Fluid dynamics of unsteady separated flow. Part II. Lifting surfaces

Progress in Aerospace Sciences - Tập 24 - Trang 249-356 - 1987
L.E Ericsson1, J.P Reding1
1Lockheed Missiles & Space Company, Inc. Sunnyvale, California, U.S.A.

Tài liệu tham khảo

1978 Orlik-Rückemann, 1975, Dynamic stability testing of aircraft-needs versus capabilities, Prog. Aerosp. Sci., 16, 431, 10.1016/0376-0421(75)90005-6 Ericksson, 1969, Unsteady airfoil stall, NASA CR-66787 Ericksson, 1971, Unsteady airfoil stall and stall flutter, NASA CR-111906 Ericsson, 1971, Dynamic stall simulation problems, J. Aircr., 8, 579, 10.2514/3.59140 Ericsson, 1971, Unsteady airfoil stall, review and extension, J. Aircr., 8, 609, 10.2514/3.59146 Ericsson, 1972, Dynamic stall of helicopter blades, J. Am. Helicopter Soc., 17, 10, 10.4050/JAHS.17.11 Ericsson, 1973, Stall flutter analysis, J. Aircr., 10, 5, 10.2514/3.60192 Ericsson, 1973, Unsteady aerodynamic analysis of space shuttle vehicles, Part I: Summary report, NASA CR-124424 Ericsson, 1973, Unsteady aerodynamic analysis of space shuttle vehicles, Part II: steady and unsteady aerodynamics of sharp-edged delta wings, NASA CR-120123 Reding, 1973, Unsteady aerodynamic analysis of space shuttle vehicles, Part III: booster interference effects, NASA CR-120124 Reding, 1973, Unsteady aerodynamic analysis of space shuttle vehicles, Part IV: effect of control deflections on orbiter unsteady aerodynamics, NASA CR-120125 Ericsson, 1976, Unsteady aerodynamic flow field analysis of the space shuttle configuration, Part I: orbiter aerodynamics, NASA CR-14432 Reding, 1976, Unsteady aerodynamic flow field analysis of the space shuttle configuration, Part II: launch vehicle aeroelastic analysis, NASA CR-144333 Ericsson, 1976, Unsteady aerodynamic flow field analysis of the space shuttle configuration, Part III: unsteady aerodynamics of bodies with concave nose geometries, NASA CR-144334 Reding, 1976, Unsteady aerodynamic flow field analysis of the space shuttle configuration, Part IV: 747/orbiter aeroelastic stability, NASA CR-144335 Reding, 1973, Effects of delta wing separation on shuttle dynamics, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 10, 421, 10.2514/3.61903 Reding, 1974, Unsteady aerodynamics could dominate the space shuttle aeroelastic stability Ericsson, 1975, Unsteady aerodynamics of slender delta wings at large angles of attack, J. Airer., 12, 721 Ericsson, 1975, Unsteady aerodynamics of slender delta wings at large angles of attack, J. Aircraft, 12, 832, 10.2514/3.59863 Ericsson, 1977, Approximate nonlinear slender wing aerodynamics, J. Aircr., 14, 1197, 10.2514/3.58915 Reding, 1977, Effects of flow separation on shuttle longitudinal dynamics and aeroelastic stability, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 14, 711, 10.2514/3.57254 Ericsson, 1981, Aeroelastic analysis of the space shuttle external tank cable trays final technical report, LMSC D766543 Ericsson, 1983, Aeroelastic stability analysis of the new SRB cable tray, LMSC D059412 Ericsson, 1982, Aeroelastic stability of space shuttle protuberances, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 19, 307, 10.2514/3.62257 Reding, 1982, Analysis of static and dynamic wind tunnel tests of the shuttle cable trays, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 19, 412, 10.2514/3.62278 Ericsson, 1985, Aeroelastic characteristics of the space shuttle external tank cable trays, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 22, 289, 10.2514/3.25746 Ericsson, 1984, Shock-induced dynamic stall, J. Aircr., 21, 316, 10.2514/3.44966 Ericsson, 1985, Subsonic dynamic stall in pitching and plunging oscillations including large ground interference effects, J. Aircr., 22, 109, 10.2514/3.45093 Chapman, 1979, Dryden lecture of computational aerodynamics development and outlook, AIAA J., 17, 1293, 10.2514/3.61311 Ericsson, 1978, Scaling problems in