Digital audio steganography: Systematic review, classification, and analysis of the current state of the art

Kaur, 2017, Localized & self adaptive audio watermarking algorithm in the wavelet domain, J. Inf. Secur. Appl., 33, 1 Vimal, 2014, Audio steganography using dual randomness LSB method, 941 Ballesteros L, 2012, Highly transparent steganography model of speech signals using efficient wavelet masking, Expert Syst. Appl., 39, 9141, 10.1016/j.eswa.2012.02.066 Asad, 2011, An enhanced least significant bit modification technique for audio steganography, 143 Djebbar, 2012, Comparative study of digital audio steganography techniques, EURASIP J. Audio Speech Music Process., 2012, 1, 10.1186/1687-4722-2012-25 Bender, 1996, Techniques for data hiding, IBM Syst. J., 35, 313, 10.1147/sj.353.0313 Bilal, 2015, Recent advancement in audio steganography, 402 Dastoor, 2011, Comparative analysis of steganographic algorithms intacting the information in the speech signal for enhancing the message security in next generation mobile devices, 279 Farouk, 2014, Steganography and security of speech signal, 45 Tanwar, 2014, Audio steganography, 322 Balgurgi, 2013, Audio steganography used for secure data transmission, Adv. Intell. Syst. Comput., 174, 699, 10.1007/978-81-322-0740-5_83 Zamani, 2012, An overview on audio steganography techniques, Int. J. Digit. Content Technol. Appl., 6, 107 Djebbar, 2011, A view on latest audio steganography techniques, 409 Kiah, 2011, A review of audio based steganography and digital watermarking, Int. J. Phys. Sci., 6, 3837 Das, 2012, Steganography: Secret data hiding in multimedia, 275 Johri, 2015, Review paper on text and audio steganography using GA, 190 Abdelfattah, 2013 C. Paulin, S.-A. Selouani, E. Hervet, A comparative study of audio/speech steganalysis techniques catherine, in: 2017 IEEE 30th Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering (CCECE) A, 2017. Atoum, 2016, Exploring the challenges of MP3 audio steganography, 156 Atoum, 2015, A comparative study of combination with different LSB techniques in MP3 steganography, 551 Shafi, 2010, A novel audio steganography scheme using amplitude differencing, 163 Bhattacharyya, 2010, Hiding data in audio signal, 23, 10.1007/978-3-642-13405-0_3 M. Khademi, M. Ali Tinati, Audio steganography by using of linear predictive coding analysis in the safe places of discrete wavelet transform domain, in: Electrical Engineering (ICEE), 2011 19th Iranian Conference on. IEEE, 2011, pp. 1–5. Collins, 2011, System for non-disruptive high capacity indexed data embedding and recovery using multimedia signal covers, 1 Shafi, 2010, A novel audio steganography scheme using amplitude differencing, 163 Sakthisudhan, 2012, Dual steganography approach for secure data communication, Proc. Eng., 38, 412, 10.1016/j.proeng.2012.06.051 Baritha Begum, 2012, LSB Based audio steganography based on text compression, Proc. Eng., 30, 702 Balgurgi, 2012, Intelligent processing: An approach of audio steganography, 1 Olanrewaju, 2013, Increasing the hiding capacity of low-bit encoding audio steganography using a novel embedding technique, World Appl. Sci. J., 21, 79 Ballesteros L, 2013, Speech-in-speech hiding scheme based on least significant bit substitution and adaptive key, Comput. Electr. Eng., 39, 1192, 10.1016/j.compeleceng.2013.02.006 Huo, 2013, Reversible audio watermarking algorithm using non-causal prediction, Wuhan Univ. J. Nat. Sci., 18, 455, 10.1007/s11859-013-0956-2 Zhu, 2013, Content integrity and non-repudiation preserving audio- hiding scheme based on robust digital signature, Secur. Commun. Netw., 6, 1331, 10.1002/sec.715 Shahadi, 2014, Lossless audio steganography based on lifting wavelet transform and dynamic stego key, Indian J. Sci. Technol., 7, 323, 10.17485/ijst/2014/v7i3.14 Li, 2014, An audio hiding algorithm based on spline interpolation and wavelet transform, Appl. Mech. Mater., 571–572, 39 Bazyar, 2015, A new method to increase the capacity of audio steganography based on the LSB algorithm, J. Teknol., 74, 49 Bazyar, 2015, A robust data embedding method for MPEG layer