Aristotle and the Management Consultants: Shooting for Ethical Practice

Philosophy of Management - 2020
David Shaw1
1Queen Mary University of London, London, UK

Tóm tắt

AbstractThe academic literature on management consulting raises many questions about the ethics of management consulting. The uncertain, emergent, and often socially constructed nature of management consultancy knowledge limits the scope both for regulating the industry in the manner of the established professions, and for evaluating management consultants’ work objectively. The character of management consultants is therefore a central issue in how far clients and other stakeholders can trust them. This paper considers three questions, using Aristotle’sNicomachean Ethicsas a guide. These are, first, ‘What is the function of a management consultant?’, second, ‘How should a management consultant act in order to be a good management consultant?’, and third, ‘Where does the boundary lie between the ethical responsibilities of the management consultant and those of the client and other stakeholders?’ Aristotelian virtue ethics are valuable in answering these questions. Their focus on character is well suited to the distinct ethical problems of management consulting. Aristotle’s overarching concern with human flourishing, and an ethically balanced approach towards benefiting from the good things to which a virtuous person may aspire, has more promise as an influence on consultants’ behaviour than the lists of prohibitions that typify codes of ethical practice in the industry. Aristotle’s call for leaders to habituate their people to ethical behaviour should be heard by the leaders of management consultancy firms. In accordance with Aristotle’s philosophy, this paper proposes a positive target at which management consultants can aim in shooting for ethical practice.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Ackrill, J.L. (1974), “Aristotle on Eudaimonia”, Dawes Hicks lecture on philosophy, available from www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk/pubs/proc/files/60p339.pdf?_ga=2.137930483.250982088.1558022202-1148893669.1557328753, accessed on 16 November 2019.

Allen, J., and D. Davis. 1993. Assessing some determinant effects of ethical consulting behaviour: The case of personal and professional values. Journal of Business Ethics 12 (6): 449–458.

Alvesson, M. 2000. Social identity and the problem of loyalty in knowledge-intensive companies. Journal of Management Studies 37 (8): 1101–1123.

Alvesson, M., and A.W. Johansson. 2002. Professionalism and politics in management consultancy work. In Critical consulting: New perspectives on the management advice industry, ed. T. Clark and R. Fincham, 228–246. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers Ltd.

Alvesson, M., and D. Kärreman. 2004. Interfaces of control: Technocratic and socio-ideological control in a global management consultancy firm. Accounting Organisations and Society 29 (2–3): 423–444.

Alvesson, M., and M. Robertson. 2006. The best and the brightest: The construction, significance and effects of elite identities in consulting firms. Organisation 13 (2): 195–224.

Alvesson, M., D. Kärreman, A. Sturdy, and K. Handley. 2009. Unpacking the client(s): Constructions, positions and client-consultant dynamics. Scandinavian Journal of Management 25: 253–263.

Appelbaum, S.H., and A.J. Steed. 2005. The critical success factors in the client-consulting relationship. Journal of Management Development 24 (1): 68–93.

Aristotle (1934), Nicomachean Ethics, Trans. Rackham, H., Cambridge Mass: Harvard University Press.

Bloch, B. 1998. How they put the ‘con’ in consulting. Managerial Auditing Journal 14 (3): 115–118.

Briner, R.B., D. Denyer, and D.M. Rousseau. 2009. Evidence-based management: Concept cleanup time? Academy of Management Perspectives 23 (4): 19–32.

Bronnenmayer, M., and B.W. Wirtz. 2016. Determinants of perceived success in management consulting: An empirical investigation. Management Research Review 39 (6): 707–738.

Brown, L. 1997. What is ‘the mean relative to us’ in Aristotle’s ethics? Phronesis 42 (1): 77–93.

Carroll, M., and E. Shaw. 2013. Ethical maturity in the helping professions: Making difficult life and work decisions. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

Chelliah, J., and D. Davis. 2010. But do you like your (expensive management) consultant? Journal of Business Strategy 31 (2): 34–42.

