Tổng Quan Toàn Diện Về Các Phương Pháp và Tiêu Chí Chọn Lựa Địa Điểm Chôn Lấp Rác Thải Rắn Đô Thị

Springer Science and Business Media LLC - Tập 101 - Trang 509-521 - 2021
Katerina Donevska1, Jozhe Jovanovski2, Ljopche Gligorova1
1Faculty of Civil Engineering, University Ss Cyril and Methodius, Skopje, Republic of North Macedonia
2Public Enterprise for State Roads, Skopje, Republic of North Macedonia

Tóm tắt

Bài báo này trình bày một đánh giá toàn diện về các khuôn khổ phương pháp và tiêu chí được sử dụng để lựa chọn địa điểm chôn lấp rác thải rắn đô thị. Đánh giá dựa trên 89 bài báo khoa học được công bố trong các tạp chí đã qua phản biện từ năm 1983 trở đi. Các phân tích thống kê mô tả của các bài báo được xem xét xem xét các yếu tố định tính và định lượng dựa trên thời gian và địa điểm. Các bài báo được xem xét được phân loại theo quốc gia nơi thực hiện các nghiên cứu trường hợp, và việc xếp hạng định tính được thực hiện dựa vào số lượt trích dẫn. Sau đó, các phương pháp và tiêu chí được sử dụng để lựa chọn địa điểm chôn lấp đã được phân tích và phân loại một cách chi tiết. Tóm tắt các phân tích cho thấy rằng Hệ Thống Thông Tin Địa Lý (GIS), là một kỹ thuật riêng lẻ hoặc kết hợp với các phương pháp khác, được sử dụng rộng rãi. Phương pháp phân tích quyết định đa tiêu chí theo trọng số tuyến tính là phương pháp thường được áp dụng nhất để xếp hạng các lựa chọn. Phương pháp phân tích thứ bậc (AHP) là phương pháp chiếm ưu thế trong việc xác định trọng số của các tiêu chí. Một sự kết hợp giữa GIS và các kỹ thuật Cảm Biến Từ Xa được sử dụng trong một số nghiên cứu lựa chọn địa điểm chôn lấp như một phương pháp hấp dẫn hơn, nhờ khả năng cập nhật dữ liệu theo thời gian thực. Các đánh giá về các tiêu chí lựa chọn địa điểm chôn lấp cho thấy rằng tiêu chí chính thường gặp nhất là tiêu chí môi trường, tiếp theo là tiêu chí kinh tế và xã hội, trong khi tiêu chí phụ được ưa chuộng nhất là khoảng cách đến nguồn nước mặt. Những phát hiện và phân loại này có lợi cho cả các nhà nghiên cứu và các nhà ra quyết định, đồng thời hỗ trợ cho quá trình lựa chọn địa điểm chôn lấp trong thực tế phức tạp và khó khăn.

Từ khóa

#chôn lấp rác thải #tiêu chí lựa chọn #Hệ Thống Thông Tin Địa Lý #phương pháp phân tích quyết định đa tiêu chí

Tài liệu tham khảo

Mahini AS, Gholamalifard M (2006) Siting MSW landfills with a weighted linear combination (WLC) methodology in a GIS environment. Int J Environ Sci Tech 3:435–445 Council EU (1999) Council directive 1999/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the landfill of waste. Off J Eur Commun 16/07/1999 182:1–19 Council EU (2003) Council decision 2003/33/EC of 19 December 2002 establishing criteria and procedures for the acceptance of waste at landfills persuant to Article 16 of and Annex II to Directive 1999/31/EC. Off J Eur Commun 16.1.2003 11:27–49 Hostovsky C (2000) Integrating planning theory and waste management. An annotated bibliography. J Plan Lit 15:305–332 Barlaz M, Kaplan P, Ranjithan S, Rynk R (2003) Evaluating environmental impacts of solid waste management alternatives. Biocycle 44:52–56 Gorsevski PV, Donevska KR, Mitrovski CD, Frizado JP (2012) Integrating multi-criteria evaluation techniques with geographic information systems for landfill site selection: a case study using ordered weighted average. Waste Manag 32(2):287–296 McBean EA, Rovers FA, Farquhar GJ (1995) Solid waste landfill engineering and design. Prentice-Hall Publishing Co., Inc., Englewood Cliffs Chang NB, Parvathinathan G, Breeden JB (2008) Combining GIS with fuzzy multicriteria decision-making for landfill siting in a fast-growing urban region. J Environ Manag 87(1):139–153 Nazari A, Salarirad MM, Bazzazi AA (2012) Landfill site selection by decision-making tools based on fuzzy multi-attribute decision-making method. Environ Earth Sci 65(6):1631–1642 Demesouka OE, Vavatsikos AP, Anagnostopoulos KP (2014) GIS-based multicriteria municipal solid waste landfill suitability analysis: a review of the methodologies performed and criteria implemented. Waste Manag Res 32(4):270–296 Mat NA, Benjamin