Best Practices or Best Guesses? Assessing the Efficacy of Corporate Affirmative Action and Diversity Policies

American Sociological Review - Tập 71 Số 4 - Trang 589-617 - 2006
Alexandra Kalev1, Frank Dobbin2, E. Lowell Kelly3
1University of California, Berkeley
2Harvard University
3University of Minnesota

Tóm tắt

Employers have experimented with three broad approaches to promoting diversity. Some programs are designed to establish organizational responsibility for diversity, others to moderate managerial bias through training and feedback, and still others to reduce the social isolation of women and minority workers. These approaches find support in academic theories of how organizations achieve goals, how stereotyping shapes hiring and promotion, and how networks influence careers. This is the first systematic analysis of their efficacy. The analyses rely on federal data describing the workforces of 708 private sector establishments from 1971 to 2002, coupled with survey data on their employment practices. Efforts to moderate managerial bias through diversity training and diversity evaluations are least effective at increasing the share of white women, black women, and black men in management. Efforts to attack social isolation through mentoring and networking show modest effects. Efforts to establish responsibility for diversity lead to the broadest increases in managerial diversity. Moreover, organizations that establish responsibility see better effects from diversity training and evaluations, networking, and mentoring. Employers subject to federal affirmative action edicts, who typically assign responsibility for compliance to a manager, also see stronger effects from some programs. This work lays the foundation for an institutional theory of the remediation of workplace inequality.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Ashenfelter Orley, 1976, Evaluating the Labor- Market Effects of Social Programs, 46

10.1177/0730888497024004005

10.1146/annurev.so.10.080184.000345

Baron James N., 1985, Gender and the Life Course, 233

10.1086/229690

10.2307/2786876

10.1177/1059601197223004

10.1086/259394

Bendick Mark, 1998, The Documentation and Evaluation of Antidiscrimination Training in the United States.

Bisom-Rapp Susan, 1999, Florida State University Law Review, 26, 959

10.1016/S0277-2833(01)80021-2

10.2307/2109659

10.2307/256829

10.1177/105649269873007

Briscoe Forrest, Safford Sean 2005. “Agency in Diffusion: Activism, Imitation, and the Adoption of Domestic Partner Benefits among the Fortune 500.” Unpublished paper. Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA.

10.1177/000312240106600203

Bureau of National Affairs., 1986, Work and Family: A Changing Agenda.

10.1108/09649429710171163

Burstein Paul, 2000, Legacies of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, 129

10.1177/104346398010001001

10.1057/9780230005822

10.1086/427319

Catalyst., 1998, Advancing Women in Business - the Catalyst Guide: Best Practices from the Corporate Leaders.

10.2307/2657335

Collins Randall, 1979, The Credential Society: A Historical Sociology of Education and Stratification.

Crow Kelly, 2003, New York Times, G2

Dobbin Frank, 1988, Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment, 71

10.1086/230269

Donohue John J., 1991, Journal of Economic Literature, 29, 1603

10.2307/1228893

10.1086/229459

10.1086/321303

Edelman Lauren B., Hamilton Krieger Linda, Eliason Scott, Albiston K. T. 2005. “Judicial Deference to Institutionalized Compliance Strategies.” Working Paper Thesis, Boalt Hall School of Law, University of California, Berkeley, CA.

Edelman Lauren B., 1999, Research in Social Stratification and Mobility, 17, 107

10.1111/1468-232X.00248

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)., 1998, “Best Practices of Private Sector Employers.”

10.1016/0049-089X(88)90010-5

10.1177/000312240607100103

Fisher Anne B., 1985, Fortune, 26

Fiske Susan T., 1998, Stereotyping, Prejudice and Discrimination, 357

Fox John, 1997, Applied Regression Analysis, Linear Models, and Related Methods.

Fretz C. F., 1973, Harvard Business Review, 133

10.1111/j.0019-8676.2004.00362.x

10.1177/001979397602900401

10.1177/000312240507000408

Granovetter Mark, 1974, Getting a Job: A Study of Contracts and Careers.

10.1111/j.1467-9930.2005.00199.x

Greene W. H., 1997, Econometric Analysis.

Hanushek Erin A., 1977, Statistical Methods for Social Scientists.

10.1177/001979397602900402

10.2307/1912352

Heckman James J., 1989, American Economic Review, 79, 138

Heilman Madeline E., 1995, Journal of Social Behavior and Personality, 10, 3

10.2307/257055

Hemphill Hellen, 1997, Discrimination, Harassment, and the Failure of Diversity Training: What to Do Now.

10.1017/CBO9781139174053.007

10.1177/001979390005300204

Hsiao Cheng, 1986, Analysis of Panel Data, 11

10.2307/2393451

10.2307/256742

10.1086/229217

Jacobs Jerry A., 1989, Revolving Doors: Sex Segregation and Women's Careers.