Clark, T., and G. Salaman. 1998. Creating the ‘right’ impression: Towards a dramaturgy of management consultancy. The Services Industries Journal 18 (1): 18–38.

Clegg, S.R., M. Kornberger, and C. Rhodes. 2004. Noise, parasites and translation: Theory and practice in management consulting. Management Learning 35 (1): 31–44.

Czarniawska, B., and C. Mazza. 2003. Consulting as a liminal space. Human Relations 56 (3): 267–290.

De Wit, A. 1988. Measurement of project success. Project Management 6 (3): 164–170.

Exton, W. 1982. Ethical and moral considerations and the principle of excellence in management consulting. Journal of Business Ethics 1 (3): 211–212.

Fincham, R. 1999. The consultant-client relationship: Critical perspectives on the Management of Organisational Change. Journal of Management Studies 36 (3): 335–351.

Furusten, S. 2013. Commercialised professionalism on the field of management consulting. Journal of Organisational Change Management 26 (2): 265–285.

Glückler, J., and T. Ambrüster. 2003. Bridging uncertainty in management consulting: The mechanisms of trust and networked reputation. Organisation Studies 24 (2): 269–297.

Greiner, L., and I. Ennsfellner. 2010. Management consultants as professionals, or are they? Organisational Dynamics 39 (1): 72–83.

Hagenmeyer, U. 2007. Integrity in management consulting: A contradiction in terms? Business Ethics: A European Review 16 (2): 107–113.

Hansen, M.T., N. Nohria, and T. Tierney. 1999. What’s your strategy for managing knowledge. Harvard Business Review 77 (2): 106–116.

Harvey, W., T. Morris, and M. Müller Santos. 2017. Reputation and identity conflict in management consulting. Human Relations 70 (1): 92–118.

Hursthouse, R. (1980–81) A false doctrine of the mean. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, new series, Vol. 81, pp. 57-72.

Irwin, T.H. 1975. Aristotle on reason, desire, and virtue. The Journal of Philosophy 72 (17): 567–578.

Kaptein, M. 2017. When organisations are too good: Applying Aristotle’s doctrine of the mean to the corporate ethical virtues model. Business Ethics: A European Review, Vol. 26 3: 300–311.

Kieser, A., and L. Leiner. 2009. Why the rigour-relevance gap in management research is unbridgeable. Journal of Management Studies 46 (3): 516–533.

Kipping, M., and T. Clark. 2012. Researching management consulting: An introduction to the handbook. In Kipping, M, ed. T. Clark, 1–26. Oxford University Press: The Oxford Handbook of Management Consulting.

Kirkpatrick, I., D. Muzio, and S. Ackroyd. 2012. Professions and professionalism in management consulting. In Kipping, M, ed. T. Clark, 187–206. Oxford University Press: The Oxford Handbook of Management Consulting.

Kitay, J., and C. Wright. 2004. Take the money and run? Organisational boundaries and consultants’ roles. The Services Industries Journal 24 (3): 1–18.

Koehn, G. 2012. The archer and Aristotle’s doctrine of the mean. Peitho/Examina Antiqua 1 (3): 155–167.

Lalonde, C., and M. Gilbert. 2016. Dramaturgical awareness of consultants through the rhetoric and rituals of cooperation. Journal of Organisational Change Management 29 (4): 630–656.

Losin, P. 1987. Aristotle's doctrine of the mean. History of Philosophy Quarterly 4 (3): 329–341.

Maister, D.H. 1993. Managing the professional service firm. New York: Free Press.

Molloy, E., and R. Whittington. 2005. Practices of organising: Inside and outside the processes of change. Strategy Process 22: 491–515.

Moss, J. 2011. "virtue makes the goal right": Virtue and "Phronesis" in Aristotle's ethics. Phronesis 56 (3): 204–261.

Nikolova, N., M. Reihlen, and J. Schlapfner. 2009. Client-consultant interaction: Capturing social practices of professional service production. Scandinavian Journal of Management 25: 289–298.

