A meta-analysis of comparative studies on Chinese and US students’ mathematics performance: Implications for mathematics education reform and research

Apple, 1992, Do the standards go far enough? Power, policy, and practice in mathematics education, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 23, 412, 10.2307/749562 Baker, 1997, Good news, bad news, and international comparison: Comment on Bracey, Educational Researcher, 26, 16 Ball, 1996, Reform by the book: What is—or might be—the role of curriculum materials in teacher learning and instructional reform?, Educational Researcher, 25, 6 Beaton, 1996 Bempechat, 1999, Cross-national differences in academic achievement: Beyond ectic conceptions of children's understandings, Review of Educational Research, 69, 287, 10.3102/00346543069003287 Benjamin, J. (2006). Cross-cultural comparison of rural education practice in China, Taiwan, and the United States. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL. Blair, 1998, Family and Asian students’ educational performance: A consideration of diversity, Journal of Family Issues, 19, 355, 10.1177/019251398019004001 Bolinger, R. W. (1992). The effect of socioeconomic levels and similar instruction on scholastic aptitude test scores of Asian, Black, Hispanic, and White students. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Midwestern Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL. Bracey, 1993, American students hold their own, Educational Leadership, 50, 65 Bracey, 1996, International comparisons and the condition of American education, Educational Researcher, 25, 5, 10.3102/0013189X025001005 Bracey, 1997, The Japanese education system is a failure, say some Japanese, Phi Delta Kappan, 79, 328 Bracey, 1997, Response: Good news, bad news, and international comparisons: Comment on Bracey, Educational Researcher, 26, 19, 10.2307/1176434 Bracey, 1999, The demise of the Asian math gene, Phi Delta Kappan, 80, 619 Bracey, 2000, The TIMSS “final year” study and report: A critique, Educational Researcher, 29, 4, 10.3102/0013189X029004004 Bradburn, 1991, A rejoinder to “I never promised you first place”, Phi Delta Kappan, 72, 774 Brenner, 1999, Cross-national comparison of representational competence, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 30, 541, 10.2307/749773 Cai, 1995, Cognitive analysis of U.S. and Chinese students’ mathematical performance on tasks involving computation, simple problem solving, and complex problem solving., Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, Monograph 7, 160 pp. Cai, 1997, Beyond computation and correctness: Contributions of open-ended tasks in examining U S. and Chinese students’ mathematical performance, Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 16, 5, 10.1111/j.1745-3992.1997.tb00580.x Cai, 1998, An investigation of U S. and Chinese Students’ mathematical problem posing and problem solving, Mathematics Education Research Journal, 10, 37, 10.1007/BF03217121 Cai, 2000, Mathematical thinking involved in U.S. and Chinese students’ solving of process-constrained and process-open problems, Mathematical Thinking and Learning, 2, 309, 10.1207/S15327833MTL0204_4 Cai, 2003, Investigating parental roles in students’ learning of mathematics from a cross-national perspective, Mathematics Education Research Journal, 15, 87, 10.1007/BF03217372 Chen, 1995, Motivation and mathematics achievement: A comparative study of Asian Americans, Caucasian Americans, and East Asian high school students, Child Development, 66, 1215, 10.2307/1131808 Cheung, 1998, World class education ranking: Is it worth the effort?, Rural Educator, 20, 1 Cohen, 1992, Policy and practice: The relations between governance and instruction, Review of Research in Education, 18, 3 d’Ailly, 1992, Asian mathematics superiority: A search for explanations, Educational Psychologist, 27, 243, 10.1207/s15326985ep2702_7 Eckstein, 1993 Fejgin, 1995, Factors contributing to the academic excellence of American Jewish and Asian students, Sociology of Education, 68, 18, 10.2307/2112761 Geary, 1996, Are East Asian versus American differences in arithmetical ability a recent phenomenon?, Developmental Psychology, 32, 254, 10.1037/0012-1649.32.2.254 Geary, 1993, Even before formal instruction Chinese children outperform American children in mental addition, Cognitive Development, 8, 517, 10.1016/S0885-2014(05)80007-3 Geary, 1996, Development of arithmetical competencies