Addressing ‘deep’ uncertainty over long-term climate in major infrastructure projects: four innovations of the Thames Estuary 2100 Project
Tóm tắt
Climate change brings new challenges for traditional environmental risk management, particularly for major infrastructure projects, where the decisions made today can have long-term implications. A major challenge is that projections of future climate are deeply uncertain. If this uncertainty is not managed appropriately, long-lived infrastructure may need to be replaced or expensively retrofitted before the end of the design lifetime. The Thames Estuary 2100 Project (TE2100) was one of the first major infrastructure projects to explicitly recognise and address the issue of the deep uncertainty in climate projections throughout the planning process. In this paper, we discuss the innovations and techniques that were adopted in this case that enabled it to cope with this uncertainty. We classify the overall approach as ‘dynamic robustness’, which aims to build flexible strategies that can be changed over time as more is learnt or as conditions change. The project combined four key innovations: (1) the ‘decision-centric’ process; (2) the combination of numerical models and expert judgement to develop narrative sea level rise scenarios; (3) the adoption of an ‘Adaptation Pathways’ approach to identify the timing and sequencing of possible ‘pathways’ of adaptation measures over time under different scenarios; and (4) the development of a monitoring framework that triggers defined decision points. A secondary focus of this paper is an exploration of how climate information was used in TE2100. We suggest that the techniques employed in TE2100 imply different needs from climate science that may cause them to redefine their research priorities related to adaptation; namely a shift in emphasis away from probabilistic modelling, toward greater investment in observations and monitoring; improved understanding of historical climate variability; and improved understanding of physical Earth system processes and their representation in models to enhance ‘best guess’ models and to better bound future projections using narrative scenarios.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Brown C, Werick W, Leger W et al (2011) A decision-analytic approach to managing climate risks: application to the Upper Great Lakes. J Am Water Resour Assoc 47:524–534
Brown C, Ghile Y, Laverty M, Li K (2012) Decision-scaling: linking bottom-up vulnerability analysis with climate projections in the water sector. Water Resour Res 48:W09537. doi:10.1029/2011WR011212
Carter TR, Jones RN, Lu X, Bhadwal S, Conde C, Mearns LO, O’Neill BC, Rounsevell MDA, Zurek MB (2007) New assessment methods and the characterisation of future conditions. Climate change (2007) impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. In: Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE (eds) Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 133–171
Cox P, Stephenson D (2007) A changing climate for prediction. Science 317:207–208. doi:10.1126/science.1145956
Defra (2006) Flood and coastal defence appraisal guidance, FCDPAG3 economic appraisal Supplementary Note to Operating Authorities –Authorities, Climate Change Impacts. October 2006
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (2006) Flood and Coastal Defence Appraisal Guidance, FCDPAG3 Economic Appraisal Supplementary Note to Operating Authorities, Climate Change Impacts. October 2006. http://archive.defra.gov.uk/environment/flooding/documents/policy/guidance/fcdpag/fcd3climate.pdf
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (2012) UK Climate Change Risk Assessment. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-climate-change-risk-assessment-government-report
Dessai S, Hulme M (2007) Assessing the robustness of adaptation decisions to climate change uncertainties: a case study on water resources management in the East of England. Global Environ Chang 17(1):59–72
Dessai S, van der Sluijs J (2007) Uncertainty and climate change adaptation—a scoping study. Report NWS-E-2007-198, ISBN 978-90-8672-025-5
