A hybrid model integrating FMEA and HFACS to assess the risk of inter-city bus accidents
Tóm tắt
The incidence of inter-city bus accidents receives a lot of attention from the public because they often cause heavy casualties. The Human Factors Analysis and Classification System (HFACS) is the prevailing tool used for traffic accident risk assessment. However, it has several shortcomings, for example: (1) it can only identify the potential failure modes, but lacks the capability for quantitative risk assessment; (2) it neglects the severity, occurrence and detection of different failure modes; (3) it is unable to identify the degree of risk and priorities of the failure modes. This study proposes a novel hybrid model to overcome these problems. First, the HFACS is applied to enumerate the failure modes of inter-city bus operation. Second, the Z-number-based best–worst method is used to determine the weights of the risk factors based on the failure mode and effects analysis results. Then, a Z-number-based weighted aggregated sum product Assessment is utilized to calculate the degree of risk of the failure modes and the priorities for improvement. The results of this study determine the top three ranking failure modes, which are personal readiness from pre-conditions for unsafe behavior, human resources from organizational influence, and driver decision-making error from unsafe behavior. Finally, data for inter-city buses in Taiwan in a case study to illustrate the usefulness and effectiveness of the proposed model. In addition, some management implications are provided.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Aboutorab H, Saberi M, Asadabadi M-R, Hussain O, Chang E (2018) ZBWM: the Z-number extension of best worst method and its application for supplier development. Expert Syst Appl 107:115–125
Akyuz E (2017) A marine accident analysing model to evaluate potential operational causes in cargo ships. Saf Sci 92:17–25
Alvand A, Mirhosseini S-M, Ehsanifar M, Zeigham E, Mohammadi A (2021) Identification and assessment of risk in construction projects using the integrated FMEA-SWARA-WASPAS model under fuzzy environment: a case study of a construction project in Iran. Int J Constr Manag 1–23. (In Press)
Arabian-Hoseynabadi H, Oraee H, Tavner P-J (2010) Failure modes and effects analysis (FMEA) for wind turbines. Int J Electr Power Energy Syst 32(7):817–824
Badalpur M, Nurbakhsh E (2021) An application of WASPAS method in risk qualitative analysis: a case study of a road construction project in Iran. Int J Constr Manag 21(9):910–918
Beanland V, Sellbom M, Johnson A-K (2014) Personality domains and traits that predict self-reported aberrant driving behaviours in a Southeastern US University Sample. Accid Anal Prev 72:184–192
Boral S, Howard I, Chaturvedi S-K, McKee K, Naikan V-N-A (2020) An integrated approach for fuzzy failure modes and effects analysis using fuzzy AHP and fuzzy MAIRCA. Eng Fail Anal 108:104195
Celik M, Cebi S (2009) Analytical HFACS for investigating human errors in shipping accidents. Accid Anal Prev 41(1):66–75
Chen X, Liu X, Qin Y (2019) An extended HFACS based risk analysis approach for human error accident with interval type-2 fuzzy sets and prospect theory. J Intell Fuzzy Syst 37(6):8381–8395
Chiu M-C, Hsieh M (2016) Latent human error analysis and efficient improvement strategies by fuzzy TOPSIS in aviation maintenance tasks. Appl Ergon 54:136–147
Cohen T-N, WiegmannShappell D-AS-A (2015) Evaluating the reliability of the human factors analysis and classification system. Aerosp Med Hum Perform 86(8):728–735
