Consumer lending efficiency: commercial banks versus a fintech lender

Financial Innovation - 2022
Joseph P. Hughes1, Julapa Jagtiani2, Choon-Geol Moon3
1Department of Economics, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ 08901-1248, USA
2Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, Ten Independence Mall, Philadelphia, PA, 19106, USA
3Department of Economics and Finance, College of Economics and Finance, Hanyang University, Seoul, 04763, Korea

Tóm tắt

Abstract

Fintechs are believed to help expand credit access to underserved consumers without taking on additional risk. We compare the performance efficiency of LendingClub’s unsecured personal loans with similar loans originated by banks. Using stochastic frontier estimation, we decompose the observed nonperforming loan (NPL) ratio into three components: the best-practice minimum NPL ratio, the excess NPL ratio, and a statistical noise, the former two of which reflect the lender’sinherent credit riskandlending inefficiency, respectively. As of 2013 and 2016, we find that the higher NPL ratios at the largest banks are driven by inherent credit risk, rather than lending inefficiency. Smaller banks are less efficient. In addition, as of 2013, LendingClub’s observed NPL ratio and lending efficiency were in line with banks with similar lending volume. However, its lending efficiency improved significantly from 2013 to 2016. As of 2016, LendingClub’s performance resembled the largest banks – consistent with an argument that its increased use of alternative data and AI/ML may have improved its credit risk assessment capacity above and beyond its peers using traditional approaches. Furthermore, we also investigate capital market incentives for lenders to take credit risk. Market value regression using the NPL ratio suggests that market discipline provides incentives to make less risky consumer loans. However, the regression using twodecomposed components(inherent credit risk and lending inefficiency) tells a deeper underlying story: market value is significantly positively related to inherent credit risk at most banks, whereas it is significantly negatively related to lending inefficiency at most banks.Market discipline appears to reward exposure to inherent credit risk and punish inefficient lending.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Allen F, Xian G, Jagtiani J (2021) A survey of fintech research and policy discussion. Rev Corp Financ 1(2–3):1–81

Berg T, Burg V, Gombovic A, Puri M (2020) On the rise of FinTechs: Credit scoring using digital footprints. Rev Financ Stud 33(7):2845–2897

Berger AN, Black LK (2011) Bank size, lending technologies, and small business finance. J Bank Finance 35:724–735

Berger AN, Bouwman CH, Norden L, Roman RA, Udell GF, Wang T (2021) Piercing through opacity: relationships and credit card lending to consumers and small businesses during normal times and the COVID-19 crisis. Working Paper, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3829240.

Berger AN, Mester LJ (1997) Inside the black box: what explains differences in the efficiencies of financial institutions. J Bank Finance 21:895–947

Bernanke B (2011) Speech at the independent community bankers of America national convention. San Diego, California, March 23

Brook Y, Hendershott R, Lee D (1998) The gains from takeover deregulation: evidence from the end of interstate banking restrictions. J Finance 53:2185–2204

Caprio G, Laeven L, Levine R (2007) Governance and bank valuation. J Financ Intermed 16(4):584–617

Croux C, Jagtiani J, Korivi T, Vulanovic M (2020) Important factors determining fintech loan default: evidence from LendingClub consumer platform. J Econ Behav Organ 173:270–296

Demsetz RS, Saidenberg MR, Strahan PE (1996) Banks with something to lose: the disciplinary role of franchise value. Econ Policy Rev 2:1–14

Di Maggio M, Yao V (2021) Fintech borrowers: lax screening or cream skimming. Rev Financ Stud (forthcoming)

Dorfleitner G, Priberny C, Schuster S, Stoiber J, Weber M, de Castro I, Kammler J (2016) Description-text related soft information in peer-to-peer lending — evidence from two leading european platforms. J Bank Finance 64:169–187

Gao Q, Lin M, Sias RW (2018) Words matter: the role of texts in online credit markets. J Financ Quant Anal, forthcoming in 2021. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2446114

Goldstein I, Jagtiani J, Klein A (2019) Fintech and the new financial landscape. Bank Policy Institute (BPI): Banking Perspectives, 1st Quarter, March

