Decentralization Effects in Ecological Fiscal Transfers: A Bayesian Structural Time Series Analysis for Portugal

Droste, Nils1,2, Becker, Claudia1, Ring, Irene3, Santos, Rui4
1Department of Economics, Martin-Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Halle an der Saale, Germany
2Department of Economics, UFZ – Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research, Leipzig, Germany
3International Institute Zittau, Technische Universität Dresden, Zittau, Germany
4Centre for Environmental and Sustainability Research (CENSE), Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Caparica, Portugal

Tóm tắt

Portugal has a unitary system in which the central government transfers funds to lower government levels for their public functions. In 2007, Portugal introduced Ecological Fiscal Transfers (EFT), where municipalities receive transfers for hosting protected areas (PA). We study whether introducing EFT in Portugal incentivized municipalities to designate PA and has led to a decentralization of conservation decisions. We employ a Bayesian structural time series approach to estimate the effect of introducing EFT in comparison to a simulated counterfactual time series. Quantitative results show a significant increase in the ratio of municipal and national PA designations following Portugal’s EFT introduction—which we infer to be a causal consequence. The analysis furthermore places emphasis on the importance of relevant municipal conservation competencies for the functioning of the instrument. Results have important implications for conservation policy-making in terms of allocating budgets and competencies in multi-level governments.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

citation_journal_title=Policy Sci; citation_title=Analyzing decentralized resource regimes from a polycentric perspective; citation_author=KP Andersson, E Ostrom; citation_volume=41; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=71-93; citation_doi=10.1007/s11077-007-9055-6; citation_id=CR1

citation_journal_title=Biol Conserv; citation_title=Management costs for small protected areas and economies of scale in habitat conservation; citation_author=PR Armsworth, L Cantú-Salazar, M Parnell, ZG Davies, R Stoneman; citation_volume=144; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2011; citation_pages=423-429; citation_doi=10.1016/j.biocon.2010.09.026; citation_id=CR2

citation_journal_title=Rev Econo Stat; citation_title=Using the longitudinal structure of earnings to estimate the effect of training programs; citation_author=O Ashenfelter, D Card; citation_volume=67; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=1985; citation_pages=648-660; citation_doi=10.2307/1924810; citation_id=CR3

Athey S, Imbens GW (2015) Recursive Partitioning for Heterogeneous Causal Effects, pp 1–9. arXiv:1504.01132

citation_journal_title=J Public Econ; citation_title=Reassessment of the Tiebout model; citation_author=R Boadway, JF Tremblay; citation_volume=96; citation_issue=11–12; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=1063-1078; citation_doi=10.1016/j.jpubeco.2011.01.002; citation_id=CR5

citation_journal_title=J Urban Econ; citation_title=Partial fiscal decentralization and demand responsiveness of the local public sector: theory and evidence from Norway; citation_author=LE Borge, JK Brueckner, J Rattsø; citation_volume=80; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=153-163; citation_doi=10.1016/j.jue.2014.01.003; citation_id=CR6

citation_journal_title=Ecol Soc; citation_title=Exploring the contribution of fiscal transfers to protected area policy; citation_author=M Borie, R Mathevet, A Letourneau, I Ring, JD Thompson, P Marty; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_doi=10.5751/ES-05716-190109; citation_id=CR7

citation_journal_title=J Am Stat Assoc; citation_title=Intervention with applications analysis to economic and environmental problems; citation_author=GEP Box, GC Tiao; citation_volume=70; citation_issue=349; citation_publication_date=1975; citation_pages=70-79; citation_doi=10.1080/01621459.1975.10480264; citation_id=CR8

citation_title=Time series analysis: forcasting and control; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_id=CR9; citation_author=GEP Box; citation_author=GM Jenkins; citation_author=GC Reinsel; citation_author=GM Ljung; citation_publisher=Wiley

citation_title=The power to tax: analytic foundations of a fiscal constitution; citation_publication_date=1980; citation_id=CR10; citation_author=G Brennan; citation_author=JM Buchanan; citation_publisher=Liberty Fund