in Chinese and American children: Influence of age, language, and schooling, Child Development, 67, 2022, 10.2307/1131607 Geary, 1992, Numerical cognition: Loci of ability differences comparing children from China and the United States, Psychological Science, 3, 180, 10.1111/j.1467-9280.1992.tb00023.x Geary, 1999, Contributions of computational fluency to cross-national differences in arithmetical reasoning abilities, Journal of Educational Psychology, 91, 716, 10.1037/0022-0663.91.4.716 Gu, W. (1997). The differences of mathematics achievement between American children and Chinese children. Unpublished Master of Science Graduate Paper, Winona State University, Winona State University, Winona, Minnesota. Hayness, 1997, World class schools, American School Board Journal, 184, 20 Hedges, 1985 Hess, 1987, Cultural variations in family beliefs about Children's performance in mathematics: Comparisons among the People's Republic of China, Chinese-American, and Caucasian Americans families, Journal of Educational Psychology, 79, 179, 10.1037/0022-0663.79.2.179 Hiebert, 2002, A knowledge base for the teaching profession: What would it look like and how can we get one?, Educational Researcher, 31, 3, 10.3102/0013189X031005003 Ho, 1998, Children's knowledge of teen quantities as tens and ones; comparisons of Chinese, British, and American kindergartners, Journal of Educational Psychology, 90, 536, 10.1037/0022-0663.90.3.536 Ho, 2003 Huntsinger, 1997, Cultural differences in early mathematics learning: Comparison of Euro-American, Chinese-American Taiwan-Chinese family., International Journal of Behavioral Development, 21, 371, 10.1080/016502597384929 Interstate New Teachers Assessment and Support Teaching Consortium, 1992 Kaufman, P., Chavez, L., & Lauen, D. (1998). Generational status and educational outcomes among Asian and Hispanic 1988 eighth graders. National postsecondary student aid study: 1995–96 (Statistical Analysis Report No. NCES 1999-020). Washington, DC: Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement. Kim, 1998, Student characteristics, school characteristics, and educational aspirations of six Asian American Ethnic groups, Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development, 26, 166, 10.1002/j.2161-1912.1998.tb00196.x Ladson-Billings, 1997, It doesn’t add up: African American students’ mathematics achievement, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 28, 697, 10.2307/749638 Lipsey, 2001 Livingstone, 1986 Ma, 1999 Mayer, 1995, A comparison of how textbooks teach mathematical problem solving in Japan and the United States, American Educational Research Journal, 32, 443 Mayer, 1991, Mathematics problem solving in Japan and the United States, Journal of Educational Psychology, 83, 69, 10.1037/0022-0663.83.1.69 Miller, 1987, Counting in Chinese: Cultural variation in a basic cognitive skills, Child Development, 2, 279 Miura, 1987, Mathematics achievement as a function of language, Journal of Educational Psychology, 79, 79, 10.1037/0022-0663.79.1.79 Miura, 1988, Effects of language characteristics on children's cognitive representation of number: Cross-national comparisons, Child Development, 59, 1445, 10.2307/1130659 Miura, 1994, Comparisons of children's cognitive representation of number: China, France, Japan, Korea, Sweden, and the United States, International Journal of Behavioral Development, 17, 401, 10.1177/016502549401700301 Mullis, 1997 Mullis, 1998 Mullis, 2005 Mullis, 2004 Mullis, 2000 National Board for Professional Teaching Standards, 2002 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 1989 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 1991 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2000 Nomi, T. (2004). The Asian-White achievement gap: Evidence for kindergarten and first grade. Paper presented at the Annual Meetings of the American Sociological Association, San Francisco, CA. Ogbu, J. U., & Simons, H. D. (1994). Cultural models of school achievement: A quantitative test of Ogbu's theory (A Comparative Study No. Project 12). Berkeley, CA: University of California at Berkeley. Paine, 1993, Teachers working together: A dialogue on organizational and cultural perspectives of Chinese teachers, International Journal of Educational Research, 19, 667, 10.1016/0883-0355(93)90009-9 Pan, 2006, American and Chinese parental involvement in young children's mathematics learning, Cognitive Development, 21, 17, 