Di Pasquale V, Miranda S, Iannone R, Riemma S (2015) A simulator for human error probability analysis (SHERPA). Reliab Eng Syst Saf 139:17–32
Ergai A, Cohen T, Sharp J, Wiegmann D, Gramopadhye A, Shappell S (2016) Assessment of the human factors analysis and classification system (HFACS): intra-rater and inter-rater reliability. Saf Sci 82:393–398
Gugaliya A, Boral S, Naikan V-N-A (2019) A hybrid decision making framework for modified failure mode effects and criticality analysis: A case study on process plant induction motors. Int J Qual Reliab Manag 36(8):1266–1283
Hale A, Walker D, Walters N, Bolt H (2012) Developing the understanding of underlying causes of construction fatal accidents. Saf Sci 50(10):2020–2027
Havle C-A, Kılıç B (2019) A hybrid approach based on the fuzzy AHP and HFACS framework for identifying and analyzing gross navigation errors during transatlantic flights. J Air Transp Manag 76:21–30
Hsieh MC, Chiang P-Y, Lee Y-C, Wang E-M-Y, Kung W-C, Hu Y-T, Hsieh H-C (2021) An investigation of human errors in medication adverse event improvement priority using a hybrid approach. Healthc (Amst) 9(4):442–457
Hsieh M-C, Wang E-M-Y, Lee W-C, Li L-W, Hsieh C-Y, Tsai W, Liu T-C (2018) Application of HFACS, fuzzy TOPSIS, and AHP for identifying important human error factors in emergency departments in Taiwan. Int J Ind Ergon 67:171–179
Jiang W, Xie C, Wei B, Tang Y (2018) Failure mode and effects analysis based on Z-numbers. Intell Autom Soft Comput 24(1):165–172
Jiang W, Zhang Z, Deng X (2019) A novel failure mode and effects analysis method based on fuzzy evidential reasoning rules. IEEE Access 7:113605–113615
Karthick M, Robert T-P, Kumar C-S (2020) HFACS-based FAHP implementation to identify critical factors influencing human error occurrence in nuclear plant control room. Soft Comput 24(21):16577–16591
LAARAJ N, JAWAB F (2018) Road accident modeling approaches: literature review. In: 2018 international colloquium on logistics and supply chain management (LOGISTIQUA), pp 188–193
Leveson N (2004) A new accident model for engineering safer systems. Saf Sci 42(4):237–270
Liu H-C, Chen X-Q, Duan C-Y, Wang Y-M (2019) Failure mode and effect analysis using multi-criteria decision making methods: a systematic literature review. Comput Ind Eng 135:881–897
Liu H-C, Liu L, Liu N, Mao L-X (2012) Risk evaluation in failure mode and effects analysis with extended VIKOR method under fuzzy environment. Expert Syst Appl 39(17):12926–12934
Liu H-C, Wang L-E, You X-Y, Wu S-M (2019) Failure mode and effect analysis with extended grey relational analysis method in cloud setting. Total Qual Manag Bus Excell 30(7–8):745–767
Liu R, Cheng W, Yu Y, Xu Q, Jiang A, Lv T (2019) An impacting factors analysis of miners’ unsafe acts based on HFACS-CM and SEM. Process Saf Environ Prot 122:221–231
Li W-C, Harris D, Yu C-S (2006) Routes to failure: analysis of 41 civil aviation accidents from the Republic of China using the human factors analysis and classification system. Accid Anal Prev 40(2):426–434
Li Y, Guldenmund F-W (2018) Safety management systems: a broad overview of the literature. Saf Sci 103:94–23
Lo H-W, Liou J-J (2018) A novel multiple-criteria decision-making-based FMEA model for risk assessment. Appl Soft Comput 73:684–696
Lo H-W, Liou J-J, Huang C-N, Chuang Y-C (2019) A novel failure mode and effect analysis model for machine tool risk analysis. Reliab Eng Syst Saf 183:173–183
Mohammed A-A, Ambak K, Mosa A-M, Syamsunur D (2019) A review of traffic accidents and related practices worldwide. Open Transp J 13(1):65–83
