Does co-teaching improve academic achievement for students with disabilities? A meta-analysis

Adams, 2014 Andrews-Tobo, 2009 Appelbaum, 2018, Journal Article Reporting Standards for Quantitative Research in Psychology: The APA Publications and Communications Board Task Force Report, American Psychologist, 73, 3, 10.1037/amp0000191 Austin, 2019, The relationship between study quality and the effects of supplemental reading interventions: A meta-analysis, Exceptional Children, 48, 347, 10.1177/0014402918796164 Barrett, 2020, Relationship between disability category, time spent in general education and academic achievement, Educational Studies, 46, 497, 10.1080/03055698.2019.1614433 Beachum, 2016 Beam, 2005 Begg, 1994, Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias, Biometrics, 50, 1088, 10.2307/2533446 Bessette, 2008, Using students' drawings to elicit general and special educators' perceptions of co-teaching, Teaching and Teacher Education, 24, 1376, 10.1016/j.tate.2007.06.007 Booker, 2018, The high tide raises all ships: Middle grades teachers' perspectives on school belonging in early adolescence, RMLE Online, 41, 1, 10.1080/19404476.2018.1505402 Borenstein, 2011 Bottge, 2018, Comparisons of mathematics intervention effects in resource and inclusive classrooms, Exceptional Children, 84, 197, 10.1177/0014402917736854 Bottge, 2015, Impact of enhanced anchored instruction in inclusive math classrooms, Exceptional Children, 81, 158, 10.1177/0014402914551742 Brown, 2010, Quality control in systematic reviews and meta-analysis, European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, 40, 669, 10.1016/j.ejvs.2010.07.011 Brusca-Vega, 2011, Science achievement of students in co-taught, inquiry-based classrooms, Learning Disabilities: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 17, 23 Burke, 2020, A meta-analysis of interventions to promote self-determination for students with disabilities, Remedial and Special Education, 41, 176, 10.1177/0741932518802274 Castro, 2007 Cheung, 2016, How methodological features affect effect sizes in education, Educational Researcher, 45, 283, 10.3102/0013189X16656615 Clements, 2012 Cole, 2020, The relationship of special education placement and student academic outcomes, The Journal of Special Education, 54, 217, 10.1177/0022466920925033 Cole, 2004, Academic progress of students across inclusive and traditional settings, Mental Retardation, 42, 136, 10.1352/0047-6765(2004)42<136:APOSAI>2.0.CO;2 Conn, 2003, Grey literature in meta-analyses, Nursing Research, 52, 256, 10.1097/00006199-200307000-00008 Cook, 2014, CEC's standards for classifying the evidence base of practices in special education, Remedial and Special Education, 36, 220, 10.1177/0741932514557271 Cook, 2017, Co-teaching for students with disabilities: A critical and updated analysis of the empirical literature, 233 Deeks, 2019, Analysing data and undertaking meta‐analyses, 241 Department for Education, 2020 Department of Education, 2015 Didion, 2020, Teacher professional development and student reading achievement: A meta-analytic review of the effects, Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, 13, 29, 10.1080/19345747.2019.1670884 Doran, 2008 Dusty, 2012, Co‐teaching in inclusive classrooms using structured collaborative planning, Kentucky Journal of Excellence in College Teaching & Learning, 10, 36 Duval, 2000, Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis, Biometrics, 56, 455, 10.1111/j.0006-341X.2000.00455.x Egger, 1997, Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test, British Medical Journal, 315, 629, 10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629 Embury, 2013, Co-teaching in inclusive classrooms using structured collaborative planning, Kentucky Journal of Excellence in College Teaching & Learning, 10, 36 Fennick, 2001, Responsibilities and preparation for collaborative teaching: Co-teachers' perspectives, Teacher Education and Special Education, 24, 229, 10.1177/088840640102400307 Ferguson, 2012, Publication bias in psychological science: Prevalence, methods for identifying and controlling, and implications for the use of meta-analyses, Psychological Methods, 17, 120, 10.1037/a0024445 Fontana, 2005, The effects of co-teaching on the achievement of eighth grade students with learning disabilities, Journal of At-Risk Issues, 11, 17 Franklin, 2015 Freeman-Green, 2021, Culturally sustaining practices