Engineering Variables to Replace the Concept of ‘Noncombustibility’

Vytenis Babrauskas1
1Fire Science and Technology Inc., San Diego, USA

Tóm tắt

The concept of noncombustibility evolved in the early days of building codes, before quantitative methods of measuring and assessing components of fire hazard were available. ‘Noncombustible’ lacks a technical definition of general scope, but in the US codes, which are the primary focus of this study, it is defined as a material which meets the criteria of the ASTM E136 test. The hazard variables underlying the noncombustibility concept are examined in this study. In view of today’s state of the art, it is shown that noncombustibility requirements, in most cases, constitute a misapplication of fire safety principles and that their use should be discontinued, in preference of using variables that express quantitative fire safety principles. Heat release rate (HRR) is the primary variable which correctly establishes the relevant hazard. In recent years, some regulations have been promulgated which use bench-scale HRR test results directly for this purpose. The ultimate hazard to be addressed, however, is the full-scale HRR behavior. When the hazard involves fires which may spread over surface linings, however, the full-scale HRR is not simply directly scaled to the bench-scale HRR. To quantify this hazard properly, additional properties of the material which govern the flame spread behavior need to be considered. A simple, easy-to-use method for this purpose are described, which is based solely on data obtainable from the Cone Calorimeter (ASTM E1354; ISO 5660) test. Validation of the concept against room-scale data is provided and is shown to be successful.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Claret AM, Andrade AT (2007) Fire load survey of historic buildings: a case study. J Fire Prot Eng 17:103–112

Narayanan P (1995) Fire severities for structural fire engineering design (Study Report No. 67), BRANZ, Porirua

Bird EL, Docking SJ (1949) Fire in buildings. Adam & Charles Black, London

Babrauskas V (1976) Fire endurance in buildings (Ph.D. dissertation). University of California, Berkeley

Building Code Recommended by the National Board of Fire Underwriters. James Kempster Printing Co., New York (1905)

The National Building Code (1976) Recommended by the American Insurance Association. American Insurance Association, Engineering and Safety Service, New York

Building Code Recommended by the National Board of Fire Underwriters, New York (1915) An ordinance providing for fire limits, and regulations governing the construction, alteration, equipment, repair or removal of buildings or structures. National Board of Fire Underwriters, New York

Lyons PR (1976) Fire in America, NFPA, Boston

Powers WR (1970) One New York Plaza Fire, New York, August 5, 1970, The New York Board of Fire Underwriters, New York

Sachs EO (1898) The Paris Charity Bazaar Fire (Publications of The British Fire Prevention Committee, No. 3), The British Fire Prevention Committee, London

Standard test method for surface burning characteristics of building materials (ASTM E84). ASTM, West Conshohocken

Steiner AJ (1943) Method of fire–hazard classification of building materials. ASTM Bull 19–22

Steiner AJ (1944) Fire hazard classification of building materials (Bull. of Research No. 32), Underwriters’ Laboratories, Inc., Chicago

Cocoanut Grove Night Club Fire, Boston, November 28, 1942, National Fire Protection Association, Quincy (1943)

Steiner AJ (1964) Historical background of the Fire Protection Department, Underwriters’ Laboratories, Inc., pp 15–40. In: Brandon M, eds., The Departments of Underwriters’ Laboratories, Inc., Underwriters’ Laboratories, Chicago

Babrauskas V (2003) Ignition handbook. Fire Science Publishers/Society of Fire Protection Engineers, Issaquah

Fire resistance, incombustibility, and noninflammability of building materials and structures (BS 476). British Standards Institution, London (1932)

Setchin NP, Ingberg SH (1945) Test criterion for an incombustible material, Proc ASTM 45:866–877

Shorter GW, Sumi K (1952) ASTM combustibility tests (Research Report 6). Division of Building, Research, National Research Council Canada, Ottawa

Sumi K (1955) Comparison of combustibility test procedures (DBR Report No. 43), Division of Building, Research, National Research Council Canada, Ottawa

Setchkin NP (1952) Combustibility tests of 47 ASTM material samples (NBS 1454), U. S. National Bureau Standards, Washington

ASTM (1957) Proposed method of test for defining noncombustibility of building materials. ASTM Bull 33–34

Noncombustibility of elementary materials (ASTM E136-65), ASTM, Philadelphia (1965). In the 1979 edition, this standard was renamed as: behavior of materials in a vertical tube furnace at 750°C.

