Empirical research methods in operations management
Tóm tắt
This paper discusses the need for more research in operations management which is based on data from the real world. Tying operations management theory in with practice has been called for over a long period of time, however, many P/OM researchers do not have a strong foundation in gathering and using empirical data. This paper provides a starting point that encourages operations management researchers to use empirical data and provides a systematic approach for conducting empirical studies.
Empirical research can be used to document the state of the art in operations management, as well as to provide a baseline for longitudinal studies. It can also be invaluable in the development of parameters and distributions for mathematical and simulation modeling studies. A very important use for empirical data is in theory building and verification, topics which are virtually ignored in most P/OM research.
Operations management researchers may be reluctant to undertake empirical research, due to its cost, both in dollars and time and the relative risk involved. Because empirical research may be considered “soft,” compared with mathematical modeling, it may be perceived as risky. This paper attempts to provide a foundation of knowledge about empirical research, in order to minimize the risks to researchers. It also provides a discussion of analytical techniques and examples of extremely rigorous empirical P/OM research.
Although operations management researchers may not recognize it, all research is based on theory. The initial step in conducting empirical research deals with articulating the theoretical foundation for the study. It also includes determining whether the problem under investigation involves theory building or theory verification.
In the second step, a research design should be selected. Although surveys are fairly common in empirical P/OM research, a number of other designs, including single and multiple case studies, panel studies and focus groups, may also be used, depending on the problem being studied. Third, a data collection method should be selected. One method, or a combination of several data collection methods, should be used in conjunction with the research design. These include historical archive analysis, participant observation, outside observation, interviews, questionnaires and content analysis.
The implementation stage involves actually gathering the data. This section of the paper focuses on using questionnaires as the method of data analysis, although some of the concepts discussed may be applicable to other data collection methods, as well. A brief overview of data analysis methods is given, along with documentation of the types of data analysis which have been used in various types of empirical research conducted by operations management researchers over the past ten years. Potential outlets for publication of empirical P/OM research are discussed and their history of publishing such research is documented.
Underlying every step of the process are considerations of reliability and validity. Conducting empirical research without considering its reliability and validity is pointless, because the researcher will not be able to generalize from the results. This should be considered in each of the four stages listed in the approach described above.
A number of conclusions are discussed. These include the need for more empirical research and the need for P/OM researchers to become more critical readers of the empirical research done by others. Colleagues in the social sciences can be a valuable source of information about conducting empirical research. Industry contacts can be useful, as well, in pilot testing, finding industry sites and determining consensus on the definition of terms. Finally, researchers in operations management need to be more aware of the theory which underlies their work. Empirical research can be highly useful in both theory building and theory verification.
Từ khóa
Tài liệu tham khảo
W.J.Abernathy K.Wayne.The Limits of the Learning Curve.Harvard Business ReviewSeptember–October1974;109–119.
Alreck P., 1985, The Survey Research Handbook
Amoako‐Gyampah K., 1989, A Journal Review of Operations Management Research, 1021
Anderson J.C., 1982, Material Requirement Planning Systems: The State of the Art, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 24, 51
Ansari A., 1987, The Potential Benefits of Just‐in‐Time Purchasing for U.S. Manufacturing, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 28, 30
Bahl H.C., 1989, Teaching Production and Operations Management at the MBA Level—A Survey, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 30, 5
Benson P.G., 1982, Manufacturing Systems of the Future—A Delphi Study, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 24, 87
Best J.W., 1970, Research in Education
Blackstone J.H., 1985, Selecting MRP Software for Small Businesses, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 26, 42
Blalock H.M., 1969, Theory Construction: From Verbal to Mathematical Formulations
Bouchard T.J., 1976, Unobtrusive Measures: An Inventory of Uses, Sociological Methods and Research, 4, 10.1177/004912417600400301
Campbell D.T., 1963, Experimental and Quasi‐Experimental Designs for Research
Chase R.B., 1984, Designing High‐Contact Service Systems: Application to Branches of a Savings and Loan, Decision Sciences, 15, 543, 10.1111/j.1540-5915.1984.tb01241.x
Chervany R.P., 1989, A Survey of MRP Implementation, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 30, 31
Cook J.D., 1981, The Experience of Work: A Compendium and Review of 249 Measures and Their Use
De Meyer A., 1987, Managerial Focal Points in Manufacturing Strategy, International Journal of Production Research, 25, 1551
Dubin R., 1976, Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology
1986, Dun's Industrial Guide: The Metalworking Directory
Ebert R.J., 1990, Announcement on Empirical/Field Based Methodologies in JOM, Journal of Operations Management, 90, 135
Emory C.W., 1980, Business Research Methods
Ettlie J. Personal communication. 1989
Feldman H.D., 1985, The Senior Production Manager Job: Comparisons Through an Assessment of Demands, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 27, 88
Ferdows K., 1987, FMS as Indicator of the Strategic Role of Manufacturing, International Journal of Production Research, 25, 1563
Flynn B.B., 1989, Proceedings, Decision Sciences Institute
Ford F.N., 1987, Use of Operations Research in Production Managemen, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 28, 52
D.A.Garvin.Quality on the Line.Harvard Business ReviewSeptember–October1983;64–75.
