Application of uncertainty and variability in LCA
Tóm tắt
As yet, the application of an uncertainty and variability analysis is not common practice in LCAs. A proper analysis will be facilitated when it is clear which types of uncertainties and variabilities exist in LCAs and which tools are available to deal with them. Therefore, a framework is developed to classify types of uncertainty and variability in LCAs. Uncertainty is divided in (1) parameter uncertainty, (2) model uncertainty, and (3) uncertainty due to choices, while variability covers (4) spatial variability, (5) temporal variability, and (6) variability between objects and sources. A tool to deal with parameter uncertainty and variability between objects and sources in both the inventory and the impact assessment is probabilistic simulation. Uncertainty due to choices can be dealt with in a scenario analysis or reduced by standardisation and peer review. The feasibility of dealing with temporal and spatial variability is limited, implying model uncertainty in LCAs. Other model uncertainties can be reduced partly by more sophisticated modelling, such as the use of non-linear inventory models in the inventory and multi media models in the characterisation phase.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Albritton, D., R. Derwent, I. Isaksen, M. Lal &D. Wuebblk (1996): Trace gas radiative forcing indices. In:Houghton, J.T., L.G. Meira Filho, B.A. Callander, N. Harris, A. Kattenberg &K. Maskell. Climate change 1995: the science of climate change. University Press, Cambridge, London, UK
Andersson-Sköld, Y., P. Grennfelt &K. Pleijel (1992): Photochemical ozone creation potentials: a study of different concepts. J. Air Waste Manage. Assoc. 42 (9): 1152–1158
Beccali, G., M. Beccali amp:M. Cellura (1997): Fuzzy set application in life cycle inventory of building materials. Paper. Building and the Environment: Proceedings of the Second International Conference. Volume 1: Assessment methods and natural resources. Centre Scientifique et Technique du Bâtiment, Paris, France
Boustead, I. (1993): Eco-profiles of the European plastics industry. Report 3: polyethylene and polypropylene. A report for the European Centre for Plastics in the Environment (PWMI), Brussels, Belgium
Bretz, R. &P. Frankhauser (1996): Screening LCA for large number of products: estimation tools to fill data gaps. Int. J. LCA 1 (3): 139–146
Chevalier, J.L. &J.F. Le Téno (1996): Life cycle analysis with illdefined data and its application to building products. Int. J. LCA 1 (2): 90–96
Decisioneering Inc. (1996): Crystal Ball version 4.0. Forecasting and risk analysis for spreadsheet users. Denver, Colorado, USA
Funtowics, S.O. &J.R. Ravetz (1990): Uncertainty and quality in science for policy. Kluwer Academic Publishers. Dordrecht, The Netherlands
Guinée, J.,R. Heijungs,L. van Oers,D. van de Meent,T. Vermeire &M. Rikken (1996): LCA impact assessment of toxic releases. Generic modelling of fate, exposure and effect for ecosystems and human beings with data for about 100 chemicals. Publication serie: Product policy 1996/21. Dutch Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment, The Hague, The Netherlands
Hanssen, O.J. &O.A. Asbjørnsen (1996): Statistical properties of emission data in life cycle assessments. J. Cleaner Prod. 4 (3-4): 149–157
Heijungs, R.,J.B. Guinee,G. Huppes,R.M. Lankreijer,H.A. Udo de Haes,A. Wegener Sleeswijk,A.M.M. Ansems,A.M.M. Eggels,R. van Duin & H.P. de Goede (1992): Environmental life cycle assessment of products. Guidelines and backgrounds. Centre of Environmental Science, Leiden, The Netherlands
Heijungs, R. (1996): Identification of key issues for further investigation in improving the reliability of life cycle assessments. J. Cleaner Prod. 4 (3-4): 159–166
Hoffman, L. B.P. Weidema, K. Kristiansen &A.K. Ersbøll (1995): Statistical analysis and uncertainties in relation to LCA. Special reports no. 1. Nordic Council of Ministers, Copenhagen, Denmark
Huijbregts, M.A.J. (1998): Application of uncertainty and variability in LCA. Part II: Dealing with parameter uncertainty and uncertainty due to choices in life cycle assessments. Int. J. LCA, in press
ISO (1997a): Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Principles and framework. ISO/FDIS 14040
ISO (1997b): Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Goal and scope definition and inventory analysis. ISO/FDIS 14041