Fire tests—building materials—non-combustibility test (ISO 1182), ISO, Geneva

Herpol GA (1972) Noncombustibility—its definition, measurement, and applications. In: Ignition, heat release, and noncombustibility of materials (ASTM STP 502), pp 99–111. ASTM, Philadelphia

Gross D, Lindauer RA, Willard R (1973) Evaluation of two test methods for noncombustibility: ASTM E136 and ISO R1182 (Report of Test No. FR 3846), U. S. National Bureau Standards, Washington

Standard test method for behavior of materials in a vertical tube furnace at 750°C (ASTM E136-2012). ASTM Intarnational, West Conshohocken (2012)

International Building Code. International Code Council, Inc., Country Club Hills (2006)

Uniform Building Code, 1970 edition, International Conference of Building Officials, Whittier CA (1970).

Hall JR, Jr. (2011) Fatal effects of fire, NFPA, Quincy

Christian WJ (1974) The effect of structural characteristics on dwelling fire fatalities. Fire J 68(1)22

Vogel BM (1977) A study of fire spread in multi-family residences: the causes, the remedies. Build Stand 46(2)56–59, 80

Vogel BM (1977) A study of fire spread in multi-family residences: the causes—the remedies (NBSIR 76–1194), U.S. National Bureau Standards, Gaithersburg

Chamberlain D, King E (1987) Heat release rates of construction assemblies by the substitution method (Technical Report No. 9). American Forest & Paper Associationn, Washington

Tran H, White R (1990) Heat release rate from wood wall assemblies using oxygen consumption method. In: Fire and polymers: hazards identification and prevention (ACS symposium series 425). American Chemical Society, Washington, pp 411–428

Thompson NJ, Cousins EW (1959) The FM construction materials calorimeter, NFPA Q 52:186–192

Babrauskas V, Grayson SJ (1992) Heat release in fires. E&FN Spon, London

Sharry JL, Walker E (1974) Military personnel records center fire, Overland, Missouri. Fire J 68:3:5–9, 65–70

Ingberg SH (1928) Tests of the severity of building fires. Q NFPA 22(3)43–61

International Standard—fire tests—full scale room test for surface products. ISO 970. ISO, Geneva (1993)

Standard test method for room fire test of wall and ceiling materials and assemblies (ASTM E2257). ASTM Interantional, West Conshohocken

Standard methods of fire tests for evaluating contribution of wall and ceiling interior finish to room fire growth (NFPA 286), National Fire Protection Assocaiation, Quincy

Standard test method for evaluating room fire growth contribution of textile wall covering (UBC Standard 8-2), Uniform Building Code, Vol. 3, International conference of Building Officials, Whittier (1997)

International Standard—fire tests—reaction to fire—part 1: rate of heat release from building products (Cone Calorimeter method). ISO 5660-1:2015(E). ISO, Geneva (2015)

Standard test method for heat and visible smoke release rates for materials and products using an oxygen consumption calorimeter (E1354). ASTM International, West Conshohocken

Hakkarainen T, Hayashi Y (2001) Comparison of Japanese and European Fire Classification Systems for Surface Linings. Fire Sci Technol (Jpn) 21(1)19–42

Fire Tests—Reduced-scale model box test (ISO TS 17431), ISO, Geneva (2006)

Hermesky M, Murrell J (2009) Cone calorimeter—a cautionary tale. J ASTM Intl. 6:8

Babrauskas V, Peacock RD (1992) Heat release rate: the single most important variable in fire hazard. Fire Saf J 18:255–272

Standard test method for the determination of combustibility parameters of building materials using an oxygen consumption calorimeter (cone calorimeter), CAN/ULC-S135-04, Underwriters’ Laboratories of Canada, Toronto (2004)

Richardson L. R, Brooks ME (1991) Combustibility of building materials. Fire Saf J 15:131–136

Richardson LR (1994) Determining degrees of combustibility of building materials: National Building Code of Canada. Fire Mater 18:99–106

Carpenter K, Janssens M (2005) Using heat release rate to assess combustibility of building products in the cone calorimeter. Fire Technol 41:79–92

National Building Code of Canada (2010) Canadian Commission on Building and Fire Codes. National Research Council Canada, Ottawa

