The Behavioral Foundations of Retaliatory Justice
Tóm tắt
Norms of positive and negative reciprocity constitute important constraints that affect human behavior. While much attention has been devoted to the economics of reciprocity in cooperation, the stylized fact that humans have a natural predisposition towards negative reciprocity and retaliation has received little consideration in the literature. In this study we investigate the behavioral foundations of retaliatory justice by considering the conditions under which norms of retaliation may constitute instruments for promoting desirable cooperation. The results suggest that human instincts for revenge may an important ingredient for the sustainability of peaceful social behavior.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Angell RobertC. (1965). The sociology of human conflict. Pp. 91–115 in E. B. McNeil (ed.) The Nature of Human Conflict. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Robert Axelrod (1986) ArticleTitleAn evolutionary approach to norms American Political Science Review 80 IssueID4 1095–1111
Georges Balandier (1986) ArticleTitleAn anthropology of violence and war International Social Science Journal 38 IssueID4 499–511
Regina. Barreca (1995) Sweet revenge: the wicked delights of getting even Harmony Books New York
Leonard Berkowitz (1962) Aggression: a social–psychological analysis McGraw-Hill New York
Ken Binmore (1994) Game theory and the social contract, playing fair vol.1 MIT Press Cambridge MA
Blau Joel (1916). Lex Talionis. 26 Yearbook of the Central Conference of American Rabbis 1, p. 4.
Christopher Boehm (1984) Blood revenge: the anthropology of feuding in Montenegro and other tribal societies University Press of Kansas Lawrence
Samuel Bowles Gintis Herbert (2001) ArticleTitleThe evolution of strong reciprocity Journal of Theoretical Biology 213 103–119
Robert Boyd P.J. Richerson (1992) ArticleTitlePunishment allows the evolution of cooperation (or anything else) in sizeable groups Ethology and Sociobiology 13 171–195
A.H. Buss (1961) The psychology of aggression Wiley New York
Napoleon Chagnon (1988) ArticleTitleLife histories, blood revenge, and warfare in a tribal population Science 239 985–992
Chorvat Terrence, Kevin McCabe, Vernon Smith (2005). Law and neuroeconomics. Supreme Court Economic Review, 13.
David Daube (1947) Lex Talionis Daube David (Eds) Studies in Biblical Law Cambridge University Press Cambridge 102–153
JamesC. Davies (1970) ArticleTitleViolence and aggression: innate or not? Western Political Quarterly 23 611–623
Richard Dawkins (1976) The selfish gene Oxford University Press Oxford
Ernst Fehr Gächter Simon (2000) ArticleTitleFairness and retaliation: the economics of reciprocity Journal of Economic Perspectives 14 159–181
Ernst Fehr Gächter Simon (2002) ArticleTitleAltruistic punishment in humans Nature 415 137–140
Brian R. Ferguson (1990) Explaining war J. Haas (Eds) The anthropology of war Cambridge University Press Cambridge 26–55
Vincy Fon Parisi Francesco (2003) ArticleTitleReciprocity-induced cooperation Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 159 IssueID1 76–92
Derek Freeman (1964) Human aggression J.D. Carthy J.F. Ebling (Eds) The natural history of aggression Academic Press New York 109–120
Friedman Daniel, NirvikarSingh. (1999a). On the viability of vengeance. UC Santa Cruz, Discussion Paper, 11.
Friedman, Daniel & Nirvikar Singh. 1999b. On the viability of vengeance. UC Santa Cruz, Discussion Paper, 19.
Herbert Gintis (2000) Game theory evolving: a problem-centered introduction to modeling strategic behavior Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ
Robert Glasse (1959) ArticleTitleRevenge and redress among the Huli: a preliminary account Mankind 5 273–289
William Hamilton (1964) ArticleTitleThe genetical evolution of social behavior, I and II Journal of Theoretical Biology 7 1–52
Elizabeth Hoffman McCabe Kevin Smith. Vernon (1998) ArticleTitleBehavioral foundations of reciprocity: experimental economics and evolutionary psychology Economic Inquiry 36 335–352
Susan. Jacoby (1983) Wild justice: the evolution of revenge Harper and Row New York
Janet T. Landa (1981) ArticleTitleA theory of the ethnically homogeneous middleman group: an institutional alternative to contract law The Journal of Legal Studies 10 IssueID2 349–362
Janet T. Landa (1999) ArticleTitleThe law and bioeconomics of ethnic cooperation and conflict in plural societies of Southeast Asia: a theory of Chinese merchant success Journal of Bioeconomics 1 IssueID3 269–288
Pietroand Marongiu Newman. Graeme (1987) Vengeance: the fight against injustice Rown and Littlefield Lanham MD
Robert Netting (1977) Cultural ecology Cummings Menlo Park, CA
Francesco Parisi (2001) ArticleTitleThe genesis of liability in ancient law American Law and Economics Review 3 82
Steven. Pinker (2002) The blank slate: the modern denial of human nature Viking Press New York
Richard A. Posner (1981) An economic theory of justice Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
Jane Bennet Ross (1984) Effects of contact on revenge hostilities among the Achuara Jivaro B. Ferguson (Eds) Warfare, Culture, and Environment Academic Press Orlando 83–109
Anthony Storr (1983) Aggression is an instinct D. Bender B. Leone (Eds) War and Human Nature Greenhaven Press St. Paul 16–21
Mayer Sulzberger (1915) The ancient Hebrew law of homicide Julius H. Greenstone Philadelphia
Andrew Vayda (1967) ArticleTitleResearch on the functions of primitive war Peace Research Society (International) Papers 7 133–138
Sloan Wilson David (2000) ArticleTitleReligious groups and homogeneous merchant groups as adaptive units: a multilevel evolutionary perspective Journal of Bioeconomics 2 IssueID2 271–273
Robert Wright (1994) The moral animal Vintage Books New York