citation_journal_title=Ann Appl Stat; citation_title=Inferring causal impact using Bayesian structural time-series models; citation_author=KH Brodersen, F Gallusser, J Koehler, N Remy, SL Scott; citation_volume=9; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=247-274; citation_doi=10.1214/14-AOAS788; citation_id=CR11

citation_journal_title=Conserv Lett; citation_title=Shortfalls and solutions for meeting national and global conservation area targets; citation_author=SHM Butchart, M Clarke, RJ Smith, RE Sykes, JPW Scharlemann, M Harfoot, GM Buchanan, A Angulo, A Balmford, B Bertzky, TM Brooks, KE Carpenter, MT Comeros-Raynal, J Cornell, GF Ficetola, LDC Fishpool, RA Fuller, J Geldmann, H Harwell, C Hilton-Taylor, M Hoffmann, A Joolia, L Joppa, N Kingston, I May, A Milam, B Polidoro, G Ralph, N Richman, C Rondinini, DB Segan, B Skolnik, MD Spalding, SN Stuart, A Symes, J Taylor, P Visconti, JEM Watson, L Wood, ND Burgess; citation_volume=8; citation_issue=5; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=329-337; citation_doi=10.1111/conl.12158; citation_id=CR12

citation_journal_title=Economica; citation_title=The nature of the firm; citation_author=RH Coase; citation_volume=4; citation_issue=16; citation_publication_date=1937; citation_pages=386-405; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1468-0335.1937.tb00002.x; citation_id=CR13

citation_title=An introduction to state space time series analysis; citation_publication_date=2007; citation_id=CR14; citation_author=JJ Commandeur; citation_author=SJ Koopman; citation_publisher=Oxford University Press

citation_title=Yardstick competition among Portuguese municipalities: the case of Urban Property Tax (IMI ); citation_publication_date=2013; citation_id=CR15; citation_author=JS Costa; citation_author=A Carvalho; citation_publisher=Universidade do Porto

Direção-Geral das Autarquias Locais (2015) Portal Autárquico - Municípios. http://www.portalautarquico.pt/pt-PT/financas-locais/transferencias/municipios/

citation_journal_title=Environ Policy Gov; citation_title=Municipal Responses to Ecological Fiscal Transfers a microeconometric panel data approach; citation_author=N Droste, GR Lima, P May, I Ring; citation_volume=27; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=378-393; citation_doi=10.1002/eet.1760; citation_id=CR17

EU (2015) Natura 2000 Barometer. http://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/natura2000/barometer/index_en.htm

citation_journal_title=Nat Conserv; citation_title=Building the European Union’s Natura 2000 network; citation_author=D Evans; citation_volume=1; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=11; citation_doi=10.3897/natureconservation.1.1808; citation_id=CR19

citation_journal_title=J Public Econ; citation_title=Does decentralization increase government responsiveness to local needs? evidence from Bolivia; citation_author=JP Faguet; citation_volume=88; citation_issue=3–4; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=867-893; citation_doi=10.1016/S0047-2727(02)00185-8; citation_id=CR20

citation_journal_title=World Dev; citation_title=Decentralization and governance; citation_author=JP Faguet; citation_volume=53; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=2-13; citation_doi=10.1016/j.worlddev.2013.01.002; citation_id=CR21

citation_journal_title=Const Polit Econ; citation_title=James Buchanan’s theory of federalism: from fiscal equity to the ideal political order; citation_author=LP Feld; citation_volume=25; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=231-252; citation_doi=10.1007/s10602-014-9168-9; citation_id=CR22

citation_journal_title=Stat Sin; citation_title=Approaches for bayesian variable selection; citation_author=EI George, RE McCulloch; citation_volume=7; citation_publication_date=1997; citation_pages=339-373; citation_id=CR23