Dowling VP, Blackmore JM (1998) Fire performance of wall and ceiling linings (Final Report Project 2, Stage A). Fire Code Reform Centre, Sydney

NCC 2015—National Building Code of Australia (2015) Australian Building Codes Board, Canberra, ACT

Wade C (1995) Fire performance of external wall claddings under a performance-based building code. Fire Mater 19:127–132

Cowles GS, Soja E (1999) Flame spread classification method for exterior wall claddings. In: Interflam’99. Interscience Communications Ltd., London, pp 1021–1031

Approved Document for New Zealand Building Code (2006) Fire safety. Clauses C1, C2, C3, C4. Building Industry Authority/Standards New Zealand, Wellington (2001). Reissued as: Compliance Document for New Zealand Building Code. Clauses C1, C2, C3, C4. Fire Safety. Dept. of Building and Housing, Wellington

Alpert RL, Khan MM (2003) A new test method for rating materials as noncombustible. In: Fire safety science—proceedings of 7th international symposium, International Association for Fire Safety Science, pp 791–802

Ahonen A, Weckman H, Yli-Penttilä M (1985) Application of oxygen-consumption calorimetry to non-combustibility testing. Fire Mater 9:135–144

Babrauskas V (1984) Bench-scale methods for prediction of full-scale fire behavior of furnishings and wall linings (SFPE Technical Report 84-10). Society of Fire Protection Engineers, Boston

Drysdale DD (2011) An introduction to fire dynamics, 3rd edn. Wiley, Chichester

Baroudi D, Kokkala M (1992) Analysis of upward flame spread, Project 5 of the EUREFIC Fire Research Programme (VTT Publications 89). VTT, Technical Research Centre of Finland, Espoo

Cleary TG, Quintiere JG (1991) Framework for utilizing fire property tests. In: Proceedings of 3rd international symposiums on fire safety science, International Association for Fire Safety Science, pp 647–656. Elsevier Applied Science, New York

Sundström B (1986) Full scale fire testing of surface materials (SP-RAPP 1986:45), Borås

Söderbom J (1991) EUREFIC—large scale tests according to ISO DIS 9705. Project 4 of the EUREFIC Fire Research Programme (SP Report 1991:27), Borås

Thureson P (1996) fire tests of linings according to room/corner test, ISO 9705 (Client report 95R22049), Borås

Tsantaridis L, Östman B (1989) Smoke, gas and heat release data for building products in the cone calorimeter (Rapport I 8903013), Trätek, Stockholm

Thureson P (1991) EUREFIC—cone calorimeter test results. Project 4 of the EUREFIC Fire Research Programme (SP Report 1991:24), Borås

Dillon SE, Kim WH, Quintiere JG (1998) Determination of properties and the prediction of the energy release rate of materials in the ISO 9705 room-corner test. Appendices. (NIST-GCR-98-754), Nat. Inst. Stand. & Technol., Gaithersburg

Tsantaridis L, Östman B (1999) Cone calorimeter data and comparisons for the SBI RR products (Report I 9812090), Trätek

Babrauskas V, White JA. Jr., Urbas J (1997) Testing for surface spread of flame: new tests to come into use. Build Stand 66(2):13–18

Babrauskas V, Lucas D, Eisenberg D, Singla V, Dedeo M, Blum A (2012) Flame retardants in building insulation: a case for re-evaluating building codes. Build Res Inf 40:738–755

Standard Methods of Fire Tests for Flame Propagation of Textiles and Films (NFPA 701), National Fire Protection Association, Quincy

Babrauskas V, Gray BF, Janssens ML (2007) Prudent practices for the design and installation of heat-producing devices near wood materials. Fire Mater 31:125–135

Babrauskas V (2016) Explosions of ammonium nitrate fertilizer in storage or transportation are preventable accidents. J Hazard Mater 304:134–149

Torsuev NS (1936) Explosive fertilizer containing ammonium nitrate. J Chem Indus [Russian] 13:102–104

Babrauskas V (2016) UN Test O.1 errors in quantifying the behavior of solid oxidizers. J Loss Prevent Process Indus 39:1–6

Su JZ, Lougheed GD (2014) Report to research consortium for wood and wood-hybrid mid-rise buildings (Report A1-004377.1), National Research Council of Canada