End-of-Life Decisions in Albania: The Call for an Ethical Revision
Tóm tắt
While in Western European countries, the end-of-life decisions have become a matter of public policy, this paper provides a detailed analysis of end-of-life decisions in Albania by focusing on instructional medical directives. The manuscript investigates the Albanian legal system, the documents published by the National Ethics Committee and the National Committee of Health, as the two main advisory public bodies on health issues, as well as the national medical jurisprudence and the Code of Medical Ethics. After emphasizing the importance of instructional medical directives and considering the international literature that has underlined the ethical principle of patient autonomy, this paper provides some policy suggestions. In the conclusion, this contribution highlights the importance of ad hoc rules governing instructional medical directives as well as the ethical principles and international literature as an instrument to fill the gap in the national system. In addition, particular attention is given to the application of ethical principles in end-of-life decisions in the current pandemic situation.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Alfonso, Heather. 2009. The importance of instructional medical directives and advance directives. Journal of gerontological nursing 10: 42–45.
Andorno, Roberto. 2008. The previously expressed wishes relating to health care Common principles and differing rules in national legal systems. In Steering Committee on Bioethics 35th meeting.
Bara, Brunilda, and Gentian Vyshka. 2014. A right to die: a comparing discourse of case laws in United States of America, European Court of Human Rights, United Kingdom and Albania. JAHR 9: 135–156.
Berger, Jeffrey T., and Deborah Majerovitz. 1998. Stability of preferences for treatment among nursing home residents. The Gerontologist 2: 217–223.
Biddison, Lee Daugherty, et al. 2014. Ethical considerations: Care of the critically Ill and injured during pandemics and disasters: CHEST consensus statement. Chest 4: e145S–e155S.
Boçari, Gëzim, Elmaz Shaqiri, and Gentian Vyshka. 2010. The actuality and the historical background of covert euthanasia in Albania. Journal of Medical Ethics 12: 842–844.
Brock, Dan W. 2009. Medical decisions at the end of life. In A companion to bioethics, ed. Helga Kuhse and Peter Singer, 263–273. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Buchanan, Allen E., and Dan W. Brock. 1989. Deciding for others: The ethics of surrogate decision making. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Burlá, Claudia, et al. 2014. Alzheimer, dementia and the living will: A proposal. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 3: 389–395.
Canestrari, Stefano. 2003. Le diverse tipologie di eutanasia: una legislazione possibile. Rivista Italiana di Medicina Legale 5: 751–775.
Dudley, Katerina M., et al. 2019. Understanding service usage and needs for adults with ASD: The importance of living situation. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 2: 556–568.
Emanuel, Ezekiel J., et al. 2020. Fair allocation of scarce medical resources in the time of Covid-19. The New England Journal of Medicine 382: 2049–2055.
Erin, Charles A., and John Harris. 1994. Instructional medical directives: Anticipatory decisions and advance directives. Reviews in Clinical Gerontology 3: 269–275.
Gardiner, Clare, et al. 2011. Exploring the transition from curative care to palliative care: A systematic review of the literature. British Medical Journal of Supportive & Palliative Care 1: 56–63.
Hendriks, Arend Cornelis. 2019. End-of-life decisions. Recent jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights. Era Forum. 19 (4): 561–570.
Hoppe, Nils, and José Miola. 2014. Medical law and medical ethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hunt, Matthew R., and Carolyn Ells. 2011. Partners towards autonomy: Risky choices and relational autonomy in rehabilitation care. Disability and Rehabilitation 1: 961–967.
Iadecola, G. 2003. Note critiche in tema di “testamento biologico”. Rivista Italiana di Medicina Legale 3–4: 473–483.
Kelly, David F. 2006. Medical care at the end of life a catholic perspective. Washington: Georgetown University Press.
Koka, Enkelejda, and Denard Veshi. 2019. A new law of ‘living will’ in Italy: A critical analysis. Liverpool Law Review 40: 113–130.
Moye, Jennifer, et al. 2007. Assessment of capacity to consent to treatment: Challenges, the “ACCT” approach, directions. Clinical Gerontologist 31 (3): 37–66.
Omar, Luan, and Anastasi Aurela. 2008. Constitutional law. Tirana: ABC.