in content area instruction for CLD students with learning disabilities, Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 36, 12, 10.1111/ldrp.12240 Friend, 2010, Co-teaching: An illustration of the complexity of collaboration in special education, Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation, 20, 9, 10.1080/10474410903535380 Fuchs, 2015, Inclusion versus specialized intervention for very-low-performing students: What does access mean in an era of academic challenge?, Exceptional Children, 81, 134, 10.1177/0014402914551743 Gage, 2017, Publication bias in special education meta-analyses, Exceptional Children, 83, 428, 10.1177/0014402917691016 Garrote, 2017, Facilitating the social participation of pupils with special educational needs in mainstream schools: A review of school-based interventions, Educational Research Review, 20, 12, 10.1016/j.edurev.2016.11.001 Gerlach, 2017 Gersten, 2005, Quality indicators for group experimental and quasi-experimental research in special education, Exceptional Children, 71, 149, 10.1177/001440290507100202 Gersten, 2020, Meta-analysis of the impact of reading interventions for students in the primary grades, Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, 13, 401, 10.1080/19345747.2019.1689591 Gilmour, 2019, Are students with disabilities accessing the curriculum? A meta-analysis of the reading achievement gap between students with and without disabilities, Exceptional Children, 85, 329, 10.1177/0014402918795830 Gindi, 2020, Educational placement of students with autism spectrum disorder and its relation to socioeconomic status, intelligence, and diagnosis, International Journal of Developmental Disabilities, 66, 235, 10.1080/20473869.2019.1569359 Graham, 2018, Reading for writing: A meta-analysis of the impact of reading interventions on writing, Review of Educational Research, 88, 243, 10.3102/0034654317746927 Hang, 2009, An examination of co-teaching: Perspectives and efficacy indicators, Remedial and Special Education, 30, 259, 10.1177/0741932508321018 Harari, 2020, Literature searches in systematic reviews and meta-analyses: A review, evaluation, and recommendations, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 118, 10.1016/j.jvb.2020.103377 Hedges, 2019, Stochastically dependent effect sizes, 281 Holmes, 2018 van Hover, 2012, A case study of co-teaching in an inclusive secondary high-stakes World History I classroom, Theory & Research in Social Education, 40, 260, 10.1080/00933104.2012.705162 Hunter, 2004 2020 Indiana State Department of Education, 2021 Keefe, 2004, The challenge of co-teaching in inclusive classrooms at the high school level: What the teachers told us, American Secondary Education, 32, 77 Khoury, 2014 Kim, 2019, Socioeconomic status and academic outcomes in developing countries: A meta-analysis, Review of Educational Research, 89, 875, 10.3102/0034654319877155 Kiefer, 2010, Understanding middle grades students’ perceptions of their peer worlds: Implications for teaming, Middle School Journal, 42, 48, 10.1080/00940771.2010.11461756 Kim, 2006, Facilitating co-teaching for literacy in general education classrooms through technology: Focus on students with learning disabilities, Reading & Writing Quarterly, 22, 269, 10.1080/10573560500455729 King, 2015 King-Sears, 2014, Co-teaching perspectives from secondary science co-teachers and their students with disabilities, Journal of Science Teacher Education, 25, 651, 10.1007/s10972-014-9391-2 Kugley, 2016 Laffitte, 2012 Leafstedt, 2007, Perspectives on co-teaching: Views from high school students with learning disabilities, Learning Disabilities: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 14, 177 Lehane, 2020, Collaborative teaching: Exploring the impact of co- teaching practices on the numeracy attainment of pupils with and without special educational needs, European Journal of Special Needs Education, 35, 303, 10.1080/08856257.2019.1652439 Lemons, 2018, Envisioning an improved continuum of special education services for students with learning disabilities: Considering intervention intensity, Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 33, 131, 10.1111/ldrp.12173 Lipsey, 2000 Lochner, 2019, The effect of co-teaching on student cognitive engagement, Theory & Practice in Rural Education, 9, 6, 10.3776/tpre.2019.v9n2p6-19 Logan, 2017, School segregation and disparities in urban, suburban, and rural