Rethinking the sustainability of rural water delivery under the community ownership and management model
Tóm tắt
Community ownership and management (COM) is, without a doubt, a viable alternative for rural water management. However, the extent to which communities control their water supply infrastructure in terms of engaging in crucial decisions and the performance of all stakeholders along the service delivery chain—from national to community levels—continues to be a challenge. The goal of this research is to add to the conversation on COM by clarifying the paradigm and its implications for the long-term viability of rural water services. It is also expected to spark debate in the rural water sector and, in turn, influence a revision of the National Community Water and Sanitation Programme to reflect current needs. The study looked at how the COM model of rural water provision was implemented. Using focus groups and surveys, the study used a non-probability purposive sample technique to identify stakeholders at the regional, district, and community levels. The paper discovers and suggests that COM has been the least responsive to rural water service sustainability. In actuality, at all stages of the delivery chain, there is a flagrant disregard for clearly stated functions in sector manuals. Regional and district players face logistical challenges, while community service providers struggle with governance, technical operations, and financial management. For effective and efficient management of water systems, more needs to be done by key stakeholders, including greater capacity support and oversight of service providers' activities, as well as engagement with partners.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Adank M (2013) Small town water services: trends, challenges and models, thematic overview. Paper 27, The Hague: IRC, https://www.ircwash.org/sites/default/files/small_towns_top2.pdf. Accessed 04 July 2019
Adank M, Kumasi TC, Abbey E, Dickinson N, Dzansi P, Atengdem J, Chimbar T, Effah-Appiah E (2013) The status of rural water supply services in Ghana, a synthesis of findings from 3 districts. Triple-S working paper. Accra, Ghana: IRC Ghana
Adank M, Kumasi TC, Chimbar TL, Atengdem J, Agbemor BD, Dickinson N, Abbey E (2014) The state of handpump water services in Ghana: findings from three districts. In: Shaw RJ, Anh NV, Dang TH (eds) Proceedings of the 37 WEDC International Conference on sustainable water and sanitation services for all in a fast changing world, pp 7. Hanoi, Vietnam 15–19 September 2014
Alexander KT, Tesfaye Y, Dreibelbis R, Abaire B, Freeman MC (2015) Governance and functionality of community water schemes in rural Ethiopia. Int J Public Health 60(8):977–986
Behnke NL, Klug T, Cronk R, Shields KF, Lee K, Kelly ER, Allgood G, Bartram J (2017) Resource mobilization for community-managed rural water systems: evidence from Ghana, Kenya, and Zambia. J Clean Prod 156:437–444
Ben-Eli M (2015) Sustainability: definition and five core principles a new framework the sustainability laboratory, New York
Bonye ZS, Aasonlenang AT, Owusu-Sekyere E (2013) Community development in Ghana: theory and practice. Eur Sci J 9(17)
Braimah CA, Kheni NA (2013) Institutional framework and challenges in small towns’ water supply in Ghana. Int J Dev Sustain 2(4):2311–2323
Breslin DE (2003) Demand response approach in practice: why sustainability remains elusive. Discussion paper. Poverty dialogue initiative, World water forum
Brikké F (2002) Operation and maintenance of rural water supply and sanitation systems: a training package for managers and planners. World Health Organization, Geneva
Brundtland GH (1987) Our common future: report of the world commission on environment and development. Med Confl Surviv 4(1):300
Chowns E (2015) Is community management an efficient and effective model of public service delivery? Lessons from the rural water supply sector in Malawi. Public Adm Dev 35(4):263–276
Cleaver F, Toner A (2006) The evolution of community water governance in Uchira, Tanzania: the implications for equality of access, sustainability and effectiveness. Nat Res Forum 30(3):207–218
