The use of refusal postcards in recruiting older adults
Tóm tắt
This article examines whether a refusal postcard makes recruitment more efficient or instead reduces response rates to a telephone survey of older adults. Medicare health maintenance organization (HMO) members were randomly sampled in sequential phases. All samples received an initial contact letter from a HMO geriatrician. A refusal postcard was included in the first sample (N=178); however, the remaining six samples did not receive this postcard (N=1,003). An overall refusal rate of 32% was observed when postcards were included versus a 14% rate of refusal when postcards were excluded (p<.001). When potential respondents were reached by telephone, refusal rates were similar (9% versus 10%). Despite the higher refusal rate among the sample receiving the refusal postcard, no significant differences in demographics, health, and health behaviors were observed between the two final sample groups completing the survey. We conclude that refusal postcards greatly increase the refusal rates without offering any prescreening advantage in the recruitment process of older adults and could increase the costs of recruitment for a telephone survey. Furthermore, use of a refusal postcard precludes individuals from making fully informed decisions about participating in research.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Carter WB, Elward K, Malmgren J, Martin ML, Larson E: Participation of older adults in health programs and research: A critical review of the literature.The Gerontologist. 1991,31:584–592.
Zimmer AW, Calkins E, Hadley E, et al: Conducting clinical research in geriatric populations.Annals of Internal Medicine. 1985,103:276–283.
Marcus A, Crane L: Telephone surveys in public health research.Medical Care. 1986,24:97–112.
Aday LA:Designing and Conducting Health Surveys. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 1989.
Herzog AR, Rodgers WL: Interviewing older adults: Mode comparison using data from face-to-face survey and a telephone resurvey.Public Opinion Quarterly. 1988,52:84–99.
Herzog AR, Rodgers WL, Kulka RA: Interviewing older adults: Mode comparison of telephone and face-to-face modalities.Public Opinion Quarterly. 1983,47:405–418.
Herzog A, Rodgers W: Age and response rates to interview sample surveys.Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences. 1988,43:S200-S205.
Demaio TJ: Refusals: Who, where, and why.Public Opinion Quarterly. 1980,44:223–233.
Hawkins DF: Estimation of nonresponse bias.Sociological Methods Research. 1975,3:461–488.
Massey JT, Barker PR, Hsiung S: An investigation of response in telephone survey. InProceedings of the Section on Survey Research Methods, American Statistical Assocation. Alexandria, VA: The American Statistical Association, 1981, 426–431.
Elks M: The right to participate in research studies.The Journal of Laboratory and Clinical Medicine. 1993,122:130–136.
Worth A, Tierney AJ: Conducting research interviews with elderly people by telephone.Journal of Advanced Nursing. 1993,18:1077–1084.
Cornoni-Huntley J, Ostfeld AM, Taylor JO, et al: Established populations for epidemiologic studies of the elderly: Study design and methodology.Aging. 1993,5:27–37.
Frey J:Survey Research by Telephone (2nd ED.). London: Sage, 1989.
Botwinick J:Aging and Behavior (2nd Ed.): New York: Springer, 1989.
Steele JG, Walls AWG, Murray JJ: Methodological issues involved in sampling a population of the elderly for a dental survey.Community Dental Health. 1995,12:77–82.
Fowler FJ:Survey Research Methods (2nd Ed.). Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 1993.
Stewart AL, Hays RD, Ware JE: The MOS Short-Form General Health Survey: Reliability and validity in a patient population.Medical Care. 1988,26:724–735.
National Center for Health Statistics:National Health Interview Survey. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Public Health Service, 1991.
Ware JE, Nelson EC, Sherbourne CD, Steward AL: Preliminary tests of a 6-item general health survey: A patient application. In Stewart AL, Ware JE (eds),Measuring Functioning and Well-Being. The Medical Outcomes Study Approach. Durham, NC: Duke Unviersity Press, 1992, 291–308.
Berwick DM, Murphy JM, Goldman PA, et al: Performance of a five-item mental health screening test.Medical Care. 1991,29: 169–176.
Kuppermann M, Lubeck DP, Mazonson PD, et al: Sleep problems and their correlates in a working population.Journal of General Internal Medicine. 1995,10:25–32.
Groves RM, Cialdini RB, Couper MP: Understanding the decision to participate in a survey.Public Opinion Quarterly. 1992,56:475–495.