Economic, Political, and Institutional Prerequisites for Monetary Union Among the Members of the Gulf Cooperation Council
Tóm tắt
The paper reviews the arguments for and against monetary union among the six members of the Gulf Cooperation Council—the United Arab Emirates, the State of Bahrain, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Sultanate of Oman, the State of Qatar and the State of Kuwait. Both technical economic arguments and political economy considerations are discussed. I conclude that there is an economic case for GCC monetary union, but that it is not overwhelming. The lack of economic integration among the GCC members is striking. Without anything approaching the free movement of goods, services, capital and persons among the six GCC member countries, the case for monetary union is mainly based on the small size of all GCC members other than Saudi Arabia, and their high degree of openness. Indeed, even without the creation of a monetary union, there could be significant advantages to all GCC members, from both an economic and a security perspective, from greater economic integration, through the creation of a true common market for goods, services, capital and labour, and from deeper political integration. The political arguments against monetary union at this juncture appear overwhelming, however. The absence of effective supranational political institutions encompassing the six GCC members means that there could be no effective political accountability of the GCC central bank. The surrender of political sovereignty inherent in joining a monetary union would therefore not be perceived as legitimate by an increasingly politically sophisticated citizenry. I believe that monetary union among the GCC members will occur only as part of a broad and broadly based movement towards far-reaching political integration. And there is little evidence of that as yet.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Abu-Bader S, Abu-Qarn A (2006) On the optimality of a GCC Monetary Union: Structural VAR, common trends and common cycles evidence. Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Department of Economics working papers series, No. 225, September
Akarli AO (2007) The GCC dream: between the BRICs and the developed world. Goldman sachs global economics paper No: 155, April. Available at https://portal.gs.com, (subscription only)
Al-Raisi Ali H, Pattanaik S, Yousuf Al Raisi A (2007) Transmission mechanism of monetary policy under the fixed exchange regime of Oman. Central Bank of Oman occasional paper No. 2007-1, April
Bayoumi T, Masson PR (1995) Fiscal flows in the United States and Canada: lessons for monetary union in Europe. Eur Econ Rev 39:253–274
Buiter WH (1997) The economic case for monetary union in the European union. In: Deissenberg C, Owen RF, Ulph D (eds) European economic integration. Supplement to the Review of International Economics 5(4):10–35
Buiter WH (1999) Alice in Euroland. J Common Mark Stud 37(2):181–209, June
Buiter WH (2005) To purgatory and beyond; when and how should the accession countries from Central and Eastern Europe become full members of the EMU. In: Breuss F, Hochreiter E (eds) Challenges for Central Banks in an enlarged EMU. Springer, New York, pp 145–186
Buiter W (2006a) The ‘sense and nonsense of maastricht’ revisited: what have we learnt about stabilization in EMU? J Common Mark Stud 44(4):687–710
Buiter WH (2006b) Rethinking inflation targeting and Central Bank independence, Background paper for an Inaugural Lecture for the Chair of European Political Economy in the European Institute at the London School of Economics and Political Science, given on Thursday, 26th October 2006, at 18:30, in the Old Theatre, London School of Economics and Political Science
Buiter WH (2007a) Seigniorage, economics—the open-access, open-assessment, E-Journal, 2007–10. http://www.economics-ejournal.org/economics/journalarticles/2007-10
Buiter WH (2007b) Clipping wings; the case for minimalist Central Banking. Central Banking XVIII(2):28–33, November 2007
Buiter WH (2007c) Lessons from the 2007 financial crisis; paper submitted in evidence to the UK Treasury Select Committee in connection with my appearance before the Committee on Tuesday, 13 November 2007; Abstract here; published as CEPR Policy Insight No. 18, December 2007
Buiter WH, Sibert AC (2006a) Eurozone entry of new EU member states from Central Europe: should they? Could they?, with Anne C. Sibert, in Development & Transition, UNDP-LSE Newsletter, 4, June 2006, 16–19