III audio steganography, Int. J. Secur. Appl., 9, 317 Kanhe, 2015, Robust audio steganography based on advanced encryption standards in temporal domain, 1449 Datta, 2015, Robust high capacity audio steganography using modulo operator H. S, 2015, Audio steganography in discrete wavelet transform domain, Int. J. Appl. Eng. Res. ISSN, 10, 973 Devi, 2016, Ideal sampling rate to reduce distortion in audio steganography, Proc. Comput. Sci., 85, 418, 10.1016/j.procs.2016.05.185 Taneja, 2016, Implementation of dual security through DSA and audio steganography, 1349 Gambhir, 2016, Integrating RSA cryptography & audio steganography, 481 Baig, 2016, Onion steganography: a novel layering approach, Nonlinear Dynam., 84, 1431, 10.1007/s11071-015-2580-5 Sahu, 2016, A novel technique for embedding audio in audio to ensure secrecy, 83 Renza, 2016, Highly transparent and secure scheme for concealing text within audio, 10125 Trivedi, 2017, Metamorphic cryptography using strength of chaotic sequence and XORing method, J. Intell. Fuzzy Syst., 32, 3365, 10.3233/JIFS-169277 Parthasarathi, 2017, Secured data hiding in audio files using audio steganography algorithm, Int. J. Pure Appl. Math., 114, 743 S.E. El-Khamy, N. Korany, M.H. El-Sherif, Robust image hiding in audio based on integer wavelet transform and chaotic maps hopping, in: Radio Science Conference (NRSC), 2017 34th National. IEEE, 2017, 2017, pp. 205–212. Devi, 2016, Novel audio steganography technique for ECG signals in point of care systems (NASTPOCS), 101 Huang, 2008, Design and implementation of synchronized audio-to-audio steganography scheme, 331 Pal, 2013, Lossless audio steganography in spatial domain (LASSD), 575 Pathak, 2014, A new audio steganography scheme based on location selection with enhanced security, 1 Kakde, 2015, Audio-video steganography, 1 Shah, 2008, Adaptive wavelet packet based audio steganography using data history, 0 Gopalan, 2010, Audio steganography using bit modification - A tradeoff on perceptibility and data robustness for large payload audio embedding Asad, 2012, Three layered model for audio steganography, 270 Ghosh, 2012, A double layered additive space sequenced audio steganography technique for mobile network, 29 Kumar, 2012, Enhanced LSB technique for audio steganography Rekik, 2012, Speech steganography using wavelet and fourier transforms, EURASIP J. Audio Speech Music Process., 1, 1 Zhang, 2013, A novel algorithm for embedding watermarks into audio signal based on DCT, 29 Mukherjee, 2013, Evolutionary multibit grouping steganographic algorithm, vol. 8303, 285 Jiang, 2013, Real-time covert voip communications over smart grids by using AES-based audio steganography, 2102 Dieu, 2013, Hiding data in audio using modified CPT scheme, 396 Tang, 2014, Audio steganography with AES for real-time covert voice over internet protocol communications, Sci. China Inf. Sci., 57, 1 Gupta, 2014, Dwt and LSB based audio steganography, 428 Verma, 2014, A novel technique for data hiding in audio carrier by using sample comparison in DWT domain, 639 Charfeddine, 2014, A new DCT audio watermarking scheme based on preliminary MP3 study, Multimedia Tools Appl., 70, 1521, 10.1007/s11042-012-1167-0 Bilal, 2015, Audio steganography using QR decomposition and fast fourier transform, Indian J. Sci. Technol., 8, 10.17485/ijst/2015/v8i1/69604 Punetha, 2015, Safe transmission of text files through a new audio steganography technique, 58 N.C. Debnath, H. Abushama, C. Science, A Multilayered Scheme for Transparent Audio Data Hiding, in: 2015 IEEE/ACS 12th International Conference of Computer Systems and Applications (AICCSA), 2015, pp. 1–6. G.P. TVS, S. Varadarajan, A novel hybrid audio steganography for imperceptible data hiding, in: Communications and Signal Processing (ICCSP), 2015, pp. 634–638. V. Sharma, LSB modification based audio steganography using trusted third party key indexing method, in: 2015 Third International Conference On Image Information Processing (ICIIP), 2015, pp. 403–406. Huang, 2016, Covert voice over internet protocol communications based on spatial model, Sci. China