Differentiating between a consultant nurse and a clinical nurse specialist

British Journal of Nursing - Tập 14 Số 8 - Trang 463-468 - 2005
Miles E Maylor1
1Tissue Viability, School of Care Sciences, University of Glamorgan, Pontypridd, Mid Glamorgan

Tóm tắt

With the introduction of nurse consultants, and regulation of the use of the designation ‘specialist nurse’, experienced practitioners such as clinical nurse specialists have seen their position eroded. Nurse consultants are a new NHS-employment category, and are expected to be at the top rank of the profession both in status and in salary. However, this article argues that nurses at various levels have the same core functions, and that these do not differ for nurse consultants. Distinguishing between practitioners that might have the same job description could be better done by measuring outcomes. More care needs to be taken over the use of words such as ‘expert’, which is used differently in different contexts, and it is suggested that competencies be developed by which to measure the effects of expertise. Although nurse consultant appointments are often driven by various political directives and they are employed to meet local and national priorities, difficult issues need to be faced. First, if nurse consultant jobs are the top of the clinical career ladder, will clinical nurse specialists (CNSs) need to accept a lower rung on it? Further, perhaps the title CNS should become obsolete or be regulated? Can CNSs claim parity of pay using the Agenda for Change framework?

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

1990, or occurrence (Allen

Source, 1999, Department of Health (DoH

Source, 1999, 2 Guest et al (2001);3 adapted from Storr (1988)

However, 2001, the NC study (Guest et al

Source, 2001, Trent Cancer Nurses Allied Health Professionals Advisory Group (TCN

Castledine, 2003, the advanced (higher) level practitioner has

Source, 2003, 2 Adapted from Cattini and Knowles

Allen RE, 1990, The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Current English, 8

NICATS, 2004, Northern Ireland Credit Accumulation andTransfer System Handbook

Castledine G, 2003, Advanced Nursing Practice, 2

Castledine, Proceedings of Consensus Conference -- New Nursing Roles: Deciding the Future for Scotland. Royal College of Physicians

10.1046/j.1365-2702.1999.00285.x

Do H, 1994, London

Do H, 1999, London

Do H, 2003, London (http://www.dh.gov.uk/assetRoot/ 04/07/37/53/04073753.pdf) (last accessed

Do H, 2003, Job Evaluation Handbook, 1

10.12968/bjon.2003.12.Sup1.11251

Guest D, 2001, A Preliminary Evaluation of the Establishment of Nurse, Midwife and Health Visitor Consultants

10.7748/ns.17.26.7.s13

McGee P, 2003, Advanced Nursing Practice, 2

National Health Service Executive, 1999, London

NMC, 2001, London

Peccei R, 2003, echnical Report)

10.7748/ns2003.02.17.22.96.c3343

10.1111/j.1365-2648.1988.tb01416.x

TCN (Trent Cancer Nurses Allied Health Professions Advisory Group, 2001, Nurse Consultants, Nurse Leads: the Development of New Roles to Improve Cancer and Palliative Care.An Advisory Report. National Health Service Executive/Leicestershire Health Authority, Leicester