Convergent cultural evolution and multilevel selection: Reply to comments on Janet Landa’s ‘The bioeconomics of homogenous middleman groups as adaptive units: Theory and empirical evidence viewed from a group selection framework’
Tóm tắt
The comments on Janet Landa’s (J Bioecon 10(3):259–278, 2008) target article provide a fascinating snapshot of how multilevel selection theory is perceived across several disciplines. When we focus on the zone of agreement among the commentators, Landa’s article provides an important example of convergent cultural evolution. When we focus on the zone of disagreement, we find a snapshot of the current status of the group selection controversy that goes beyond narrow scientific issues and requires a ‘truth and reconciliation’ process to resolve, as discussed in my series of blogs titled “Truth and Reconciliation for Group Selection” (Wilson
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-sloan-wilson/#blogger_bio
, 2009) and briefly summarized here.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Bell A.V., Richerson P.J. (2008) Charles J. Lumsden and Edward O. Wilson, Genes, mind, and culture: 25th anniversary edition. Journal of Bioeconomics, Special Issue 10(3): 307–314
Choi J.-K. (2008) Play locally, learn globally: Group selection and structural basis of cooperation. Journal of Bioeconomics, Special Issue 10(3): 239–258
Corning P.A. (2008) Adaptation in human societies: Proximate vs. ultimate causation: Comments on Janet Landa’s paper. Journal of Bioeconomics, Special Issue 10(3): 291–292
Dawkins R. (1976) The selfish gene. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Epstein R.A. (2008) Is group selection necessary? An alternative interpretation of homogenous middleman groups: Comments on Janet Landa’s paper. Journal of Bioeconomics, Special Issue 10(3): 279–286
Field A.J. (2008) Why multilevel selection matters. Journal of Bioeconomics, Special Issue 10(3): 203–238
Gintis H., Bowles S., Boyd R., Fehr E. (2005) Moral sentiments and material interests: The foundations of cooperation in economic life. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Landa J.T. (2008) The bioeconomics of homogenous middleman groups as adaptive units: Theory and empirical evidence viewed from a group selection framework. Journal of Bioeconomics, Special Issue 10(3): 259–278
Lumsden C.J., Wilson E.O. (1981) Genes, mind and culture. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Netting R. M. (1986) Cultural ecology. Waveland Press, Long Grove, IL
Richerson P.J., Boyd R. (2005) Not by genes alone: How culture transformed human evolution. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Sosis R., Swartwout P. (2008) Demonstrating group selection: A comment on Janet Landa’s ‘The bioeconomics of homogenous middleman groups as adaptive units’. Journal of Bioeconomics, Special Issue 10(3): 297–302
Turchin P. (2005) War and peace and war. Pi Press, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Wilson D.S. (2004) The new fable of the bees. In: Roger K. (eds) Evolutionary psychology and economic theory: Advances in Austrian economics, Vol. 7. JAI Press, Greenwich, CN, pp 201–220
Wilson, D. S. (2009). Truth and reconciliation for group selection. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-sloan-wilson/#blogger_bio
Wilson D.S., Wilson E.O. (2007) Rethinking the theoretical foundation of sociobiology. Quarterly Review of Biology 82: 327–348