Technol. Sci., 59, 117, 10.1007/s11431-015-5955-4 Datta, 2016, Multi-bit data hiding in randomly chosen LSB layers of an audio, 283 Hussain, 2016, Enhanced audio LSB steganography for secure communication, Int. J. Adv. Comput. Sci. Appl., 7, 340 Jadhav, 2016, An efficient new audio steganography scheme based on location selection with enhanced security, Int. J. Eng. Sci. Comput., 5, 334 Bhalde, 2016, Performance improvement: Audio steganography technique parity bit combined with cryptography Alsabhany, 2017, A hybrid method for data communication using encrypted audio steganography, Adv. Sci. Lett., 23, 10.1166/asl.2017.8946 Jiang, 2017, An efficient and secure voip communication system with chaotic mapping and message digest, Multimed. Syst., 1 Shiu, 2017, High-capacity data-hiding scheme on synthesized pitches using amplitude enhancement—A new vision of non-blind audio steganography, Symmetry (Basel), 9, 92, 10.3390/sym9060092 El-Khamy, 2017, A security enhanced robust audio steganography algorithm for image hiding using sample comparison in discrete wavelet transform domain and RSA encryption, Multimedia Tools Appl., 76, 24091, 10.1007/s11042-016-4113-8 Zou, 2015, A wav-audio steganography algorithm based on amplitude modifying, 489 Shahreza, 2007, Adaptive wavelet domain audio steganography with high capacity and low error rate, 25 Pooyan, 2007, LSB-Based audio steganography method based on lifting wavelet transform, 600 Delforouzi, 2008, Adaptive digital audio steganography based on integer wavelet transform, Circuits, Syst. Signal Process., 27, 247, 10.1007/s00034-008-9019-x Gopalan, 2008, Audio steganography by modification of cepstrum at a pair of frequencies, 2178 Gopalan, 2009, A unified audio and image steganography by spectrum modification Delforouzi, 2009, Adaptive and efficient audio data hiding method in temporal domain, 0 Chang, 2010, Copyright-proving scheme for audio with counter-propagation neural networks, Digit. Signal Process., 20, 1087, 10.1016/j.dsp.2009.12.001 Skopin, 2010, Advanced algorithms in audio steganography for hiding human speech signal, 3, 29 Wakiyama, 2010, An audio steganography by a low-bit coding method with wave files, 530 Ahmed, 2010, A novel embedding method to increase capacity and robustness of low-bit encoding audio steganography technique using noise gate software logic algorithm, J. Appl. Sci., 10, 59, 10.3923/jas.2010.59.64 Sheikhan, 2011, Improvement of embedding capacity and quality of DWT-based audio steganography systems, World Appl. Sci. J., 13, 507 Wu, 2011, Audio watermarking scheme with dynamic adjustment in mute period, Expert Syst. Appl., 38, 6787, 10.1016/j.eswa.2010.12.069 Roselinkiruba, 2013, Secure steganography in audio using inactive frames of voip streams, 491 H.B. Dieu, An Improved Technique for Hiding Data in Audio, in: Digital Information and Communication Technology and it’s Applications (DICTAP), 2014 Fourth International Conference on. IEEE, 2014, pp. 149–153. Gopalan, 2015, An imperceptible and robust audio steganography employing bit modification, 1635 K. Gopalan, A robust bit modification audio steganography for covert communication, in: The Eleventh Advanced International Conference on Telecommunications A, 2015, no. c, pp. 7–10. Kar, 2015, A multi-threshold based audio steganography scheme, J. Inf. Secur. Appl., 23, 54 Bazyar, 2016, A new data embedding method for mpeg layer iii audio steganography, J. Teknol., 78, 65 Kanhe, 2016, DCT Based audio steganography in voiced and un-voiced frames, 1 Shoaib, 2016, Performance improvement of threshold based audio steganography using parallel computation, Int. J. Adv. Comput. Sci. Appl., 7, 290 Liu, 2017, Adaptive audio steganography scheme based on wavelet packet energy, 26 Nathan, 2011, Audio steganography using spectrum manipulation, 152 Luo, 2017, Adaptive audio steganography based on advanced audio coding and syndrome-trellis coding, 177 Esen, 2012, Comparison of forbidden zone data hiding and quantization index modulation, Digit. Signal Process., 22, 181, 10.1016/j.dsp.2011.10.005 Sun, 2010, Dynamic matrix encoding