AM, Abdul-Rahman S (2017) A review on criteria and decision-making techniques in solving landfill site selection problems. J Adv Rev Sci Res 37(1):14–32 Özkan B, Özceylan E, Sarıçiçek İ (2019) GIS-based MCDM modeling for landfill site suitability analysis: a comprehensive review of the literature. Environ Sci Pollut Res 26:1–20 Lin HY, Kao JJ (1998) A vector-based spatial model for landfill siting. J Hazard Mater 58(1–3):3–14 Siddiqui M, Everett JM, Vieux BE (1996) Landfill siting using geographic information systems: a demonstration. J Environ Eng 122:515–523 Noble G (1992) Siting landfills and other LULU’s. Technomic Publishing Company Inc, Lancaster Sharma HD, Reddy KR (2004) Geoenvironmental engineering: site remediation, waste containment, and emerging waste management technologies. Wiley, Hoboken Delgado OB, Mendoza M, Granados EL, Geneletti D (2008) Analysis of land suitability for the siting of inter-municipal landfills in the Cuitzeo Lake Basin, Mexico. Waste Manag 28(7):1137–1146 Malczewski J (2006) GIS-based multicriteria decision analysis: a survey of the literature. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 20(7):703–726 Malczewski J (2000) On the use of weighted linear combination method in GIS: common and best practice approaches. Trans GIS 4(1):5–22 Donevska KR, Gorsevski PV, Jovanovski M, Peševski I (2012) Regional non-hazardous landfill site selection by integrating fuzzy logic, AHP and geographic information systems. Environ Earth Sci 67(1):121–131 Gemitzi A, Tsihrintzis VA, Voudrias E, Petalas C, Stavrodimos G (2007) Combining geographic information system, multi criteria evaluation techniques and fuzzy logic in siting MSW landfills. Environ Geol 51:797–811 Geneletti D (2010) Combining stakeholder analysis and spatial multicriteria evaluation to select and rank inert landfill sites. Waste Manag 30:328–337 Khamehchiyan M, Nikoudel MR, Boroumandi M (2011) Identification of hazardous waste landfill site: a case study from Zanjan province, Iran. Environ Earth Sci 64(7):1763–1776 Kontos TD, Komilis DP, Halvadakis CP (2005) Siting MSW landfills with a spatial multiple criteria analysis methodology. Waste Manag 25(8):818–832 Nas B, Cay T, Iscan F et al (2010) Selection of MSW landfill site for Konya, Turkey using GIS and multi-criteria evaluation. Environ Monit Assess 160:491. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-008-0713-8 Şener B, Süzen ML, Doyuran V (2006) Landfill site selection by using geographic information systems. Environ Geol 49:376–388 Şener S, Şener E, Nas B, Karaguzel R (2010) Combining AHP with GIS for landfill site selection: a case study in the Lake Beysehir catchment area (Konya, Turkey). Waste Manag 30:2037–2046 Sharifi M, Hadidi M, Vessali E, Mosstafakhani P, Taheri K, Shahoie S, Khodamoradpour M (2009) Integrating multi-criteria decision analysis for a GIS-based hazardous waste landfill sitting in Kurdistan Province, Western Iran. Waste Manag 29:2740–2758 Zamorano M, Molero E, Hurtado A, Grindlay A, Ramos A (2008) Evaluation of a municipal landfill site in Southern Spain with GIS-aided methodology. J Hazard Mater 160:473–481 Jensen JR, Christensen EJ (1986) Solid and hazardous waste disposal site selection using digital geographic information system techniques. Sci Total Environ 56:265–276 Vatalis K, Manoliadis O (2002) A two-level multicriteria DSS for landfill site selection using GIS: case study in Western Macedonia, Greece. J Geogr Inf Decis Anal 6(1):49–56 Voogd H (1983) Multi-criteria evaluations for urban and regional planning. Pion, London Saaty TL (1980) The analytic hierarchy process. McGraw-Hill, New York Al-Jarrah O, Abu-Qdais H (2006) Municipal solid waste landfill siting using intelligent system. Waste Manag 26:299–306 Gupta R, Kewalramaniz MA, Ralegaonkar RV (2003) Environmental impact analysis using fuzzy relation for landfill siting. J Urban Plan Dev 129:121–139 Şener Ş, Sener E, Karagüzel R (2011) Solid waste disposal site selection with GIS and AHP methodology: a case study in Senirkent-Uluborlu (Isparta) Basin, Turkey. Environ Monit Assess 