Grieg-Gran M (2000) Fiscal incentives for biodiversity conservation: the ICMS Ecológico in Brazil. Environmental Economics Programme Discussion Paper 00-01. International Institute for Environment and Development, London

citation_journal_title=Int Stat Rev; citation_title=Econometric causality; citation_author=JJ Heckman; citation_volume=76; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=1-27; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1751-5823.2007.00024.x; citation_id=CR25

Hyndman RJ (2014) Fitting models to short time series. http://robjhyndman.com/hyndsight/short-time-series/

citation_journal_title=Foresight; citation_title=Minimum sample size requirements; citation_author=RJ Hyndman, AV Kostenko; citation_volume=6; citation_publication_date=2007; citation_pages=12-15; citation_id=CR27

ICNF (2015) Áreas Protegidas. http://www.icnf.pt/portal/ap

INE (2015) Portal de Estastística. http://www.ine.pt/xportal/xmain?xpid=INE&xpgid=ine_main&xpid=INE

citation_journal_title=J Econ Perspect; citation_title=Rethinking federalism; citation_author=RP Inman, DL Rubinfeld; citation_volume=1; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=1997; citation_pages=43-64; citation_doi=10.3817/0694100003; citation_id=CR30

citation_journal_title=Land Use Policy; citation_title=Designing intergovernmental fiscal transfers for conservation: the case of REDD+ revenue distribution to local governments in Indonesia; citation_author=S Irawan, L Tacconi, I Ring; citation_volume=36; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=47-59; citation_doi=10.1016/j.landusepol.2013.07.001; citation_id=CR31

citation_journal_title=Basic Appl Ecol; citation_title=Integrating biodiversity into intergovernmental fiscal transfers based on cantonal benchmarking: a Swiss case study; citation_author=T Köllner, O Schelske, I Seidl; citation_volume=3; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=2002; citation_pages=381-391; citation_doi=10.1078/1439-1791-00104; citation_id=CR32

citation_journal_title=Ecol Econ; citation_title=Environmental attitudes, motivations, and contingent valuation of nonuse values: a case study involving endangered species; citation_author=MJ Kotchen, SD Reiling; citation_volume=32; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2000; citation_pages=93-107; citation_doi=10.1016/S0921-8009(99)00069-5; citation_id=CR33

citation_journal_title=Ecol Econ; citation_title=Compensation for environmental services and intergovernmental fiscal transfers: the case of India; citation_author=S Kumar, S Managi; citation_volume=68; citation_issue=12; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=3052-3059; citation_doi=10.1016/j.ecolecon.2009.07.009; citation_id=CR34

citation_journal_title=Public Choice; citation_title=“Beggar thy neighbor”: testing for free riding in state-level endangered species expenditures; citation_author=JA List, EH Bulte, JF Shogren; citation_volume=111; citation_issue=3–4; citation_publication_date=2002; citation_pages=303-315; citation_doi=10.1023/A:1014947110729; citation_id=CR35

Loureiro W (2002) Contribuição do ICMS Ecológico à Conservação da Biodiversidade no Estado do Paraná. Doctoral thesis, Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba

Loureiro W, Pinto MA, Motta MNJ (2008) Legislação atualizada do ICMS Ecológico por Biodiversidade

citation_title=Using fiscal instruments to encourage conservation: municipal responses to the ’ecological’ value-added tax in Paraná and Minas Gerais, Brazil; citation_inbook_title=Selling forest environmental services: market-based mechanisms for conservation and development; citation_publication_date=2002; citation_pages=173-199; citation_id=CR38; citation_author=P May; citation_author=F Veiga Neto; citation_author=V Denardin; citation_author=W Loureiro; citation_publisher=Earthscan

citation_title=Ecosystems and human well-being: biodiversity synthesis; citation_publication_date=2005; citation_id=CR39; citation_publisher=World Resources Institute

citation_journal_title=J Bus Econ Stat; citation_title=Natural und quasi-experiments in economics; citation_author=BD Meyer; citation_volume=13; citation_issue=2; citation_publication_date=1995; citation_pages=151-161; citation_id=CR40

