Disruptive Innovation and Moral Uncertainty
Tóm tắt
This paper develops a philosophical account of moral disruption. According to Robert Baker, moral disruption is a process in which technological innovations undermine established moral norms without clearly leading to a new set of norms. Here I analyze this process in terms of moral uncertainty, formulating a philosophical account with two variants. On the harm account, such uncertainty is always harmful because it blocks our knowledge of our own and others’ moral obligations. On the qualified harm account, there is no harm in cases where moral uncertainty is related to innovation that is “for the best” in historical perspective or where uncertainty is the expression of a deliberative virtue. The two accounts are compared by applying them to Baker’s historical case of the introduction of mechanical ventilation and organ transplantation technologies, as well as the present-day case of mass data practices in the health domain.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Baker R (2013) Before bioethics. Oxford University Press, New York
Christensen CM (1997) The innovator’s dilemma: when new technologies cause great firms to fail. Harvard Business School Press, Boston
Markides C (2006) Disruptive innovation: in need of better theory. J Prod Innov Manag 23:19–25
Brey P (2017) Ethics of emerging technology. In: Hansson SO (ed) The ethics of technology: methods and approaches. Rowman & Littlefield, London, pp 175–191
Hansson SO (2013) The ethics of risk. Palgrave Macmillan, London
Ellsberg D (1961) Risk, ambiguity, and the savage axioms. Q J Econ 75:643–669
Berenbaum H, Bredemeier K, Thompson RJ (2008) Intolerance of uncertainty: exploring its dimensionality and associations with need for cognitive closure, psychopathology, and personality. J Anxiety Disord 22:117–125
Freeston MH, Rheaume J, Letart H, Dugas MJ, Ladouceur R (1994) Why do people worry? Personal Individ Differ 17:791–802
Feinberg J (1984) The moral limits of the criminal law, volume one: harm to others. Oxford University Press, New York
Slutsky AS (2015) History of mechanical ventilation: from Vesalius to ventilator-induced lung injury. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 191(10):1106–1115
Baker R (2019) The structure of moral revolutions: studies of changes in the morality of abortion, death, and the bioethics revolution. MIT Press, Cambridge
Fox R, Swazey J (2002) Spare parts: organ replacement in American society, 2nd edn. Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick
Scheper-Hughes N (2007) The tyranny of the gift: sacrificial violence in living donor transplants. Am J Transplant 7(3):507–511
Harris J, Erin C (2002) An ethically defensible market in organs: a single buyer like the NHS is an answer. BMJ 325:114–115
Richardson R (2006) Human dissection and organ donation: a historical and social background. Mortality 11:2, 151–165. https://doi.org/10.1080/13576270600615419
Hamilton D (2012) A history of organ transplantation: ancient legends to modern practice. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh
Walzer M (1974) Political action: the problem of many hands. In: Cohen M, Nagel T, Scanlon T (eds) War and moral responsibility. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp 62–82
Appiah KA (2011) The honor code: how moral revolutions happen. W.W. Norton & Co., New York
Carlsen H, Dreborg KH, Godman M, Hansson SO, Johansson L, Wikman-Svahn P (2010) Assessing socially disruptive technological change. Technol Soc 32:209–218
Rosenberger R (2014) Multistability and the agency of mundane artifacts: from speed bumps to subway benches. Hum Stud 37:369–392
Nyholm S (2016) The normative and evaluative status of moral distress in health care contexts. Am J Bioeth 16:17–19
Mittelstadt BD, Floridi L (2015) The ethics of big data: current and foreseeable issues in biomedical contexts. Sci Eng Ethics 22:303–341. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11948-015-9652-2
Iliadis A, Russo F (2016) Critical data studies: an introduction. Big Data & Society. July–Dec.:1–7
Madden M, Gilman M, Levy K, Marwick A (2017) Privacy, poverty, and big data: a matrix of vulnerabilities for poor Americans. Wash Univ Law Rev 95(1):53–125
Nickel PJ (2019) The ethics of uncertainty for data subjects. In: Krutzinna J, Floridi L (eds) The ethics of medical data donation. Springer, Cham, pp 55–74
Lockhart T (2000) Moral uncertainty and its consequences. Oxford University Press, New York
Zimmerman MJ (2008) Living with uncertainty: the moral significance of ignorance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Barry C, Tomlin P (2016) Moral uncertainty and permissibility: evaluating option sets. Can J Philos 46:898–923
Lazar S (2018) In dubious battle: uncertainty and the ethics of killing. Philos Stud 175:859–883
Macaskill W (2016) Normative uncertainty as a voting problem. Mind 125:967–1004
Nagel T (1993) Moral luck. In: Statman D (ed) Moral luck. State University of New York Press, Albany, pp 57–71
Fox R (2003) Medical uncertainty revisited. In: Albrecht GL, Fitzpatrick R, Scrimshaw SC (eds) Handbook of Social Studies in Health and Medicine. Sage, Newbury Park, CA, pp 409–425