Achieving the promise of transdisciplinarity: a critical exploration of the relationship between transdisciplinary research and societal problem solving

Sustainability Science - 2014
Merritt Polk1,2
1Mistra Urban Futures, Chalmers University of Technology, Göteborg, Sweden
2Human Ecology, School of Global Studies, The University of Gothenburg, Göteborg, Sweden

Tóm tắt

Transdisciplinarity is often presented as a way to effectively use scientific research to contribute to societal problem solving for sustainability. The aim of this paper is to critically explore this statement. This is done in two ways. First, a literature survey of transdisciplinary research is used to identify the assumptions that underlie the positive relationship between transdisciplinarity and societal problem solving for sustainability. This mapping identifies the claim that in-depth participation of users and the integration of relevant knowledge from both practice and research in real-world problem contexts produce socially robust results that contribute to sustainability. Second, the ability to live up to this claim is presented and discussed in five case study projects from Mistra Urban Futures, a transdisciplinary center in Göteborg, Sweden. The conclusions show that transdisciplinary processes, which fulfill the above conditions, do produce different types of socially robust knowledge, but this does not necessarily result in the ability to influence change in a sustainable direction. This instead creates a paradox in that the participation of stakeholders and the integration of knowledge from diverse sources require spaces that are both embedded in and insulated from practice and science proper. Such spaces produce results that are not easily aligned with sector-based target groups and formal policy processes. Institutionalizing transdisciplinarity in a boundary organization therefore solves some problems regarding participation and balanced problem ownership. However, it also creates new, hybrid problems, regarding knowledge transfer and scalability, which bridge the boundaries and challenge the praxis of planning and policy making.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Bammer G (2013) Disciplining interdisciplinarity: integration and implementation sciences for researching complex real-world problems. ANU e-press, Canberra

Bergmann M, Jahn T, Knobloch T, Krohn W, Pohl C, Schramm E (2012) Methods for transdisciplinary research: a primer for practice. Campus Verlag, Frankfurt

Billger M, Alfredsson K, Lindkvist J, Myren P, Clase K (2012) Urbana spel (Urban Games). Mistra Urban Futures working paper, Mistra Urban Futures, Göteborg, Sweden

Blackstock KL, Carter CE (2007) Operationalising sustainability science for a sustainability directive? Reflecting on three pilot projects. Geogr J 173(4):343–357

Blackstock KL, Kelly GJ, Horsey BL (2007) Devloping and applying a framework to evaluate participatory research for sustainbility. Ecol Econ 60:726–742

Castro C (2004) Sustainable development: mainstream and critical perspectives. Organ Environ 17(2):195–225

Earth Charter (2000) Values and principles for a sustainable future. Accessed on the web at: http://www.earthcharterinaction.org/content/pages/Read-the-Charter.html

Elias K, Forsemalm J, Gustafsson J, Johansson M, Lilled L, Montin S, Löf Y (2011) Governance: att styra med insikt snarare än avsikt. En studie om flernivåstyrning och sektorssamverkan i Göteborg och Malmö (Governance: to govern by insight instead of by intent, a study of multi-level governance and cross-sector collaboration in Göteborg and Malmö), Mistra Urban Futures Pilot Project Report, Mistra Urban Futures, Göteborg, Sweden

Eriksson E, Sandoff A, Värmby G, Rönnborg P, Jensen C, Molnar S, Bergstrand BO, Antonsson AB, Elias K, Kildsgaard I, Bolin L, Wolf C (2011) Affärsdriven hållbar stadsutveckling: Goda exempel och potential (Business driven sustainable urban development: good examples and potential). Mistra Urban Futures Policy Project Report, Mistra Urban Futures, Göteborg, Sweden

Frodeman R (ed) (2010) The Oxford handbook of interdisciplinarity. Oxford University Press, Oxford

Funtowicz S, Ravetz J (1993) Science for the post-normal age. Futures 25(7):739–755

Gibbons M, Limoges C, Nowotny H, Schwartzman S, Scott P, Trow M (1994) The new production of knowledge: the dynamics of science and research in contemporary society. Sage Publications, London

Healey P, de Magalhaes C, Madanipour A, Pendlebury J (2003) Place, identity and local politicis: analyzing initiatives in deliberative governance. In: Hajer M, Wagenaar H (eds) Deliberative policy analysis: understanding governance in the network society. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 60–87

Hellström T, Jacob M (2003) Boundary construction in science: from discourse to construction. Sci Public Policy 30(4):235–238

Hirsch Hadorn G, Hoffman-Reim H, Biber-Klemm S, Grossenbacher-Mansury W, Joye D, Pohl C, Wiesmann U, Zemp E (eds) (2008) Handbook of transdisciplinary research. Springer, Berne

Holden E (2007) Achieving sustainable mobility: everyday and leisure-time travel in the EU. Ashgate, Aldershot

Hopwood B, Mellor M, O’Brien G (2005) Sustainable development: mapping different approaches. Sustain Dev 13:38–52

Innes J, Booher D (2003) Collaborative policy making: governance through dialogue. In: Hajer M, Wagenaar H (eds) Deliberative policy analysis: understanding governance in the network society. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 33–59

Jacob M (1996) Sustainable development: a reconstructive critique of the United Nations debate. Department of Theory of Science and Research, Göteborgs University, Sweden