Dessai S, Hulme M, Lempert R, Pielke R, Jr. (2009) Climate prediction: a limit to adaptation? In: Adapting to climate change: thresholds, values, governance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Dewar J, Builder C, Hix W, Levin M (1993) Assumption-based planning: a planning tool for very uncertain times. RAND Corporation, Santa Monica
Environment Agency (2009) TE2100 Technical Report. Environment Agency, Bristol (due to be updated in 2013)
Environment Agency (2010) Flood and coastal erosion risk management appraisal guidance (FCERM-AG). Environment Agency, UK
Environment Agency (2012a) Thames Estuary 2100: managing risks through London and the Thames Estuary. TE2100 Plan; 2012. https://brand.environment-agency.gov.uk/mb/CtyxlR
Environment Agency (2012b) TE2100 strategic environmental assessment (SEA) statement of environmental particulars; 2012. http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/static/documents/Research/SE_TE2100_environmentalparticulars.pdf
Evans E, Ashley R, Hall J, Penning-Rowsell E, Sayers P, Thorne C, Watkinson A (2004) Foresight. Future flooding. Scientific summary: managing future risks, vol II. Office of Science and Technology, London
Fankhauser S, Smith J, Tol R (1999) Weathering climate change: some simple rules to guide adaptation decisions. Ecol Econ 30
Füssel H-M (2007) Vulnerability: a general applicable conceptual framework for climate change research. Global Environ Change 17:155–167
Gilboa I, Postlewaite A, Schmeidler D (2009) Is it always rational to satisfy savage’s axioms? Econ Philos 25:285–296
Gregory R, Failing L, Harstone M, Long G, McDaniels T, Ohlson D (2012) Structured decision making: a practical guide to environmental management choices. Wiley-Blackwell, Chichester
Groves DG, Yates D, Tebaldi C, (2008) Developing and applying uncertain global climate change projections for regional water management planning. Water Resour Res 44 (W12413). doi:10.1029/2008WR006964
Groves DG, Lempert RJ, Knopman D, Berry SH (2008b) Preparing for an uncertain future climate in the inland empire: identifying robust water-management strategies. RAND Corporation, Santa Monica
Haasnoot M, Middelkoop H, Offermans A, van Beek E, van Deursen WPA (2012) Exploring pathways for sustainable water management in river deltas in a changing environment. Clim Change 115:795–819. doi:10.1007/s10584-012-0444-2
Haasnoot M, Kwakkel JH, Walker WE, ter Maat J (2013) Dynamic adaptive policy pathways: a method for crafting robust decisions for a deeply uncertain world. Global Environ Change 23:485–498. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2012.12.006
Hall JW (2007) Probabilistic climate scenarios may misrepresent uncertainty and lead to bad adaptation decisions. Hydrol Process 21(8):1127–1129
Hallegatte S (2009) Strategies to adapt to an uncertain climate change. Global Environ Chang 19:2040–2047. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2008.12.003
Hawkins E, Sutton R (2009) The potential to narrow uncertainty in regional climate predictions. Bull Am Meteorol Soc. doi:10.1175/2009BAMS2607.1
HM Treasury (2003) Appraisal and evaluation in central government—the “Green Book”. HMSO London
HM Treasury (2011) National Infrastructure Plan 2011. http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/d/national_infrastructure_plan291111.pdf
HM Treasury and Defra (2009) Accounting for the effects of climate change: supplementary green book guidance. http://archive.defra.gov.uk/environment/climate/documents/adaptation-guidance.pdf
Jones RN (2000) Managing uncertainty in climate change projections: issues for impact assessment. Clim Change 45:403–419. doi:10.1023/A:1005551626280
Keeney RL (1982) Decision analysis: an overview. Oper Res 30(5):803–838
Keeney RL (1996) Value-focussed thinking: identifying decision opportunities and creating alternatives. Eur J Oper Res 92:537–549
Knight FH (1921) Risk, uncertainty, and profit. Hart, Schaffner & Marx; Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston
Knutti R, Abramowitz G, Collins M, Eyring V, Glecker PJ, Hewitson B, Mearns L (2010) In: Stocker T, Dahe Q, Plattner G-K, Tignor M, Midgley P (eds) Good practice guidance paper on assessing and combining multi model climate projections. Report of the IPCC Expert Meeting on Assessing and Combining Multi Model Climate Projections. http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/supporting-material/IPCC_EM_MME_GoodPracticeGuidancePaper.pdf
Kwadijk JCJ, Haasnoot M, Mulder JPM, Hoogvliet MMC, Jeuken ABM, van der Krogt RAA, van Oostrom NGC, Schelfhout HA, van Velzen EH, van Waveren H, de Wit MJM (2010) Using adaptation tipping points to prepare for climate change and sea level rise, a case study for in the Netherlands. Wiley Interdiscipl Rev. doi:10.1002/wcc.64
Kwakkel JH, Walker WE, Marchau VAWJ (2010) Adaptive airport strategic planning. Eur J Infrastruct Res 10:227–250
Lempert RJ, Schlesinger ME (2000) Robust strategies for abating climate change. Clim Change 45:387–401. doi:10.1023/a:1005698407365
Lempert RJ, Popper SW, Bankes SC (2003) Shaping the next one hundred years: new methods for quantitative. Long-term policy analysis. RAND, Santa Monica
Lempert RJ, Groves D, Popper S, Bankes S (2006) A general, analytic method for generating robust strategies and narrative scenarios. Manage Sci 52:514–528
Lowe JA, Howard TP, Pardaens A, Tinker J, Holt J, Wakelin S, Milne G, Leake J, Wolf J, Horsburgh K, Reeder T, Jenkins G, Ridley J, Dye S, Bradley S (2009) UK climate projections science report: marine and coastal projections. Met Office Hadley Centre, Exeter
Marchau VAWJ, Walker WE, van Duin R (2008) An adaptive approach to implementing innovative urban transport solutions. Transp Policy 15:405–412
Masson D, Knutti R (2011) Climate model genealogy. Geophys Res Lett 38(8):L08703. doi:10.1029/2011GL046864
Meehl GA, Stocker TF, Collins WD, Friedlingstein P, Gaye AT, Gregory JM, Kitoh A, Knutti R, Murphy JM, Noda A, Raper SCB, Watterson IG, Weaver AJ, Zhao Z-C (2007) Global climate projections. In: Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M, Chen Z, Marquis M, Averyt KB, Tignor M, Miller HL (eds) Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (1999). Flood and coastal defence project appraisal guidance: economic appraisal (FCDPAG3)
Morgan MG (2003) Characterizing and dealing with uncertainty: insights from the integrated assessment of climate change. Integrat Assess 4(1):46–55
Morgan MG, Kandlikar M, Risbey J, Dowlatabadi H (1999) Why conventional tools for policy analysis are often inadequate for problems of global change: an editorial essay. Clim Change 41:271–281
Murphy JM et al (2004) Quantification of modelling uncertainties in a large ensemble of climate change simulations. Nature 429:768–772
Murphy JM, Sexton DMH, Jenkins GJ, Boorman PM, Booth BBB, Brown CC, Clark RT, Collins M, Harris GR, Kendon EJ, Betts RA, Brown SJ, Howard TP, Humphrey KA, McCarthy MP, McDonald RE, Stephens A, Wallace C, Warren R, Wilby R, Wood RA (2009) UK climate projections science report: climate change projections. Met Office Hadley Centre, Exeter
Nicholls RJ, Lowe JA (2004) Benefits of mitigation of climate change for coastal areas. Glob Environ Chang 14(3):229–244. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2004.04.005
Oreskes N, Stainforth D, Smith L (2010) Adaptation to global warming: do climate models tell us what we need to know? Philos Sci 77(5):1012–1028
Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE (eds) (2007) Climate change 2007: impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Parson EA (2008) Useful global change scenarios: current issues and challenges. Environ Res Lett 3:045016. doi:10.1088/1748-9326/3/4/045016
Penning-Rowsell EC, Haigh N, Lavery S, McFadden L (2013) A threatened world city: the benefits of protecting London from the sea. Nat Hazards 66:1383–1404. doi:10.1007/s11069-011-0075-3
Pielke RA Sr, Wilby R, Niyogi D, Hossain F, Dairuku K, Adegoke J, Kallos G, Seastedt T, Suding K (2012) Dealing with complexity and extreme events using a bottom-up, resource-based vulnerability perspective. Extreme events and natural hazards: the complexity perspective. Geophys Monogr Series 196. doi:10.1029/2011GM001086