Nikolova, N., G. Möllering, and M. Reihlen. 2015. Trusting as a ‘leap of faith’: Trust-building practices in client-consultant relationships. Scandinavian Journal of Management 31 (2): 232–245.

O’Mahoney, J. 2011. Advisory anxieties: Ethical individualisation in the UK consulting industry. Journal of Business Ethics 104 (1): 101–113.

O’Mahoney, J., and C. Markham. 2013. Management consultancy (2nd edition). Oxford: University Press.

Pellegrino, E.D. 1989. Character, virtue and self-interest in the ethics of the professions. Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy 5 (1): 53–73.

Pellegrino, E.D. 1995. Toward a virtue-based normative ethics for the health professions. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 5 (3): 253–277.

Pellegrino, E.D. 2002. Professionalism, profession and the virtues of the good physician. The Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine 69 (6): 378–384.

Pettigrew, A.M. 2012. Context and action in the transformation of the firm: A reprise. Journal of Management Studies 49 (7): 1304–1328.

Poulfelt, F. 1997. Ethics for management consultants. Business Ethics: A European Review 6 (2): 65–71.

Provis, C. 2010. The ethics of impression management. Business Ethics: A European Review 19 (2): 200–2012.

Russell, B. 1967. A history of Western philosophy. New York: Simon and Schuster.

Schein, E.H. 1988. Process consultation: Its role in organisation development (second edition). Reading, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley.

Schein, E. 1997. The concept of “client” from a process consultation perspective: A guide for change agents. Journal of Organisational Change Management 10 (3): 202–216.

Solomon, R.C. 1992. Corporate roles, personal virtues: An Aristotelean approach to business ethics. Business Ethics Quarterly 2 (3): 317–339.

Sturdy, A. 1997. The consultancy process – An insecure business. Journal of Management Studies 34 (3): 389–413.

Sturdy, A., M. Schwarz, and A. Spicer. 2006. Guess who’s coming to dinner? Structures and uses of liminality in strategic management consultancy. Human Relations 59 (7): 929–960.

Sturdy, A., T. Clark, R. Fincham, and K. Handley. 2009. Between innovation and legitimation – Boundaries and knowledge flow in management consultancy. Organisation 16 (5): 627–653.

Urmson, J.O. 1973. Aristotle's doctrine of the mean. American Philosophical Quarterly 10 (3): 223–230.

Visscher, K. 2006. Capturing the competence of management consulting work. Journal of Workplace Learning 18 (4): 248–260.

Werr, A., and F. Pemer. 2007. Purchasing management consulting services — From management autonomy to purchasing involvement. Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management 13: 98–112.

Werr, A., and T. Stjernberg. 2003. Exploring management consulting firms as knowledge systems. Organisation Studies 24 (6): 881–908.

Werr, A., and A. Styhre. 2003. Management consultants – Friend or foe? Understanding the ambiguous client-consultant relationship. International Studies of Management and Organisation 32 (4): 43–66.

Werr, A., T. Stjernberg, and P. Docherty. 1997. The functions of methods of change in management consulting. Journal of Organisational Change Management 10 (4): 288–307.

Whipp, R., R. Rosenfeld, and A.M. Pettigrew. 1989. Culture & Competitiveness: Evidence from mature UK industries. Journal of Management Studies 26 (6): 561–586.

Wiggins, D. (1975–76) Deliberation and Practical Reason. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Vol. 76, pp. 29–51.

Williams, B. 1981. Moral luck: Philosophical papers 1973–1980. Cambridge: University Press.

Wright, C., and J. Kitay. 2002. ‘But does it work?’ Perceptions of the impact of management consulting. Strategic Change 11 (5): 271–278.

Wright, C., A. Sturdy, and N. Wylie. 2012. Management innovation through standardisation: Consultants as standardisers of organisational practice. Research Policy 41: 652–662.

Young, C.M. 1988. Aristotle on justice. The Southern Journal of Philosophy 27 (S1): 233–249.

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

Philosophy of Management

Thông tin tác giả