Gergen K.J., 1986, Methodology in Social Science
Glaser B.G., 1967, The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research
Groff G. Personal communication 1989.
Hamilton S., 1986, Computer‐Based Manufacturing and Accounting Systems for Smaller Manufacturing Firms, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 25, 92
R.H.Hayes S.C.Wheelwright.Line Manufacturing Process and Product Life Cycles.Harvard Business ReviewJanuary–February 1979.
Horte S.A., 1987, Manufacturing Strategies in Sweden, International Journal of Production Research, 25, 1573
Hsu J.I.S., 1988, Equipment Replacement Policy—A Survey, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 29, 23
Huck S.W., 1974, Reading Statistics and Research
Kerlinger F.N., 1973, Foundations of Behavior Research
J.A.Klein.Why Supervisors Resist Employee Involvement.Harvard Business ReviewSeptember–October1984;87–95.
LaForge R.L., 1986, MRP Practices in a Random Sample of Manufacturing Firms, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 27, 129
LaForge R.L., 1983, A Survey of Production Management Supervisors, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 24, 99
McGuigan F., 1978, Experimental Psychology: A Methodological Approach
Mehrens W.A., 1967, Principals of Educational and Psychological Measurement: A Book of Selected Readings
Miles M., 1984, Qualitative Data Analysis
Modarress B., 1989, Quality Control Techniques in U.S. Firms: A Survey, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 30, 58
Monden Y., 1983, Toyota Production System: Practical Approach to Production Management
Monniot J.P., 1987, Report of a Study of Computer Aided Production Management in UK Batch Manufacturing, International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 7, 7, 10.1108/eb054788
Morris J.S., 1988, Manufacturing Planning and Control in Korea, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 29, 39
Narroll R., 1973, A Handbook of Method in Cultural Anthropology
Nunnally J., 1978, Psychometric Theory
Oakland J.S., 1987, Production and Operations Management Techniques in Manufacturing: Comparing the United Kingdom and the United States, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 28, 12
Parsons D., 1984, Employment and Manpower Surveys: A Practitioner's Guide
Pesch M., 1989, Ph.D. dissertation
Price J.L., 1986, Handbook of Organizational Measurement
Raiszadeh F.M.E., 1989, POM in Academia: Some Causes for Concern, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 30, 37
Rao A., 1989, Manufacturing Systems Changes to Support JIT, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 30
Roth A., 1987, Differentiated Manufacturing Strategies for the Competitive Advantage: An Empirical Investigation
Roth A., 1989, Linking Manufacturing Strategy and Performance: An Empirical Investigation
Runcie J.F., 1980, By Days I Make the Cars, Harvard Business Review, 58, 106
Schonberger R.J., 1982, Japanese Manufacturing Techniques: Nine Hidden Lessons in Simplicity
Schwab D.P, 1980, Construct Validity in Organizational Behavior, Research in Organizational Behavior, 2, 3
Spradley J.R, 1979, The Ethnographic Interview
Stahl M.J., 1983, Using Decision Modeling to Examine Management Consensus: A Study of a Maintenance Management Control System, Journal of Operations Management, 3, 98, 10.1016/0272-6963(83)90010-4
Stone E., 1978, Research Methods in Organizational Behavior
Voss C.A., 1987, Application of Just‐in‐Time Manufacturing Techniques in the United Kingdom, International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 7, 462
Wathen S.A, 1988, Ph.D. dissertation
Weber R.P., 1985, Basic Content Analysis
Weick K., 1984, Handbook of Social Psychology
A.Weiss.Simple Truths of Japanese Manufacturing.Harvard Business ReviewJuly–August1984;119–125.
White C.R., 1988, Educational and System Requirements for Production Control, Production and Inventory Management, 29, 10
Yin R.K., 1989, Case Study Research