strategy for voice-over-IP steganography, J. Cent. South Univ. Technol., 17, 1285, 10.1007/s11771-010-0633-y Zamani, 2011, Genetic substitution-based audio steganography for high capacity applications, Internet Technol. Secur. Trans., 3, 97, 10.1504/IJITST.2011.039681 Anguraj, 2011, A fusion of A-B MAP cipher and ASET algorithms for the enhanced security and robustness in audio steganography, 205 Darsana, 2011, Audio steganography using modified LSB and PVD, Trends Netw. Commun., 197, 11, 10.1007/978-3-642-22543-7_2 Roy, 2012, Audio steganography using LSB encoding technique with increased capacity and bit error rate optimization, 372 Banerjee, 2013, A variable higher bit approach to audio steganography, 46 Bhowal, 2013, A GA based audio steganography with enhanced security, Telecommun. Syst., 52, 2197, 10.1007/s11235-011-9542-0 Tanwar, 2014, A robust substitution technique to implement audio steganography, 290 Rahim, 2014, An audio steganography technique to maximize data hiding capacity along with least modification of host, 277 Bhattacharjee, 2015, Hiding of compressed bit stream into audio file to enhance the confidentiality and portability of a data transmission system, 196 Huang, 2014, Reversible audio information hiding based on integer DCT coefficients with adaptive hiding locations, Digit. Watermarking, 8389, 376 Zamani, 2015, Genetic algorithm for fragile audio watermarking, Telecommun. Syst., 59, 291, 10.1007/s11235-014-9936-x M. Rana, F.B. Kunwar, A temporal domain audio steganography technique using genetic algorithm, in: Computing for Sustainable Global Development (INDIACom), 2016 3rd International Conference on. IEEE, 2016, pp. 2016, pp. 3141–3146. Liu, 2017, Steganography integrated into linear predictive coding for low bit-rate speech codec, Multimed. Tools Appl., 76, 2837, 10.1007/s11042-016-3257-x Yang, 2017, Adaptive MP3 steganography using equal length entropy codes substitution, 202 Ren, 2017, An AMR adaptive steganography algorithm based on minimizing distortion, Multimed. Tools Appl., 77, 12095, 10.1007/s11042-017-4860-1 Shahadi, 2011, High capacity and inaudibility audio steganography scheme, 104 E.T. Su, Robust data embedding based probabilistic global search in MDCT domain, in: International Conference on Informatics Engineering and Information Science, 2011, pp. 290–300. Srivastava, 2011, A novel approach to secure communication using audio steganography, Adv. Mater. Res., 403–408, 963, 10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.403-408.963 Shahadi, 2014, A novel and high capacity audio steganography algorithm based on adaptive data embedding positions, Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol., 7, 2311, 10.19026/rjaset.7.531 Mandal, 2014, An approach for enhancing message security in audio steganography, 383 Van Tam, 2015, Embedding data into audio signal by combining sliding window technique with a novel marking bit method, Adv. Multimed. Ubiquitous Eng., 352, 191, 10.1007/978-3-662-47487-7_29 Tian, 2015, Improved adaptive partial-matching steganography for Voice over IP, Comput. Commun., 70, 95, 10.1016/j.comcom.2015.08.011 Chowdhury, 2016, A view on LSB based audio steganography, Int. J. Secur. Appl., 10, 51 Hemalatha, 2016, Audio data hiding technique using integer wavelet transform, Int. J. Electron. Secur. Digit. Forensics, 8, 131, 10.1504/IJESDF.2016.075586 Ali, 2017, Enhancing the hiding capacity of audio steganography based on block mapping, J. Theor. Appl. Inf. Technol., 95, 1441 Ali, 2020, An adaptive high capacity model for secure audio communication based on fractal coding and uniform coefficient modulation, circuits, syst, Signal Process., 1 Djebbar, 2013, Unified phase and magnitude speech spectra data hiding algorithm, Secur. Commun. Networks, 6, 961, 10.1002/sec.644 Rivas, 2007, Fourier phase domain steganography: Phase bin encoding via interpolation, mob. Multimedia/image process, Mil. Secur. Appl., 6579, 65790W Parab, 2011, Audio steganography using differential phase encoding, Technol. Syst. Manag., 146, 10.1007/978-3-642-20209-4_20 Lu, 2012, Digital audio information hiding based on arnold transformation and double random-phase encoding technique, Optik (Stuttg), 123, 697, 10.1016/j.ijleo.2011.06.027 F. Djebbar, B. Ayad, Audio steganograpgy by phase modification, in: 8th International Conference on Emerging Security Information. Syst. Technol. 