Buiter WH, Sibert AC (2006b) When should the new central European members join the Eurozone? Bankni vestnik—The Journal for Money and Banking of the Bank Association of Slovenia, Special Issue, Small Economies in the Euro Area: Issues, Challenges and Opportunities, 11/2006 5–11
Buiter WH, Corsetti G, Pesenti P (1998) Financial markets and European monetary cooperation; the lessons of the 92–93 ERM Crisis. Cambridge University Press
Chamley C (1986) Optimal taxation of capital income in general equilibrium with infinite lives. Econometrica 54:607–622
Dasgupta P, Stiglitz J (1972) On optimal taxation and public production. Review of Economic Studies 39:87–103
De Grauwe P (1997) The economics of monetary integration. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK
Diamond P, Mirrlees J (1971) Optimal taxation and public production I: production efficiency. Am Econ Rev 61:8–27
Dormans EHM (1991) Het tekort. Staatsschuld in de tijd van de Republiek. Amsterdam, NEHA
Dowd K, Greenaway D (1993) Currency competition, network externalities and switching costs: towards an alternative view of optimum currency areas. Econ J 102:1180–1189
Eichengreen B (1996) On the links between monetary and political integration. Mimeo, University of California at Berkeley, CIDER WP #C96–077, December
Engel C, Rogers JH (1996) How wide is the border. Am Econ Rev 86(5):1112–11225, December
Erbas SN, Behrouz G, Abed GT (2003) The GCC monetary union: some considerations for the exchange rate regime, IMF Working Papers 03/66, International Monetary Fund
European Commission (1990) One market, one money. European Economy, No. 44, October
Fasano-Filho U, Schaechter A (2003) Monetary union among member countries of the gulf cooperation council. IMF occasional papers 223, International Monetary Fund
Fidrmuc J, Horvath J (1999) Stability of monetary unions: lessons from the break-up of Czechoslovakia. J Comp Econ 27(4):753–781, December
Frankel JA, Rose AK (1997) Is EMU more justifiable ex post than ex ante? Econ J, Elsevier 41(3–5):753–760, April
Frankel JA, Rose AK (1998) The endogeneity of the optimum currency area criteria. Econ J 108(449):1009–1025, July 19
Gilbert E (2004) What is at stake in the NAMU debates? A review of the arguments for and against north American monetary union. Int J Can Stud/Revue internationale d’études canadiennes 30:161–184
Ingram J (1969) The currency area problem. In: Mundell RA, Svoboda AK (eds) Monetary problems of the international economy. Chicago University Press, Chicago, Illinois
Kamar B, Naceur SB (2007) GCC Monetary union and the degree of macroeconomic policy coordination IMF Working Paper WP/07/249, October
Kenen PB (1969) The theory of optimal currency areas: an eclectic view. In: Mundell RA, Svoboda AK (eds) Monetary problems of the international economy. Chicago University Press, Chicago, Illinois
Kenen PB (2001) Currency areas, policy domains, and the institutionalization of fixed exchange rates. Centre for Economic Performance, August
Kenen PB, Meade EE (2008) Regional monetary integration. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Masson PR, Taylor MP (1992) Currency unions: a survey of the issues. In: Masson PR, Taylor MP (eds) Policy issues in the operation of currency unions. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, pp 3–53
McKinnon RI (1963) Optimum currency areas. Am Econ Rev 53:717–725
Mundell RA (1961) A theory of optimum currency areas. Am Econ Rev 51:657–675
Pattanaik S (2007) How closely the GCC approximates an optimum currency area? J Econ Integr 22(3):573–597, September
Poole W (1970) Optimal choice of monetary policy instruments in a simple stochastic macromodel. Q J Econ 84:197–216
Sala-i-Martin X, Sachs J (1992) Fiscal federalism and optimum currency areas: evidence for Europe from the United States. In: Canzoneri MB, Grilli V, Masson PR (eds) Establishing a Central Bank: issues in Europe and lessons from the U.S. Cambridge University Press
Stiglitz J, Dasgupta P (1971) Differential taxation, public goods and economic efficiency. Rev Econ Stud 38:151–174
Sturm M, Siegfried N (2005) Regional monetary integration in the member states of the Gulf Cooperation Council. Occasional Paper Series 31, European Central Bank
Tietmeyer H (1998) Political consequences of monetary union, speech given at the Social Congress of the Commission of Bishop’s Conferences of the European Community, 20 February