Cronk R, Bartram J (2017) Factors influencing water system functionality in Nigeria and Tanzania: a regression and Bayesian network analysis. Environ Sci Technol 51:11336–11345. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.7b03287
CWSA (2010). Sector guidelines – General, rural communities and small towns: Accra, Ghana
CWSA (2011) Regulations Legislative Instrument (L.I. 2007)
CWSA (2014a) District operation manual. Accra, Ghana
CWSA (2014b) Project implementation manual. Accra, Ghana
CWSA (2014c) National community water and sanitation strategy. Accra, Ghana
CWSA (2014d) Framework for assessing and monitoring rural and small town water supply services in Ghana. Accra, Ghana
Fielmua N (2011) The role of the community ownership and management strategy towards sustainable access to water in Ghana (A case of Nadowli District). Journal of Sustainable Development. https://doi.org/10.5539/jsd.v4n3p174
Fisher MB, Shields KF, Chan TU, Christenson E, Cronk RD, Leker H, Bartram J (2015) Understanding handpump sustainability: determinants of rural water source functionality in the greater Afram plains region of Ghana. Water Resour Res 51(10):8431–8449. https://doi.org/10.1002/2014WR016770
Foster T (2013) Predictors of sustainability for community-managed handpumps in sub-saharan Africa: evidence from Liberia, Sierra Leone, and Uganda. Environ Sci Technol 47(21):12037–12046
Garn M (1998) Managing water as an economic good. The transition from supply-oriented to demand responsive services in community water supply and sanitation conference proceedings. UNDP-World Bank water and sanitation programme, Washington DC. 5–8 May 1998
Ghana Statistical Service (2013) Population and housing census, National analytical report, pp 387–390
Government of Ghana (2007) Ghana national water policy. Ministry of water resources, works and housing, Accra, Ghana, p 17
Harvey PA, Reed RA (2007) Community-managed water supplies in Africa: sustainable or dispensable? Community Dev J 42(3):365–378
Hope R (2015) Is community water management the community’s choice? Implications for water and development policy in Africa. Water Policy 17(4):664–678
Isham J, Narayan D, Pritchett L (1995) Does participation improve performance? Establishing causality with subjective data. World Bank Econ Rev 9(2):175–200
Kotoku G (2017) The practice of community ownership and management in the sustainability of rural water delivery. A case of selected small towns systems in the Central Gonja District in the Northern Region, MSc thesis
Kotoku G, Gyamfi P, Koffie E (2015) Rural and small towns water services. Retrieved July 15th, 2016, from http://www.cwsa.gov.gh/downloads/FACT-SHEET-NORTHERN-REGION1.PDF
Kumasi TC (2018) Financing sustainable water service delivery of small town water systems in Ghana: the gaps and needs. J Sustain Dev Energy Water Environ Syst 6(3):427–445
Kumasi TC (2019) District water budgets and expenditure tracking for sustainable rural service delivery in Ghana. Sustain Water Resource Management 5:1057–1071
Kumasi TC (2020) Monitoring and evaluation of rural water supplies sustainability in Ghana. Int J Water Res 2(1):107. https://doi.org/10.36266/ijwr/123r
Kumasi TC, Agbemor BD (2018) Tracking user satisfaction of rural water services in northern Ghana. J Water Sanit Hyg Dev 8(2):307–318
Kumasi TC, Adank M, Dickinson N, Abbey E, Chimbar TL, Atengdem J, Agbemor BD (2014) Monitoring water services in Ghana: the why, the what, the how and the cost. In: Shaw RJ, Anh NV, Dang TH (eds): Proceedings of the 37 WEDC International Conference on sustainable water and sanitation services for all in a fast changing world, pp. 7. Hanoi, Vietnam 15–19 Sept 2014
Kumasi TC, Agbemor BD, Burr P (2019) Rural water asset management practices in Ghana: the gaps and needs. Water Environ J 33:252–264
Kumasi TC, Nyarko KB, Antwi-Agyei P (2022) Universal water service delivery: insights on what it takes from Ghana. World Water Policy 8(1):9–30. https://doi.org/10.1002/wwp2.12072
Lockwood H, Le Gouais A (2011) Professionalizing community-based management for rural water services. International research council 1–8. https://www.ircwash.org/sites/default/files/084-201502triple. Accessed on 17July 2020