2014, pp. 31–35. Moon, 2014, Application of data hiding in audio-video using anti forensics technique for authentication and data security, 1110 Pal, 2015, Secured data transmission through audio signal (SDTAS) Fatnassi, 2016, A new hybrid steganalysis based approach for embedding image in audio and image cover media, IFAC-PapersOnLine, 49, 1809, 10.1016/j.ifacol.2016.07.845 Alsabhany, 2019, The adaptive multi-level phase coding method in audio steganography, IEEE Access, 7, 129291, 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2940640 R.M. Nugraha, Implementation of direct sequence spread spectrum steganography on audio data, in: 2011 International Conference on Electrical Engineering and Informatics (ICEEI), 2011, pp. 1–6. Chang, 2012, Location based robust audio watermarking algorithm for social TV system, 726 Shokri, 2013, Error probability in spread spectrum (SS) audio watermarking, 169 Kaur, 2015, Enhanced steganographic method preserving base quality of information using LSB, parity and spread spectrum technique, 148 Crawford, 2009, Supraliminal audio steganography: Audio files tricking audiophiles, Vol. 5806, 1 Szczypiorski, 2016, Stegibiza: New method for information hiding in club music, 20 Mazurczyk, 2010, LACK-A voip steganographic method, Telecommun. Syst., 45, 153, 10.1007/s11235-009-9245-y Yan, 2011, Huffman table swapping-based steganograpy for MP3 audio, Multimed. Tools Appl., 52, 291, 10.1007/s11042-009-0430-5 Yan, 2012, Steganography for MP3 audio by exploiting the rule of window switching, Comput. Secur., 31, 704, 10.1016/j.cose.2012.04.006 Sun, 2012, Data hiding in audio based on audio-to-image wavelet transform and vector quantization, 313 Mazurczyk, 2014, Using transcoding for hidden communication in IP telephony, Multimed. Tools Appl., 70, 2139, 10.1007/s11042-012-1224-8 Ghasemzadeh, 2016, Toward a robust and secure echo steganography method based on parameters hopping, 143 Naumann, 2016, Micro protocol engineering for unstructured carriers: on the embedding of steganographic control protocols into audio transmissions, Secur. Commun. Networks, 9, 2972, 10.1002/sec.1500 Yadav, 2016, Audio steganography using ZDT : Encryption using indexed based chaotic sequence Janicki, 2014, Steganalysis of transcoding steganography, Ann. des Telecommun. Telecommun., 69, 449, 10.1007/s12243-013-0385-4 Mohammed, 2015, A system for semantic information extraction from mixed soundtracks deploying MARSYAS framework, 1084 2018 Liu, 2009, Temporal derivative-based spectrum and mel-cepstrum audio steganalysis, IEEE Trans. Inf. Forensics Secur., 4, 359, 10.1109/TIFS.2009.2024718 Wei, 2007, A novel steganalysis algorithm of phase coding in audio signal, 261 Zeng, 2008, An algorithm of echo steganalysis based on power cepstrum and pattern classification, 1344 Ghasemzadeh, 2018, Comprehensive review of audio steganalysis methods, IET Signal Process., 12, 673, 10.1049/iet-spr.2016.0651 Ren, 2017, A steganalysis scheme for AAC audio based on MDCT difference between intra and inter frame, 217 Wang, 2020, MP3 steganalysis based on joint point-wise and block-wise correlations, Inf. Sci. (Ny), 512, 1118, 10.1016/j.ins.2019.10.037 Özer, 2006, Detection of audio covert channels using statistical footprints of hidden messages, Digit. Signal Process. A Rev. J., 16, 389, 10.1016/j.dsp.2005.12.001 Liu, 2009 Ghasemzadeh, 2017, Universal audio steganalysis based on calibration and reversed frequency resolution of human auditory system, IET Signal Process., 11, 916, 10.1049/iet-spr.2016.0690 Han, 2018, A new audio steganalysis method based on linear prediction, Multimed. Tools Appl., 77, 15431, 10.1007/s11042-017-5123-x Z. Zhang, X. Yi, X. Zhao, Improving audio steganalysis using deep residual networks, in: International Workshop on Digital Watermarking, 2019, pp. 57–70.