areas, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 674, 199, 10.1177/0002716217733936 Lory, 2020, A meta-analysis of challenging behavior interventions for students with developmental disabilities in inclusive school settings, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 50, 1221, 10.1007/s10803-019-04329-x Losinski, 2019, An investigation of co-teaching to improve academic achievement of students with disabilities: A meta-analysis, Journal of the American Academy of Special Education Professionals, 149 Magiera, 2005, Co‐teaching in middle school classrooms under routine conditions: Does the instructional experience differ for students with disabilities in co‐taught and solo‐taught classes?, Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 20, 79, 10.1111/j.1540-5826.2005.00123.x Marusic, 2020, Methodological tools and sensitivity analysis for assessing quality or risk of bias used in systematic reviews published in the high-impact anesthesiology journals, BMC Medical Research Methodology, 20, 1 McCullough, 2008 Moher, 2009, Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement, PLoS Medicine, 6, 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097 Moser, 2019, Rethinking content teaching at the middle level: An interdisciplinary approach, Middle School Journal, 50, 17, 10.1080/00940771.2019.1576579 Mote, 2010 Murawski, 2006, Student outcomes in co-taught secondary English classes: How can we improve?, Reading & Writing Quarterly, 22, 227, 10.1080/10573560500455703 Murawski, 2001, A meta-analysis of co-teaching research: Where are the data?, Remedial and Special Education, 22, 258, 10.1177/074193250102200501 Nagle, 2017, Using a personal learning framework to transform middle grades teaching practice, Middle Grades Research Journal, 11, 85 Namkung, 2019, The relation between mathematics anxiety and mathematics performance among school-aged students: A meta-analysis, Review of Educational Research, 89, 459, 10.3102/0034654319843494 Nash-Aurand, 2013 Nese, 2017, Modeling the time-varying nature of student exceptionality classification on achievement growth, The Journal of Special Education, 51, 38, 10.1177/0022466916668164 Nguyen, 2019, The effects of grant aid on student persistence and degree attainment: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the causal evidence, Review of Educational Research, 89, 831, 10.3102/0034654319877156 Packard, 2011, Academic achievement of secondary students with learning disabilities in co-taught and resource rooms, Journal of Research in Education, 21, 100 Paez, 2017, Gray literature: An important resource in systematic reviews, Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine, 10, 233, 10.1111/jebm.12266 Pancsofar, 2013, Professional development experiences in co-teaching: Associations with teacher confidence, interests, and attitudes, Teacher Education and Special Education, 36, 83, 10.1177/0888406412474996 Pigott, 2020, Methodological guidance: High-quality meta-analysis in a systematic review, Review of Educational Research, 90, 24, 10.3102/0034654319877153 Polanin, 2017, Overviews in education research: A systematic review and analysis, Review of Educational Research, 87, 172, 10.3102/0034654316631117 Popp, 2001 Powell, 2007 Preston-Smith, 2020, What do high school students think about co-teaching in science classrooms?, Learning Disabilities: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 25, 29 Pulkkinen, 2020, How do educational reforms change the share of students in special education? Trends in special education in Finland, European Educational Research Journal, 19, 364, 10.1177/1474904119892734 Reese, 2017 Richter, 2016, Signaling text-picture relations in multimedia learning: A comprehensive meta-analysis, Educational Research Review, 17, 19, 10.1016/j.edurev.2015.12.003 Royer, 2017 Rude, 2018, Policy challenges and opportunities for rural special education, Rural Special Education Quarterly, 37, 21, 10.1177/8756870517748662 Rudolph, 2020, Meta-analysis in vocational behavior: A systematic review and recommendations for best practices, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 118, 1, 10.1016/j.jvb.2020.103397 Sanders, 2018, Does a rising school climate lift all boats? Differential associations of perceived climate and achievement for students with disabilities and limited English proficiency, School Psychology International, 39, 646, 10.1177/0143034318810319 