Antinomies of community: some thoughts on geography, resources and empire

Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers - Tập 29 Số 2 - Trang 195-216 - 2004
Michael Watts1
1University of California, Berkeley

Tóm tắt

Community is a fundamental modality for the conduct of modern politics. This paper explores the antinomies of community in an oil nation: Nigeria. Oil states stand in relation to a particular sort of capitalism (what I call petro‐capitalism) in which a key resource (petroleum) and a logic of extraction figure centrally in the making and breaking of community. I pose the following questions: how are communities imagined (or not), territorialized (or not), identified (or not) and ruled (or not) at a multiplicity of scales and in relation to a particular natural resource, namely oil? Each community is imagined, so to say, through and with oil – the communities are ‘naturalized’ in relation to the effects, social, environmental, political, of oil exploration and production – but produces forms of rule and identity that are often fragmented, unruly and violent. The communities I address are, in a sense, all oil‐producing communities but of rather different qualities: namely, the chieftainship as a local form of customary community rule at the level of the village; the ethnic or indigenous community at the level of the region; and the nation, or more properly the nation‐state known as Nigeria. And standing at the heart of each community is a fundamental contradiction. Nigerian petro‐capitalism operates through a particular sort of ‘oil complex’ (a configuration of firm, state and community) that generates or refigures differing sorts of community, what I shall refer to as governable spaces, in which differing sorts of identities, forms of rule and territory come into play. These sorts of community emerge from oil extraction, but the dynamics of petro‐capitalism and the oil complex contribute to, and are constitutive of, a deep crisis of secular nationalist development. Imperial oil and its concessionary political economy can be read as a sort of enclosure or dispossession and it is out of this development crisis in Nigeria that particular senses of community are being constituted – with and through oil.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Achebe C, 1987, Anthills of the savannas

AhmedEandSinghR2003Political economy of revenue sharing in a developing country Working paper 03/16 International Monetary Fund Washington DC March

Alagoa M, 2001, The report of the Nembe peace and reconciliation committee

Al‐Azmeh A, 1996, Islams and modernities

Al‐Azmeh A, 2003, Socialist register, 28

10.4324/9780203451557

10.1093/0195139690.001.0001

Anderson B, 1983, Imagined communities

Anderson B, 1998, Spectres of comparisons, 29

Anderson J, 2000, Blood and oil, The New Yorker, 14, 46

Anderson P, 2001, Scurrying towards Bethlehem, New Left Review, 10, 5

Anderson P, 2002, Force and consent, New Left Review, 17, 5

Archibugi D, 1998, Reimagining political community

Balibar E, 1991, Race, nation, class, 45

Bardhan P, 1997, The role of governance in economic development

Bender T, 1978, Community and social change in America

Berlant L, 1991, The anatomy of national fantasy

Berman M, 1982, All that is solid melts into air

Blok A, 1974, The Mafia in a Sicilian village

Buck Morss S, 2003, Thinking beyond terror

BurawoyM2004For a sociological Marxism Unpublished manuscript University of California Berkeley

Central Bank of Nigeria19902002Annual Report various Federal Government of Nigeria Lagos

Chatterjee P, 2004, The politics of the governed

Christian Aid, 2002, Fuelling poverty

Clifford M, 1999, Political genealogy after Foucault

Collier P, 2003, Breaking the conflict trap

Coronil F, 1997, The magic of the state

DiMaggio P, 1994, Structures of capital: the social organization of the economy

Douglas O, 2001, Where vultures feast

Durkheim E, 1893, The division of labor in society

ERA, 2000, The Emperor has no clothes

Escobar E, 1995, Encountering development

Forrest T, 1995, Politics and economic development in Nigeria

10.1086/448181

Foucault M, 1984, The Foucault reader

Foucault M, 1988, Technologies of the self, 23

Foucault M, 2000, Power

Fraser N, 2003, Redistribition or recognition?

