Efficacy of inundative release ofTrichogramma chilonis in the management of the sugarcane internode borer,Chilo sacchariphagus indicus (K.)

Sugar Tech - Tập 8 - Trang 36-43 - 2018
N. Mukunthan1
1Section of Entomology, Sugarcane Breeding Institute, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India

Tóm tắt

This paper analyses the factors governing the efficacy ofTrichogramma chilonis and the basis for its popularity as a management tool for sugarcane internode borer. Published evidences were taken as the basis for the analysis. The factors taken in to consideration in the analysis are, the capabilities of egg parasitoids as prime tool to manage pests, attributes in the biology and innate abilitiesof T.chilonis as a candidate for inundative release and, the influence of sugarcane plant characters, the aspects in commercial production and the field release procedures in influencing its efficiency. Taking all the favourable attributes ofT.chilonis and reinforcing it with assumptions favouring at various stages of its parasitisation, the impact of inundative release on the suppression of internode borer damage was extrapolated based on the literature information on the biology, life table studies and damage potential of internode borer. The theoretical prevention of intensity of internode borer damage through the current recommended dose of inundative release ranged from 3.2 tol .93 per cent between the first and 6th release. The fortnightly release procedure, the limitation ofT.chilonis to parasitise eggs for the first day of release only, its selective preference within the egg stage rendering 17 per cent of the eggs that would be in black head stage in a given time unsuitable for it coupled with the daily egg laying of internode borer due to intra and inter brood overlappings rendered this prevention insignificant and transitory. The principle of inundative release and the term ‘natural enemy’ assumed for bioagents is also discussed to reveal it as being unscientific.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Agarwal, R.A. (1964). Studies on the effect of time of planting on the incidence of sugarcane borers in Coimbatore.Proceedings of Biennial Conference of Sugarcane Research and Development Workers.,5: 526–533 Albes, J.R.,McCommas, D.W.,Jones S.Land Morrison, R.K. (1980). Effect of cotton plant size, host egg location, and location of parasite release on parasitism byTrichogramma pretiosum.Southwest.Entomology,5: 261–64 Anon. (2004). 36th meeting of sugarcane research and development workers of Tamil Nadu. Sugarcane Breeding Institute, Coimbatore. 263 pp Bharadwaj, S.C., Chaudhary., J.P. and Singh., S.P.(1980). Studies on assessment of losses caused by stalk borer,Chilo auricilius Ddgn.Proc. Natn.Symp. Stalk borer, Karnal. p. 52–56 Bigler, F., Bosshart, S. Freig and Cerutti, F. (1993). Product control ofTrichogramma brassicae in Switzerland. Proceedings of the 7 th Workshop on quality control of Mass Reared Arthropods Eds. Nicoli, G., Leppla, N.C and Bonuzzi,M.) Rimini, Italy, 13–16 September 1993. p. 73–80 Cave, R.D. (2000). Biology, ecology and use inpest management ofTelenomus remus.Biocontrol News and Information,21(1) N21-N26 Cherian, M.C.and Subramaniam, C.K. (1940) Studies onDiatrea venosata, a pyralid pest of sugarcane in India.Madras Argicultue Journal,30: 44–49 David, B.V. (1992). Pest management and Pesticides: Indian Scenario. Namrutha Publications, Anna Nagar, Madras. 384 pp David, H. (1986). The internode borer,Chilo sacchariphagus indiens (Kapur). In “Sugarcane Entomology in India” (Eds. David, H. Easwaramoorthy, S and Jayanthi, R.) Sugarcane Breeding Institute, Coimbatore. p. 121–134 David, Hand Easwaramoorthy, S. (1986). Biological Control. (Eds. David, H., Easwaramoorthy, S and Jayanthi, R.) Sugarcane Breeding Institute, Coimbatore. p. 383–421 David, Hand Easwaramoorthy, S. (1991). Biocontrol technology for sugarcane pest management. Sugarcane Breeding Institute, ICAR. Coimbatore. 372 pp De Bach, P. (1964). Biological control by natural enemies, Cambridge University Press. New York. 323 pp De Bach, P.and Hagen, K.S. (1964). Manipulation of entomophagus species. In” Biological control of insect pests and weeds (Ed. De Bach, P.). Chapman and Hall Ltd., London, p. 429–458. Deshraj, (1975). Studies on the optimum potential and economics of mass rearing ofTrichogramma brasiliensis Ashmead. M.Sc. thesis. Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi. 50 PP Easwaramoorthy, S. (1986). Ecology of sugarcane pests. In ”Sugarcane Entomology inIndia” (Eds. David, H., Easwaramoorthy, S and Jayanthi, R.) Sugarcane Breeding Institute, ICAR, Coimbatore, p. 31–67 Easwaramoorthy, Sand Nandagopal, V. (1986). Life tables of internode borer,Chilo sachhariphagus indicus (K.) on resistant and susceptible varieties of sugarcane.Tropical Pest management,32(3): 221–228 Easwaramoorthy, S.Kurup, N.Kand Santhalakshmi, G. (1991). Arthropod predators in sugarcane pest management. In “Biocontrol technology for sugarcane pest management” (Eds. David, H and Easwaramoorthy, S).Sugarcane Breeding Institute, ICAR, Coimbatore. p. 201–248 Easwaramoorthy, S.and Salin, K.P. (2002). Hundred years of sugarcane entomology in India. In “Sugarcane Crop Management” (Eds. Singh, S.B. Rao, G.P and Easwaramoorthy, S). SCI Tech Publishing LLC, Texas (USA). p. 400–492 Ferson, P. (1985). Fungal Control. In: “Comprehensive insect physiology, biochemistry and pharmacology” (Eds. Kerkut,G.A and Gilbert, L.I. Eds.). Pergamon Press.12 (11): 313–346 Geetha, N.and Mukunthan, N. (2005).Trichogramma chilonis for internode borer management. In “Training manual on biocontrol of insect pests and diseases in sugarcane”. Sugarcane Breeding Institute, ICAR. Coimbatore. p. 12–36 Gross, H.R. (1988). Effect of temperature, relative humidity, and free water on the number and normalcy ofTrichogramma pretiosum Riley (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae) emerging from eggs ofHeliothis zea (Boddie) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae).Environmental Entomology,17: 470–475 Gupta, B.D. (1951). A resume of the trials conducted during 1941-44 withTrichogramma evanescens minutum Riley against the stem borer,Argyria strcticraspis Hampsn. and the root borer,Emmalocera depressella Swinh. in Uttar Pradesh.Proceedings of the Biennial. Conference on Sugarcane Research and Development Workers. India, 1: 15–23. Haward, L.O.and Fiske, W.F. (1911) The importation into the United States of the parasites of the Gypsy moths and the brown tail moths. US Dept. Agric. Bor.Ent. Bulletin,91: 1–312. Jayanthi, R. (1985). Reaction of sugarcane germplasm to internode borer,Chilo sacchariphagus indicus (K.) infestation.72 nd Indian Science Congress Association. Lucknow. Jayanthi, R.and Mehta, U.K. (1984). Performance of sugarcane varieties in relation to internode borer attack,Chilo sacchariphagus indicus (K.). In: Oriental Entomology Symposium, University of Kerala, Kariavattam. p 21–24 Kalra, A.Nand David, H (1964). Introduction ofIsotima janvensis Roh. a parasite of top borer of sugarcane in Tanjore areas of Madras State. Proceedings ofAII India Conference of Sugarcane Research and Development Workers.5: 602–605 Khan, M.S.Farid, A.,Ullah, Fand Badshah, H. (2004). Effect of host and parasitoid density on parasitism efficiency ofTrichogramma chilonis (Ishii).Asian Journal of Plant Sciences,3(5) 647–650 Krishnamoorthy, B. (1938). A microscopical study of the developmentof Trichogramma minutum Riley (the egg parasite of the sugarcane borers in Mysore) and its parasitisation of the eggs ofCorcyra cephalonica St. the flour moth employed in the mass production ofTrichogramma. Proceedings of Indian Academy of Sciences (B),7: 36–40 Manjunath, T.M. (1988). Procedures and techniques for mass production of the rice mothCorcyra cephalonica. All India Summer Institute on Techniques for mass production of biological Agents for the Management of Pests and Diseases. Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, Coimbatore. June. 17–26 Manjunath, T.M. (1991). Practical aspects related to mass production, storage, packing and field release ofTrichoramma. In ”Biocontrol technology for sugarcane pest management” (Eds. David, H and Easwaramoorthy, S). Sugarcane Breeding Institute, ICAR, Coimbatore. p. 109–126 Metcalfe. J.R.and Breniere, J. (1969). Egg parasitesTrichogramma spp) for control of sugarcane moth borers. In “Pests of sugarcane” (Eds. William, J.R., Metcalfe, J.R., Mungomery, R.W and Mathes, R). Elsevier Publication. Co. Amsterdam. p. 81–116 Mukunthan, N. (1991) Scope of pheromone technology in sugarcane pest management.. In: “Biological control of sugarcane pests” (Eds. David, H and Easwaramoorthy, S.) Sugarcane Breeding Institute. ICAR, Coimbatore. p. 337–346 