173(1–4):533–554 Guiqin W, Li Q, Guoxue L, Lijun C (2009) Landfill site selection using spatial information technologies and AHP: a case study in Beijing, China. J Environ Manag 90(8):2414–2421 Saaty TL, Vargas LG (2006) Decision making with the analytic network process. Springer Science + Business Media Inc, New York Afzali A, Sabri S, Rashid M, Samani JMV, Ludin ANM (2014) Inter-municipal landfill site selection using analytic network process. Water Resour Manag 28(8):2179–2194 Banar M, Kose BM, Ozkan A et al (2007) Choosing a municipal landfill site by analytic network process. Environ Geol 52:747–751 Hamzeh M, Ali Abbaspour R, Davalou R (2015) Raster-based outranking method: a new approach for municipal solid waste landfill (MSW) siting. Environ Sci Pollut Res 22:12511–12524 Ferretti V (2011) A multicriteria spatial decision support system development for siting a landfill in the province of Torino (Italy). J Multi-Criteria Decis Anal 18(5–6):231–252 Zadeh LA (1965) Fuzzy sets. Inform Control 8:338–353 Beskese A, Demir HH, Ozcan HK et al (2015) Landfill site selection using fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS: a case study for Istanbul. Environ Earth Sci 73:3513–3521 Hanine M, Boutkhoum O, Tikniouine A et al (2016) Comparison of fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TODIM methods for landfill location selection. Springerplus 5:501 Kharat MG, Kamble SJ, Raut RD, Kamble SS, Dhume SM (2016) Modeling landfill site selection using an integrated fuzzy MCDM approach. Model Earth Syst Environ 2(2):53 Torabi-Kaveh M, Babazadeh R, Mohammadi SD, Zaresefat M (2016) Landfill site selection using combination of GIS and fuzzy AHP, a case study: Iranshahr, Iran. Waste Manag Res 34(5):438–448 Ekmekçioğlu M, Kaya T, Kahraman C (2010) Fuzzy multicriteria disposal method and site selection for municipal solid waste. Waste Manag 30(8–9):1729–1736 Yager RR (1988) On ordered weighted averaging aggregation operators in multicriteria decision making. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern 8:183–190 Gbanie SP, Tengbe PB, Momoh JS, Medo J, Kabba VTS (2013) Modelling landfill location using geographic information systems (GIS) and multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA): case study Bo, Southern Sierra Leone. Appl Geogr 36:3–12 Melo AL, Calijuri ML, Duarte IC, Azevedo RF, Lorentz JF (2006) Strategic decision analysis for selection of landfill sites. J Surv Eng 132(2):83–92 Motlagh ZK, Sayadi MH (2015) Siting MSW landfills using MCE methodology in GIS environment (Case study: Birjand plain, Iran). Waste Manag 46:322–337 Alexakis DD, Sarris A (2014) Integrated GIS and remote sensing analysis for landfill sitting in Western Crete Greece. Environ Earth Sci 72(2):467–482 Abd-El Monsef H, Smith SE (2019) Integrating remote sensing, geographic information system, and analytical hierarchy process for hazardous waste landfill site selection. Arab J Geosci 12(5):1–14 Demesouka OE, Vavatsikos AP, Anagnostopoulos KP (2013) Suitability analysis for siting MSW landfills and its multicriteria spatial decision support system: method, implementation and case study. Waste Manag 33(5):1190–1206 Chau KW (2005) Prototype expert system for site selection of a sanitary landfill. Civil Eng Environ Syst 22:205–215 Demesouka OE, Vavatsikos AP, Anagnostopoulos KP (2016) Using MACBETH multicriteria technique for GIS-based landfill suitability analysis. J Environ Eng 142(10):1–11 Liu HC, You JX, Chen YZ, Fan XJ (2014) Site selection in municipal solid waste management with extended VIKOR method under fuzzy environment. Environ Earth Sci 72(10):4179–4189 Opricovic S (1998) Multi-criteria optimization of civil engineering systems. Faculty of Civil Engineering, Belgrade Santhosh LG, Sivakumar Babu GL (2018) Landfill site selection based on reliability concepts using the DRASTIC method and AHP integrated with GIS—a case study of Bengaluru city, India. Georisk: Assess Manag Risk Eng Syst Geohazards. https://doi.org/10.1080/17499518.2018.1434548 Baban SM, Flannagan J (1998) Developing and implementing