Frynas G, 2000, Oil in Nigeria

Furro T, 1992, Federalism and the politics of revenue allocation in Nigeria PhD dissertation

Gary I, 2003, Bottom of the barrel

Global Witness, 2002, Resources conflict and corruption

Gordon G, 1980, Knowledge/power

Granovetter M, 2001, Economic sociology at the millennium, 134

Habermas J, 1987, The philosophical discourse of modernity

HammerJ1996Nigerian crudeHarpers MagazineJune58–68

Hart G, 2003, Disabling globalization

Harvey D, 1987, The urban experience

10.1093/oso/9780199264315.001.0001

Human Rights Watch, 1999, The price of oil

Human Rights Watch, 2002, Testing democracy

Ikein A, 1990, The impact of oil on a developing country

IMF, 2003, Nigeria: selected issues and statistical appendix Country report 03/60

Jacquard R, 2002, In the name of Osama Bin Laden

Joseph M, 2002, Against the romance of community

Joyce P, 2003, The rule of freedom

Kapucinski R, 1982, The shah of shahs

10.1525/9780520918696

Keane J, 1998, Civil society

Kelly J, 2001, Represented communities

KemediV2000 Oil on troubled waters Environmental politics working papers Berkeley

Khan S, 1994, Nigeria: the political economy of oil

Klare M, 2001, Resource wars

Lasch C, 1991, The true and only heaven

Lash S, 1994, Another modernity a different rationality

10.1111/j.1467-7660.1996.tb00601.x

10.1017/CBO9780511815447

Lubeck P, 2001, Global social movements, 78

Mamdani M, 1996, Citizen and subject

Mamdani M, 1998, When does a settler become a native? Inaugural lecture

Mamdani M, 2004, Good Muslim, bad Muslim

MartinSandSubramanianA2003Addressing the resource curse: an illustration from Nigeria Working paper IMF Washington DC July

10.1215/08992363-12-1-259

Mertes T, 2003, Movement of movements

10.1525/9780520928251

Munif A, 1989, Cities of salt

Munif A, 1993, The trench

Munif A, 1993, Variations on night and day

10.1080/14662049508447695

Nairn T, 1997, Faces of nationalism

Nelson D, 1999, A finger in the wound, 10.1525/9780520920606

Niethammer L, 2003, The infancy of Tarzan, New Left Review, 19, 79

Obi C, 2001, The changing forms of identity politics in Nigeria

Ogoni Crisis, 1996, Lagos

Okilo M, 1980, Derivation: a criterion of revenue allocation

Okonta I, 2002, The struggle of the Ogoni for self‐determination DPhil

Okpu U, 1977, Ethnic minority problems in Nigerian politics

Oldfield A, 1990, Citizenship and community

Osaghae E, 1995, The Ogoni uprising, African Affairs, 94, 325, 10.1093/oxfordjournals.afraf.a098833

OXFAM, 2001, The extractive sector and the poor

Painter D, 1986, Oil and the American century

PandeyG2003Some notes on the modern political community Paper presented to the School of American Research Santa Fe Workshop on ‘The romance of community’ April 2003

Polanyi K, 1945, The origins of our time

Poulantzas N, 1978, State, power, socialism

10.1145/358916.361990

Renner M, 2002, The anatomy of resource wars

RodrikD2003Growth strategies NBER working paper 10050 October NBER Cambridge MA (http://www.nber.org/papers/w10050) Accessed 12 January 2004

10.1017/CBO9780511488856

10.1353/wp.2001.0011

Roy O, 1994, The failure of political Islam

Rutherford J, 1990, Community, culture, difference

Ruthven M, 2003, The fury of God

10.3386/w9804

Saro‐Wiwa K, 1992, Genocide in Nigeria

10.1177/0038038502036003009

Sennett R, 1998, The corrosion of character

Steyn M, 2003, Oil politics in Ecuador and Nigeria PhD dissertation University of the Free State

StorperM2004Society community and economic development Unpublished manuscript School of Public Policy UCLA

Taylor C, 1989, Sources of the self

Thompson J, 1998, Reimagining political community, 179

Tonnies F, 1887, Community and society

WalzerM1991The idea of civil societyDissentOctober23–37

Watts M, 1985, Money, power and space, 406

Watts M, 1998, Cities and citizenship, 67

Watts M, 2000, Struggles over geography Hettner lectures University of Heidelberg

Williams R, 1973, Keywords

Yergin D, 1991, The prize

Young I, 1990, Feminism/postmodernism, 300

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers

Tập 29 Số 2

195-216

Thông tin tác giả