10.2307/2393225

10.1111/j.1467-9221.2004.00402.x

Kalev Alexandra, Law and Social Inquiry.

Kalleberg Arne L., 1996, Organizations in America: Analyzing Their Structures and Human Resource Practices.

10.1177/0730888401028002004

Kanter Rosabeth Moss., 1977, Men and Women of the Corporation.

Kelly Erin 2000. “Corporate Family Policies in U.S. Organizations, 1965–1997.” Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ.

10.1086/379631

10.1108/eb022908

King Mary C., 1992, Monthly Labor Review, 115, 30

10.1257/jep.12.1.115

10.1002/hrm.10061

10.2307/256746

Krawiec Kimberly D., 2003, Washington University Law Quarterly, 81, 487

10.1007/978-3-322-89014-6_18

10.1086/298041

10.1177/001979398503900109

10.2307/145782

10.1257/jep.3.1.61

10.1257/jep.4.4.47

Liberman Vadim, 2003, Across the Board, 51

10.1177/105649269984009

Lunding F. S., 1979, Harvard Business Review, 56, 89

10.1177/001979399504800201

10.1177/0730888400027004004

10.1086/226550

Milkman Ruth, 1985, Women, Work, and Protest: A Century of Women's Labor History

Miller Joanne, 1994, Corporate Responses to Diversity.

Moore Paul Cameron. 2001. “The Transfer of Human and Social Capital: Employee Development Through Assigned Peer Mentoring.” Ph.D. dissertation, Stanford Graduate School of Business, Stanford, CA.

10.1177/000312240306800604

10.1081/PAD-120024399

10.1006/jesp.1996.0002

Neumark David, Gardecki Rosella 1996. “Women Helping Women? Role Model and Mentoring Effects on Female Ph.D. Student in Economics.” Working Paper. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

10.5465/amr.1990.4308154

10.1177/001979399404700202

10.1177/001979390005300201

10.2307/1556339

10.2307/2095348

10.1086/318961

Posner Richard A., 1992, Economic Analysis of Law, 4

Presidential Glass Ceiling Commission., 1995, A Solid Investment: Making a Full Use of our Nations' Human Capital.

Rose Ragins Belle, 1995, Diversity in Organizations: New Perspectives for a Changing Workplace, 91, 10.4135/9781452243405.n5

Reskin Barbara F., 1998, The Realities of Affirmative Action in Employment.

10.2307/2654387

10.1177/000312240306800101

10.1177/000312240006500204

Reskin Barbara F., 1990, Job Queues, Gender Queues: Explaining Women's Inroads into Male Occupations.

10.1177/0730888404272008

Roche Gerard R., 1979, Harvard Business Review, 57, 14

Rossi Peter H., 2004, Evaluation: A Systematic Approach.

10.1111/j.1744-6570.1995.tb01756.x

10.2307/3033561

Scott W. Richard., 2001, Institutions and Organizations.

Selznick Philip, 1949, TVA and the Grass Roots.

Shaeffer Ruth G., 1973, “Nondiscrimination in Employment: Changing Perspectives, 1963–1972.”

10.2307/2579969

10.1080/00224545.1992.9924713

10.1017/CBO9780511606281

Skaggs Sheryl 2001. “Discrimination Litigation: Implications for Women and Minorities in Retail Supermarket Management.” Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC.

10.7208/chicago/9780226216423.001.0001

10.1086/298034

Snyder Lori D., 2003, “Are Management-Based Regulations Effective?: Evidence from State Pollution Prevention Programs.”

Society for Human Resources Management., 2004, “What Are The Components of a Successful Diversity Initiative?”

10.2307/1123737

10.2307/2096454

Tajfel Henri, 1979, The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations, 33

10.1093/sf/73.4.1385

10.2307/3033683

Thomas David A., 2001, Harvard Business Review, 99

10.2307/2392383

10.1177/000312240607100403

10.7591/9781501717505

10.1111/0019-8676.00210

U.S. Department of Labor., 2005, “Placement Goals. Code of Federal Regulations Pertaining to Employment Standards Administration, Title 41, Part 60-2 subpart B.”

10.1177/0730888403256454

Vernon-Gerstenfeld Susan, 1985, Personnel, 62, 54

Weber Max, 1978, Economy and Society, 1, 63

Wernick Ellen D., 1994, Preparedness, Career Advancement, and the Glass Ceiling.

10.2307/3088944

Williams Joan, 2000, Unbending Gender: Why Family Work Conflict and What to Do about It?

Williams Katherine Y., 1998, Research in Organizational Behavior, 20, 77

10.1177/0049124194023002004

Winterle Mary J., 1992, Work Force Diversity: Corporate Challenges, Corporate Responses.

10.1080/01621459.1962.10480664