GIS-assisted constraints criteria for planning landfill sites in the UK. Plan Pract Res 13(2):139–151 De Feo G, De Gisi S (2014) Using MCDA and GIS for hazardous waste landfill siting considering land scarcity for waste disposal. Waste Manag 34(11):2225–2238 Eskandari M, Homaee M, Mahmodi S (2012) An integrated multi criteria approach for landfill siting in a conflicting environmental, economical and socio-cultural area. Waste Manag 32(8):1528–1538 Kontos TD, Komilis DP, Halvadakis CP (2003) Siting MSW landfills on Lesvos Island with a GIS based methodology. Waste Manag Res 21(3):262–277 Moeinaddini M, Khorasani N, Danehkar A, Darvishsefat AA, Zienalyan M (2010) Siting MSW landfill using weighted linear combination and analytical hierarchy process (AHP) methodology in GIS environment (case study: Karaj). Waste Manag 30:912–920 Vasiljević TZ, Srdjević Z, Bajčetić R, Miloradov MV (2012) GIS and the analytic hierarchy process for regional landfill site selection in transitional countries: a case study from Serbia. Environ Manag 49(2):445–458 Kao JJ, Chen WY, Lin HY, Guo SJ (1996) Network expert geographic information system for landfill siting. J Comput Civ Eng 10(4):307–317 Sumathi VR, Natesan U, Sarkar C (2008) GIS-based approach for optimized siting of municipal solid waste landfill. Waste Manag 28(11):2146–2160 Charnpratheep K, Zhou Q, Garner B (1997) Preliminary landfill site screening using fuzzy geographical information systems. Waste Manag Res 15(2):197–215 Spigolon LM, Giannotti M, Larocca AP, Russo MA, Souza NDC (2018) Landfill siting based on optimisation, multiple decision analysis, and geographic information system analyses. Waste Manag Res 36(7):606–615 Khan MMUH, Vaezi M, Kumar A (2018) Optimal siting of solid waste-to-value-added facilities through a GIS-based assessment. Sci Total Environ 610:1065–1075 Wang Y, Li J, An D, Xi B, Tang J, Wang Y, Yang Y (2018) Site selection for municipal solid waste landfill considering environmental health risks. Resour Conserv Recycl 138:40–46 Balew A, Alemu M, Leul Y et al (2020) Suitable landfill site selection using GIS-based multi-criteria decision analysis and evaluation in Robe town, Ethiopia. GeoJ. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10708-020-10284-3 Ali SA, Parvin F, Al-Ansari N et al (2020) Sanitary landfill site selection by integrating AHP and FTOPSIS with GIS: a case study of Memari Municipality, India. Environ Sci Pollut Res. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-11004-7 Khan D, Samadder SR (2015) A simplified multi-criteria evaluation model for landfill site ranking and selection based on AHP and GIS. J Environ Eng Landsc Manag 23(4):267–278 Kumar S, Hassan MI (2013) Selection of a landfill site for solid waste management: an application of AHP and spatial analyst tool. J Indian Soc Remote Sens 41:45–56 Alavi N, Goudarzi G, Babaei AA, Jaafarzadeh N, Hosseinzadeh M (2013) Municipal solid waste landfill site selection with geographic information systems and analytical hierarchy process: a case study in Mahshahr County Iran. Waste Manag Res 31(1):98–105 Bahrani S, Ebadi T, Ehsani H, Yousefi H, Maknoon R (2016) Modeling landfill site selection by multi-criteria decision making and fuzzy functions in GIS, case study: Shabestar, Iran. Environ Earth Sci 75(4):337 Eskandari M, Homaee M, Mahmoodi S et al (2015) Optimizing landfill site selection by using land classification maps. Environ Sci Pollut Res 22:7754–7765 Eskandari M, Homaee M, Falamaki A (2016) Landfill site selection for municipal solid wastes in mountainous areas with landslide susceptibility. Environ Sci Pollut Res 23:12423–12434 Isalou AA, Zamani V, Shahmoradi B et al (2013) Landfill site selection using integrated fuzzy logic and analytic network process (F-ANP). Environ Earth Sci 68:1745–1755 Shahabi H, Keihanfard S, Ahmad BB, Amiri MJT (2014) Evaluating boolean, AHP and WLC methods for the selection of waste landfill sites using GIS and satellite images. Environ Earth Sci 71(9):4221–4233 Chabuk A, Al-Ansari N, Hussain HM, Knutsson S, Pusch R (2016) Landfill site