dynamic tests of aircraft-like configurations, Paper 25, AGARD-CP-227 Harper, 1949, The effect of rate of change of angle of attack on maximum lift of a small model, NACA TN 2061 Ericsson, 1975, Dynamic stall analysis in light of recent numerical and experimental results, J. Aircr., 13, 248, 10.2514/3.58654 Ericsson, 1986, Fluid dynamics of unsteady separated flow, Part I: Bodies of revolution, Prog. Aerosp. Sci., 23, 1, 10.1016/0376-0421(86)90005-9 von Kármán, 1938, Airfoil theory for non-uniform motion, J. Aerosp. Sci., 5, 379 Multhopp, 1938, Die Berechnung der Auftriebsverteilung von Tragflügeln, Luftfahrt Forsch., 15, 153 Lomax, 1952, Two and three-dimensional unsteady lift problems in high speed flight, NACA TR R 1077 Carta, 1971, Effect of unsteady pressure gradient reduction on dynamic stall delay, J. Aircr., 8, 839, 10.2514/3.59179 McCullough, 1951, Examples of three representative types of airfoil-section stall at low speed, NACA TN 2502 Kistler, 1962, The fluctuating pressure field in a subsonic turbulent boundary layer, Jet Prop. Lab. TR 32-277 Ericsson, 1972, Analytic prediction of dynamic stall characteristics Scrugg's, 1974, Analysis of flow-reversal delay for a pitching foil Lang, 1973, On predicting leading-edge bubble bursting on an airfoil in unsteady incompressible flow, Cranfield Memo 109 Shamroth, 1972, Application of time-dependent boundary-layer analysis to the problem of dynamic stall, J. Appl. Mech., 823, 10.1115/1.3422799 Schlichting, 1955 Modi, 1985, Joukowski airfoil with circulation control Jumper, 1986, Lift-curve characteristics for an airfoil pitching at constant rate Brady, 1963, Unsteady stall of axial flow compressors, CAL Report No. AM-1762-S-4 Carta, 1967 Ham, 1967, Stall flutter of helicopter rotor blades—a special case of the dynamic stall phenomenon Ham, 1968, Dynamic stall considerations in helicopter rotors, J. Am. Helicopter Soc., 13, 44, 10.4050/JAHS.13.49 Favier, 1979, Profil d'aile a grande incidence animé d'un movement de pilonnement McCroskey, 1981, Dynamic stall on advanced airfoil sections, J. Am. Helicopter Soc., 13, 40, 10.4050/JAHS.26.40 Ericsson, 1985, A critical look at dynamic simulation of viscous flow, Paper 6, AGARD CP-386 Maresca, 1979, Experiments on an airfoil at high angle of incidence in longitudinal oscillations, J. Fluid Mech., 91, 671, 10.1017/S0022112079000823 Halfman, 1951, Evaluation of high-angle-of-attack aerodynamic derivative data and stall flutter prediction techniques, NACA TN 2533 Carr, 1977, Analysis of the development of dynamic stall based on oscillating airfoil experiments, NASA TN D-8382 Ericsson, 1980, Dynamic stall at high frequency and large amplitude, J. Aircr., 17, 136, 10.2514/3.57884 Critzos, 1955, Aerodynamic characteristics of NACA-0012 airfoil section at angles of attack from 0 to 180°, NACA TN 336 Liiva, 1968, Two-dimensional tests of airfoils oscillating near stall Philippe, 1968, Le décrochage instationnaire d'un profil, ONERA TP No. 936 Wérlé, 1969, Mesures des visualisations instationnaires sur les rotors, ONERA TP No. 777 Hurley, 1963, Experiments on the effects of airjets and surface roughness on the boundary layer near the nose of a NACA 64-006 airfoil McCroskey, 1976, Dynamic stall experiments on oscillating airfoils, AIAA J., 14, 57, 10.2514/3.61332 Ericsson, 1976, Quasi-steady and transient dynamic stall characteristics, Paper 24, AGARD CP-204 Ericsson, 1976, Spilled leading edge vortex effects on dynamic stall characteristics, J. Aircr., 13, 313, 10.2514/3.44527 Ericsson, 1977, Further consideration of “spilled” leading edge vortex effects on dynamic stall, J. Aircr., 14, 601, 10.2514/3.58827 Ericsson, 1977, Further consideration of “spilled” leading edge vortex effects on dynamic stall, J. Aircr., 15, 64, 10.2514/3.58314 Carta, 1974, Analysis of oscillatory pressure data including dynamic stall effects, NASA CR-2394 Silcox, 1974, Wind