Changing behaviour, ‘more or less’: do implementation and de-implementation interventions include different behaviour change techniques?
Tóm tắt
Decreasing ineffective or harmful healthcare practices (de-implementation) may require different approaches than those used to promote uptake of effective practices (implementation). Few psychological theories differentiate between processes involved in decreasing, versus increasing, behaviour. However, it is unknown whether implementation and de-implementation interventions already use different approaches. We used the behaviour change technique (BCT) taxonomy (version 1) (which includes 93 BCTs organised into 12 groupings) to investigate whether implementation and de-implementation interventions for clinician behaviour change use different BCTs. Intervention descriptions in 181 articles from three systematic reviews in the Cochrane Library were coded for (a) implementation versus de-implementation and (b) intervention content (BCTs) using the BCT taxonomy (v1). BCT frequencies were calculated and compared using Pearson’s chi-squared (χ2), Yates’ continuity correction and Fisher’s exact test, where appropriate. Identified BCTs were ranked according to frequency and rankings for de-implementation versus implementation interventions were compared and described. Twenty-nine and 25 BCTs were identified in implementation and de-implementation interventions respectively. Feedback on behaviour was identified more frequently in implementation than de-implementation (Χ2(2, n=178) = 15.693, p = .000057). Three BCTs were identified more frequently in de-implementation than implementation: Behaviour substitution (Χ2(2, n=178) = 14.561, p = .0001; Yates’ continuity correction); Monitoring of behaviour by others without feedback (Χ2(2, n=178) = 16.187, p = .000057; Yates’ continuity correction); and Restructuring social environment (p = .000273; Fisher’s 2-sided exact test). There were some significant differences between BCTs reported in implementation and de-implementation interventions suggesting that researchers may have implicit theories about different BCTs required for de-implementation and implementation. These findings do not imply that the BCTs identified as targeting implementation or de-implementation are effective, rather simply that they were more frequently used. These findings require replication for a wider range of clinical behaviours. The continued accumulation of additional knowledge and evidence into whether implementation and de-implementation is different will serve to better inform researchers and, subsequently, improve methods for intervention design.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Brownlee S, Chalkidou K, Doust J, Elshaug AG, Glasziou P, Heath I, et al. Evidence for overuse of medical services around the world. The Lancet. 2017;390(10090):156–68.
Grimshaw JM, Patey AM, Kirkham KR, Hall A, Dowling SK, Rodondi N, et al. De-implementing wisely: developing the evidence base to reduce low-value care. BMJ Quality & Safety. 2020:bmjqs-2019-010060.
Information; CIfH. Unnecessary care in Canada: technical report. . Ottawa, ON: CIHI; 2017.
Moynihan R, Glasziou P, Woloshin S, Schwartz L, Santa J, Godlee F. Winding back the harms of too much medicine. BMJ (Clinical research ed). 2013;346:f1271.
Glasziou P, Moynihan R, Richards T, Godlee F. Too much medicine; too little care. British Medical Journal Publishing Group; 2013.
Levinson W, Kallewaard M, Bhatia RS, Wolfson D, Shortt S, Kerr EA, et al. ‘Choosing Wisely’: a growing international campaign. BMJ quality & safety. 2014:bmjqs-2014-003821.
Cassel CK, Guest JA. Choosing wisely: helping physicians and patients make smart decisions about their care. Jama. 2012;307(17):1801–2.
Malhotra A, Maughan D, Ansell J, Lehman R, Henderson A, Gray M, et al. Choosing Wisely in the UK: reducing the harms of too much medicine. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2016;50(13):826–8.
Bhatia RS, Levinson W, Shortt S, Pendrith C, Fric-Shamji E, Kallewaard M, et al. Measuring the effect of Choosing Wisely: an integrated framework to assess campaign impact on low-value care. BMJ Qual Saf. 2015;24(8):523–31.
Gifford EV, Tavakoli S, Weingardt KR, Finney JW, Pierson HM, Rosen CS, et al. How do components of evidence-based psychological treatment cluster in practice?: a survey and cluster analysis. Journal of substance abuse treatment. 2012;42(1):45–55.
Prasad V, Ioannidis JP. Evidence-based de-implementation for contradicted, unproven, and aspiring healthcare practices. Implementation Science. 2014;9(1):1–5.
Patey AM, Hurt CS, Grimshaw JM, Francis JJ. Changing behaviour ‘more or less’—do theories of behaviour inform strategies for implementation and de-implementation? A critical interpretive synthesis. Implementation Science. 2018;13(1):134.
Skinner BF. Science and human behavior. Cambridge, Massachusettes: B.F. Skinner Foundation; 2005.
Eccles M, Foy R, Sales AE, Wensing M, Mittman B. Implementation Science six years on—our evolving scope and common reasons for rejection without review. Implement Sci. 2012;7:71.
Olds D, Øvretveit J. Innovations in quality improvement research for more useful answers to research users’ questions. Implementation Science. 2013;8(Suppl 1):S7.
Nieuwlaat R, Schwalm J-D, Khatib R, Yusuf S. Why are we failing to implement effective therapies in cardiovascular disease? European heart journal. 2013;34(17):1262–9.
Michie S, Richardson M, Johnston M, Abraham C, Francis J, Hardeman W, et al. The behavior change technique taxonomy (v1) of 93 hierarchically clustered techniques: building an international consensus for the reporting of behavior change interventions. Ann Behav Med. 2013;46(1):81–95.
Powell BJ, Waltz TJ, Chinman MJ, Damschroder LJ, Smith JL, Matthieu MM, et al. A refined compilation of implementation strategies: results from the Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change (ERIC) project. Implementation Science. 2015;10(1):21.