Randall DA, Wood RA, Bony S, Colman R, Fichefet T, Fyfe J, Kattsov V, Pitman A, Shukla J, Srinivasan J, Stouffer RJ, Sumi A, Taylor KE (2007) Climate models and their evaluation. In: Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M, Chen Z, Marquis M, Averyt KB, Tignor M, Miller HL (eds) Climate change. The physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ranger N, Garbett-Shiels S-L (2012) Accounting for a changing and uncertain climate in planning and policymaking today: lessons for developing countries. Clim Dev. doi:10.1080/17565529.2012.732919
Ranger N, Niehorster F (2012) Deep uncertainty in long-term hurricane risk: scenario generation and implications for future climate experiments. Global Environ Change. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2012.03.009
Ranger N, Millner A, Dietz S, Fankhauser S, Lopez A, Ruta G (2010) Adaptation in the UK: a decision making process. Grantham/CCCEP Policy Brief
Ranger N, Hallegatte S, Bhattacharya S, Bachu M, Priya S, Dhore K, Rafique F, Mathur P, Naville N, Henriet F, Herweijer C, Pohit S, Corfee-Morlot J (2011) A preliminary assessment of the potential impact of climate change on flood risk in Mumbai. Clim Change 104:139–167
Reeder T, Wicks J, Lovell L, Tarrant T (2009) Protecting London from tidal flooding: limits to engineering adaptation. In: Adapting to climate change: thresholds, values, governance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Rosenzweig C et al (2010) Climate change adaptation in New York city: building a risk management response. Ann N Y Acad Sci. ISSN 0077-8923
Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M, Chen Z, Marquis M, Averyt KB, Tignor M, Miller HL (eds) (2007) Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Solomon S, Plattner G-K, Knutti R, Friedlingstein P (2009) Irreversible climate change due to carbon dioxide emissions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106:1704–1709
Stainforth D, Downing TE, Washington R, Lopez A, New M (2007) Issues in the interpretation of climate model ensembles to inform decisions. Philos Trans R Soc A 365:2163–2177
Stern N (2007) The economics of climate change: the stern review. Cambridge University Press, UK
United Kingdom Climate Impacts Programme (UKCIP) (2006) Expressed preferences for the next package of UK climate change information: Final report on the user consultation. http://www.ukcip.org.uk/wordpress/wp-content/PDFs/Users_panel/user_consultation_report_v5.pdf
Van der Heijden K (2005) Scenarios: the art of strategic conversation, 2nd edn. Wiley, Chichester
Walker WE, Rahman SA, Cave J (2001) Adaptive policies, policy analysis and policymaking. Eur J Oper Res 128:282–289
Walker WE, Haasnoot M, Kwakkel JH (2013) Adapt or perish: a review of planning approaches for adaptation under deep uncertainty. Sustainability 5:955–979. doi:10.3390/su5030955
Whetton P, Hennessy K, Clarke J, McInnes K, Kent D (2012) Use of representative climate futures in impact and adaptation assessment. Clim Change 115:433–442
Wilby RL, Dessai S (2010) Robust adaptation to climate change. Weather 65:180–185
Wilby RL, Troni J, Biot Y, Tedd L, Hewitson BC, Smith DG, Sutton RT (2009) A review of climate risk information for adaptation and development planning. Int J Climatol 29:1193–1215
Wilby RL, Nicholls RJ, Warren R, Wheater HS, Clarke D, Dawson RJ (2011) Keeping nuclear and other coastal sites safe from climate change. Proc Inst Civil Eng Civil Eng 164:129–136
Williams BK, Brown ED (2012) Adaptive management: the U.S. Department of the Interior Applications Guide. U.S. Department of the Interior, Washington, DC
Willows RI, Connell RK (eds) (2003) Climate adaptation: risk, uncertainty and decision-making: UKCIP Technical Report. UKCIP, Oxford
World Meteorological Organisation (2012) Draft of the implementation plan of the Global Framework for Climate Services (GFCS); 2012. http://www.wmo.int/pages/gfcs/documents/2012.09.07GFCSImplementationPlan_FinalOrder.pdf
Yohe G (1990) Imbedding dynamic responses with imperfect information into static portraits of the regional impact of climate change. International Workshop on the Natural Resource and Economic Implications of Global Climate Change, Interlaken