Mumbunan S (2011) Ecological fiscal transfers in Indonesia. Ph.D. thesis, University Leipzig, Helmholt Centre for Environmental Research–UFZ, Leipzig

citation_title=The theory of public finance: a study in public economy; citation_publication_date=1959; citation_id=CR42; citation_author=RM Musgrave; citation_publisher=McGraw-Hill

citation_title=Fiscal Federalism; citation_publication_date=1972; citation_id=CR43; citation_author=WE Oates; citation_publisher=Harcourt Brace Jovanovich

citation_journal_title=Int Tax Public Finance; citation_title=Toward a second-generation theory of fiscal federalism; citation_author=WE Oates; citation_volume=12; citation_publication_date=2005; citation_pages=349-373; citation_doi=10.1007/s10797-005-1619-9; citation_id=CR44

citation_journal_title=Ecol Econ; citation_title=Altruistic, egoistic and biospheric values in willingness to pay (WTP) for wildlife; citation_author=E Ojea, ML Loureiro; citation_volume=63; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=2007; citation_pages=807-814; citation_doi=10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.02.003; citation_id=CR45

citation_title=The logic of collective action: public goods and the theory of groups; citation_publication_date=1965; citation_id=CR46; citation_author=M Olson; citation_publisher=Harvard University Press

citation_journal_title=Am Econ Rev; citation_title=The principle of “fiscal equivalence”: the division of responsibilities among different levels of government; citation_author=M Olson; citation_volume=59; citation_issue=2; citation_publication_date=1969; citation_pages=479-487; citation_id=CR47

citation_title=Governing the commons: the evolution of institutions for collective action; citation_publication_date=1990; citation_id=CR48; citation_author=E Ostrom; citation_publisher=Cambridge University Press

citation_title=Conserving biodiversity: reconciling local and global public benefits; citation_inbook_title=Providing global public goods: managing globalization; citation_publication_date=2003; citation_pages=532-555; citation_id=CR49; citation_author=C Perrings; citation_author=M Gadgil; citation_publisher=Oxford University Press

citation_journal_title=J Econ Perspect; citation_title=Federalism as a commitment to preserving market incentives; citation_author=Y Qian, BR Weingast; citation_volume=11; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=1997; citation_pages=83-92; citation_doi=10.1257/jep.11.4.83; citation_id=CR50

R Development Core Team (2016) R: a language and environment for statistical computing. http://www.r-project.org/

citation_journal_title=Ecol Econ; citation_title=Ecological public functions and fiscal equalisation at the local level in Germany; citation_author=I Ring; citation_volume=42; citation_publication_date=2002; citation_pages=415-427; citation_doi=10.1016/S0921-8009(02)00124-6; citation_id=CR52

citation_journal_title=Gaia; citation_title=Compensating municipalities for protected areas: fiscal transfers for biodiversity conservation in Saxony, Germany; citation_author=I Ring; citation_volume=17; citation_issue=S1; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=143-151; citation_doi=10.14512/gaia.17.S1.12; citation_id=CR53

citation_journal_title=Land Use Policy; citation_title=Integrating local ecological services into intergovernmental fiscal transfers: the case of the ecological ICMS in Brazil; citation_author=I Ring; citation_volume=25; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=485-497; citation_doi=10.1016/S0921-8009(02)00124-6; citation_id=CR54

citation_journal_title=J Public Econ; citation_title=Can decentralization be beneficial?; citation_author=A Rubinchik-Pessach; citation_volume=89; citation_issue=7; citation_publication_date=2005; citation_pages=1231-1249; citation_doi=10.1016/j.jpubeco.2003.11.005; citation_id=CR55

citation_journal_title=Rev Econ Stat; citation_title=The pure theory of public expenditure; citation_author=PA Samuelson; citation_volume=36; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=1954; citation_pages=387-389; citation_doi=10.2307/1925895; citation_id=CR56

citation_journal_title=Rev Econ Stat; citation_title=Diagrammatic exposition of a theory of public expenditure; citation_author=PA Samuelson; citation_volume=37; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=1955; citation_pages=350-356; citation_doi=10.2307/1925849; citation_id=CR57