Mukunthan, N. (2002). Varietal resistance against sugarcane pests.. In “Sugarcane crop management” (Eds. Singh, S.B., Rao, G.P., and Easwaramoorthy, S.). SWCI. Technology Publishers Lie. Country Creekdrive, Houston, Texas, USA. p. 696–708 Mukunthan. Nand Rakkiyappan, P. (1989). Bunchy top formation in sugarcane by the internode borer and its effect on yield and quality.Sugarcane,2: 17–19. Narayanan. E.S.and Chacko, M.J. (1954). Experimental studies in insect parasitism – super parasitism inTrichogramma evanescens minutum Riley.Proceedings of Indian Science Congress,41: 261 Navarajan, P. A.V. (1980). Some important nutritional and ecological factors in breedingTrichogramma species.. In “Biological control of sugarcane pests in India”. (Eds. Sithanantham, S and Solayappan, A.R.) Tamil Nadu Co-op sugar Federation, Madras. p. 21–28 Ozder, N. (2004). Effect of different cold storage periods on parasitisation performance adsorption to leaf surface: bridge in time for chemical spies.Physiological, Entomology,16: 329–344 Pawar, A.D. (1981). SugarcanePyrilla attacking rice and its biological control. International Rice Research Institute, Newsletter,.6:17 Price, P.W. (1975). Insect Ecology. A Wiley-Inter science publication.514 pp Rahman, K.A. (1941). Parasites of the insect pests of sugarcane in the Punjab,India J. Agric. Sci. 11: 119–128 Raja Rao, S.A. (1964). Biological control of top borer,Scirpophaga nivella F. of sugarcane at Pugalur (Madras State).Proceedings of All India conference of Sugarcane Research Workers.5: 588–592 Ramachandran. S.,Krishnamurthy. C.and Basheer, M. (1951). Biological control of the early shoot borer,Argyria stircticrapsis Hampson byTrichogramma minutum Riley in the Madras state.Proceedings of Biennial Conference of Sugarcane Research and Development Workers. India. I:31–39 Rao. Y.R.V.J.and Rao, Y.S. (1980). Suitability tests with indigenous and exotic natural enemies onChilo aricilius Dudgn. in the laboratory.Indian J. Agric. Res.,14: 169–179 Romeis. J,Shanower. T.Gand Jyothirmayi, K.N.S. (1998). Constraints on the use ofTrichogramma egg parasitoids in biological control programmes in India.Biocontrol Science and Technology,8: 289–299 Sankaran. Tand Manjunath, T.M. (1988). Biological control: Progress and Problems. In “Forty years of Plant Protection in India”. (Eds. Sithanantham, S. and Solayappan, A.R.). The Tamil Nadu Co-op. Sugar Federation, Madras. p. 1–12 Sithanantham, S. (1980). Inundative release of Trichogramma and integration with insecticidal methods. In “Biological control of sugarcane pests in India”. (Eds. Sithanantham, S. and Solyappan, A.R.) The Tamil Nadu Co operative Sugar Federation, Madras, p. 43–60 Sithanantham. S.,Muthusamy. S.and Durai, R. (1973). Experiments on the inundative release ofTrichogramma australicum Gir. in the biological control of sugarcane stem borerChilo indicus (Kapur).Madras Agricultural Journal,60: 547–561 Solyappan, A.R. and Krishnamoorthy, V. (1973). Role of biological control of sugarcane borers in improving sugar recovery in sugar factory areas in Tamil Nadu State.Proceedings of Annual Conference of Production Council. Tiruchirapalli Smith, S.M. (1996). Biological control with Trichogramma: Advances, Successes, and Potential of their use.Annual Review of Entomology,41:375–406 Solyappan, A.R. (1980). Mass production ofTrichogramma for release in factory areas. In “Biological control of sugarcane pests in India” (Eds. Sithanantham, S. and Solyappan, A.R.). The Tamil Nadu Co operative Sugar Federation, Madras. p. 29–35 Subramaniam, T.V. (1941). Control of the sugarcane borer by the egg parasiteTrichogramma minutum in Mysore.Journal of Mysore Agricultural University,19: 183–187 Varadharajan, G. (1976). Studies on the utilization ofTrichogramma australicum Gir., for the control of sugarcane internode borer.Madras Agricultural Journal,63: 569–570 Varadharajan, G.,Saivaraj.K.and Raghavan, S. (1971). A note on egg parasites of sugarcane borers at Cuddalore.Indian Sugar,21:433–434 Yadav, R.P. (1983). Bionomics, effectiveness and basic requirement for mass multiplication of common egg parasitoids ofPyrilla perpusilla Walker. Ph.D. thesis, Haryana Agricultural University, Hissar. Haryana. Yamashita, O and Hasegawa, K. (1985). Embryonic diapause. In “Comprehensiveinsect physiology, biochemistry and pharmacology” (Eds. Kerkut, G.A. and Gilbert. L.I).. Pergamon Press. 1(11). 407–434