Accuracy of hospital discharge data for cancer registration and epidemiological research in Northern Ireland
Tóm tắt
Background: Cancer registries provide a basis for many epidemiological studies in cancer. Electronic data provide for prompt, economical data capture for disease registries; doubts, however, exist about their data quality.
Materials and methods: We examined the accuracy for cancer registration of a subset of 7043 electronically captured hospital discharge data.
Results: Note availability was 82%. Of the notes available for examination demographic data accuracy was high; however, 7.4% of cases coded on discharge as cancer had no malignancy recorded in case notes while 4.1% had in-situ or benign tumors. Almost a third had some inaccuracy in coding tumor site. Prevalent cases accounted for 17.2% of cases examined reflecting a new registry. Electronic data capture reduces time spent examining notes; only 40% of cases notified from PAS required a quick validation check. It enhances data completeness; without electronic discharge data 11.5% of the final database would have been missed. The validation check prevented over-inflation of the cancer registration database by 7.5%. Measures of accuracy in the final database were high.
Conclusion: This study shows that discharge data are a valuable data source for cancer registries but require a targeted note review aimed at cases without corroborating data.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Black RJ, Simonato L, Storm HH, Démaret E (1998) Automated Data Collection in Cancer Registration. IARC Technical Report No. 32. Lyon: IARC.
Clarke EA, Marrett LD, Kreiger N (1991) Appendix 3 (c) Cancer registration in Ontario: a computer approach. In: Jensen OM, Parkin DM, Maclennan R, Muir CS, Skeet RG, eds. Cancer Registration: Principles and Methods. IARC Publication 95. Lyon: IARC, pp. 246–257.
Codling BW, Pheby D, Hagen DL, Duffin MF (1990) Cancer registration by linking of pathology and district PAS data. Br J Cancer 62: 271–274.
Simonato L, Zambon P, Rodella S, et al. (1996) A computerised cancer registration network in the Veneto region, north-east of Italy: a pilot study. Br J Cancer 73: 1436–1439.
Storm HH (1991) Appendix 3 (a) The Danish Cancer Registry, a self reporting national cancer registration system with elements of active data collection. In: Jensen OM, Parkin DM, Maclennan R, Muir CS, Skeet RG, eds. Cancer Registration: Principles and Methods. IARC Publication 95. Lyon: IARC, pp. 220–236.
Storm HH, Pihl J, Michelsen E, Nielsen AN (1996) Cancer Incidence in Denmark 1993. Copenhagen: Danish Cancer Society.
Rossi A, Vincenti P, Donato F, et al. (1998) Affidabilitá dei dati delle schede di dismissone ospedaliera e dei referti anatomo-patologici per la registrazone dei tumori nella popolazione. Ann Ig 10: 35–43.
Kendrick S, Clarke J (1993) The Scottish Record Linkage System. Health Bulletin 51: 72–79.
Gavin AT, Reid SJ (1999). Cancer Incidence in Northern Ireland 1993–95. HMSO; available on www.qub.ac.uk/nicr/intro.htm
Brewster D, Crichton J, Muir C (1994) How accurate are Scottish cancer registration data? Br J Cancer 70: 954–959.
Storm H, Clemmensen I, Black R (1998) Survey of Cancer Registries in the European Union. IARC Technical Report No. 28. Lyon: IARC.