selection using geographic information system and analytical hierarchy process: a case study Al-Hillah Qadhaa, Babylon, Iraq. Waste Manag Res 34(5):427–437 Chabuk AJ, Al-Ansari N, Hussain HM, Knutsson S, Pusch R (2017) GIS-based assessment of combined AHP and SAW methods for selecting suitable sites for landfill in Al-Musayiab Qadhaa, Babylon, Iraq. Environ Earth Sci 76(5):209 Baiocchi V, Lelo K, Polettini A, Pomi R (2014) Land suitability for waste disposal in metropolitan areas. Waste Manag Res 32(8):707–716 Ahmad SZ, Ahamad MSS, Yusoff MS (2014) Spatial effect of new municipal solid waste landfill siting using different guidelines. Waste Manag Res 32(1):24–33 Kara C, Doratli N (2012) Application of GIS/AHP in siting sanitary landfill: a case study in Northern Cyprus. Waste Manag Res 30(9):966–980 El Baba M, Kayastha P, De Smedt F (2015) Landfill site selection using multi-criteria evaluation in the GIS interface: a case study from the Gaza Strip, Palestine. Arab J Geosci 8:7499–7513 Djokanović S, Abolmasov B, Jevremović D (2016) GIS application for landfill site selection: a case study in Pančevo, Serbia. Bull Eng Geol Environ 75:1273–1299 Lee S (2003) Evaluation of waste disposal site using the DRASTIC system in Southern Korea. Environ Geol 44:654–664 Chiueh PT, Lo SL, Chang CL (2008) A GIS-based system for allocating municipal solid waste incinerator compensatory fund. Waste Manag 28(12):2690–2701 Kao JJ, Lin HY (1996) Multifactor spatial analysis for landfill siting. J Environ Eng 122(10):902–908 Lin HY, Kao JJ (2005) Grid-based heuristic method for multifactor landfill siting. J Comput Civ Eng 19(4):369–376 Kamdar I, Ali S, Bennui A, Techato K, Jutidamrongphan W (2019) Municipal solid waste landfill siting using an integrated GIS-AHP approach: a case study from Songkhla, Thailand. Resour Conserv Recycl 149:220–235 Aydi A, Zairi M, Dhia HB (2013) Minimization of environmental risk of landfill site using fuzzy logic, analytical hierarchy process, and weighted linear combination methodology in a geographic information system environment. Environ Earth Sci 68:1375–1389 Aksoy E, San BT (2019) Geographical information systems (GIS) and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) integration for sustainable landfill site selection considering dynamic data source. Bull Eng Geol Environ 78:779–791 Ersoy H, Bulut F (2009) Spatial and multi-criteria decision analysis-based methodology for landfill site selection in growing urban regions. Waste Manag Res 27(5):489–500 Kahraman C, Cebi S, Onar SC, Oztaysi B (2018) A novel trapezoidal intuitionistic fuzzy information axiom approach: an application to multicriteria landfill site selection. Eng Appl Artif Intell 67:157–172 Simsek C, Kincal C, Gunduz O (2006) A solid waste disposal site selection procedure based on groundwater vulnerability mapping. Environ Geol 49:620–633 Uyan M (2014) MSW landfill site selection by combining AHP with GIS for Konya, Turkey. Environ Earth Sci 71:1629–1639 Yal GP, Akgün H (2013) Landfill site selection and landfill liner design for Ankara, Turkey. Environ Earth Sci 70(6):2729–2752 Yesilnacar MI, Süzen ML, Kaya BŞ, Doyuran V (2012) Municipal solid waste landfill site selection for the city of Şanliurfa-Turkey: an example using MCDA integrated with GIS. Int J Digit Earth 5(2):147–164 Yildirim V (2012) Application of raster-based GIS techniques in the siting of landfills in Trabzon Province, Turkey: a case study. Waste Manag Res 30(9):949–960 Al-Ruzouq R, Shanableh A, Omar M, Al-Khayyat G (2018) Macro and micro geo-spatial environment consideration for landfill site selection in Sharjah, United Arab Emirates. Environ Monit Assess 190(3):147 Lane WN, McDonald RR (1983) Land suitability analysis: landfill siting. J Urban Plan Dev 109(1):50–61 Lin HY, Kao JJ (1999) Enhanced spatial model for landfill siting analysis. J Environ Eng ASCE 125:845–851 Nascimento VF, Yesiller N, Clarke KC, Ometto JPHB, Andrade PR, Sobral AC (2017) Modeling the environmental susceptibility of landfill sites in California. GIScience Remote Sens 54(5):657–677