citation_journal_title=Land Use Policy; citation_title=Fiscal transfers for biodiversity conservation: the Portuguese local finances law; citation_author=R Santos, I Ring, P Antunes, P Clemente; citation_volume=29; citation_issue=2; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=261-273; citation_doi=10.1016/j.landusepol.2011.06.001; citation_id=CR58

citation_journal_title=Environ Policy Gov; citation_title=Engaging local private and public actors in biodiversity conservation: the role of agri-environmental schemes and ecological fiscal transfers; citation_author=R Santos, P Antunes, I Ring, P Clemente; citation_volume=25; citation_issue=2; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=83-96; citation_doi=10.1002/eet.1661; citation_id=CR59

citation_journal_title=Ecol Econ; citation_title=Protected areas, local governments, and strategic interactions: the case of the ICMS-Ecológico in the Brazilian state of Paraná; citation_author=A Sauquet, S Marchand, J Féres; citation_volume=107; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=249-258; citation_doi=10.1016/j.ecolecon.2014.09.008; citation_id=CR60

citation_journal_title=Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie; citation_title=Intergovernmental fiscal transfers to support local conservation action in Europe; citation_author=C Schröter-Schlaack, I Ring, T Koellner, R Santos, P Antunes, P Clemente, R Mathevet, M Borie, M Grodzińska-Jurczak; citation_volume=58; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=98-114; citation_doi=10.1515/zfw.2014.0007; citation_id=CR61

citation_journal_title=Int J Math Model Optim; citation_title=Predicting the present with bayesian structural time series; citation_author=SL Scott, H Varian; citation_volume=5; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=4-23; citation_doi=10.1504/IJMMNO.2014.059942; citation_id=CR62

citation_journal_title=Philos Public Affairs; citation_title=Rational fools: a critique of the behavioral foundations of economic theory; citation_author=A Sen; citation_volume=6; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=1977; citation_pages=317-344; citation_doi=10.2307/2264946; citation_id=CR63

citation_journal_title=Quart J Econ; citation_title=A behavioral model of rational choice; citation_author=HA Simon; citation_volume=69; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=1955; citation_pages=99-118; citation_doi=10.2307/1884852; citation_id=CR64

citation_journal_title=Psychol Bull; citation_title=Cross sectional time series experiments: some suggested statistical analyses; citation_author=DK Simonton; citation_volume=84; citation_issue=3; citation_publication_date=1977; citation_pages=489-S02; citation_doi=10.1037/0033-2909.84.3.489; citation_id=CR65

citation_journal_title=World Dev; citation_title=Micro-incentives and municipal behavior: political decentralization and fiscal federalism in Argentina and Mexico; citation_author=HJM Smith, KD Revell; citation_volume=77; citation_issue=November; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_pages=231-248; citation_doi=10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.08.018; citation_id=CR66

citation_journal_title=Nature; citation_title=Let the locals lead; citation_author=R Smith, D Veríssimo, N Leader-Williams, RM Cowling, AT Knight; citation_volume=462; citation_issue=November; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=280-281; citation_doi=10.1038/462280a; citation_id=CR67

citation_journal_title=Land Econ; citation_title=Non-economic motivation for contingent values: rights and attitudinal beliefs in the willingness to pay for environmental improvements; citation_author=CL Spash; citation_volume=82; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=2006; citation_pages=602-622; citation_doi=10.3368/le.82.4.602; citation_id=CR68

citation_journal_title=Ecol Econ; citation_title=Motives behind willingness to pay for improving biodiversity in a water ecosystem: Eeconomics, ethics and social psychology; citation_author=CL Spash, K Urama, R Burton, W Kenyon, P Shannon, G Hill; citation_volume=68; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=955-964; citation_doi=10.1016/j.ecolecon.2006.09.013; citation_id=CR69

citation_journal_title=Polit Anal; citation_title=Estimating voter registration deadline effects with web search data; citation_author=A Street, TA Murray, JB Blitzer, RS Patel; citation_volume=23; citation_issue=2; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=225-241; citation_doi=10.1093/pan/mpv002; citation_id=CR70