Lockwood H, Smits S (2011) Supporting rural water supply moving towards a service delivery approach. Practical action publishing ltd, Rugby, Warwickshire, United Kingdom, pp i–xii
Loukola O, Kyllönen S (2005) The philosophies of sustainability. Sustainable use of renewable natural resources: from principles to practices
Maganga FP, Butterworth JA (2002) Domestic water supply, competition for water resources and IWRM in Tanzania: a review and discussion paper. Tanzania Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 27(11):919–926
Mandara CG, Butijn C, Niehof A (2013) Community management and sustainability of rural water facilities in Tanzania. Water Policy 15:79–100
McLaughlin TAO, Kazooba F (2015) Improving the effectiveness of Ugandan water user committees. Dev Pract 25(5):715–727
Mensah J (2019) Sustainable development: meaning, history, principles, pillars, and implications for human action: literature review. Cogent Social Sci. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2019.1653531
Montangero A (2009) Promising management models of rural water supply services: outcomes of the 24th AGUASAN workshop, agency for development. 46p. water and sanitation in developing countries (SANDEC), Bern, Switzerland
Montgomery MA, Bartram J, Elimelech M (2009) Increasing functional sustainability of water and sanitation supplies in rural sub-saharan Africa. Environ Eng Sci 26(5):1017–1023
Moriarty P, Smits S, Butterworth J, Franceys R (2013) Trends in rural water supply: towards a service delivery approach. Water Altern 6(3):329–349
Mulenga M, Fawcett B (2003) Impediments to the implementation of the DRA methodology in urban sanitation programmes in Zambia and South Africa. University of Southampton, Southampton. Accessed 04 July 2019
Naiga R, Penker M, Hogl K (2015) Challenging pathways to safe water access in rural Uganda: from supply to demand-driven water governance. Int J Commons 9(1):237–260
National Research Council (1997) Safe water from every tap: improving water service to small communities. The national academies press, Washington, DC. https://doi.org/10.17226/5291
Nyumba T, Wilson K, Derrick C, Mukherjee N (2018) The use of focus group discussion methodology: insights from two decades of application in conservation. Methods Ecol Evol 9(9):20–32
Opare S (2011) Sustaining water supply through a phased community management approach: lessons from Ghana’s ‘‘oats” ‘water supply scheme. Environ Dev Sustain 13:1021–1042
Osumanu IK, Zumayelleh EA, Kosoe EA (2022) Sustainability of community-managed small town and rural water systems in northern Ghana: lessons from upper west region. Community Dev J 57(1):93–111. https://doi.org/10.1093/cdj/bsab015
Phologane LS (2014) Evaluating community participation in rural development projects: the case of Mokgalwaneng village, university of South Africa, Pretoria
RWSN (2010) Myths of the rural water supply sector. Perspectives No. 4, RWSN executive steering committee, July 2009. St Gallen: rural water supply network
Stoddart H, Schneeberger K, Dodds F, Shaw A, Bottero M, Cornforth J, White R (2011) A pocket guide to sustainable development governance. Stakeholder Forum, Commonwealth Secretariat, 2011 https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.php?menu=35&nr=147&page=view&type=400. Accessed 04 May 2022
Sun Y, Asante F, Birner R (2010). Opportunities and challenges of community-based rural drinking water supplies: an analysis of water and sanitation committees in Ghana
Thomas CF (2015) Naturalizing sustainability discourse: paradigm, practices and pedagogy of Thoreau, Leopold, Carson and Wilson: PhD Thesis: Arizona State University
WELL (1998) DFID guidance manual on water supply and sanitation system programs. WEDC publications, Loughborough university, UK
Whittington D, Davis J, Prokopy L, Komives K, Thorsten R, Lukacs H, Wakeman W (2009) How well is the demand-driven, community management model for rural water supply systems doing? Evidence from Bolivia, Peru and Ghana. Water Policy 11(6):696–718
World Bank (1998) Demand responsive approaches to community water supply: moving from policy to practice, East and Southern Africa. World Bank
World Bank (2017) Sustainability assessment of rural water service delivery models: findings of a multi-country review. World Bank, Washington, DC