Greene WH (2018) Econometric analysis, 8th edn, Pearson Education, Inc., 924–930

Hildebrandt T, Puri M, Rocholl J (2017) Adverse incentives in crowdfunding. Manage Sci 63(3):587–608

Hughes JP, Jagtiani J, Mester LJ, Moon C-G (2019) Does scale matter in community bank performance? Evidence obtained by applying several new measures of performance. J Bank Finance 106:471–499

Hughes JP, Mester LJ (2019) The performance of financial institutions: modeling, evidence, and some policy implications. In: Berger AN, Molyneux P, Wilson J (eds) The Oxford handbook of banking, 3rd edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 229–261

Hughes JP, Moon CG (2017) How bad is a bad loan? Distinguishing inherent credit risk from inefficient lending (does the capital market price this difference?). Department of Economics, Rutgers University Working Paper 201802 (Supercedes Working Paper 201709)

Iyer R, Khwaja AI, Luttmer EEP, Shue K (2016) Screening peers softly: inferring the quality of small borrowers. Manage Sci 62(6):1554–1577

Jagtiani J, Lemieux C (2019) The roles of alternative data and machine learning in Fintech lending: evidence from the LendingClub consumer platform. Financ Manage 48(4):1009–1029

Jagtiani J, Lambie-Hanson L, Lambie-Hanson T (2021) Fintech lending and mortgage credit access. J FinTech (forthcoming). https://www.philadelphiafed.org/-/media/research-and-data/publications/working-papers/2019/wp19-47.pdf

Jagtiani J, Lemieux C (2018) Do Fintech lenders penetrate areas that are underserved by traditional banks? J Econ Bus 100:43–54

Jagtiani J, John K (2018) Fintech — the impact on consumers and regulatory responses. J Econ Bus 100:1–6

Jagtiani J, Vermilyea T, Wall LD (2018) The roles of big data and machine learning in bank supervision. The Clearing House: Banking Perspectives, 1st Quarter, March

Jondrow J, Knox Lovell CA, Materov IS, Schmidt P (1982) On the estimation of technical efficiency in the stochastic frontier production function model. J Econom 19:233–238

Kou G, Peng Yi, Wang G (2014) Evaluation of clustering algorithms for financial risk analysis using MCDM methods. Inf Sci 275:1–12

Kou G, Xu Y, Peng Y, Shen F, Chen Y, Chang K, Kou S (2021) Bankruptcy prediction for SMEs using transactional data and two-stage multiobjective feature selection. Decis Supp Syst 140:113429

Kou G, Akdeniz ÖO, Dinçer H, Yüksel S (2021) Fintech investments in European banks: a hybrid IT2 fuzzy multidimensional decision-making approach. Financ Innov 7(1):1–28

Li T, Kou G, Peng Y, Philip SY (2021) An integrated cluster detection, optimization, and interpretation approach for financial data. IEEE Trans Cybernet

Lin M, Prabhala NR, Viswanathan S (2013) Judging borrowers by the company they keep: friendship networks and information asymmetry in online peer-to-peer lending. Manage Sci 59(1):17–35

McConnell JJ, Servaes H (1995) Equity ownership and the two faces of debt. J Financ Econ 39:131–157

Morck R, Shleifer A, Vishny RW (1988) Management ownership and market valuation: an empirical analysis. J Financ Econ 20:293–315

Morgan DP, Ashcraft AB (2003) Using loan rates to measure and regulate bank risk: findings and an immodest proposal. J Financ Serv Res 24(2/3):181–200

Pérez-González F (2006) Inherited control and firm performance. Am Econ Rev 96:1559–1588

Petersen MA, Rajan RG (1995) The effect of credit market competition on lending relationships. Quart J Econ 110(2):407–443

Vuong QH (1989) Likelihood ratio test for model selection and non-nested hypotheses. Econometrica 57:307–333

Wang H, Kou G, Peng Yi (2021) Multi-class misclassification cost matrix for credit ratings in peer-to-peer lending. J Oper Res Soc 72(4):923–934

Zha Q, Kou G, Zhang H, Liang H, Chen X, Li CC, Dong Y (2020) Opinion dynamics in finance and business: a literature review and research opportunities. Financ Innov 6(1):1–22

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

Financial Innovation

Thông tin tác giả