TEEB (2010) The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity: mainstreaming the economics of nature: a synthesis of the approach, conclusions and recommendations of TEEB. http://www.teebweb.org/our-publications/

citation_title=Economic benefits of the natura 2000 network. Synthesis report; citation_publication_date=2013; citation_id=CR72; citation_author=P Brink; citation_author=S Bassi; citation_author=T Badura; citation_author=S Gantioler; citation_author=M Kettunen; citation_author=L Mazza; citation_author=K Hart; citation_author=M Rayment; citation_author=M Pieterse; citation_author=E Daly; citation_author=H Gerdes; citation_author=M Lago; citation_author=S Lang; citation_author=A Markandya; citation_author=P Nunes; citation_author=H Ding; citation_author=R Tinch; citation_author=I Dickie; citation_publisher=European Union

citation_journal_title=J Public Adm Res Theory; citation_title=Improving outcomes in fiscal federalism: local political leadership and administrative capacity; citation_author=JN Terman, RC Feiock; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_doi=10.1093/jopart/muu027; citation_id=CR73

citation_journal_title=Land Use Policy; citation_title=Constitutional state structure and scalar re-organization of natural resource governance: the transformation of polycentric water governance in Spain, Portugal and Germany; citation_author=A Thiel; citation_volume=45; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=176-188; citation_doi=10.1016/j.landusepol.2015.01.012; citation_id=CR74

citation_journal_title=J Polit Econ; citation_title=A pure theory of local expenditures; citation_author=CM Tiebout; citation_volume=64; citation_issue=5; citation_publication_date=1956; citation_pages=416-424; citation_doi=10.1086/257839; citation_id=CR75

citation_title=Institutions and the environment; citation_publication_date=2007; citation_id=CR76; citation_author=A Vatn; citation_publisher=Edward Elgar

citation_journal_title=Biopolicy J; citation_title=The successful use of economic instruments to foster sustainable use of biological diversity: six case studies from latin America and the Caribbean; citation_author=J Vogel; citation_volume=2; citation_issue=5; citation_publication_date=1997; citation_pages=1-44; citation_id=CR77

citation_journal_title=Am Econ Rev; citation_title=The use of knowledge in society; citation_author=FK Hayek; citation_volume=35; citation_issue=4; citation_publication_date=1945; citation_pages=519-530; citation_id=CR78

citation_journal_title=J Urban Econ; citation_title=Second generation fiscal federalism: the implications of fiscal incentives; citation_author=BR Weingast; citation_volume=65; citation_issue=3; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=279-293; citation_doi=10.1016/j.jue.2008.12.005; citation_id=CR79

citation_journal_title=World Dev; citation_title=Second generation fiscal federalism: political aspects of decentralization and economic development; citation_author=BR Weingast; citation_volume=53; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=14-25; citation_doi=10.1016/j.worlddev.2013.01.003; citation_id=CR80

citation_journal_title=J Public Econ; citation_title=Growing state-federal conflicts in environmental policy: the role of market-based regulation; citation_author=RC Williams; citation_volume=96; citation_issue=11–12; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=1092-1099; citation_doi=10.1016/j.jpubeco.2011.08.003; citation_id=CR81

World Bank (2015) World development indicators. World DataBank. http://databank.worldbank.org/data/home.aspx

citation_journal_title=J Public Econ; citation_title=Public open-space conservation under a budget constraint; citation_author=J Wu; citation_volume=111; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=96-101; citation_doi=10.1016/j.jpubeco.2013.12.008; citation_id=CR83

citation_journal_title=J Urban Econ; citation_title=Pigou, Tiebout, property taxation, and the underprovision of local public goods; citation_author=GR Zodrow, P Mieszkowski; citation_volume=19; citation_issue=3; citation_publication_date=1986; citation_pages=356-370; citation_doi=10.1016/0094-1190(86)90048-3; citation_id=CR84