(EPOC); EPaOoC. EPOC Taxonomy 2015 [Available from: https://epoc.cochrane.org/epoc-taxonomy.
Ivers N, Jamtvedt G, Flottorp S, Young JM, Odgaard-Jensen J, French SD, et al. Audit and feedback: effects on professional practice and healthcare outcomes. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012;6.
Davey P, Brown E, Fenelon L, Finch R, Gould I, Hartman G. Interventions to improve antibiotic prescribing practices for hospital inpatients. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013;19.
French SD, Green S, Buchbinder R, Barnes H. Interventions for improving the appropriate use of imaging in people with musculoskeletal conditions. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010;1.
Fleiss JL, Cohen J, Everitt B. Large sample standard errors of kappa and weighted kappa. Psychological Bulletin. 1969;72(5):323.
Graphpad S. Graphpad QuckCals Website 2014 [Quantify agreement with Kappa]. Available from: http://graphpad.com/quickcalcs/kappa1/.
Fleiss JL. The measurement of interrater agreement. Statistical methods for rates and proportions. 1981;2:212–36.
Fleiss JL. Measuring nominal scale agreement among many raters. Psychological Bulletin. 1971;76(5):378.
Moore DS, McCabe GP. Introduction to the practice of statistics: WH Freeman/Times Books/Henry Holt & Co; 1989.
McHugh ML. The chi-square test of independence. Biochemia Medica. 2013;23(2):143–9.
Climo MW, Israel DS, Wong ES, Williams D, Coudron P, Markowitz SM. Hospital-wide restriction of clindamycin: effect on the incidence of Clostridium difficile-associated diarrhea and cost. Annals of Internal Medicine. 1998;128(12_Part_1):989-95.
Meyer KS, Urban C, Eagan JA, Berger BJ, Rahal JJ. Nosocomial outbreak of Klebsiella infection resistant to late-generation cephalosporins. Annals of internal medicine. 1993;119(5):353–8.
Christ-Crain M, Stolz D, Bingisser R, Muller C, Miedinger D, Huber PR, et al. Procalcitonin guidance of antibiotic therapy in community-acquired pneumonia: a randomized trial. American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine. 2006;174(1):84–93.
Wyatt JC, Paterson-Brown S, Johanson R, Altman DG, Bradburn MJ, Fisk NM. Randomised trial of educational visits to enhance use of systematic reviews in 25 obstetric units. BMJ. 1998;317(7165):1041–6.
Ferguson TB Jr, Peterson ED, Coombs LP, Eiken MC, Carey ML, Grover FL, et al. Use of continuous quality improvement to increase use of process measures in patients undergoing coronary artery bypass graft surgery: a randomized controlled trial. Jama. 2003;290(1):49–56.
Majumdar SR, Beaupre LA, Harley CH, Hanley DA, Lier DA, Juby AG, et al. Use of a case manager to improve osteoporosis treatment after hip fracture: results of a randomized controlled trial. Archives of internal medicine. 2007;167(19):2110–5.
Himmelberg CJ, Pleasants RA, Weber DJ, Kessler JM, Samsa GP, Spivey JM, et al. Use of antimicrobial drugs in adults before and after removal of a restriction policy. American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy. 1991;48(6):1220–7.
Eccles MP, Grimshaw JM, Johnston M, Steen N, Pitts NB, Thomas R, et al. Applying psychological theories to evidence-based clinical practice: identifying factors predictive of managing upper respiratory tract infections without antibiotics. Implementation Science. 2007;2(1):26.
Francis JJ, Tinmouth A, Stanworth SJ, Grimshaw JM, Johnston M, Hyde C, et al. Using theories of behaviour to understand transfusion prescribing in three clinical contexts in two countries: development work for an implementation trial. Implementation Science. 2009;4(1):70.
Islam R, Tinmouth AT, Francis JJ, Brehaut JC, Born J, Stockton C, et al. A cross-country comparison of intensive care physicians’ beliefs about their transfusion behaviour: a qualitative study using the Theoretical Domains Framework. Implementation Science: IS. 2012;7:93-.
Bussieres AE, Patey AM, Francis JJ, Sales AE, Grimshaw JM. Identifying factors likely to influence compliance with diagnostic imaging guideline recommendations for spine disorders among chiropractors in North America: a focus group study using the Theoretical Domains Framework. Implementation Science. 2012;7(1):82.
McKenzie JE, French SD, O’Connor DA, Grimshaw JM, Mortimer D, Michie S, et al. IMPLEmenting a clinical practice guideline for acute low back pain evidence-based manageMENT in general practice (IMPLEMENT): cluster randomised controlled trial study protocol. Implement Sci. 2008;3(1):11.
Lee C, Jafari M, Brownbridge R, Phillips C, Vanstone JR. The viral prescription pad-a mixed methods study to determine the need for and utility of an educational tool for antimicrobial stewardship in primary health care. BMC family practice. 2020;21(1):1–12.
Dweck CS. Implicit theories as organizers of goals and behavior. In: Gollwitzer PM, Bargh JA, editors. The psychology of action: Linking cognition and motivation to behavior: The Guilford Press; 1996. p. 69-90.
The Improved Clinical Effectiveness through Behavioural Research G. Designing theoretically- informed implementation interventions. Implementation Science. 2006;1(4).
Bohlen LC, Michie S, de Bruin M, Rothman A, Kelly MP, Groarke H, et al. Do combinations of behaviour change techniques that occur frequently in interventions reflect underlying theory? Annals of Behavioral Medicine. 2020;XX:1-16.