tunnel analysis of an oscillating airfoil Philippe, 1977, Le décrochage dynamique; un example d'interaction forte entre écoulements visqueaux et non visqueaux, Paper 21, AGARD CP-227 McCroskey, 1975, Recent developments in dynamic stall, Vol. 1, 1 Liiva, 1968, Dynamic stall of airfoil sections for high-speed rotors Moss, 1971, Two-dimensional low-speed tunnel tests on the NACA-0012 section including measurements made during pitch oscillation at the stall Gregory, 1971, Progress report on observations of three-dimensional flow patterns obtained during stall development on airfoils, and the problem of measuring two-dimensional characteristics McCroskey, 1974, Unsteady viscous flow on oscillating airfoils, AIAA J., 13, 71, 10.2514/3.49633 Ericsson, 1975, Dynamic stall analysis in light of recent numerical and experimental results Herbst, 1983, Dynamics of air combat, J. Aircr., 20, 594, 10.2514/3.44916 Herbst, 1983, 1 Mitchell, 1980, Simulation analysis of unorthodox control force fighter aircraft, AFWAL-TR-80-3036 Goetz, 1970, Exploratory study of buffet and stall flutter of space shuttle wing concepts, NASA LWP-872 Ville, 1967, Influence des décallements au bord d'attaque sur les characteristiques aérodynamiques des voilures Abbott, 1945, Summary of airfoil data, NACA TR 824 Glauert, 1927, The effect of compressibility on the lift of airfoils, Vol. CXVIII, 113 Harper, 1948, Investigation of the variation of maximum lift for a pitching airplane model and comparison with flight results, NACA TN 1734 Jacobs, 1937, Airfoil section characteristics as affected by variations in the Reynolds number, NACA TR 586 Spreiter, 1945, Effect of Mach and Reynolds number on the maximum lift coefficient obtainable in gradual and abrupt stalls of a pursuit airplane equipped with a low drag wing, NACA RMA5G06 Daley, 1955, Aerodynamic characteristics of several 6-percent-thick airfoils at angles of attack from 0 to 20° at high subsonic speeds, NACA TN 3424 Pearcy, 1955, Some effects of shock-induced separation of turbulent boundary-layers in transonic flow past airfoils Abbot, 1949 Stengel, 1971, Optimal transition from entry to cruising flight, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 8, 1126, 10.2514/3.59778 Benson, 1972, Influence of airfoils on stall flutter boundaries of articulated helicopter rotors Erickson, 1971, Effects of space shuttle configurations on wing buffet and flutter, Part II, thick high-aspect-ratio wing, NASA TMX-2274, 201 Erickson, 1974, Transonic single-mode flutter and buffet of a low aspect ratio wing having a subsonic airfoil shape, NASA TN D-7346 Moss, 1971 Ericsson, 1975, Dynamic effects of shock-induced flow separation, J. Aircr., 12, 86, 10.2514/3.59805 Ericsson, 1975, Dynamic effects of shock-induced flow separation, J. Aircr., 18, 608, 10.2514/3.57535 Fung, 1968 Polhamus, 1959, Effect of flow incidence and Reynolds number on low-speed aerodynamics of several noncircular cylinders with applications to directional stability and spinning, NASA TR R-29 Lambourne, 1958, Some instabilities arising from the interaction between shock waves and boundary layers Orlik-Rückemann, 1983, Dynamic wind tunnel tests of the simulated shuttle external tank cable trays, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 20, 5, 10.2514/3.28349 LaBerge, 1981, Dynamic wind tunnel tests of the shuttle external tank cable trays at subsonic speeds Michna, 1980, Test results from the pressure test of a 0.12 scale model of the external tank, LO2 cable tray and GO2 pressure line and a 0.175 scale model of the aft ET/SRB cable tray in the MSFC 14 inch trisonic wind tunnel test no. 661 Revell, 1970, Analysis of transonic airfoil independent research data, based on transonic tests on airfoils 1 to 4 conducted at the ARA 8″ × 18″ (2—1) transonic wind tunnel Lindsey, 1958, Compilation of information on transonic attachment of flows at the leading edge