10.1016/j.cogdev.2005.08.001 Perry, 2000, Explanations of mathematical concepts in Japanese, Chinese, and U.S. first- and fifth-grade classrooms, Cognition and Instruction, 18, 181, 10.1207/S1532690XCI1802_02 Programme for International Student Assessment. (2004a). Learning for tomorrow's world: First results from PISA 2003 (OECD Publication No. 53799 2004). Paris, France: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Programme for International Student Assessment, 2004 Programme for International Student Assessment, 2007 Putnam, 1990, Alternative perspectives on knowing mathematics in elementary schools, Review of Research in Education, 16, 57 Reys, 1998, Relationship between computational performance and number sense among sixth- and eighth-grade students in Taiwan, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 29, 225, 10.2307/749900 Romberg, 1992, Problematic features of the school mathematics curriculum, 749 Romberg, 1997, The influence of programs from other countries on the school mathematics reform curricula in the United States, American Journal of Education, 106, 127, 10.1086/444178 Romberg, 1999, School mathematics: The impact of international comparisons on national policy, 189 Rosenthal, 1982, Comparing effect sizes of independent studies, Psychological Bulletin, 92, 500, 10.1037/0033-2909.92.2.500 Sanchez, K., Kellow, T., & Ye, R. (2000). A comparison of Stanford Achievement Test (SAT-9) performance across grade, gender, ethnicity, and educational program placement. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA. Schmidt, 1996 Schmidt, 1999, Apples to apples, American School Board Journal, 186, 29 Stedman, 1997, Deep achievement problem: The case for reform still stand, Educational Researcher, 26, 27 Stedman, 1997, International achievement differences: An assessment of a new perspective, Educational Researcher, 26, 4, 10.3102/0013189X026003004 Stevenson, 1993, Bracey's broadsides are unfounded, Educational Leadership, 50, 68 Stevenson, 1993, Why Asian students still outdistance Americans, Educational Leadership, 50, 63 Stevenson, 1990, Mathematics achievement of children in China and the United States, Child Development, 61, 1053, 10.2307/1130875 Stevenson, 1986, Mathematics achievement of Chinese, Japanese and American children, Science, 231, 693, 10.1126/science.3945803 Stevenson, 1992 Stevenson, 1985, Cognitive performance and academic achievement of Japanese, Chinese, and American children, Child Development, 56, 718, 10.2307/1129761 Stigler, 1999 Stigler, 1987, Mathematics classrooms in Japan, Taiwan, and the United States, Child Development, 58, 1272, 10.2307/1130620 Stigler, 1990 Sue, 1990, Asian Americans educational achievements: A phenomenon in search of an explanation, American Psychologist, 45, 913, 10.1037/0003-066X.45.8.913 Tobin, 1989 Tsang, S.-L. (1993, October 5). Asian American education and the national education goals. Paper presented at the Symposium Convened by the Center for Applied Linguistics, Washington, DC. Tuss, 1995, Causal attributions of underachieving fourth-grade students in China, Japan, and the United States, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 26, 408, 10.1177/0022022195264006 Wang, 2001, Contexts of mentoring and opportunities for learning to teach: A comparative study of mentoring practice, Teaching and Teacher Education, 17, 51, 10.1016/S0742-051X(00)00038-X Wang, 2005, Comparative studies on US and Chinese mathematics learning and the implications for standards-based mathematics teaching reform, Educational Researcher, 34, 3, 10.3102/0013189X034005003 Wirth, J., & Fleischer, J. (2006, April 7–12). A closer look at mathematical literacy and problem-solving competence. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of American Education Research Association, San Francisco, CA. Zhou, Z., Cheng, C., Mottram, L., & Rosenblum, S. (1999, April 15–18). Understanding informal and formal mathematical abilities in Mainland Chinese and Chinese-American children. Paper presented at the Biennial Meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Albuquerque, NM. Zhou, 2005, Understanding early mathematical competencies in American and Chinese children, School Psychology International, 26, 413, 10.1177/0143034305059018 Zusho, 2005, Motives, goals, and adaptive patterns of performance in Asian American and Anglo American students, Learning and Individual Differences, 15, 141, 10.1016/j.lindif.2004.11.003