Organ, Helen, and Rudina Rama. 2016. Approaches to end-of-life care: A comparison between the UK and Albania. Future Hospital Journal 2: 134.
Parfit, Derek. 1984. Reasons and persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Rabkin, Mitchell T., et al. 1976. Orders not to resuscitate. New England Journal of Medicine 7: 364–366.
Rama, Rudina, and Agim Sallaku. 2012. Perception and attitude toward end of life in Albania. Advances in Palliative Medicine 1: 1–5.
Rosenbaum, Sara J. 2011. Ethical considerations for decision-making regarding the allocation of mechanical ventilators during a severe influenza pandemic or other public health emergencies. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Office of the Associate Director for Science.
Schmidt, P., R. Dettmeyer, and B. Madea. 2000. Withdrawal of artificial nutrition in the persistent vegetative state: a continuous controversy. Forensic Science International 1–3: 505–509.
Seymour, Jane, et al. 2004. Planning for end of life: the views of older people about advance care statements. Social Science and Medicine 1: 57–68.
Spoto, Giuseppe. 2011. Questione di Fine Vita tra modelli adottati in Europa, negli Stati Uniti e Proposte Interne. Europa e diritto privato 4: 1175–1196.
Swetz, Keith M., et al. 2014. Advance directives, advance care planning, and shared decision making: Promoting synergy over exclusivity in contemporary context. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 3: e1–e3.
Teno, Joan, et al. 1997. Advance directives for seriously ill hospitalized patients: Effectiveness with the patient self-determination act and the SUPPORT intervention. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 4: 500–507.
Tibaldi, Giuseppe, Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Juan Carlos Garcia-Gutierrez. 2011. From treatment adherence to advanced shared decision making: New professional strategies and attitudes in mental health care. Current Clinical Pharmacology 2: 91–99.
Vergano, Marco, et al. 2020. Clinical ethics recommendations for the allocation of intensive care treatments in exceptional, resource-limited circumstances: The Italian perspective during the COVID-19 Epidemic. Critical Care 24: 165.
Veshi, Denard, and Gerald Neitzke. 2015a. Advance directives in some Western European countries: A legal and ethical comparison between Spain, France, England, and Germany. European Journal of health law 4: 321–345.
Veshi, Denard, and Gerald Neitzke. 2015b. Living Wills in Italy: Ethical and comparative law approaches. European Journal of Health Law 1: 38–60.
Veshi, Denard. 2015. Studio relativo alla Raccomandazione CM / Rec (2009) 11 in merito agli Stati di lingua latina (Italia, Francia, Portogallo e Spagna), tedesca (Austria, Germania e Svizzera) e inglese (Irlanda e Regno Unito di Gran Bretagna e Irlanda del Nord). Rivista Italiana di Medicina Legale 3: 1277–1294.
Veshi, Denard. 2017. Comments on the Lambert case: The rulings of the French Conseil d’État and the European Court of Human Rights. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 2: 187–193.
Vyshka, Gentian, and Jera Kruja. 2011. Inapplicability of advance directives in a paternalistic setting: The case of a post-communist health system. BMC Medical Ethics 1: 12.
Winter, Laraine. 2013. Patient values and preferences for end-of-life treatments: Are values better predictors than a living will? Journal of palliative medicine 4: 362–368.
Albanian Constitutional Court no. 25 of 28 April 2014.
Albanian Constitutional Court no. 33 of 10 April 2017.
Albanian Law no. 107 of March 30th, 2009.
British Medical Association. 1992. Statement on Advance Directives.
British Medical Association. 1995. Advanced Statements about Medical Treatment. London: BMJ Publishing Group.
Council of Europe. 2014. Guide on the decision-making process regarding medical treatment in end-of-life situations.
Decision of the Council of Ministers Nr.595 of Septermber 21st, 1998.
Department of Health. End of life care strategy: promoting high quality care for all adults at the end of life.
ECtHR, Glass v. the UK, Application No. 61827/00, 9 March 2004.
ECtHR, Pretty v. the UK, application no. 2346/02, 29 April 2002.
ECtHR, Vo v. France, Application No. 53924/00, 8 June 2004.
German Constitutional Court, 2 BvR 2347/15.
Italian Constitutional Court, R.O. 43/2018, 29 September 2019.
Italian National Bioethics Committee. 2003. Advance directives. Roma.