of airfoils, NACA TN-4204 Chevalier, 1963, Pressure fluctuations resulting from alternating flow separation and attachment at transonic speeds, 10.21236/AD0423095 Ericsson, 1971, Unsteady aerodynamics of separating and reattaching flow on bodies of revolution, Vol. I, 481 Ericsson, 1965, Separated flow effects on the static and dynamic stability of blunt nosed cylinder flare bodies, NASA CR-76919 Ericsson, 1985, Subsonic dynamic stall in pitching and plunging oscillations including large ground interference effects, J. Aircr., 22, 109, 10.2514/3.45093 Runyan, 1971, Dynamics and aeroelasticity an appraisal, Astronaut. Aeronaut., 9, 48 Tischler, 1971, Critical areas-thermal protection systems, vehicle weight, and aeroelasticity, Astronaut. Aeronaut., 9, 8 Ericsson, 1965, Analysis of flow separation effects on the dynamics of a large space booster, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 2, 481, 10.2514/3.28216 Polhamus, 1971, Prediction of vortex-lift characteristics by a leading-edge suction analogy, J. Aircr., 8, 193, 10.2514/3.44254 Jones, 1945, Properties of low-aspect-ratio pointed wings at speeds below and above the speed of sound, NASA Rept. 835 Hummel, 1967, Zur Umströmung scharfkantiger schlanker Deltaflügel bei grossen Anstellwinkeln, Z. Flugwiss., 15, 376 Smith, 1966, Improved calculations of leading-edge separation from slender delta wings Örnberg, 1954, A note on the flow around delta wings Snyder, 1972, Application of the leading-edge suction analogy to prediction of longitudinal load distribution and pitching moments for sharp-edged delta wings, NASA TN D-6994 Margason, 1971, Vortex-lattice FORTRAN program for estimating subsonic aerodynamic characteristics of complex planforms, NASA TN D-6142 Maltby, 1963 Davenport, 1971, Experimental and analytical investigation of subsonic longitudinal and lateral aerodynamic characteristics of slender sharp-edge 74° swept wings, NASA TN D-6344 Rainbird, 1968, Turbulent boundary-layer growth and separation on a yawed cone, AIAA J., 6, 2410, 10.2514/3.5002 Peckham, 1958, Low-speed wind-tunnel tests on a series of uncambered slender pointed wings with sharp edges Bisplinghoff, 1955 Woodgate, 1963, Measurements of the pitching-moment derivatives on a sharp-edged delta wing in incompressible flow Woodgate, 1968, Measurements of the oscillatory pitching moment derivatives on a slender sharp-edged delta wing in incompressible flow Woodgate, 1968, Measurements of lift, drag, and pitching moments on a series three delta wings Woodcock, 1971, A comparison of methods used in lifting surface theory, AGARD Rept. 583 Lambourne, 1962, A preliminary note on the behavior of the leading-edge vortices on a delta wing following a sudden change of incidence Lambourne, 1969, The behavior of the leading-edge vortices over a delta wing, following a sudden change of incidence Lambourne, 1970, Pressure measurements on a model delta wing undergoing oscillatory deformation Lambourne, 1961, The bursting of leading-edge vortices—some observations and discussion of the phenomenon Keating, 1967, Measurements of pressures on a delta wing oscillating in heave at a high angle of incidence Lambourne, 1959, Some measurements in the vortex flow generated by a sharp leading edge having 65° sweep Earnshaw, 1961, An experimental investigation of a leading edge vortex Gersten, 1961, Nichtlineare Tragflächen Theorie insbesonderer für Tragflügel mit kleinen Seitenverhältnis, Ing. Aerchiv., 30, 431, 10.1007/BF00531785 Lamar, 1974, Extension of leading-edge suction analogy to wings with separated flow around the side edges at subsonic speeds, NASA TR R-424 Lamar, 1976, Prediction for vortex flow characteristics of wings at subsonic and supersonic speeds, J. Aircr., 13, 490, 10.2514/3.58681 Hummel, 1967, Vortex breakdown effects on the low-speed aerodynamic characteristics of slender delta wings in symmetrical