22(2):411–430
Sharifi S, Macciotta R, Hendry MT (2022b) Algorithms to enhance detection of landslide acceleration moment and time-to-failure forecast using time-series displacements. Eng Geol 309:106832
Sharifi S, Macciotta R, Hendry M (2022c) InSAR time-series displacement analysis on the Oldman River Dam, southern Alberta. In: Proceedings of the 8th GeoHazards Conference of Canadian Geotechnical Society, Quebec City, Quebec, Canada
Shi X, Xu Q, Zhang L, Zhao K, Dong J, Jiang H, Liao M (2019) Surface displacements of the Heifangtai terrace in Northwest China measured by X and C-band InSAR observations. Eng Geol 259:105181
Shi X, Zhang L, Zhou C, Li M, Liao M (2018) Retrieval of time series three-dimensional landslide surface displacements from multi-angular SAR observations. Landslides 15(5):1015–1027
Simons M, Rosen PA (2007) Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar Geodesy Geodesy 3:391–446
Soltanieh A, Macciotta R (2022a) Updated understanding of the Thompson River Valley landslides kinematics using satellite InSAR. Geosciences 12(10):359
Soltanieh A, Macciotta R (2022b) Updated understanding of the Ripley landslide kinematics using satellite InSAR. Geosciences 12(8):298
Stanton RB (1898) The great land-slides on the Canadian Pacific Railway in British Columbia. Minutes Proc Inst Civ Eng 132(1898):1–20
Sun Q, Hu J, Zhang L, Ding X (2016) Towards slow-moving landslide monitoring by integrating multi-sensor InSAR time series datasets: The Zhouqu case study. China Remote Sens 8(11):908
Tarighat F, Foroughnia F, Perissin D (2021) Monitoring of power towers’ movement using persistent scatterer SAR interferometry in south west of Tehran. Remote Sens 13(3):407
Taunk K, De S, Verma S, Swetapadma A (2019). A brief review of nearest neighbor algorithm for learning and classification. In: Proceedings of the 2019 International Conference on Intelligent Computing and Control Systems, Madurai, India
Wang Z, Yu S, Tao Q, Liu G, Hao H, Wang K, Zhou C (2018) A method of monitoring three-dimensional ground displacement in mining areas by integrating multiple InSAR methods. Int J Remote Sens 39(4):1199–1219
Wasowski J, Bovenga F (2014) Investigating landslides and unstable slopes with satellite Multi Temporal Interferometry: Current issues and future perspectives. Eng Geol 174:103–138
Yang ZF, Li ZW, Zhu JJ, Preusse A, Yi HW, Wang YJ, Papst M (2017) An extension of the InSAR-based probability integral method and its application for predicting 3-D mining-induced displacements under different extraction conditions. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 55(7):3835–3845
Yi Z, Xingmin M, Allesandro N, Tom D, Guan C, Colm J, Yuanxi L, Xiaojun S (2022) Characterization of pre-failure deformation and evolution of a large earthflow using InSAR monitoring and optical image interpretation. Landslides 19(1):35–50
Zhu W, Zhang Q, Ding X, Zhao C, Yang C, Qu F, Qu W (2014) Landslide monitoring by combining of CR-InSAR and GPS techniques. Adv Space Res 53(3):430–439
Zhu Y, Yao X, Yao L, Zhou Z, Ren K, Li L, Yao C, Gu Z (2022) Identifying the mechanism of toppling deformation by InSAR: a case study in Xiluodu Reservoir. Jinsha River Landslides 19(10):2311–2327