Kates RW, Parris TM, Leiserowitz AA (2005) What is sustainble development: goals, indicators, values and practice. Environment 47(3):9–21

Klein JT (2010) A taxonomy of interdisciplinarity. In: Frodeman R (ed) The Oxford handbook of interdisciplinarity. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 15–30

Klein JT, Grossenbacher-Mansuy W, Häberli R, Bill A, Scholz RW, Welti M (eds) (2001) Transdisciplinarity: joint problem solving among science, technology and society. Birkhäuser, Basel

Lang DJ, Wiek A, Bergmann M, Stauffacher M, Martens P, Moll P, Swilling M, Thomas CJ (2012) Transdisciplinary research in sustainability science: practice, principles and challenges. Sustain Sci 7(Supplement 1):25–43

Morrison G, Knutsson P, Buhr K, Thörn P, Moback U, Areslätt H (2012) Climate adaptation and sustainability strategies for a waterfront development, Mistra Urban Futures Working paper, Mistra Urban Futures, Göteborg, Sweden

Nowotny H, Scott P, Gibbons M (2001) Re-thinking science: knowledge and the public in an age of uncertainty. Polity Press, Cambridge

Owen S, Cowell R (2011) Land and limits: interpreting sustainability in the planning process, 2nd edn. Routledge, London

Parr A (2009) Hijacking sustainability. The MIT Press, London

Pohl C, Hirsch Hadorn G (2007) Principles for designing transdisciplinary research. Oekom, Munich

Pohl C, Rist S, Zimmermann A, Fry P, Gurung GS, Schneider F, Speranza CI, Kiteme B, Boillat S, Serrano E, Hadorn GH, Wiesmann U (2010) Researchers roles in knowledge co-production: experience from sustainability research in Kenya, Switzerland, Bolivia and Nepal. Sci Public Policy 37(4):267–281

Polk M (2010) Sustainability in practice: the interpretation of sustainable development in a regional planning arena for dialogue and learning in Western Sweden, Planning. Theory Pract 11(4):473–489

Polk M (2011) Institutional capacity building in urban planning and policy making for sustainable development: success or failure? Plan Pract Res 26(2):185–206

Polk M, Malbert B, JH Kain (2009) The Göteborg Center of excellence for sustainable urban futures, Göteborg, Mistra Center Application

Polk M, Kain JH, Holmberg J (2013) Mistra Urban Futures: a living laboratory for urban transformations in regenerative sustainable development of universities and cities. In: Ariane König (ed) The role of living laboratories, Chapter 9. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham

Redclift M (1987) Sustainable development: exploring the contradictions. Routledge, London

Robinson J (2008) Being undisciplined: transgressions and intersections in academia and beyond. Futures 40:70–86

Roth S, Thörn P, Buhr K, Moback U, Morrison G, Knutsson P, Areslätt H (2011) Frihamnen i ett förändrat klimat Klimatanpassningsstrategiers påverkan på hållbar utveckling (The influence of climate adaptation strategies on sustainable development) Mistra Urban Futures Pilot Project Report. Mistra Urban Futures, Göteborg

Scholz RW (2011) Environmental literacy in science and society. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

Spangenberg J (2011) Sustainability science: a review, an analysis and some empirical lessons. Environ Conserv 38(3):275–287

Stauffacher M, Flüeler T, Krütli P, Scholz RW (2008) Analytic and dynamic approach to collaboration: a transdisciplinary case study on sustainable landscape development in a Swiss prealpine region. Syst Pract Action Res 21:409–422

Stenberg J, Fryk L, Bolin E, Borg P, Castell P, Evenås U, Larberg V (2011) Urban empowerment: cultures of participation and learning. Mistra Urban Futures Working Paper, Mistra Urban Futures, Göteborg, Sweden

Stokols D, Hall KL, Moser MP, Feng A, Misra S, Taylor BK (2010) Cross-disciplinary team science initiatives: research, training, and translation. In: Frodeman R (ed) The Oxford handbook of interdisciplinarity. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 471–493

Tabàra J, Pahl-Wostl C (2007) Sustainability learning in natural resource use and management. Ecol Soc 12(2):3

Talwar S, Wiek A, Robinson J (2011) User engagement in sustainability research. Sci Public Policy 38(5):379–390

UNCED (1992) Agenda 21. United Nations conference on environment and development

Walter AI, Helgenberger S, Wiek A, Scholz RW (2007) Measuring societal effects of transdisciplinary research projects: design and application of an evaluation method. Eval Program Plan 30(4):325–338

WCED (World Commission on Environment and Development) (1987) Our common future. Oxford University Press, Oxford

Weingart P (2008) How robust is socially robust knowledge? In: Carrier M, Howard D, Kourany JA (eds) The challenge of the social and the pressure of practice. Science and values revisited. University of Pittsburg Press, Pittsburgh

Wiek A, Ness B, Schweizer-Ries P, Band FS, Farioli F (2012) From complex systems analysis to transformational change: a comparative appraisal of sustainability science projects. Sustain Sci 7(Supplement 1):5–24

Wiek A, Talwar S, O’Shea M, Robinson J (2014) Toward a methodological scheme for capturing societal effects of participatory sustainability research. Res Eval 23:1–16

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

Sustainability Science

Thông tin tác giả