flow, J. R. Aer. Soc., 71, 319, 10.1017/S000192400005586X Woodgate, 1968, Measurements of the oscillatory pitching moment derivatives on a delta wing with round leading edges in incompressible flow Engler, 1965, Low-speed windtunnel tests on a 18th scale model of the Handley-Page HP 115 Hummel, 1967, Uber den Einfluss des Aufplatzens der Wirbel auf die aerodynamische Beiwerte von Deltaflügeln mit kleinen Seitenverhältnis bein Scherbeflug, Jahrbuch der W.G.L.R., 232 Hummel, 1965, Untersuchungen über das Aufplatzen der Wirbel an schlanken Deltaflügeln, Z. Flugwiss., 13, 158 Chambers, 1978, Results of piloted simulator studies of fighter aircraft at high angles of attack, Paper 33, AGARD CP-235 Ericsson, 1983, Review of support interference in dynamic tests, AIAA J., 21, 1652, 10.2514/3.60166 Nguyen, 1981, Self induced wing rock of slender delta wings Ericsson, 1984, The fluid mechanics of slender wing rock, J. Aircr., 21, 322, 10.2514/3.44967 Letko, 1957, Experimental determination at subsonic speeds of the oscillatory and static lateral stability derivatives of a series of delta wings with leading-edge sweep from 30° to 86.5°, NACA RM 1.57A30 Ericsson, 1981, Review of vortex-induced asymmetric loads Part I, Z. Flugwiss., Weltraumforsch., 5, 162 Ericsson, 1981, Review of vortex-induced asymmetric loads Part II, Z. Flugwiss., Weltraumforsch., 5, 349 Bird, 1969, Tuft-grid surveys at low speeds for delta wings, NASA TN D-5045 Johnson, 1980, Exploratory investigation of vortex bursting on the high-angle-of-attack lateral-directional stability characteristics of highly-swept wings Levin, 1948, Dynamic load measurements with delta wings undergoing self-induced rolloscillations, J. Aircr., 211, 30 Shanks, 1963, Low-subsonic measurements of static and dynamic stability derivatives of six flat-plate wings having leading edge sweep angles of 70° to 84°, NASA TN D-1822 Boyden, 1974, Subsonic and transonic dynamic stability derivatives of a modified 089B Shuttle orbiter, NASA TMX-72631, DMS-0R-2107 Lomax, 1952, Chordwise and compressibility corrections to slender wing theory, NACA Report 1105 Brown, 1946, Theoretical lift and drag of thin triangular wings at supersonic speeds, NACA Report 839 Wendtz, 1967, An experimental investigation of the flow fields above delta and double-delta wings at low speeds, NASA CR-521 Reding, 1972, Review of delta wing shuttle vehicle dynamics, Vol. III Allen, 1975, An investigation to verify the static stability and control characteristics of the 0.004 scale model (74-0) of the shuttle 5 orbiter (0A108), NASA CR 141.537 Garner, 1957, Experimental study of surface flow and part-span vortex layers on a cropped arrowhead wing Ericsson, 1973, Elastic launch vehicle response to sinusoidal gusts, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 10, 244, 10.2514/3.61874 Ericsson, 1971, Analytic difficulties in predicting dynamic effects of separated flow, J. Spacecr. Rockets, 8, 872, 10.2514/3.59737 Crema, 1979, Damping effects in joints and experimental tests on riveted specimens, Paper 12, AGARD CP-277 1981, 51 Ericsson, 1983, Aeroelastic stability analysis of the light weight LH2 cable tray, LMSC D059511 Poisson-Quinton, 1967, Étude aérodynamique d'un élément de pale d'hélicoptére, AGARD CP-22, 4.1 Greidanus, 1952, Experimental determination of the aerodynamic characteristics of an oscillating wing with fixed axis of rotation Kline, 1969, Some new concepts of the mechanics of stall in turbulent boundary layers, J. Aerosp. Sci., 24, 470 Loving, 1966, Wind-tunnel-flight correlation of shock induced separated flow, NASA TN D-5380 Blackwell, 1969, Preliminary study of effects of Reynolds number and boundary layer transition location on shock-induced separation, NASA TN D-5003 Ohman, 1970, The NAE high Reynolds number 15 in. × 60 in. two-dimensional test facility Howell, 1976, The US 2.5 meter cryogenic high Reynolds number tunnel 1976