ISO (1997c): Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — part 3: Life cycle impact assessment. ISO/CD 14042.3
ISO (1997d): Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Life cycle interpretation. ISO/CD 14043.2
Janssen, P.H.M., W. Slob &J. Rotmans (1990): Gevoeligheid-sanalyse en onzekerheidsanalyse: een inventarisatie van idee#x00EB;n, methoden en technieken. Rapport no. 958805001. Rijksinstituut voor Volksgezondheid en Milieuhygiëne, Bilthoven, The Netherlands
Kennedy, D.J., D.C. Montgomery &B.H. Quay (1996): Data quality. Stochastic environmental life cycle assessment modelling. A probabilistic approach to incorporating variable input data quality. Int. J. LCA 1 (4): 199–207
Kortman, J.G.M., R G. Eccels, G. Huppes, L. van Oers, E.W. Lindeijer, B.L. van der Ven &J.B. Guinêe (1996): Inschatting milieu-effecten van de afdankfase van langcyclische produkten. SPA Programma rapportnr. 96.005. Rijksinstituut voor Integraal Zoetwaterbeheer en Afvalwaterbehandeling Werkdocument nr. 96.155x. Lelystad, The Netherlands
Lindfors, L.-G.,K. Christiansen,L. Hoffman,Y. Virtanen,V. Juntilla,O.-J. Hanssen,A. Rønning &T. Ekvali. (1995a): Technical reports no. 1-10. Nordic Council of Ministers, Copenhagen, Denmark
Lindfors, L.-G.,K. Christiansen,L. Hoffman,Y. Virtanen,V. Juntilla,O.-J. Hanssen,A. Running &T. Ekvali. (1995b): Nordic guidelines on life-cycle assessment. Nordic Council of Ministers, Nord 1995: 20, Copenhagen, Denmark
Lindeijer, E. (1996): Normalisation and valuation. In:H.A. Udo de Haes (ed.), Towards a methodology for life cycle impact assessment. SETAC-Europe, Brussels, Belgium
Morgan, M.G. &M. Henrion (1990): A guide to dealing with uncertainty in quantitative risk and policy analysis. Cambridge University Press, New York, NY, USA
Nichols, P., M. Hauschild, J. Potting &P. White (1996): Impact assessment of non toxic pollution in life cycle assessment. In:H.A. Udo de Haes (ed.), Towards a methodology for life cycle impact assessment. SETAC-Europe, Brussels, Belgium
Owens, J.W. (1996): LCA impact assessment categories: technical feasibility and accuracy. Int. J. LCA 1 (3): 151–158
Petersen, E.H. (1997): Life-cycle assessment of building components. Handling uncertainties in LCAs. Paper. Building and the Environment: Proceedings of the Second International Conference. Volume 1: Assessment methods and natural resources. Centre Scientifique et Technique du Bâtiment, Paris, France
Potting, J. &K. Blok (1994): Spatial aspect of life-cycle impact assessment. In:H.A. Udo de Haes, A.A. Jensen, W. Klöpffer &L.-G. Lindfors (eds.), Integrating impact assessment in LCA, Proceedings of the LCA symposium held at the Fourth SETAC- Europe Congress, 11-14 April 1994, Free University of Brussels (Belgium), SETAC-Europe, Brussels, Belgium
Potting, J., W. Schöpp, K. Blok &M. Hauschild (1997): Site-dependent life cycle impact assessment of acidification. In:B.J.M. Ale, M.P.M. Janssen &M.J.M. Pruppers (eds.), Mapping Environmental Risks in Risk Comparison, Book of papers of the International Conference RISK 97, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Powell, J.C., D.W. Pearce &A.L. Craighill (1997): Approaches to valuation in LCA impact assessment. Int. J. LCA 2(1): 11–15
Singhofen, A., C.R. Hemming, B.P. Weidema, L. Grisel, R. Bretz, B. de Smet &D. Russell (1996): Life cycle inventory data: development of a common format. Int. J. LCA 1 (3): 171–178
Solomon, S., D. Wuebbles, I. Isaksen, J. Kiehl, M. Lal, P. Simon &N.-D. Sze (1995): Ozone depletion potentials, global warming potentials and future chlorine/bromine loading. In: Scientific Assessment of ozone depletion: 1994. C.A. Ennis (ed.): World Meteorological Organization, Geneva, Switzerland
US-EPA (1997): Exposure Factors Handbook. Volume I, Chapter 2: p 2.1-2.7. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Washington DC, USA
Wegener Sleeswijk, A. &R. Heijungs (1996): Modelling fate for LCA. Int. J. LCA 1 (4): 237–240
Weidema, B.P. &M.S. Wesnæs (1996): Data quality management for life cycle inventories: an example of using data quality indicators. J. Cleaner Prod. 4 (3-4): 167–174
Wrisberg, N., H.A. Udo de Haes, R. Clift, R. Frischknecht, L. Grisel, P. Hofstetter, A.A. Jensen, L.G. Lindfors, F. Schmidt-Bleek &H. Stiller (1997): A strategic research programme for life cycle assessment. Final document for the concerted action LCANET. Centre for Environmental Science (CML), Leiden, The Netherlands