Mohsen O, Fereshteh N (2017) An extended VIKOR method based on entropy measure for the failure modes risk assessment—a case study of the geothermal power plant (GPP). Saf Sci 92:160–172
Newnam S, Goode N (2015) Do not blame the driver: a systems analysis of the causes of road freight crashes. Accid Anal Prev 6:141–151
O’Connor P (2008) HFACS with an additional layer of granularity: validity and utility in accident analysis. Aerosp Med Hum Perform 79(6):599–606
Olsen N-S (2011) Coding ATC incident data using HFACS: inter-coder consensus. Saf Sci 49(10):1365–1370
Pamučar D, Stević Ž, Sremac S (2018) A new model for determining weight coefficients of criteria in mcdm models: full consistency method (fucom). Symmetry 10(9):393
Peden M, Scurfield R, Sleet D, Mohan D, Hyder A–A, Jarawan E, Mathers C (2004) World report on road traffic injury prevention. World Health Organization, Geneva, pp 69–94
Rasmussen J (1997) Risk management in a dynamic society: a modelling problem. Saf Sci 27(2–3):183–213
Reason J (1990) Human error. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Reinach S, Viale A (2006) Application of a human error framework to conduct train accident/incident investigations. Accid Anal Prev 38(2):396–406
Rezaei J (2015) Best-worst multi-criteria decision-making method. Omega 53:49–57
Rostamabadi A, Jahangiri M, Zarei E, Kamalinia M, Banaee S, Samaei M-R (2019) A novel fuzzy Bayesian network-HFACS (FBN-HFACS) model for analyzing human and organization factors (HOFs) in process accidents. Process Saf Environ Prot 132:59–72
Sarıalioğlu S, Uğurlu Ö, Aydın M, Vardar B, Wang J (2020) A hybrid model for human-factor analysis of engine-room fires on ships: HFACS-PV&FFTA. Ocean Eng 217:107992
Shappell S-A, Wiegmann D-A (2000) The human factors analysis and classification system—HFACS. University of Illinois Institute of Aviation, Oklahoma City
Stanton N-A, Salmon P-M (2009) Human error taxonomies applied to driving: a generic driver error taxonomy and its implications for intelligent transport systems. Saf Sci 47(2):227–237
Van Elslande P (2003) Erreurs de conduite et besoins d’aide: une approche accidentologique en ergonomie. Trav Hum 66(3):197–224
Wang X, Yu H, Nie C, Zhou Y, Wang H, Shi X (2019) Road traffic injuries in China from 2007 to 2016: the epidemiological characteristics, trends and influencing factors. Peer J 7:11–25
Wei S-X, Sui Y-C, Chen Y-C (2014) Research into the human errors evaluation method of flight accidents based on HFACS. Aeron Comput Tech 44(2):50–53
Wiegmann D-A, Shappell S-A (2003) A human error approach to aviation accident analysis: the human factors analysis and classification system. Ashgate Great Britain. https://trove.nla.gov.au/version/28337285. Accessed 18 Mar 2021
Yaacob N-F-F, Rusli N, Bohari S-N (2018) A review analysis of accident factor on road accident cases using Haddon matrix approach. In: Proceedings of the second international conference on the future of ASEAN (ICoFA) 2017-2, pp 55–65
Zadeh L-A (2011) A note on Z-numbers. Inf Sci 181(14):2923–2932
Zarei E, Yazdi M, Abbassi R, Khan F (2019) A hybrid model for human factor analysis in process accidents: FBN-HFACS. J Loss Prev Process Ind 57:142–155
Zhou Z-C (2019) Research on the Estimation of Road Traffic Accident Cost. Institute of Transportation, Ministry of Transportation, Taiwan, R.O.C. MOTC-IOT-101-SEB010, pp 139–140
Zhang Y, Jing L, Sun C, Fang J, Feng Y (2019) Human factors related to major road traffic accidents in China. Traffic Inj Prev 20(8):1–5
Zhang Y, Liu T, Bai Q, Shao W, Wang Q (2018) New systems-based method to conduct analysis of road traffic accidents. Transp Res Part F Traffic Psychol Behav 54:96–109