A Quantitative Diagnosis of Notches Made by Hammerstone Percussion and Carnivore Gnawing on Bovid Long Bones
Tóm tắt
The frequency and morphology of notches produced on bovid long bones by carnivore gnawing (tooth notches) and hammerstone-on-anvil breakage (percussion notches) are quantified. Notches are semicircular- to arcuate-shaped indentations on fracture edges with corresponding negative flake scars on medullary surfaces. We restrict our analysis to notches produced under controlled conditions by either carnivores or hammerstones when diaphyses are breached to extract marrow. Percussion notches are characteristically more frequent, and, in cortical view, broader and shallower than tooth notches. The flakes removed from percussion notches are typically broader, and have a more obtuse release angle, than those removed from tooth notches. These morphological differences are statistically significant for notches on Bovid Size 1 and 2 long bones but not on Bovid Size 3 long bones.
Notches should be more durable than marks produced by carcass consumers on bone surfaces because they penetrate the entire thickness of the bone. As a result, notches are not easily obscured by weathering, chemical corrosion, or adhering matrix. Given this durability, and the initial success we have had in distinguishing the actor responsible for notch production on modern bones, notches can be used, with some limitations, to identify bone consumers archaeologically.
Từ khóa
Tài liệu tham khảo
Isaac, 1984, The Archaeology of Human Origins : Studies of the Lower Pleistocene in East Africa, Advances in World Archaeology, 3, 1
Cotterell, 1975, Lithic Use-Wear Analysis, 97
Brain, 1981
Capaldo, 1995, Unpublished Ph. D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology
Capaldo, 1990, Differential Treatment of Axial and Appendicular Elements by Scavenging Carnivores at Simulated Archaeological Sites., Paper presented at the Biennial Conference of the Society of Africanist Archaeologists, Gainesville, Florida
Bunn, 1982, Unpublished Ph. D. dissertation
Johnson, 1983, A Question of Bone Technology, 55
Wilmsen, 1970, Anthropological Papers No. 16.
Bonnichsen, 1980, Mammalian Osteology, 7
Bonnichsen, 1973, Mammalian Osteo-Archaeology, 9
Cruz-Uribe, 1991, Distinguishing Hyena from Hominid Bone Accumulations, Journal of Field Archaeology, 18, 467
Oakley, 1949
Buckland, 1978
Blumenschine, 1993, From Bones to Behavior, 273
Bunn, 1991, Cultural Beginnings, 33
Wonnacott, 1977
Fiorillo, 1989, Bone Modification, 61
Dart, 1957, Memoir No. 10.
Shipman, 1989, Bone Modification, 317
Potts, 1988
Oliver, 1989, Bone Modification, 73
Bunn, 1983, Animals and Archaeology, 143
Maguire, 1980, The Makapansgat Limeworks Grey Breccia : Hominids, Hyaenas, Hystricids or Hillwash?, Paleontologica Africana, 23, 75
Blumenschine, 1991, Human Predators and Prey Mortality, 121
Binford, 1981
Bonnichsen, 1979, Paper No. 89. Archaeological Survey of Canada
Bunn, 1989, Bone Modification, 299
White, 1992
Blumenschine, 1991, Cultural Beginnings, 17