Scalise, 2015 Scammacca, 2015, A meta-analysis of interventions for struggling readers in grades 4–12: 1980–2011, Journal of Learning Disabilities, 48, 369, 10.1177/0022219413504995 Schaefer, 2016, An historical overview of the middle school movement, 1963–2015, RMLE Online, 39, 1, 10.1080/19404476.2016.1165036 Schulte, 2016, Achievement gaps for students with disabilities: Stable, widening, or narrowing on a state-wide reading comprehension test?, Journal of Educational Psychology, 108, 925, 10.1037/edu0000107 Scruggs, 2007, Co-teaching in inclusive classrooms: A meta-synthesis of qualitative research, Exceptional Children, 73, 392, 10.1177/001440290707300401 Shaffer, 2015, Enhancing teacher competency through co-teaching and embedded professional development, Journal of Education and Training Studies, 3, 117, 10.11114/jets.v3i3.685 Shaw, 2002 Showalter, 2017 Sindelar, 2018, The demand for special education teachers in rural school revisited: An update on progress, Rural Special Education Quarterly, 37, 12, 10.1177/8756870517749247 Spencer, 2018, The comprehension problems of children with poor reading comprehension despite adequate decoding: A meta-analysis, Review of Educational Research, 88, 366, 10.3102/0034654317749187 Stefanidis, 2019, Benefits for co-teachers of students with disabilities: Do contextual factors matter?, Psychology in the Schools, 56, 539, 10.1002/pits.22207 Stockard, 2018, The effectiveness of direct instruction curricula: A meta-analysis of a half century of research, Review of Educational Research, 88, 479, 10.3102/0034654317751919 Strogilos, 2016, Co‐teachers’ attitudes towards planning and instructional activities for students with disabilities, European Journal of Special Needs Education, 31, 344, 10.1080/08856257.2016.1141512 Suurmond, 2017, Introduction, comparison, and validation of meta‐essentials: A free and simple tool for meta‐analysis, Research Synthesis Methods, 8, 537, 10.1002/jrsm.1260 Sweigart, 2016, An evaluation of the evidence base for performance feedback to improve teacher praise using CEC's quality indicators, Education & Treatment of Children, 39, 419, 10.1353/etc.2016.0019 Szumski, 2017, Academic achievement of students without special educational needs in inclusive classrooms: A meta-analysis, Educational Research Review, 21, 33, 10.1016/j.edurev.2017.02.004 Talbott, 2017, Quality indicators for reviews of research in special education, Exceptionality, 26, 245, 10.1080/09362835.2017.1283625 Therrien, 2011, Science instruction for students with learning disabilities: A meta‐analysis, Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 26, 188, 10.1111/j.1540-5826.2011.00340.x Tremblay, 2013, Comparative outcomes of two instructional models for students with learning disabilities: Inclusion with co-teaching and solo-taught special education, Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 13, 251, 10.1111/j.1471-3802.2012.01270.x 2017 Unrau, 2018, Can reading self-efficacy be modified? A meta-analysis of the impact of interventions on reading self-efficacy, Review of Educational Research, 88, 167, 10.3102/0034654317743199 2021 Valentine, 2008, A systematic and transparent approach for assessing the methodological quality of intervention effectiveness research: The Study Design and Implementation Assessment Device (Study DIAD), Psychological Methods, 13, 130, 10.1037/1082-989X.13.2.130 Van Garderen, 2012, Collaboration between general and special educators and student outcomes: A need for more research, Psychology in the Schools, 49, 483, 10.1002/pits.21610 van Leeuwen, 2019, A systematic review of teacher guidance during collaborative learning in primary and secondary education, Educational Research Review, 27, 71, 10.1016/j.edurev.2019.02.001 Walker Harris, 2009 Weichel, 2001 Weiss, 2021, Instruction in co-teaching in the age of Endrew F, Behavior Modification, 45, 39, 10.1177/0145445519836071 Wexler, 2018, Reading comprehension and co-teaching practices in middle school English language arts classrooms, Exceptional Children, 84, 384, 10.1177/0014402918771543 Williams, 2012 Woods, 2020, Explaining longitudinal patterns of special education service receipt, Exceptional Children, 87, 5, 10.1177/0014402920960655 Zigmond, 2015, Where should students with disabilities receive their education?, 198 Zigmond, 2013, Strategies for improving student outcomes in co-taught general education classrooms, 116